I absolutely love this place ! Best personal Cheesesteak Stromboli (easy shareable) Such sweet people and bonus round is a drive up window since I have my young grands all week.. read more

Two cousins pizza Columbia Avenue Lancaster - Pizza Near Me - Lancaster, Pennsylvania

This is the worst food I've ever had. The service was terrible. The quality of the ambiance is terrible. For the price you pay the quality is cheap. The seasoning is nonexistent. No flavor. Considering they're "Italian" And the cheesecake? Don't even get me started. I opened the takeout container and had to do a double-take. It literally looked like someone ate it, threw it up, and said, "yup, let's send that out." read more

great pizza but cheesesteak horrible. Meat tastes like. Chopped up hamburger rolls soft like pastry. for the price I won't do it again wings dry read more

Ordered from Uber eats. Food was inedible. I ordered bacon cheese fries where the bacon was clumpy and taste synthetic, clearly out of a bag. Cheese steak was soggy through the bread and in a puddle. Pizza had burnt crisped center without cheese. Respect to the person who answered the phone who did try to help; offered for me to come in and pick up a remade order but this didn't work for me (hence why I paid the up charge on Uber eats) Clearly a minimum of a quality control issue. Might be worth trying in person or pick up but they clearly didn't care about this Uber order. $40 in the trash with the rest of the meal read more

If I could give this Pizza place 0 stars, I literally would. This place has unseasoned food. How are you Italian and you cannot season food? This place is disgustingly expensive for you. For the fact that they serve you straight up, slop, I literally got a cheesecake, and it literally looked like someone went to the bathroom and made their own cheesecake. Chocolate flavored read more

We ate here today with a large group. Service was prompt and the food was delicious. Our group ordered a variety of food from stromboli to cheese steaks. I had the chicken cheese steak and split a large week with my niece. Even after splitting, we still had leftovers. Save room for the Nutella pizza for dessert! read more

I ordered a veal parm & the veal was wildly overcooked & awful. The spaghetti was undercooked for me but probably was traditional aldente. I don't like aldente. The marinara sauce was very bold & taked "burnt". read more

Love this place! The pizza and salads in particular are great. They seem to do more takeout than eat-in, but the service has been very attentive every time we've eaten there. read more

We live about a mile from Two Cousins Columbia Ave. There are closer pizza/Italian restaurants but we like them best, order carryout 2 to 4 times a month for many years. Tonight we had a rare problem, my wife picked up our order and when she got home and opened it, she found her order was wrong. She called and they offered to remake the sandwich and deliver it. It arrived in about 8 minutes. That's customer service like you just don't see anymore. Great job, folks. We so appreciate you! read more

Good Italian cuisine....Not Mexican! Service is great and you can build points towards discounts. It's my go-to local shop that's been in business for some time now. There's a reason! Nice pizza parlor with all the amenities. Highly recommend. You won't regret. Drive up window is convenient as well. Check out website for coupons read more

Decent pizza, not greasy and brick oven which is a plus. Only tried their cheese pizza which was good. Sauce recipe is tasty with just enough cheese layered on top. Dough could have used a little more flavor but I liked the thickness. We ordered for delivery through UberEats which I wouldn't do again. I know it's not the restaurant's fault but the pizza was cold when it arrived. read more

Two cousins pizza Columbia Avenue Lancaster - Large cheese pizza - Pizza Near Me - Lancaster, Pennsylvania

Two Cousins rarely gets my order correct unless I order a pizza. Sandwiches never come as ordered. They don't read the notes when ordering.

