The pizza and salad were delicious. We had the American Antipasto salad w/ balsamic vinaigrette. It was loaded with meat and cheese. Then we had a medium Brooklyn Full House (no mushrooms or extra cheese). We both agreed it was some of the best sausage we've had on pizza. One salad and medium pizza was plenty for the two of us. Servers were polite and had everything ready pretty quickly. We arrived around 530 pm on a Wednesday night. Plenty of seating inside. Plenty of parking as well. We would go back in a heartbeat! read more

See all

Food was very good we are impressed. I got the large chicken vodka pizza and some fries for about $30, it was a good quantity so I'd say it was worth it. The parking lot is very small for this location and the store is consistently crowded so be prepared to wait over an hour for one pie but other than that great experience. read more

Brooklyn Pizza - Grill - Chicken vodka pizza - Pizza Near Me - Lancaster, Pennsylvania

See all

100% the real deal. If you told me this was from nyc, Long Island or jersey I wouldn't even question it. I got the garlic knots, Sicilian pie (great price by the way), and an eggplant parm sub and everything was seriously on point. Without question the best pizza and eggplant I've had outside the nyc area without question. They deliver via Slice for a fee by the way... totally worth it. read more

We ordered onion rings and their Grandma Pizza. It's kind of what they are known for and now I know why. I wanted some comfort food for the snow storm and this hit the spot. The service was great. They were full and seemed to have a lot of to go orders but they were fully staffed and super friendly. Our food was hot and ready on time. It's a cute little place that is cozy with tables and a nice casual atmosphere. I'm so glad we went. read more

Brooklyn Pizza - Grill - Grandma pizza and onion rings. - Pizza Near Me - Lancaster, Pennsylvania

Must say, for Pennsylvania pizza, this place was pretty good. Just got the regular pie, but was rather tasty. As a New Yorker who gets great pizza, id recommended this spot if your in the area. Service was friendly and quick. Nice size pizza place with plenty of seating. read more

Our favorite pizza in Lancaster, Pennsylvania! Always made fresh, crisp, chewy crust, and great sauce! read more

Brooklyn Pizza - Grill - Pepperoni and onion pizza on Valentine's Day - Pizza Near Me - Lancaster, Pennsylvania

As much as I wanted to love this place, sadly, I just couldn't. The Stromboli, actually a large, crescent shaped calzone (Stromboli is rolled into layers) was pretty empty inside, and where there was evidence of steak and cheese it wasn't great. Its only salvation was the accompanying vat of tomato sauce. My companion's chicken cheesesteak was left flat by the old school bland Amoroso's roll. The sample slice was dry and flavorless. Not much good to write home about here, but we'll visit again and hope for better results. read more

Solid pizza spot if you are in or around Lancaster. Eden hotel is a stones throw down the road. Its a great go to for a large pie for the family. We usually get a grilled chicken cobb salad on the side. Great portions and value. A Slice of Brooklyn - In! fuggedaboutit! read more

Ordered delivery. Fast delivery. Personal Ham & Cheese calzone was mostly bread & lacked substance. Large Cheese Pizza was decent. Pricing was a little less than our normal pizza shop. read more

Pizza La Vida *Warning* This review contains pizza that has--gasp shock horror--non-traditional ingredients on them. Pizza purists avert your delicate eyes and go take a long walk off a short pier (i.e., go fuck yourselves). We needed to feed a bunch of people before a graduation ceremony, and the one thing that everyone can agree on is pizza, of course. After looking at multiple places to order from, we settled on A Slice of Brooklyn (SoB) after one of Carissa's kids mentioned they'd been there before and tried a seafood pizza that was fantastic. That was enough to spark my curiosity, and we placed our order along with several other more "traditional" pies. The Good: *Pizza Del Mar (from the sea) lived up to the hype! They were molto generoso with the crab and shrimp, and the thick, rectangular Sicilian crust was fantastic. Crispy on the outside and pillowy soft on the inside. I don't eat pizza much anymore, but if we lived nearby, this would def be in my rotation. *They were able to whip out three pies very quickly; we ordered over the phone, drove over, and were back in less than 30 minutes. *Dug the vibe of the place with a big open kitchen and comfy-looking booths. This looked like a fine place to dine-in. *Prices were very reasonable, but I'm from Cali, so what do I know? ¯\_(ツ)_/¯ The Meh: *Wasn't a fan of their thin NY-style crust, as it just didn't have that chew I look for in it. I mean, it was OK, but nowhere near as good as their Sicilian crust. The Ugly: *Wish we ordered a second Del Mar as it was definitely the most popular of the three pies. Don't make this same mistake! TLDR: The Del Mar and Sicilian crust are both worth the price of admission. Highly recommended. read more

See all

Real good pizza! Mobster memorabilia everywhere and this joint can make a solid slice. We had the veggie and the Del Mar. In my opinion, the veg topped the seafood. read more

