I absolutely love their chef salad. It reminds me of the chef salad I used to get back home. Only missing a few ingredients like green olives, turkey, and banana peppers or peppercini peppers. Their pizza is good also but I really crave the chef salad. They offer pasta plates that are delicious and wings, also gyros. