Nice staff and clean inside. food was good. Reasonable prices. Lots to choose from on the menu. I'd come back read more

All Star Bagel Manasquan - Bagels Near Me - Manasquan, New Jersey

See all

Ordered a Pork roll egg and cheese and potato on a hard roll and they said they don't have potato. What are home fries then, which they had and hash browns. Duh .Asked for pork roll well done was there when they were making it and I got 3 slivers of pork roll that almost made one thick cut TAYLOR PORK ROLL SLICE from a store bought package and it came out like warm, I don't get it, throw some meat on the damn sandwich. Cashier was nice and pleasant but Bob cut hair woman is sorta cold, vibe was not great, hopefully just a bad day but from other reviews not so sure about that. Bagel was good but WHERE's THE MEAT! read more

I ordered for the first time today. I got an onion bagel with turkey bacon and scrambled egg with cheese. The bagel was delicious light and airy soft fresh and flavorful.turkey bacon good quality cooked Just right! The only thing that bothered me just a bit was the worker hand long hair that was not neatly put in a bun it was hanging in my bag at one point. The worker was very cheery and pleasant! I think the hair May be a lack of training. I see it a lot read more

Ordered the grand slam and triple play. Heard from a friend that their bagels are really good so we wanted to try it out. The bagel was ok for me I definitely had better ones and some parts were burnt and it didnt have that tiny taste of salt on the bagel it was just all seeds. It was also VERYYY OILYYYYYY!! It had a puddle of oil on the wrapper and on the sandwiches my hand also got oily. read more

All Star Bagel Manasquan - Grand Slam - Bagels Near Me - Manasquan, New Jersey

See all

I've had better bagels in Alabama. Everything I ordered was unfortunately awful. The bagels were overcooked and not fluffy at all. The cream cheese tasted like the Philadelphia baking block from the grocery store and my bagel was overloaded with it. Matcha was completely flavorless and watery. The staff seemed nice which was the only upside. Absurdly overpriced, better off eating a thomasville bagel at home. read more

All Star Bagel Manasquan - Bagels Near Me - Manasquan, New Jersey

While visiting a friend in Manasquan, we walked over to All Star Bagels for breakfast on Sunday morning. There were a few people in line before us which gave us time to look over the menu and decide what we wanted. They have a pretty straightforward menu with typical bagels and some speciality sandwiches. They also offer hot and iced coffee, and a nitro cold brew that looked pretty enticing. I ordered the Grand Slam breakfast sandwich because it was a cheat day, and who doesn't love 6 slices of bacon and hash brown patties on their breakfast sandwich?! I also got a regular iced coffee. My boyfriend got the regular breakfast sandwich and added a hash brown too. Overall, the price was super reasonable (compared to what I'm used to in Philly). The food was fresh and delicious and only took about 10 minutes of waiting. My sandwich looked like it was quadruple the size of my boyfriends. Definitely worth the price!! read more

All Star Bagel Manasquan - Grand Slam Breakfast Sandwich - Bagels Near Me - Manasquan, New Jersey

See all

Food is great, but that's when they actually have it. Employees are never aware of what they have in stock, and they are constantly out of things! No fries after i already ordered, no tomato for my BLT. Ridiculous! read more

Top notch service! From the welcoming smiles of the employees to the freshness of the food! All around solid place, can't wait to try it again. read more

Stopped going for a year because they never could get my order right or lost it and the place became dirty. Decided to give them another try because close and convenient. Order bacon, egg and cheese on plain bagel from a girl that answered phone. She told me ready in 5 minutes. Arrived 15 minutes later and they had no such order. Milo the owner said no one called in that order. I got my phone a showed him. He couldn't explain but was accusing me of not actually ordering. Place is a disaster. Owner young kid blames customer instead of taking responsibility for poor customer service. Wanted this place to be good because it's local and convenient but the owner is arrogant and lacks credibility for poor customer service. Never going back this time! FYI, I personally reached out last year to Milo the owner with my complaint he tried to get me back with a $50 gift card. I turned it down because I wasn't look for money just wanted it to be good because convenient but never going back. Avoid if you don't want to be annoyed first thing in the morning. Poor service and the food isn't great either. read more

let me just say. my experience at all star bagel was ethereal. as someone who isn't from the jersey shore, and this bagel shop is my first impression of what nj has to offer, i am blown away. what really got me was not the food... it was the service. i had the sweetest young woman serve me... olive or olivia i believe her name was. she chatted me up and made me feel welcomed here at the shore. she gave me great suggestions on what to do here, worked efficiently, and went out of her way to be kind to a lad in need of a good bagel recommendation. i hope she gets promoted. read more

