Food was amazing, our service was even better. We love our server Jay! He took great care of us, was timely, and very funny! Will be back. :) read more

This place is a local favorite. Solid food and drinks with lots of seating options... In the bar area, high tops, tables, indoors or outdoors. Great for groups too. All the food we tried here are yummy. We had the huge pretzel appetizer (comes with a honey mustard and cheese dipping sauce), linguini with white clam sauce (creamy and delicious), coconut shrimp, beef on weck sandwich, and margarita pizza. Highly recommended, just be prepared to wait a bit for the food since they are pretty busy all the time. read more

99 Brick Oven Bar & Grille - Chicken Milanese - Pizza Near Me - Lancaster, New York

Our waitress spilled a drink on one of us and kind of rude. The margharita pizza was not very good.

Very good food a service, club sandwich and large salad between us, plus delicious rosettes appetizer, Overall a nice experience and we will be back. To new folks: parking can be an issue in their parking lot yet there are spots on the side street. read more

We haven't been here in a few years, even though we live in Lancaster about 8 minutes away. It's always busy here, and parking can be tricky because it's located in more of a residential area. We've eaten here before, but I can't review it based on the amount of time it's been since we've been here. We did have amazingly crunchy sweet potato fries with a honey butter dip. So good with a couple of cocktails on a Thursday night. read more

See all

Normally love it. Ordered the potato chip crusted haddock and convinced a friend to do the same. When the meal came out, the server said something about breaded fish and then corrected themselves to say potato chip fish. It appears they were right. The first time we asked the server and he said no that was the potato chip fish. Unless they found potato chips with no salt and no flavor, this was definitely breaded fish. I have had potato chip fish, other places, and this was nothing like it. It was not terrible...pretty bland though. Especially when you are expecting a potato chip crust. read more

Always great food. Our favorite is the fish fry. Can be a little noisy inside but the patio is great. Highly recommend

The food was okay. Definitely not a place for fish though! Rosettes are good, but definitely an appetizer versus a meal. Service was friendly but slow, and it wasn't really busy. The ambience was fine, but they sat us right next to another table who was talking super loud and there were many empty tables around... the parking lot is a little tight on the side too. They have a nice patio spacing, a small discount paying cash, and friendly servers! read more

See all

Decided to try a Lancaster establishment. Haven't been to many places in the town, so we settled on this one. Brick Oven pizza's were delicious. Thin crust cooked perfectly. Just the right amount of toppings. We went with Hot Pepper and the "99" Pizza. The wings were decent, with a large serving of blue cheese. Cool atmosphere in the bar. We sat on the enclosed patio (wish it was opened up). There were many menu options and several that we'll be heading back to try, but with Brick Oven in the name, we had to go with their specialty. Thought prices were a tad high, but with the size of the portions, we'll both get 2 meals out of it. read more

See all

Delicious and great service! My wife and I used Yelp to find this gem while passing through the area. We were greeted and waited upon by Amanda. She was great. We ordered a Caesar salad and a mushroom and sausage pizza to split. Amanda split the salad before it arrived and the thought was appreciated. read more

99 Brick Oven Bar & Grille - Mushroom & Sausage - Pizza Near Me - Lancaster, New York

Great food Great service thanks John!!!! Nice ambiance ! I usually get the scallops My husband gets the salmon Special...yummy to both!!! read more

This place is one of the very few "up to date" restaurants in the Lancaster area which is desperately needed. You can tell that people FLOCK to it! Parking is awful however. Don't bother trying the lot, it will likely be full and very difficult to turn around out of. You are better off parking on the street but it may be a bit of a walk so prepare yourself. The food here is great. From their appetizers to their pizzas and entrees. Yes, it can be a little pricey but the food quality and service is definitely worth it! read more

99 Brick Oven Bar & Grille - Scallops entree - Pizza Near Me - Lancaster, New York

There is a parking lot in rear of building with an entrance to the main dining room. As you enter, there is a hallway with coat rack and then the restrooms ( which were clean and had 2 stalls ) and entrance to the patio and main floor dining room. There are stairs off to the side to go up to the bar and some more tables. Service was quick and accurate. We had meatball paninis which were made on house made focaccia rolls . The meatballs were sliced thin, covered with smooth red sauce and homemade melted mozzarella and toasted in a brick oven. They were tasty and easy to eat with just the right amount of char. It was accompanied by small leaf arugula greens that were that were drizzled with a refreshing light lemon vinaigrette. We enjoyed our meal and would return when in the area again. read more

99 Brick Oven Bar & Grille - Dining room at street level - Pizza Near Me - Lancaster, New York

See all

Came for dinner around Valentine's Day weekend. The place was cutely decorated and they had fun Valentine's Day drinks and specials. We sat in the "outside" section right under a heater which was warm and cozy. The food and service were great. I did order a Valentine's drink which was 25% alcohol and 75% whipped cream, and it smelled off. read more

