the Best Italian food i have eaten in a long time! Excellent service No wonder they have won awards ...,, Infact, i am at the place again today for lunch, drove from NH Must come to this place!!!! read more

Friday night went to @98 Mill & had the worse meal ever. 4 of us & only 1 didn't have a meal full of pepper! My Piccata Chicken came with a black sauce & the carrots were covered in pepper. Had to send it back & the fabulous server let me know the manager took off 30%! Oh hell no! I demand 100% of my meal off since it wasn't edible! Although that was the final outcome I can assure you that I will never go there again because the chef never saw a pepper shaker he didn't like! I rarely write a bad review & have been here before but this was the worse, so don't bother!! Be sure to go elsewhere, too much money & too much pepper! read more

frequent flyer always good/ favorite eggplant customer / service amazing ambiance/ a bit too loud outside tables enjoyable read more

We were in St.J to visit the Fairbanks Museum and went here for a lunch. There were not many options in the area on a Sunday that had beer. This place was Awesome. The rusty interior was so interesting. I love converted industrial buildings. The calamari was so different and incredible. The server was very pleasant and friendly. We will definitely be back again. read more

About every six months I come back here hoping for a better experience. I truly want the very few restaurants in St J to make it. I think to myself, perhaps they've gotten new staff members who will be kind or they stopped serving the chicken picatta in a pool of grease/without linguine or ... literally anything different. Lo and behold: every time I come it's the same ole. ATP I give up. As a note: do not open on Boxing Day next year. I know the owners want the money (clearly), but none of your servers and bartenders wanted to be there. They said it audibly about every five minutes and were quite flustered with the number of people who came in to eat. read more

Arrive early on a Sunday night in St. Johnsbury! This inviting restaurant is the only place open...but fortunately they have an excellent bar and good food. read more

Ordered the stuffed mushrooms with four on a plate. The guest I was with, ordered the same thing and she had five on a plate. They definitely need to work on consistency. They definitely need more waitresses. We were all having a good time when we were told that last round at 7:45. It was a Thursday night. They definitely need a deep clean. I would probably just go there to drink and not order food. read more

Good vibe, good food. Nice selection of beer, good service, unexpectedly nice decor. Don't know what else to say, but Yelp is forcing me to write more. read more

Arrived in the area around 9 pm and was having trouble finding a restaurant that was open. This was the only local place that was open. Walked in, and the place had an industrial vibe to it. Immediately, the staff greeted and seated us. We were close to the kitchen closing and quickly made some decisions. Overall the food was fine. The calamari had a twist to it with having olives added to it. I wasn't expecting it bit didn't mind it. read more

98 Mill - Tuscan sandwich - Burgers Near Me - Saint Johnsbury, Vermont

See all

The patio is lovely to sit on and highly recommend it if they have space. It's shady in the evening. Our waitress was absolutely wonderful, so friendly and knew the menu so well. Drinks were great. We tried a cocktail and thought they were very impressive and well-made. Food did come out quick, so that was nice. It was pretty good. I tried the eggplant ricotta and the eggplant was very thick cut and chewy. Parts of it tasted amazing, not sure why only parts of it though . Honestly, I don't recommend that particular dish. My husband had the salmon and it was pretty good. read more

See all

Nice ambiance; it's pretty empty during the day. They have a great vegan burger-- just get it without the cheese and ask for regular fries. The house salad was lovely too. The service was a little slow at first but it picked up once we sat down. read more

In from out of town. Sat at the bar. Service was attentive and food was fantastic. I ordered the bread with the garlic oil and the rigatoni rustico. The bread was warm, soft and fresh. The pasta was perfectly al dente and the combination of a flavorful meat sauce and sausage was perfect. Wouldn't hesitate to eat here again. read more

Picture industrial runoff meets picnic table -- set beside a murky dam with a pipe sticking out like some kind of plumbing experiment gone wrong. Our food showed up before the drinks, and the staff seemed ready to pack us out before we even sat down. I ordered the pasta primavera -- $19 for three lonely pieces of broccoli floating in what felt like a gallon of oil. Not exactly worth writing home about. The rest of the family got typical fare, it was mediocre. read more

Food was great, service stunk. Live music tonight had a good vibe. Loved the teriyaki wings and chicken piccata

What an amazing addition to the downtown St Johnsbury food scene! This cozy and friendly restored mill wows with a 360 degree copper bar, exposed brick and beams, and vintage newspaper art. The menu has plenty of options- from burger and fries to Italian specialties. Of important note is the great volume of gluten free options ( over 10 on the menus- and none of them a salad)- hard to find in most cities- extremely rare in northern Vermont. Service , timing and quality did not disappoint. This is a must go if you are in the area. read more

98 Mill - GF Pasta Juliette. - Burgers Near Me - Saint Johnsbury, Vermont

Food was delicious, cooked as requested, ready at the time it said it was going to be ready by, had takeout so didn't eat in, but the area is nice and tidy! read more

My boyfriend( local) and I were visiting Vermont from Texas and this was a great stop! Nice atmosphere, lovely service, good food, nice drinks. The chicken piccata and the mussels were great! The maple surf and sweet my boyfriend had and was good. We'd recommend (: read more

