Ordered a large (16") mushroom and onion pizza, and I enjoyed it. My first time getting a pie from here and next time I'll ask for it to be cooked a bit more. It's not a thin crust, but seems the fermentation of the dough is long enough for a nice subtle taste. I did my fermentation for at least 36 hrs sometimes 72 hrs when making pizza dough. The sauce had nice balance of sweet to acidic. The low-moisture mozzarella could use a bit more pull (quality) but had enough flavor. Overall a good pizza, it will satisfy the craving. read more

Strasburg Pizza - 16" mushroom onion - Pizza Near Me - Strasburg, Pennsylvania

Awesome food, great prices and the owners and staff are so very friendly!!! They also give our Strasburg Senior Citizens group a 10% discount whenever we eat there!! :) read more

Everything including taste, quality and staff. The prices are good and the taste is excellent.

Great sandwich shop! Nice selection of subs and entrees. The bread is fantastic! Super convenient to the Holiday Inn and always a go-to for me when in the area. read more

We travel to Strasburg once or twice a year and always make a point of eating here. The food is always very good and the staff is friendly.

Just okay. I wouldn't go out of my way to get good here. Decent slice of pizza if you're in the area and don't want to go out of your way, but there's definitely better pizza elsewhere. read more

amazing nuggets and pizza, flavourful crust and sauce! service is amazing and the people are very nice!

Absolutely excellent Italian American restaurant. We have been coming to Strasburg Pizza since it's inception. Food is served fresh and hot. Lasagna is bubbly hot with the perfect mix of beef, cheese and noodles. Baked ziti is also a home run. Pizza is the best in the area. The owner (Charlie) is a really great guy. Pricing is incredibly affordable. If you haven't been the this place your missing out on some great food. read more

the slices i had were good. Heres some pics https://travelmystery.blogspot.com/2024/02/strasburg-pizza.html

Don't come here here's a big warning there's photos and closed of The cheesesteak hoagies I had told the person that was in the video I just videoed that I'd like another one made with meat, and they refused and this is what they gave me for the grand total of how much is their cheese steak hoagies here $7 cheese steak hoagie! I asked if they would remake it and put meat in it, they refused ... Too many very good pizzerias around for these people to charge prices like this and the quality of food not to be found at all!!!! read more

Strasburg Pizza - Don't come here unless you want to pay $$7.00 for bread!!!! - Pizza Near Me - Strasburg, Pennsylvania

See all

Had lunch here after church. This little spot was in the informational binder at our friends hotel room. We should of gone to another place. We ordered a salad and a couple of pizzas. The salad was a very bland Iceberg lettuce and the pizzas were very doughy! Like they needed to be cooked longer. There wasn't any browning on the top of either one. On a good note. The water and diet soda Wes good. Go to plan "B" y'all . read more

Strasburg Pizza - Lunch after church! - Pizza Near Me - Strasburg, Pennsylvania

See all

Absolutely the best pizza around, served hot and bubbly from the oven. Have been coming here since they opened. Never have been disappointed. Great Italian pasta dishes also. Staff is efficient and polite. P.S. Sub sandwiches are fresh, full of various meats and cheeses, excellent. You can have a feast for a very affordable price. read more

You know about all the excellent Amish and PA Dutch food you can find in the Lancaster area, no doubt. But sometimes you have had enough broasted chicken, mashed potatoes, and shoo-fly pie for a while and want a change of pace. Pizza is a good alternative. I can speak only to the excellent thin crust pizza we had. The pepperoni was spicy, and the crust was nice and thin. A medium pizza with 6 large slices was about $10 and a good value. They also offer a thick crust Sicilian pizza and a large selection of hot and cold subs. Service was fast and friendly - it took about 10 minutes for the pick-up order to be ready. The only unusual aspect of ordering over the phone: they don't ask for a name or phone number but give you an order number. You give that number when you arrive: "I am here for order 67," for example. Not a big deal. Overall a good value and place I would return to. read more

Strasburg Pizza - Thin crust medium size pepperoni pizza - Pizza Near Me - Strasburg, Pennsylvania