Exceptional food, good service in-house and delivery. Yummy! Definitely recommend eating here! read more

Great pizza joint in Lancaster. I order here now and again for quality pizza, usually good and good prices. The pick up is very easy and the attendants are prompt. The store is clean and presentable although nothing special. read more

In from out of town. Placed a takeout order. They forgot to give me an item. I called them to credit my card. They admitted to missing the item, but refused to credit my card. They wanted me to drive back to the store to give me a store credit. What good does that do for me when I live 3,000 miles away? The pizza was average at best. Suggest you look elsewhere. read more

Another 5 star meal from Two Cousins Columbia Ave.! Got delivery thru Grub Hub and was fast, hot, and complete. Fajita Wrap was amazing. We'll be back! read more

I ordered a dozen hot wings extra crispy. They were the furthest thing from crispy, not hot, and were lackluster overall. I only ate about four of the 12 wings because I couldn't stomach the rest. For the price they charge, you think you get a good wing. read more

I live fairly close to this pizza shop. I really like he family that has this restaurant but lately the quality of the food has gotten really bad. At this point we stopped eating the dinners we used to get because taste and quality was not good, now the Stromboli's are not good more grease than meat just absolutely dripping and simply disgusting. Will not order any more of those now. Nothing left but pizza, not my favorite but hard to support local businesses if this is the quality you encounter. Wish I had something good to say but I am very disappointed read more

Always excellent food! I love their eggplant and spaghetti. You have to know what you're doing to make eggplant otherwise it'll turn out rubbery, but you never have to worry about that here. Their service is fast and friendly too! You won't be disappointed. Bon appetit!! read more

Great little pizza joint. Excellent salads and sides. They have Coke! I will go back.

Most delicious pizza and cheesesteaks!! Definitely my go to place! Friendly service too! Love!

Again this is a place where my family has been long time customers. The pizza is great with just the right amount of cheese, sauce and crispy but wonderfully soft crust. Subs, pasta dishes are popular in our family as well and everything has come out great. I believe at one point we had a mix up and the owner offered to make it right and we ended up getting that item taken off our bill and got it free the next time. Everyone is pleasant and easy to deal with as well. read more

Their Alfredo is thin. It is jarred Alfredo with water. I'm unimpressed. The rest is good

Everything was disgusting. The roll on my wife's chicken cheesesteak was cold and soaked in water. When the cheesesteak was unwrapped it fell through the wrapping paper I ordered an Italian grinder, toasted. It came cold, untoasted and had brown lettuce When we went in to return the food, owner was gruff and rude. The replacement food wasn't much better. This location is trash. Food is trash. Spend your mom elsewhere. read more

Man, why can't I find a pizzeria that doesn't serve day old pizza to their lunch customers? Pizza is very inexpensive and losing customers over saving very little doesn't make sense. read more

Good prices. Good subs and pizza. Good basic Italian food. We come here often. Try it. You will like it. Carry out window too. read more

Two cousins pizza Columbia Avenue Lancaster - Two cousins interior - Pizza Near Me - Lancaster, Pennsylvania

Pizza sauce is homemade and excellent. Stromboli is some of the best around. Delivery is always prompt and correct.

The food here is excellent. I had an Italian stromboli and it was bomb. Although, who in their right mind would put marinara on a cheesesteak sub? Anyways the service was great my waitress was super nice and accommodating I think her name starts with a k or something. I left my number on the check so who knows maybe I'll get lucky and find out... read more

I understand that late night orders are bound to be sub-par, but this was dismal. I ordered ravioli, which came with a salad. NO utensils were given to me. How are you supposed to eat a salad without utensils?? Also the marinara was watery and gross, and the raviolis were still FROZEN. Never going back. read more

Food is good; but the service is awful. I've been hung up on multiple times when placing orders for pick up or deliver after holding for 2-3 minutes. read more

As of January 2015, I have no idea what happened here. I used to recommend Two Cousins to everybody in my neighborhood... I live 5 minutes away. Last year I even had my birthday dinner here with about a dozen family members and the service and food was outstanding. (Usually we get takeout, so hadn't experienced the service dining in very often.) But over the past couple months it's taken a sudden and drastic decline. The last few times we got takeout resulted in: - Jalapeno poppers that appeared burned but were actually undercooked inside. (As a former restaurant worker, I know this is indicative of old frying oil that hasn't been changed in a while.) - A chicken parm sub on which the cheese was just this thick plastic-y strip sitting on top that I peeled away, because it was inedible. - A cheesesteak with underbaked, squishy bread (the chicken parm sub was the same with the bread) - Undercooked stromboli filled with poor quality cheese and barely any meat. Overall, the quality is just not there anymore. The bread has especially become greasy and chewy/soggy. We'll probably give it some time and try again in a couple months, just because it's in such a convenient location and the quality used to be there... but if it's more of the same I think we'll have to retire it as an option. read more