Brooklyn Pizza - Grill - Del Mar - Pizza Near Me - Lancaster, Pennsylvania

See all

This place was a 10/10. I came here for lunch ordered a cheesesteak & fries and it did its thing. The wait wasn't too long despite it being busy. The workers were cool and there wasn't anything to complain about. The place is filled with things from NYC its pretty dope. The cheesesteak tasted amazing and the cheese they used on it was really good. The fries were cripsy and did what it did. I will definitely be coming back. read more

Brooklyn Pizza - Grill - Cheese steak - Pizza Near Me - Lancaster, Pennsylvania

See all

First off, their food is absolutely delicious. I've had several different kinds of pizza, salads and subs. Definitely try their Grandma's pizza :) The service is always outstanding, every employee I've encountered is friendly & accommodating. They're quick and always will fix what doesn't seem right. The restaurant is clean and spacious. read more

Brooklyn Pizza - Grill - Crispy chicken salad and garlic knots - Pizza Near Me - Lancaster, Pennsylvania

Awesome food, people, service and prices. Highly recommended. The "Grandma's Pizza". A picture of what's left of mine as I write this serves it no justice - it is fantastic! read more

Brooklyn Pizza - Grill - Grandma's Pizza. Too good to wait to get a picture of it! - Pizza Near Me - Lancaster, Pennsylvania

Had a couple of slices of pizza. Not bad for the area. They had many different pizzas available for choosing slices.

So after a very disappointing experience at my first choice of restaurants... while walking back to my hotel saw this place... Now being born in Brooklyn and growing up in NY I was a little skeptical but was hungry! So overall the staff was very nice...but while it's a decent pizza...it doesn't compare with "Brooklyn" pizza...which is a whole other level... read more

Wow. First time here! Delicious pie. Sauce & cheese just the best!! Positive & professional the moment you walk through the door. Great service with a smile. Can't wait to try other dishes!! read more

WHAT? I'M SORRY I CAN'T HEAR YOU. CAN YOU TURN THE MUDIC DOWN?? I should have realized that the music that flooded the parking lot was coming from inside the restaurant. I had to shout my order which, of course, meant that I didn't get what I thought I was ordering. My order was a cheesesteak -- only ordinary. Super soft roll filled with a mixture of chopped meat ( ground beef and/or beef -- not sure), grilled onions, and cheese with a bit of tomato sauce. Everything was mixed together, so it was hard to say what was what. I thought I ordered one slice of pizza -- but I got -- and apparently paid for -- two slices. I don't know how long the pizza was sitting out, but it was dried up, curled up, and pretty much flavorless. No moisture, very little sauce, and a dry crust. Disappointing. Nope. Never going back. read more

3.5 Stars You know it's gonna be good, if the parking lots smells like Little Italy. This place screams, pizza! I peeked into the back cooking area and witnessed the makings of fresh pizza. Behind the counter were a variety of pizzas, some with and without toppings. I ordered a small pie with prosciutto. Loved it! A thin, chewy crust, tomato sauce tasted homemade, cheese not oily and I downed the entire pie, occasionally coming up for air. An ordered of fried mushrooms, seemed of the frozen variety and I would have preferred more prosciutto. I will definitely be back. read more

Great pizza and a lot of the charm of an old school pizza parlor. I mean they have the things.

We just got into town we just got into our hotel and they fepwith in 5 min great pizza and salad!!

It's not bad - I've lived in Brooklyn for 21 years and I can say their Grandma Pie is as close to what I can find in Bay Ridge. The aroma and overall taste are great, making the trip worthwhile. That being said, the sauce lacks that tangy tomato burst that I miss, as well as the crust missing that burnt char crunch. But overall - very happy i made the trip. read more

Stopped in for a quick lunch. Best pizza ever!!! They offer so many gourmet pizzas but I went with plain cheese. So good. I wish I lived closer because I wouldn't order pizza elsewhere! read more

I love their pizza!! The service was great and the guys vere very attentive. Dining in was a pleasant experience. Most of the time I just get the pizza to go, but either way you can't go wrong with Brooklyn Pizza! read more

This place was not what I was expecting! I was thinking that this place would be just like every other pizza and sub shop, but it turns out it wasn't. The pizza was VERY fresh and the wings had a perfect amount of sauce on them. The entire meal only costed $30 for a pizza and a dozen boneless wings! The service was fantastic, they were so friendly and very efficient with making the food. I definitely like the Brooklyn NY theme, they did a really good job decorating the place. It isn't overly decorated and is very nice! Overall, I would love to come back to this place if we're near the city again, would HIGHLY recommend if you're in the mood for pizza, but at a FANTASTIC price! read more

Brooklyn Pizza - Grill - Honey BBQ boneless wings - Pizza Near Me - Lancaster, Pennsylvania

See all

The pizza here is delicious - especially the Sicilian. This is our go to pizza place when visiting the Lancaster area. Their eggplant, meatballs, and pasta are also excellent. The owner and his staff are all so nice and welcoming. read more

Called and asked what type of sausage came on pizza. Told sliced. Definitely not. It's likely Sysco frozen premade sausage balls. Tastes like a bad Jimmy dean breakfast sausage. Pizza was raw and under cooked. 2 stars only because I got delivery in bad weather and the girl on the phone was nice, though she has no idea how the pizzas are made. Hands down worst pizza I have had in years. I'm sorry to say that but I really don't want other people to fall into these fake ratings. Ordered 3 pies. Not one person had more than one slice or could finish a slice. read more