Moved to Lancaster NY about 4 months ago and love brick oven pizza. Not a fan of local Buffalo style. So this place was a pleasant surprise and absolutely love their sauce on their pizza. True Italian authentic taste. Not the usual sweet tasting sauce western NY is known for. IMO is horrible but everyone is entitled their opinion. Bravo 99 u have a customer for life read more

Quick service! Always a nice ambiance with indoor and outdoor seating. Food is generously proportioned and always delicious! read more

99 Brick Oven Bar & Grille - 99 salad with steak - Pizza Near Me - Lancaster, New York

See all

They have the absolute best sweet potato fries and pizzas and the service is always excellent. I totally recommend it.

First time having beef on Weck. The horseradish played well with the sweet sauce provided. read more

99 Brick Oven Bar & Grille - Beef on Weck Sandwich, Sweet Potato Fries, blue moon beer - Pizza Near Me - Lancaster, New York

It was so nice to be able to eat out on their beautiful patio. It was my first time back in over a year and the food, drinks and service most definitely did not disappoint!! We first walked into he restaurant to get our table and it was very well kept up, the servers were masked and we were brought outside to the patio as it was a beautiful night! I ordered the Roast Beef on Weck sandwich and Sweet Potato fries that were out of this world! The Roast Beef was cooked perfect, not chewy or over cooked, full of flavor & a very good portion was given. The Sweet potato fries had a slight crunch, soft in the middle and enough flavor that no salt was needed I had a Delicious fruity drink but because we got there late we were a little rushed in eating and drinking. I would definitely go back(but much earlier) as they do have a Great menu & Delicious food! read more

See all

TLDR Excellent: 4 cheese stuffed banana peppers.. Royal Parmesan brick oven pizza Filet of sirloin All generous portions, served quick, fresh, filet melted in your mouth.. Great house cocktails, pineapple mule was fan-tastic..! Perfect mix of ginger beer and fruits.. Great ambiance, not noisy, staff very friendly,,, Jen helped us out with the menu selection, and was on target. Fun-fetti, Chocolate vanilla sprinkle cake. Parking lot is ALWAYS packed, a great indication of popularity,, passed by at 21:30, saw a few open spots and decided to try.... Best decision for dinner..! They have a brick pizza oven brought in from Italy,,, does what it is supposed to do...! read more

See all

Had the chicken Milanese on the $14 small plate menu. It came with linguine and was the perfect size and very good. The sangria was also very good and quite large. Service was good and I would definitely go back!! Small parking lot and a nice enclosed patio too. read more

99 Brick Oven Bar & Grille - Sangria - Pizza Near Me - Lancaster, New York

My fiancée and I went there on a whim and ordered the oven brick pizza and the beef on weck. Both were done perfectly. The service was excellent and the atmosphere was very nice. It was a Friday and we did not have to wait long for a table as well. Highly recommend for an inexpensive dinner out. read more

The food was delicious. We ordered the Buffalo traditional pizza, hot and spicy brick wings, and the chicken alla vodka. The pizza was some of the best we've had. It was a thin crust and a little floppy but other than that delicious. The wings were ok (a bit overpriced, $17.50 for $10), we wish the menu specified that the hot and spicy brick was a dry rub. The pasta was delicious, the chicken was very tender, although a few of the vegetables were cold. read more

See all

First time visit today. We received a gift card for Christmas. They were still serving off the lunch menu but were kind enough to let us order off the dinner menu. (That's what we had looked at online ahead of time.) I had the grilled sirloin with garlic mashed potatoes and some veggies and my husband had the chicken parmigiana. Both meals came with salad and bread. Both meals were cooked perfectly. My sirloin was cooked just as I asked. Thank you for a delicious meal and for being accommodating. We will be back. Highly recommend! read more

Lunch was an absolute joy here.. the food was delicious and the drink was well made! Never got to dessert though. I sat with friends out on the patio with the fans turning and was able to stay cool even though it was 82°. The waitress was very attentive to our needs and deserved to be recognized as an integral part of this establishment. The parking was a little difficult seeing as this big A$$ Yukon parked at the first spot at the entrance and blocked a good portion of the driveway. I had the Apple & Field Greens Salad with Salmon ( which was grilled PERFECTLY) worth every penny!!!!! Definitely a repeat visit is due. read more