Im from jersey and two cousins is the only pizza i would eat in this whole county! I would recommend to anyone who likes jersey/philly/nyc type pizza. I had tried italian dishes hoagies and many types of pizza here. Everything usvery good read more

I would give this zero if I could. I went here with my friend who has celiac disease...we called and asked for a simple salad...no bread because of a gluten allergy. We get the salad home and as she is eating it notices she ate a crouton. I called them to let them know and the manager wouldn't even talk to me. Kept sending the lady on the phone to me to deal with me. How unprofessional....you are servesafe certified and you can't even realize that croutons are bread. Nothing but a possible discount was offered and that was barely offered. She went to the manager twice and he would not talk to me. I'm extremely disappointed in this place now. I've been a long time customer but not anymore. You should have your cert takin away. Shame read more

I really don't understand why they don't have 5 stars because every single time I come they make their pizza fresh and it's amazing! Even if I only ordered a slice! I honestly would rate this the best best pizza in Lancaster & they're so friendly read more

I've been getting take out from these guys for the past year, so they are obviously doing something right since I can't stop myself from coming back! I enjoy their Stromboli's the most. I've ordered their personal sized pizzas and they are pretty bland; the crust is thin and wet and as I picked up a slice all the cheese and toppings fell right off. There are multiple times where they have messed up my order. read more

Last night, decided to try something different other then my favorite sub. What a mistake!!! 2 slices of cheese pizza which had absolutely no flavor at all. Also 2 wraps 1 chicken Cesar the other Italian. The chicken Cesar was just lettuce and chicken strips NO dressing and extremely tasteless. However the Italian had meat but once again there was no dressing or seasonings to compliment either sandwich. I do not recommend this place if you want some authentic flavored Italian food. I was so disappointed! read more

I used to visit the Oregon Pike location every week (I worked in the area) and I always had a great experience. I've only been to the location on Columbia twice but I won't be back. The place is always empty and both times my food was terrible. This time I asked if they would remake it (chicken Caesar wrap was all chicken so I asked if they would add lettuce) and they came back with a sloppy plate with brown lettuce stuffed in the half eaten wrap. I ended up asking to have it taken off the bill and I felt uncomfortable like I had done something wrong. There's too many pizza joints in the area for them to offer sub-par food and mediocre service. read more

This is probably the nicest and best pizza place in Lancaster. The staff is very nice too.

Went here on Friday evening and not many customers there on what should have been a busy time.Food quality has slipped in recent months and the waitress was brutal.She basically threw the menus at us and would disappear for 10 minutes at a time.We had our food and she never check with us again to see how our food was or if we need refills on our drinks.This was at one time our family's go to place,not anymore.If want to go there please rethink this as your option. read more

I don't understand what happened to this place. When they first opened their food was amazing, fresh, and tasty. We live in the neighborhood and order often . Over the past 5 years, the food quality has TANKED. I ordered the Chesapeake Alfredo for pick up. When I opened it at home, the sauce was the consistency of milk. It tasted like hot milk. Noodles were swimming in this hot soupy milk mess. OMG. Didn't even taste like Alfred. No seasoning either. I actually took it back to the restaurant and the three people in the front seemed irritated that I brought my food back. He tipped the container over and I said, is it supposed to look soupy milk? And he started talking to another employee in Spanish, looked at me, and said, this is the way we make it. No apologies, no offer to refund, or make it right . I ended up waiting for lasagna. Which also sucked. I will never ever ever ever come back here. Shame on you guys for serving food like that. It's a rip off. I don't know if ownership changed or what, but not he same place that opened years ago. You've lost two Very loyal customers. And I'll be warning friends to steer clear. read more