See all

This pizza was just ok. It was convenient. It was huge. You could feed a small army. We ate only 6 slices. read more

Strasburg Pizza - a pizza in a box - Pizza Near Me - Strasburg, Pennsylvania

Wow!! Moved here from New Jersey about a year ago looked so hard for a place to get pizza been to quite a few and never found what we were looking for Until we stoped one day here at Strasburg pizza got to say people like I said I'm from jersey where's there's a pizza place on every corner This place here in PA Ranks in the top of the list for me pizza is very good sandwiches are really good also a Must stop place we enjoy also eating there to get that pizza hot out of the oven Trust Me Try this place !!!! read more

Twice I have ordered pizza with onions. Both times the pizza had a pool of liquid sitting on the top. The pizza was so soggy you couldnt even pick it up. When I complained the second time they told me its because the onions release a lot of liquid. I have had pizza with onions from many places and it never looked like this. Would not order again. Use to love this place but it seems their quality is not as good as in the past. read more

The woman at the counter was extremely rude, we went to pick up our order and they forgot to make it and then did not offer to discount our order. when we finally got it the order was incorrect. We will not be returning. That was our second terrible experience with the same woman. read more

A nice little pizzeria place, lots of options to order. Went with my family and friend, food was good, not bad. The picture attached is what I ordered, tortellini alfredo and it came with a side salad and bread. The sauce was pretty thick and the tortellini were shaped smaller than usual but I didn't mind that. I got caesar dressing with my salad, a lot of raw onions with sweet peppers and tomatoes. The caesar dressing didn't taste that much like caesar, more like Italian/vinegar. The bread was good, came with cute little rectangle blocks of butter. Overall nice place if you want casual pizzeria dining. read more

Strasburg Pizza - Tortellini Alfredo - Pizza Near Me - Strasburg, Pennsylvania

Busy Friday night, rainy, week between Christmas & New Years, full moon.....any excuse; bottom line: terrible pizza. Crust had crunchy bottom, absolutely no rise, no air bubbles, no yeast aroma....nothing. Sauce...was there any? Cheese is generic SYSCO blend that melts into glob. So far, Lancaster PA is 0 for 2 read more

During a global pandemic, after ordering my pizza I walk in to pick it up to find out of several staff only two were wearing masks. One had a mask hanging off of his ear and was handling it with his gloves that were also used to make the pizzas. I asked for a refund because I was not risking my health by eating from them. The counter staff had NO gloves and NO mask on. After explaining why I wanted a refund the woman at the counters response was "well they're all wearing gloves!!" And I tried to educate her that the virus is spread through droplets from your respiratory tract. Such as in talking over the food while making which is exactly what they were doing. Terrible service and even worse sanitary practices and measures taken during this time. No wonder they the sign on the door said they were hiring and needed counter help. Unfortunately I have to give one star, because no stars is not an option. read more

I've only had the food here once before and it was pizza, it was very good but for whatever reason I haven't tried it again until tonight. Got it delivered due to the Coronavirus and I'm not leaving the house. I got a chicken Parm dinner and my wife got fettuccine Alfredo. Both were by far the best Italian dinners we've had in Lancaster. Will be ordering or visiting many many times in the future. read more

Excellent pizza and garlic knots with extra garlic/oil to mop up! Will definitely eat here again.

This place is amazing. I've ordered several different items and they've all been perfect. It's the best pizza in town. The employees are very helpful. It's clean, it's delicious, it's magic! read more

Placed an order off of their website and it went through GrubHub. Went to pick up.....no order. Re-placed order and waited GrubHub never refunded my account. Owner said it was not his problem. Most owners would of given my next pizza at no cost. Will NEVER return. Will go to Pizza City instead for ever. Just as good and cheaper as well. read more

No one smiles, it's like a staff of angry people who didn't want to be there. We ordered a large [works type of] pizza. I wish I would have known it was going to be smothered in ham, yuck! And not cuts of ham but lunch meat ham. It smelled horribly and was sopping wet in the middle. We took one bite and left it. No need to take it home. But I'll admit, I should have asked what comes on their pizza, my bad, lesson learned. The service is slow, and they did not look understaffed whatsoever. One person in our party (my mother) waited forever for her order. I finally went to the counter figuring they forgot about it. Oh they made it alright, they just forgot to tell the girl up front that it was done and now cold. We paid $60.00 for three of us and ended up leaving and leaving the food behind and seeking dinner elsewhere. What a huge letdown. If they had at least been cordial, I would not have left a negative review. read more

Best pizza around! Charley does so much for the community. We always love supporting Strasburg pizza!