*PRE-COVID REVIEW* This place is close to work so came over for lunch, and I had heard very good things, so I was looking forward to my first visit. The lunch menu looked delicious so we started with an appetizer order of the "Margherita Rosettes." They are made with house-made mozzarella, tomato sauce, fresh basil, Parmesan cheese and evoo. WOW! Great kick-off to our lunch, and I hoped I wasn't spoiling my appetite. After tasting the rosettes, which were like little pizza balls, I was in the mood for chicken fingers. Perfectly done, crispy, and great medium sauce. The fries were just as good. Other people got a Reuben, and a burger. Good reviews all around, and will return for lunch during the work week, when we can. They are currently doing take-out. read more

99 Brick Oven Bar & Grille - Chicken fingers - medium - Pizza Near Me - Lancaster, New York

See all

Nice little bar in the village of Lancaster. They have off street parking and entrances in the front and back of the building. I came here after some Black Friday shopping and it was very quiet inside and not busy at all. I ordered a pretzel for an appetizer and then a pizza that I split with my sister. Both items were really good. The beer cheese that comes with the pretzel was way better than the mustard. The mustard was like a honey mustard and I was not a fan. There was enough cheese for the whole pretzel though so that was good! I had the stuffed hot pepper pizza and it was HOT! I actually needed a side of marinara sauce because my mouth was burning! If you like spicy things, this is the pizza for you. The dough was great and the cook (and maybe the owner?) was hand tossing it near the brick oven! Very cool to see. I love the Naples style pizza and everything was very tasty. I would definitely return. read more

99 Brick Oven Bar & Grille - Stuffed hot pepper pizza - Pizza Near Me - Lancaster, New York

See all

This local restaurant and bar offer traditional pub fare with an emphasis on items coming out of its wood-fire oven. The pizzas are top-notch as are the stuffed hot peppers. Get out and give them a try for a casual, easy, and affordable night out. I hear the patio is heated in the winter, too. read more

See all

Excellent service. Staff was very accomodating. Food was very good. Will definitely come back! Prices are very reasonable and they offer indoor and outdoor seating. read more

This is the best pizza on the island. It is loaded with toppings and hot delivered. The service was friendly and it costs a bit more but yum.. read more

What an amazing place! We were outside our normal radius traveling for some kid basketball and needed lunch in Lancaster. A quick search led us to the giant pretzel. Little did we know how fantastic everything would be. From the super friendly server to the juicy, crispy chicken wings, to the pizza with all the magic flavor... we were blown away. 100% we will be back, and it is totally worth the 20 minute drive. read more

See all

Pizza was good and fair sized for the price, wish the broke up the anchovies at least in half. 2chovies a slice( pretty good ) but the wings. While still being a good wing. I ordered the specialty wings( Italian garlic parm) which was extra cost compared to the normal, I can understand maybe needing to rub it along the bottom get the good back on top, my wings came plain... and simple. Unhappy. But if the were sauced correctly I'm sure they'd have been great 3.8* on food alone read more

99 Brick Oven Bar & Grille - Jumbo Chicken Wings (Single - 10) Italian parm - Pizza Near Me - Lancaster, New York

Visiting from Florida so this was my First time eating at 99. I enjoyed the background music which was not as loud and annoying as most bras. I was amazed at the menu selection, not your average Bar food. My meal ( the crusted Haddock) was wonderful. Gail, the bartender gave me excellent service at the bar. I'll definitely be going back to try their Pizza and other selections. read more

We love to go to 99 Brick Oven for lunch especially when it's warm out to sit on their patio. The food is amazing and never disappoints! Everything is delicious! read more

We frequently go here when we are in the Lancaster area. The food and the ambiance is amazing, the portions are extremely generous. We had the bee sting pizza which had a nice kick of heat and paired nicely with their own beer designed specifically for the restaurant. The Bavarian pretzel is hands down the best in the area and the dipping sauces provided are great. If you are in the area, I would stop by or make this a destination if you are looking for great food and atmosphere. read more

Great food, lovely server, I can't wait to return. Next time I hope to eat on the outdoor patio area.

we were so pleased with our experience! they have a good assortment of gluten free options and even had a gluten free dessert that had been homemade that morning! read more

Glad we found this place. Appetizers: Bavarian pretzel - very good, dipping sauces - grainy honey mustard and beer cheese Cheese stuffed banana peppers - very good Pierogies - good Main: Margherita pizza with prosciutto- this was real good. The crust amazing, sauce was on the tangy side, and homemade mozzarella Service: Service was wonderful. Owner greeted us and was super nice as well as the hostess and the waitress. Would definitely come back read more

99 Brick Oven Bar & Grille - Margherita pizza with prosciutto - Pizza Near Me - Lancaster, New York

Great pizza's. Food is really good here. Friendly wait staff and outdoor seating is very nice.

The service was great and the food even better. It's very affordable and an awesome experience. Will definitely be going back!