All star Bagel is the best bagel you can get in Manasquan. Forget Corner Bagelry, the sandwich, bagel itself, and overall experience at All Star doesn't even compare. The staff are always super friendly and very knowledgeable. The sandwich itself is all time. I got the Slider on a poppy seed bagel today and it was absolutely dynamite per usual. Whoever's working the grill at this place is a breakfast pro. Stop in for a bagel whenever you're in the area. You won't regret it! read more

All Star Bagel Manasquan - The Slider on a Poppy Seed Bagel w/SPK - Bagels Near Me - Manasquan, New Jersey

Great bagels. Owner & employees are so nice & accommodating. Highly recommend them.

BURNT FOOD. DRY SANDWICH. STALE BREAD. Disgusted. I'd give zero stars if I could. Beyond disappointed. I ordered a sandwich and hash brown from here yesterday. I'll let the pictures be testimony. Burnt hash brown cooked to a crisp. Breakfast sandwich was one slice of cheese and one slice of turkey on a stale hard roll. Seeking full refund. To restaurant: Please contact me regarding this concern. read more

See all

As I was walking in, a man was complaining that he had waited 30 minutes for 1 breakfast sandwich...I should've walked out then. I waited 20 minutes for two breakfast sandwiches...I was the only person in the shop. One of the orders was for a 2-egg sandwich, and although I paid for a 2-egg sandwich, I only received 1 egg. It was a takeout order so there was nothing they could do. read more

See all

The bagel sandwiches here are fantastic! The portions are substantial and the ingredients are consistently fresh. Without a doubt, my favorite place in Manasquan for a good meal. read more

I've visited a lot of all-stars, but this is by far the greatest. Fantastic ambiance. I'm always welcomed when I enter. The food is also absolutely delicious. Personally, I have to suggest a white wrap with sausage, egg and cheese and a hash brown! read more

All star bagels lives up to its name! The bagels are absolutely delicious. The place has a fantastic atmosphere, and the staff is incredibly friendly, helpful and accommodating! My go-to treat is the onion bagel with cream cheese and lox, although I also enjoy the egg and cheese sandwiches. The sandwiches are generously filled and simply divine! read more

Our first choice for bagels every time. Lots of seating and welcoming service. To check if we were enjoying our meal, the owner and manager came to the table. I adore the place. Rainbow bagels and Fruity Pebbles are favorites of our daughter. I'm also really happy with the new management. The restaurant is also very clean. read more

Tried a new place and fully regret it. Bagels are small, thin and flavorless. Breakfast sandwich had the smallest egg on it ever and non-melted cheese. Can get a better bagel in the frozen section of the grocery store. read more

Never tried All Star before today. Pork roll is the perfect amount of salty and hash browns were PERFECT. Bagels were fresh and workers were kind and fast! read more

Terrible experience all around. Staff was confused and not organized. We waited 35 minutes for 3 bagels and only received 2. Decided to walk out without all the food I paid for because how long they were taking. read more

Nasty customer service. When you try to explain something that was wrong with your order. The nasty little girl behind the counter always has something to say. Wonder if the owners witness this at all. read more

Stop by the deli on the way to Manasquan Beach. Walked in around lunchtime and requested several different sandwiches, none of which they had. I'll keep it simple, three high school kids behind the counter, no sense of urgency, sense of direction, not sure if they have ever made sandwiches before. Things were going real slow the first seven or eight minutes until a man named Nick came from behind the wall and started to hustle big-time. I could write a lot more, but the simple story is that the sandwiches are poorly made. One slice of cheese on a cheese sandwich, one slice of bacon on a BLT, 20 minutes to make four total sandwiches, and we were the only ones in there for the first 10 minutes. Not sure how Nick is generating revenue to pay these kids, forget the overhead. Kids working there are clueless on how to make a sandwich, they need to hustle and pay attention and detail. read more