Brooklyn Pizza - Grill - a slice of cheese pizza - Pizza Near Me - Lancaster, Pennsylvania

Now charging a 4% fee for credit card charges. That is higher than they are paying. While service and food remains adequate, they are soon pricing themselves out of our "go to" location. read more

The absolutely best authentic New York pizza in Lancaster county I am an old New Yorker pizza snob and very particular of pizza Really nice hard working owners who grew up in Naples Italy'! Try it, you will NOT be disappointed Their other menu items as also excellent read more

Best pizza in Lancaster as a Brooklyn Ny native. We were visiting Lancaster when we were all crazing NYC pizza and that's exactly what we got with a slice of Brooklyn. We ordered regular pies and pepperoni , bbq wings as well and it was all amazing! read more

Must try!!.. If your from Jersey or NYC and are looking for a place to have great pizza like your used to having then look no further. The grandma pie is a must try! Service is what I would expect from a good pizza joint in Brooklyn. You can tell without asking they have Brooklyn in their blood. Place is big enough. You order at the counter and find a seat when the pizza is ready they'll call your name. read more

Brooklyn Pizza - Grill - Grandma - Pizza Near Me - Lancaster, Pennsylvania

"Pie from the sky"- The only way to describe this pizza is "heavenly " -I.e. from the heavens. I honestly read a several reviews on Yelp that suggested the Pizza Del Mar and the Sicilian crust and that's what I had. It's about 5/8" thick with a crispy buttery bottom and edges. They did not skimp on the crab or shrimps for the toppings and all in all it was a beautifully made pie! The 3 men at the oven shouted out "have you ever seen a more beautiful pie?" with a heavy accent. It was a great pie and the have a New York thin crust too that they will crisp up like a cracker if you ask or leave soft. Accommodating people work here. Try it, you'll like it! read more

Brooklyn Pizza - Grill - The delicious & beautiful Pizza Del Mar! - Pizza Near Me - Lancaster, Pennsylvania

They do not prepare your food how you would like it. Service was ok. They place is clean. My main problem was when I asked for my sauce to be cooked in my Stromboli and not on the side they said No? Why? read more

We were here a couple of weeks ago and had pizza which was good no doubt but what intrigued me was the decor. There was a poster of Italian mob families in NY, I took a picture but now cannot find it on my phone. Anyway, I liked the decor it is interesting. read more

This place is close to where I work and I recently noticed their sign changed. I assume they may now be under new ownership however the menu has remained the same as far as I can tell. They offer a 2 slice with drink lunch special here but since COVID-19 practices have been put into effect the deal has changed from being able to choose gourmet slices to regular cheese slices. Unfortunately, the price has remained the same and they will charge for extra toppings. At $7 this does not seem like a great deal. I ordered a chicken cheese steak that came with provolone, sauce, onions, peppers, mushrooms and pepperoni. The roll was good and the cheese was stringy. I felt the sauce could have been improved upon. The chicken was overcooked, mealy and dry. I do not know if adding more sauce would have remedied it but it was worth noting. Takeout is only available at this time. read more

Brooklyn Pizza - Grill - Brooklyn Full House Chicken Cheese Steak - Pizza Near Me - Lancaster, Pennsylvania

Yummy! eggplant parm sandwich was so good, my 10 year old loved the pepperoni, we also ordered the margherita pizza and it was delicious, will definitely be back 5A+ read more

Brooklyn Pizza - Grill - Pizza Near Me - Lancaster, Pennsylvania

See all

Best pizza in town by far! A weekly go to for our family. The never disappoint. This is the best pizza I've had outside of New Jersey.

I was in town for an event and the ever reliable yelp search for solid pizza lead me to this place. Based on the accents of the employees I am confident that the owners are Brooklyn bred. My table shared the Buffalo Chicken salad, the Grandmas Pizza Pie, and a salad. All were wonderful. I had 3 teenage boys that were reading to chow down and were anticipating generic pizza. To their surprise (not mine) they all loved the pizza! The grandma was terrific. They were initially turned off by the tomato sauce combined with pesto but It worked!!! The salad was wonderful as well. And the bill...wonderful as well. Great restaurant! I'd like to return to try some of the pasta as the price alone had me drooling. read more

See all

Visiting Lancaster for a basket ball tournament and as a team we decided to get pizza. Not only the food was great, the people were so kind. We ordered takeout and when we picked it up, they helped us take it out to the car. The service is amazing, too! I ordered 8 pizza's, 5 hoagies, and 3 orders of fries, and it was ready in 45 minutes. The food and service was just phenomenal. I do not regret going to " A Slice of Brooklyn Pizza." read more

4 star overall earned for the 5-star worthy Mamma's pizza. Other pizzas also good. But sandwiches a little uninspired. Knowing the pizza was good tried sandwiches a few times recently. Cheese steak just ok, and the Italian hoagie was a disappointment. But, go for the mamma's pizza! read more