Can't believe I gave them another chance. Ordered a calzone and got a pizza that was just folded in half. read more

A Pizza & More - Ordered a calzone with ham and pineapple. What we got was a medium pizza with ham + pineapple that was just folded in half. - Pizza Near Me - Homer, New York

Nicky C's June 30th 2022, went to order a large pizza and 20 wings.. $61. I hope you are rich to be able to eat here, between the gas to drive there and them bending you over. I am to poor to eat here I guess. read more

I've gotten pizza and more for many many years and I will have to say there's a 50% chance they are going to mess it up or it will taste like garbage and after you get it from there you wish you got it from somewhere better. I walked in and witnessed them burn my chicken parm sub and then proceed to scrape the chicken out of the sub and put it in a new bun and back in the oven. They charged me full price and made me wait. The chicken is as hard as a rock. Pizza more is cancelled. (The styrofoam container is my extra sauce, they told me to warm it up) read more

A Pizza & More - a person taking a bite out of a sandwich - Pizza Near Me - Homer, New York

See all

They have rebranded and are now open. This seems to come with a price increase so that 20 wings and a large pizza is $50. They used breaded deep fried chicken as the topping, instead of cut grilled chicken on the pizza. I have been going that pizza and more since it open when I was in high school, and was the food I wanted to eat at when I came home on leave during my time in the Navy. In its place sadly is a pizza shop with higher prices and looks nice... I won't be going back there. Overall food was OK but not as good. Definitely not for the price. read more

Went here with my boyfriend. I got a "cheese slice" and he got a "buffalo chicken slice". The man told my boyfriend that "that is what a buffalo chicken slice looks like" and that the hair i found in my cheese slice "was mine" and that "how dare i try to get a new slice"... I have super blonde hair. Look closely at the hair that isn't under the flash and see for yourself. Also, don't forget to see all the amount of chicken on the buffalo "chicken" slice. Enjoy your pizza. read more

A Pizza & More - a slice of cheese pizza - Pizza Near Me - Homer, New York

See all

BEST GARLIC PIZZA I HAVE EVER HAD!!!! They add additional herbs to the garlic sauce that makes the pizza more than a garlicky piece of grease! We got broccoli on the pizza, and it was fantastic. I cannot attest to the service as my mother in law picked it up for us but the pizza hit the spot! read more

Thank you Pizza n More for showing your true colors!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!After today my husband an I will NEVER order from this establishment again. At the current time its 7:23pm, my husband had placed the order in at 5:00pm, knowing that I would have to retire at a certain time. This has been my first day off since the pandemic occur being as how I am a first responder and have tended to those in critical need of my services. Not in the county of Cortland but Onondagua , Syracuse to be precise, This is the first time I have acknowledged that I am a first responder to this pandemic due to the fact that it is my job to be there for others in need.. When I am told by manager for the homer store that the driver tried to contact my husband whom had placed the order 2 hours prior, that the driver had tried to contact him. That in truth is a lie, since we have had the same delivery months prior and we have had it within 30 mins. . I and my husband will make it know through all our friends and aquintances not to frequent either establishments. To be honest, the service at both establishments are so below par, I would hope that Guy Fierrey does not make to either...Here's a thought...I will email his PA and crew not to come here along with everyone else involved with the Food Cooking Network. BTW there are no stars available for this review being as how it is soooo below standards of that of homeless kitchen.. read more

We've moved back to the area, and I'm happy to say A Pizza & More has improved their pizza, IF you order it with extra sauce and cooked well done. They still tend to undercook their pizza, but I feel like most places do. What we have discovered is their subs... they are fantastic, especially their parm subs. Their rolls are great and very fresh, and their marinara sauce is tasty. All in all, we really like this place. read more

I liked the pizza, but if you choose to eat-in, the place is creepy. I've liked the pizza a lot more when we got it to go in the past. The have lots of choices for different, fun slices, but when we ate there once the table to dirty and there were old moldy french fries in the cracks of the bench that I was sitting on. I felt uncomfortable and bleh and sat on the edge of my seat the whole time. I would say that next time we will get the slices to go, but it makes me think...if it's that dirty in the "dining room" how does it look in the kitchen? read more

I stopped in for a quick slice of pizza last week. I ordered a buffalo chicken slice as well as a plain slice. The buffalo chicken slice was a little on the bland side. I was surprised because it looked really good. The plain slice was a little better. Overall, I was a little disappointed in this place. read more

I like Pizza and More for their thin, crispy, crusts and bases. However, for those looking for a fluffier pizza not addled with grease, this place is not for you. The eatery is cozy and warm, despite being woefully average. read more

I don't know what was worse, the condition of the restaurant or the shady behavior of the unsupervised staff. We came in after a school concert 15 minutes before closing. It was on a whim hoping it was enough time to get food, we honestly hadn't been there for years but we used to eat there all the time. The old dude and three other staff let us stand there for 2-3 minutes before they said they were done cooking for the night, they were obviously not putting up with us. That was fine, we didn't complain. But for no reason at all (except for the fact that we dared to go to inquire) while we were leaving they make rude comments to us, just loudly enough so that we could hear them. We were shocked, not that they wouldn't serve us but that the employees were so comfortable acting like that with customers. Makes you wonder if the owners know they how their staff represents them and if they care one way or another. Cortland County isn't lacking for pizza and there are many other great options nearby. read more

This place was literally the only place open when I needed to bring home food during a blizzard. I was hopeful having never been there before. The place was dirty. Not just behind the counter, but all through the seating area. They have funky benches at the tables and all of them have food and crap stuck all over them and in the cracks. There is a mirror on the wall that is so greasy and scummy, that from some angles it looks like a solid off-white painting in a black frame. But, I had already committed so i was still hoping the food would be o.k. Not! Not at all! The pizza sucked big time, even by central N.Y. standards You can tell how bad the pizza problem here is because dumps like this manage to stay in business pumping out crap to an obviously tasteless public. The crust on our pizza was dense and flavorless. If I let a crust sit out over night I would have been able to hone it down into a shiv and kill with it. Horrible. The sauce was red and had only one flavor: salt. This was the saltiest thing I have ever eaten, every bite tasted like nothing but salt. We were drinking water all night after forcing down a slice a piece. We ordered half onion and half mushroom and there were hardly any toppings on the damn thing. When I did manage to find a mushroom, it tasted like salt. If you have ever had pizza in any other part of the state avoid this place like the plague. There are places around that do an adequate job, this is not one of them. If you are from this area, enjoy, you tasteless sods. The wings were acceptable. read more

The best pizza and garlic knots. They deliver when and were other places won't. I give this place my 2 thumbs up. You guys rock