All Star Bagel Manasquan - Cheese & veggie sandwich 1 slice of cheese - Bagels Near Me - Manasquan, New Jersey

See all

I'm a veggie cream cheese person and I like that theirs has small pieces of veggies instead of huge chunks (read: my toddler will eat it too) BUT I can't get passed their bagel - it sticks to your teeth! Have to say their breakfast sandwiches are awesome (they are putting hash browns on them !!!) but again, their bagel is just not right. read more

Easy to order online and go pickup in store! Admittedly I've spent the last 3 years in Florida so any bagel in NY/NJ is going to taste good... that said, these were very fresh, lots of "everything" on our everything bagels and the eggs were definitely not microwaved. We had pork roll, egg and cheese and turkey bacon and egg - both on everything bagels. Bagels do NOT need to be toasted here to taste good either. Salt, pepper, ketchup to finish the deal. We'll order from here again! read more

Ordered HEC with hot sauce on toasted everything. Bagel was ok for Jersey. Very symmetrically formed bagels with a thick layering of seeds. Portion size was good. Hot sauce could be worked on. Good price and friendly staff. I'll see how they're doing next year and report back. read more

best bagels I have ever had. it tastes great ilove all their food

Absolutely delicious breakfast café. The bagels are soft with a perfect amount of toasted crunch. Quality ingredients and they don't skimp. Fantastic coffee and a very comfortable atmosphere. The staff are super cool and welcoming lol the type to remember your preferences if you become a regular. Very impressed. read more

Pretty good tasting bagels and really good tasting cream cheese. A little stingy on the cream cheese though so I would recommend asking for extra. Bagels weren't fluffy but they were still good and had a lot of options in the store. read more

All Star Bagel has been my favorite breakfast spot on the Jersey Shore for a few years now. The customer service is always great- always a positive vibe when I walk in to grab a quick meal. Even though they mentioned a price raise on May 1st, the prices still beat all the other shops in Manasquan. I recommended this place to anyone looking for a big pork roll and I promise it won't disappoint! read more

My new favorite bagel shop. The bagels are delicious and the staff kind and efficient. Definitely will not be disappointed with bagel and or sandwiches. read more

Guess who? As we near the busy summer months, I just wanted to make sure all star bagel is ready for the onslaught of shore goers who will want their bagels within the hour. read more

Literally the best breakfast sandwich I've ever had. Their bagels are super fluffy and soft. Get a pork roll, egg, and cheese with a hash brown; it is truly a game changer! Get there early though because they run out of the more popular flavors. read more

All Star Bagel of Manasquan is the best! Scott, Alyssa, Val and the rest of the crew always serve the most delicious bagels! Check them out...you won't be disappointed! Make sure you grab a dozen to take home to your family! read more

Finally stopped in here, and was pleasantly surprised. Was in and out pretty quickly. Great bagel, good price, and the staff was fun and super friendly. read more

best bagels in the area by far. call in ahead to skip the line and save yourself some time.

Great bagels, great sandwiches, fantastic staff. A gem.

This establishment is a complete an utter disgrace. I ordered a breakfast bagel from here, I asked for a bacon eggs and cheese with a hashbrowns. The cost was 8.50 which is a little pricey to began with. Then I open it up when I get home and there is literally one egg and 2 skimpy pieces of bacon, with only one little hashbrowns on one side of the bagel. Then to top it off the entire bagel was covered in grease as if they toasted it on the same flat grill they cooked the bacon on. Fucking rookies, a breakfast sandwich is pretty easy to make. I would reccomend any other breakfast place over these smucks. read more

Most authentic bagel place in the area. My heart soared when they asked "salt, pepper, ketchup?" Bagels are great, place is clean with a lot of options for drinks, bagels and sandwiches. Everything is made to order so prepare for a little wait time but that's the best way to do it so no complaints here!Definitely my new go to spot. read more

All Star is my family's new favorite bagel shop. The bagels are very good, and the owner and his staff are friendly and courteous. I am not sure what makes theirs so much better than other places, but their pork roll, egg and cheese sandwich on an egg bagel is the best! Since All Star opened in Manasquan, they are my go-to breakfast spot. read more