Tucked away next to the beer mart, this quaint little place is very popular with locals, as almost all of the dozen or so small tables were filled with customers when we went here, and stayed that way for our entire visit, not to mention the takeout business this restaurant does. The pizza was very tasty, reminiscent of pizza we would get in upstate New York, and with so many other great things on their menu, I know we will keep coming back here. A big plus for me was finding out that they sell bottles of Pibb Xtra here. I've missed seeing those, after living in California for a year and a half. I'm quite happy here. read more

No masks during a global pandemic, the woman at the counter was very rude, went in and ordered, and went back outside to wait for my food, 20 minutes later I decided to go check if it was ready and it was just sitting there, why didn't they tell me. Anyway it was terrible dont go here !!! Food was trash and unsafe covid protocols read more

Perfect pizza. Real dough, real cheese, real ingredients. Great place to stop in for a meal after a Sight & Sound show.

As someone originally from the northeastern part of the US I totally recommend this gem in Strasburg. The staff is quick and friendly and the pizza is tasty. I had also gotten an antipasto salad which brought me right back to my hometown as a kid. My friend had gotten a calzone while her niece got some stuffed shells which she compared to her mothers as and I quote "pretty dang good" lol. So if you're in the area I say give it a try! read more

Great place to grab something quick for dinner! Strasburg Pizza is our go to for pizza night and or nights mom doesn't feel like cooking! Their pizza is always hot and delicious, my fiancé favors their pizza burger sub and I enjoy the tortellini! Employees always friendly when we order and pick up! read more

Awesome food, best pizza in Strasburg, all jokes aside and no bullshit.. I know the owner cause I see him every time I go in and he's reasonably respectful and kind, As long as your not dumb drunk irresponsible and or rude your good. Awesome place.. food like I said awesome tastes like heaven. Highly recommend if your a pizza and and hot wing fan. Also good variety plenty of options.. read more

Stopped in on a Friday evening after seeing a local show and surprised that service seemed kind of slow for Friday customer demands. The open tables were not clean and so we had to hunt for a clean one. But with all that being said, I really enjoyed my pizza. The sauce was tasty and the crust was just right... a little crispy - just the way I like it. I would definitely go back and give the place another try. read more

1 star is still too much. Worse pizza I ever had. It was already cooked with canned toppings threw on top to make it specific to our order. The only plus was it wasn't greasy... never again!! read more

We were staying at the nearby Clarion Inn, just returned from Sight and Sound show. We are originally from Brooklyn and the Bronx and just wanted some good pizza. So we took a chance and got a nice pie with mushrooms and sausage. The pizza was great and the cost was quite reasonable. Very friendly and I highly recommend Strasburg Pizza. read more

Nice small "self service" pizza place. Pizza by the slice and a lot of hot and cold subs, as well as the usual Italian pasta dinners. Bright, clean, plain interior, reasonable prices, very friendly and helpful staff. Excellent NY style pizza. read more

Great pizza...sauce isn't super sweet like most others and the wings are absolutely awesome!!! Can't comment on much else as I haven't tried it. read more

Came here for pizza with my kids a couple days ago. I really liked how tasty it was. I really liked the dough! I will defiantly be back.

We come here quite often. The pizza is great, as are the subs! The service is fast and friendly.

This place has really awesome sandwiches and fries! And the prices were great: under $20 for two sandwiches, an order of fries and a small drink. It's a little off the beaten path, as it's hidden behind Strasburg Beer Mart, but it's well worth the search. read more