Setting:
After parking around the corner, we walked down Kearney Street, quiet and dark, with our camera flashlights barely illuminating the sidewalk front of us. Then our destination, a bright and modern building almost under the shadow of the Coronado Bridge, came into view. As soon as we stepped into the light, Eddie, the owner & chef, welcomed us for our 6:45pm reservation, and seated in the unique indoor/outdoor dining space with 8 tables on the first floor and a few tables upstairs. Walk-Ins are welcome (first come, first serve) but since the space is small, reservations are recommended. The dining room is decorated with interesting pieces of art and display items, many of which are uniquely inset into the walls with a transparent window protecting them. Heat lamps and patio heaters were also present and fired up so no one caught a chill.
The experience:
Menus were already set on the table. With low lighting, it was very hard to read the tiny font (red letters on black paper). When our waiter, Alex, saw that we were using our phone flashlights to read the menu, he joked that they "really tried to make the menus as hard as possible to read." He then kindly brought over a little lamp for the table that made reading much easier. The narrative and immersive nature of the menu is a whimsical touch. The cocktail menu takes up a page and the so does the food menu, so the menu is manageable.
Marlin Empanadas (Special) - DELICIOUS!
Ceviche - It was fine, but for me, the presentation did not work. M. loved it because he really loves ceviche, but for me, the squid ink just disguised what I was eating and did not enhance the dish for me personally.
Mexican Shrimp - Tasty, but oversauced and slightly overcooked. The shrimp were very firm. The potatoes were good.
Slow Braised Beef (Braseado) - M. said it was delicious, tender, and flavorful. It was also heavily sauced and the beef portion was petite and was only accompanied by 4 brussels sprout halves and a sliver of watermelon radish. For the price ($38), the portion should have been more generous.
Pistachio Cake with mixed berries: Wonderfully light and delicious. A nice end to a good meal.
Drink: Boo-tanical: Fruit and sour forward, tasty.
Drink: Dark Aether- really smooth, slightly sweet but a delicious flavor combination.
Service:
Alex did a nice job taking care of us with humor and kindness. It was a very busy night at the restaurant, and he was hustling, but he managed to be attentive nevertheless. At this price point, perhaps another assistant for Alex to help serve food, bus tables and reset tables would be a helpful addition. I'd like completed dishes to be removed faster, the unadorned plastic table to be wiped clean between courses, and the tables to be sturdier. Our entree plates were still on our small table when dessert was served. Also, there were two decorative bottles/jars on our table that did not serve any purpose, except taking up room. I noticed that there were yellow roses in glass vases that were sitting on the Service stand, and I would have rather had a pretty living flower on my table instead.
Verdict: Alchemy has a very interesting concept and has the potential to be a go-to dining experience in Southwest San Diego. It is pricey as the check for the two of us was over $200 with tip. I think that there are still some little details that need to be worked out for this to be a true 5 star dining experience, but it absolutely has potential. I'm eager to come back again when the menu updates to try the new seasonal offerings. read more