So I don't have enough of a well-rounded experience to give a 4/5 review but I will give a 3/5 review for what I've had from here. I've never actually eaten in or gone to the A&M restaurant to pick up an order. I only have gotten Door Dash from here multiple times and never had an issue. What I really love the most about this place is their Old Bay Wings. They tasted so good every single time I've gotten them. The pizza is meh, like it's nothing special...the crust wasn't that crispy on the bottom and just tasted average. I felt a little turned off ever since reading the health inspection information on Lancaster Online, so I only order from here sometimes if I'm really craving the wings. Other than that, I don't think the place is anything special. It's just a local fast food restaurant if you want a quick, but average bite. read more

I have visited MANY of the various A&M Pizza restaurants in the Lancaster/Lebanon/Campbelltown PA areas. The food is always good-to-great, but their attention to detail has been sorely lacking over the past two years. Small issues, to be sure, but still frustrating nonetheless. A few days ago in Lebanon I ordered Fettuccine with Chicken. A salad was included. "What dressing do you want?" "Blue Cheese." This was even on my receipt. What did I get? Oil & Vinegar. A few weeks ago I order a tuna sub with (among other things) "banana peppers on the sandwich and onions on the side". I got my sub with a condiment container. Got home: Banana peppers in the container; no onions on sandwich or in the container. Please lease do go there for food. But, always, ALWAYS check your order for accuracy. read more

I thought my daughter ordered a margarita pizza. Look at the pic attached-this pizza has no tomato sauce. Since the order was a pickup-I figured we would just try it since it was not worth the effort to drive it back and ask questions. It was a good pizza, but I am definitely confused. Either the order got mixed up or they don't put sauce on a margarita pizza. read more

A&M Pizza Manheim - Supposedly this was a margarita pizza, but it had no tomato sauce. Although I am confused - I still enjoyed my 2 slices! - Pizza Near Me - Manheim, Pennsylvania

Food is hot, and delicious. We like their cheesesteak sandwiches. The staff is always friendly too.

Authentic Ny Italian pizza Absolutely one of my faves for decades! Great atmosphere Great service read more

Not sure how other food tastes but pizza fuggadabout i. No sauce more cheddar as cheese not mozzarella ugh

Pizza is good. Crispy crust. I enjoyed the pepperoni pizza. Would go back. Kids pizza was not available when I called. The prices are ok, Sunday's are the cheapest days, every other day is a little pricey. read more

This was my go to place. After noticing I was being charged differently from different people taking my money I finally figured out what was going on. I believe the actual owner does not charge when you use your debit card. Unfortunately the other person which is always rude on Tuesdays charge me more because she is charging a service for using a debit card. When I finally Called him out on it his response was you always use that. It doesn't matter there's no sign posted that there is a fee. Frankly he's stealing from me. No more. I will talk nothing about good at A&M pizza anymore frankly they steal money from you. The gentleman that works Tuesdays is a thief plain and simple. read more

I have been going to this restaurant since I was a child. Food hasn't changed much and doesn't need to. Probably top 3 places for pizza in the county. read more

First, very rude service, I mean over the top. I usually give people some wiggle room on this as everyone has a bad day but this was in-your-face rude. Second, I ordered a cheeseburger and it was terrible. I think the pattie must have been maybe 1/8th of an inch thick and then this giant bun. The pattie had no taste, I had to salt it up. I don't give out too many 1-stars, but this was bad. read more

Great cheesesteaks here! Love those. Also the bacon pizza is good too. Have had great experiences there.

Just had a sub for lunch Bread was stale and dry.... Just a bit hit or miss lately at this joint read more

Great tasting bread, philly steak 12" was more than u can eat at one sitting. Larger than any subway sandwich Worth $8 for a large. Drink are over priced at $2 for 20 oz. Need to try another hot sub to give more stars. read more

Ordered a cheese steak plain only cheese. Got a medium drink bill was 10 bucks. That had to be the most bland cheese steak ever. Clean and service was good but the cheese steak had no flavor. I get plain cheesesteaks quite a bit and this one tasted like bread and only bread. Hardly any cheese. read more

It's a pizza shop. It's good but don't expect to be wowed. They get busy and take a little bit of time at lunch. They have had serious health issues in the past couple of month but if you don't think about the violations the pizza is ok at best read more

Biggest complaint is that they refuse to get your takeout order correct. You ask for no mayo? Tough - you're getting it (and lots of it). Light on the oil? Tough - your sub will be drenched in it. Pepper and oregano? Not going to happen no matter how clearly you specify. Rolls are pretty lousy too. Francesco's around the corner is much better all around. read more

Stopped here after a business meeting in town. Never been to this town before in my life but it's quite quaint and interesting. Chose this restaurant as it was right on the green and easy to park Best ever meatball parm sub. Bread was soft, fresh, crusty from The oven. The meatballs were huge, plentiful, and very flavorful. Dripping with just the right amount of mozzarella cheese on the top. The sauce was sweet and tasted like it definitely did not come out of a can. I got a small sub cut it in half and had it for two meals. I've eaten a lot of'subs in my life but this was the best ever meatball I've ever had. And I'm Italian, so I should know! I am definitely going to come back here. It's worth the 1 Hour Dr. in the car read more

This place has decent prices and lunch specials. I like their pizza but I'm not a big fan of their subs. They generally have very fast service. read more

The bread they use is delicious! I love their subs and Stromboli, and french fries. I have ordered take out many times and havent had any issues with the specifics of my order. read more

Absolutely love their subs. Homemade bread and homemade dressings make them taste superb. The pizza definitely isn't the best but it's ok. The service is fine, they are just business like Sicilians. I normally get the turkey sub with mayo and their oil/vinegar dressing. Trust me, you won't be disappointed. read more

Had a meatball parmesan sub and it was "old school" meaning it was stuffed with actual meatballs, cheese sauce which is hard to find in this area anymore! The food was good, the staff was friendly and eager to please and the price was more than reasonable. read more

Food is excellent and portion size is acceptable for the money. Wish they delivered. Restaurant is usually clean and busy. Downsides: they're slow. If they tell you 20 minutes and you show up in 25 to pick up the order, you still wait 10 minutes. Also, my wife refuses to enter the restaurant because for some reason they tend to make her skin crawl. I had to witness it myself to understand, but they do have a tendency to be a little overly zealous when a woman walks in the door. Beyond that, excellent read more

We ordered food from this restaurant yesterday. The tuna club was not great. It did not have a taste and it was bland. The fries passed. Then they attatched a tip at the end of our bill automatically. I do not recommend this place. There is another pizza place I usuallly buy from which is much more decent than this one. read more

Love the food and staff at A&M. When I moved to Maheim 15 years ago they immediately became my favorite quick eat. Even celebrated my daughter's 5th birthday party here many years ago. The Stromboli sets the bar in my opinion. Love Joe and the staff. read more

This pizza is so wonderful. It's easily the best I've had in a while. Super cheesy gooey deliciousness. Can't wait to go back!