Great ice cream! We were really impressed with the unique flavors and quality of this little ice cream shop. Our favorites were the strawberry ice cream and the peach ice cream and both were absolutely delicious. The ice cream itself was so fluffy and creamy - the texture was absolute perfection. So yummy! What a cute little spot and the gentleman who served us was so kind and welcoming. read more

I love it when they bring these old style soda shops back! Like stepping backing in time. Such a cool nostalgic vibe with lots of candy by the pound and little toys and trinkets, a kid's paradise that adults will love and enjoy. Lots of different sundaes to choose from and scoops for waffle and sugar cones. We went for their version of a banana split. This was epic with the best ice cream combo, banana with peanut butter drizzle and peanuts. It was fantastic with tons of whipped cream! This place is perfect for birthdays or dessert after dining at one of Canton's many restaurants. Really loved it! Only thing I would say is I wished that didn't use plastic disposable spoons and boats. read more

See all

This was our first time visiting historic Canton. We spotted A Cone to Pick after kick boarding for 4 miles along the river at Etowah River Park. While the current business is newer, you get the feeling it's been there longer given the history brick. There is a bar with a soda jerk feeling which was typically found in pharmacies but there is no evidence of one here previously, and I couldn't independently verify this. Cone to Pick had a laundry list of ice crème flavors which made it difficult to come to a decision. I knew I wanted a milkshake and finally chose one with butter pecan ice crème. Our hosts gave us generous samples to make up our minds. My daughter tasted the milkshake and was not a fan, but I liked it. She had a sugar cone with birthday cake ice crème, and we took it all Togo so we could peruse all the scenery along Main Street. You can hang out inside or enjoy your sweet treats inside if it rains. Either way you'll make a good choice for desert if you come to A Cone to Pick. We look forward to our next trip here. read more

Dessert can be a tricky thing. Sometimes something light is needed- just a hint of sweetness after a heavy meal. Sometimes you want to forget the meal and get a monster dessert. And sometimes, you just need something fun. A Cone To Pick is number three. Waffle cones and bowls made in the spot. A wall full of custom flavors. Decor that sent me on a nostalgia trip. And super nice staff that was on the spot, helpful, and fun to talk with. I had the Superman regular in the waffle bowl. It's a raspberry, banana and strawberry blend, but really reminds me more of my childhood. It was a little like that seen in RATATOUILLE where the snobby food critic takes one bite and was suddenly back in his mother's kitchen. The Superman bowl was summers wading in the creek, rollerskating, and singing "Rubber Ducky" because it was the best song I knew. Yup, it's that good. My wife had a waffle bowl with banana pudding and bourbon truffle. She rates it a 9- the banana pudding was good but had a bit of that artificial banana flavor as opposed to real banana. It's just part of ice cream, unfortunately. Not bad, just life. They have CHEERWINE in glass bottles! For the unwashed heathen masses, this is a staple of college in the Carolinas. It's like cherry coke that tastes good, unlike actual cherry coke. The nostalgia trip is so cool. They have a real soda fountain and bar to sit at. The bathrooms are clean (this is important). And the hours are good. The classic candy found there really was fun to examine. Would we go back? You bet your skippy. read more

First time coming into this shop and my wife and I fell in love with it. It's a mix of an ice cream fountain store, knickknack shop, and vintage store all in one. So much cool stuff, we needed up buying couple small things (fish fortune tellers and a cat nip toy for our cats). The ice cream is so darn good (butter pecan is a must). I'm excited to live around here now because I want to try more stuff here and bring our baby girl for lil treats. read more

This place is wonderful. The flavors of ice cream are amazing. The staff is so lovely and helpful. I went in by happenstance after seeing it out of the corner of my eye. Not only do they have wonderful flavors, they also have an amazing soda fountain. I had an ice cream float with creme soda and a juicy blue cherry. It was all delicious. I brought home some apple pie and chocolate cheesecake pints. They lasted 2 days. I am actually on my way there again right now. You definitely need to stop by and visit Stephanie and her staff ! read more

See all

Great ambiance and old fashioned flavors. Haven't had a float in years. They have a wide selection and great service! read more

See all

Amazing service and the people were great and 'thats it' it was fabulous and oh so relaxing

Such a cool little place! Antiques and ice cream what more could you want? Right in the heart of downtown Canton, this location is so easy to walk to and has something for the whole family. 10/10 read more

A Cone To Pick - Bourdon Truffle & Cappuccino Crunch - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Canton, Georgia

The place has an old, pungent smell and needs to be cleaned up well. There were a young man and lady in there and she was the only one serving us, while the guy was just standing there. Then I found out that the ice cream they serve is not homemade as it was presented somewhere, but it is a Hershey ice cream, full of ... that should not be consumed by any human being. I will never be back to that place read more

Dreamy and creamy ice cream! Great location for walking off ice cream and close to delicious restaurants!

Great little shop in downtown Canton. Had a banana split and it was so good and they also had a bunch of old school candy

Cute little ice cream pallor Ice cream was great. I had the sundae and husband had strawberry ice cream in waffle cone. Definitely will be back. read more

A Cone To Pick - Kiddie sundae Build Your Own - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Canton, Georgia

We have been coming to this ice cream shop for years, though today we sat at the ice cream bar with our 3 and 6 year olds only to be shocked that the girl working was too busy chatting with a young boy to even acknowledge our presence. After a few minutes, we interrupted their conversation and asked what was required to order ice cream....we were informed that "there is a screen in front where orders can be place". This had never been the case before, we loved the old fashion ice cream shop atmosphere where employees didn't seem annoyed by our presence. She then proceeded to insinuate that we were dumb for not knowing how to order, stating "the process has been this way for awhile". We promptly left. I'd like to assume the owners would hate to know this is how a once quaint and inviting ice cream shop is now being run. If anyone wanted self service, they could go to Racetrac. Hope things improve as we would love to continue to support small town businesses read more