98 Mill - Piccata di pollo added over a bed of linguine pasta with chefs veggies (garlic butter green beans) and truffle fries. - Burgers Near Me - Saint Johnsbury, Vermont

Whats with all the flies? House flys, fruit flies, the most flies I have ever encountered when at a restaurant. Server was friendly, food was just ok Ordered the special carolina chicken wrap. Wrap was too wet and it fell apart as soon as I took a bite. But the flavor was good and I ate it all, just jad to use a knife and fork for my "wrap" read more

We really try hard as locals to like it there, but it's just not great for the price. The food is usually disappointing and the service is inconsistent. They have two great servers, but if you don't get the two gals that have worked there from the beginning, good luck to you. We will not be back. read more

ABSOLUTE DISASTER! We will not be back. We had no trouble locating the establishment; however, parking is limited to the curb with plenty of trash around. I ordered the Eggplant Ricotta and the presentation looked okay. Once I dug in to it, the eggplant was thicker and as rubbery as the bottom of my boot. She ordered the Fettuccine Juliet. After trying it, she said that it was way over spiced. We both cut our dinner short after a few bytes. $50 or more wasted dollars later, we ended up trashing both meals. There was an upside to our experience. The one bottled beer of Miller Light was a delight. read more

I travel frequently for work and visited 98 Mill last night after a long day working in the cold and my meal definitely hit the spot! I got in right before closing and sat at the bar, and had help from staff right away. My bartender was very friendly and helpful. I had butternut squash soup and the special, steak tips in alfredo sauce, both items were delicious! My steak was prepared perfectly, medium rare, and the sauce was very tasty. I liked the texture and flavor of Brussel sprouts that came with the steak. There was karaoke going on as well which I didn't expect but wasn't disappointed. I will be back! read more

Service and food were great! Been here twice and each time it was delicious. Highly recommend. read more

I was brave and tried the Maple Surf 'n' Sweet. It was the perfect blend of sweet and salty, bacon was crisp as was the side salad with a excellent maple balsamic vinegar dressing. Service was super friendly, attentive and fast. read more

The misc is nice. Song at the bar for 20 minutes now waiting to order. Took 15 to order a drink. I'm probably going to walk out and go somewhere else to get something to eat. Zero interest in taking care of me. I came in ready after reviewing the menu. But the tender walks away to clean glasses and talk with others. read more

With a new restaurant I always wait a few weeks before trying it. Which is the 98 they Saturday and had a fantastic dinner and Saturday table overlooking the river inside can be noisy but outside fantastic. The kitchen knows what it's doing spacing the ceiling so that the kitchen doesn't get overwhelmed. It's rare for the new restaurant usually takes more time to learn that food came out quickly and was hot. Would not only recommend it, but looking forward to going again soon. read more

The renovation is fantastic. Love the bar and grill vibe in this historic old mill combined with an awesome copper-top bar and big tvs. Service was top notch too. The food, however, was disappointing. Chicken piccatta made me think of a Swanson's frozen dinner with extra salt. Preformed chicken patty and a pile of boiled baby carrots. I WANT THIS RESTAURANT TO BE SUCCESSFUL! St. J NEEDS THIS VIBE. We will be back to try again and really hope they find their way with the food. read more

Service was amazing and good food. Atmosphere is really nice. A little of everything on the menu.

Look I love it up here and really go out of my way to support the local business, but this place was just not good. The service was terrific. The drinks good The food was just not good. You would think that a place that promotes itself as an Italian grill would have decent red sauce. The red sauce here was basically not eatable. I can't help them if they don't have someone on the staff that knows a chunky clumpy red sauce is horrible. So good luck 98 Mill we will pass next summer read more

I had heard they had great pork chops but I opted for the french dip...not a good move. The beef was extremely dry and bland and the dip was extremely salty. The worst french dip I have ever had. The waitress was really friendly and the ambiance was great, they had live music. Just wish the food was better. read more

Made the mistake of going here a third time. Just shoot me, this place continues to be the absolute worst! Terrible frozen food and poor service. There will never be a fourth. read more

Love love love the food and the staff. Ambiance is perfect!! We love sitting by the water.

If you love garlic and I normally do, or if you need to repel some vampires , this is your spot. I ordered the eggplant roll up and the sauce was so full of garlic that I could barely eat it . I stunk for the next two days. The eggplant itself was tough and chewy. On a positive note though the take-home pasta I could have brought home would have fed my family for a week. The portions were extremely large. read more

Food was awful. Spent $150 and it was frozen salmon over cooked; cold broccoli; and risotto out of the box is tastier. My husbands seafood platter was undercooked. The shrimp and scallops were still slightly translucent. Drinks were awesome so will return for drinks; but being the second try and food was worse than the first won't try eating here again. Restaurant was only half full so food should have been perfect. Very disappointed. read more

The food was just plain awful. I honestly think it was prepackaged frozen food heated in a microwave. When you first walk in the atmosphere is pleasant, but the seating is very uncomfortable. The service was fine. I won't come back and I do not recommend this restaurant. read more

Food was excellent, large portions, great ambiance and Haley the waitress is phenomenal