An absolutely adorable Ice shop in the heart of downtown Canton. A very warm and friendly atmosphere and serves up some wonderful ice cream dishes. The brownie Sunday was just amazing. From the bar stools to the old wooden creaking floor to all the old time signs on the wall. So many old cute antiques to looks at while enjoying your favorite treat. When dining in downtown Canton you need to stroll on over to "A Cone To Pick". read more

See all

Excellent ice cream options, including gluten free cones and dairy free options! The bourbon truffle ice cream was AMAZING, and the vibe is relaxed and cool. What a great place with excellent service and dessert!!! read more

This place is awesome! We enjoyed some delicious ice cream and a root beer float on a hot summer day. The service was friendly and we will definitely be back highly recommend! read more

Very disappointed in this place. Was ignored and didn't even get a hello or how are you when I walked in. Not to mention I heard screaming coming from the back of the store. Do not recommend. Do bette,r A Cone To Pick. read more

Awesome choices, cool atmosphere! The Brown Cow was super yummy! The kids' cup size was super generous.

Such a cute place! They have some great throwback items like 96 rock and turtles T-shirts and all sorts of cute other little things. And it's set up like an old ice cream soda bar. We got a banana split and chocolate malt. They were really good. It would've only been better if they made their own ice cream. They use Hershey's. They only have bottled water, which was a bit of a disappointment. Sometimes it's nice to just have a small cup of water when you're shoving heavy ice cream down your throat rather than having to pay 1.50+ for a whole bottle. Great location in downtown Canton and the folks are friendly and helpful. Definitely a nice treat while you're roaming around! read more

I'm obsessed!!!!!! this place was so incredible, I'll definitely be going back soon!! I was in shock at how well this place was set up, such a sweet hidden gem!! read more

See all

Five stars all around! A Cone to Pick has become our new favorite ice cream joint. The place is located in downtown canton which is so convenient for us. I LOVE the atmosphere and vibe this place gives off. They have a little shop at the front and then the ice cream parlor in the middle. The ice cream parlor kind of reminds me of a 1950's soda fountain and actually opening one of these types of places has always been my dream job. So one being so close to home is a big win on my end. They had tons of flavors to choose from and the ice cream taste great! I can't wait to go back and try lots of new flavors. Please support your local businesses and check out A Cone to Pick! read more

See all

Got the Banana Pudding ice cream in a waffle cone that I watched someone make from scratch. I'll definitely be back read more

A Cone To Pick - Banana Pudding Ice Cream in a Waffle Cone - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Canton, Georgia

Cozy, warm, cute, classic, tasty, affordable and perfect for families. Great customer service is the cherry on top :) read more

A Cone To Pick - Amazing looking place. Classic look and affordable offerings - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Canton, Georgia

A Cone to Pick is a rad little pad that will serve you up some delicious ice cream. The staff is fast, friendly, and knowledgeable. The business is clean, organized, and has its own style. In the current world, it's hard to find a place with staff that seems to enjoy their job. This is one place where you won't seem to have that problem. When we went, we brought our two kiddos and they were patient while they made their selections. Will definitely return. Only reason I didn't give it a fifth star is that their seating was very limited. With two younger kids, having only bar top seating can be challenging. But don't let that stop you from going - this place is well worth the stop. read more

Love this place, delicious flavors, cool vibe. Apple cider here in the fall is just divine. Great little date night spot.

The locals of Canton will be familiar with this nostalgic ice cream parlor that sits right in the middle of the main street of the historic downtown area. The ice cream here has definitely become a favorite of my family and friends (and we were regulars at the other ice cream stops in the area.) My go to flavors are the dark chocolate raspberry truffle with a raspberry sorbet in a waffle cone, but with a dozen other flavors there's plenty of choice for all tastes buds. Can't go wrong here folks. 5 out of 5. read more

Our family LOVES this place. We came in once over the summer on a hot day as an escape and reason to satisfy our sweet tooth's...and now we won't go anywhere else in Canton! Unique spins on classic favorites...5 Stars, all day long! read more

We were there today, 06/26/2022, at 3:00 pm. We got our order like always and sat down inside. When my four year old needed to go to the restroom, my husband went up to the register and asked the girl running the register if they had a restroom. She said the closest restroom is at Panera down the road. He walked with my four year old to Panera while I stayed with the other kids inside. I don't know any of their names because there were no name tags; so the girl working the register proceeded to laugh and joke with the other girls there about the fact that my husband had to walk with our son to Panera to use the restroom. It was not smart to do this while mom (me) was sitting 20 feet away because this made me angry and uncomfortable in a place we love to take the kids! I never noticed until today how not kid friendly this place is not having a restroom. But the snide remarks by the employee about my husband and son was it for me. I will say that when you look back on reviews the only bad ones are about their staff. There was one girl there working and was proactively very nice and polite that scooped the ice cream. read more

Wonderful ice cream parlor, trinkets, old school tees & so much more...very nice staff...highly recommend & we will be back!! Lovely location in a beautiful historic downtown area. read more

young man who works there was very disrespectful to my little boy asking for a sample. he groaned and rolled his eyes. he the continued to have a bad attitude read more

Went to try the ice cream at this store but sadly could not. With no sign posted to order at the register we sat at the bar to order with our 2 year old. After the bartender telling us that he would take our order after he completed the order for the person that sat at the bar after we did he told us to place our order at the register. Which was 10 mins after we sat down. Would have not been such an issue except now the line had gone from no one to 4 families. Glade he "didn't want to upset anyone" as he put it. When new customers are not welcome they aren't welcome, won't be going back here. read more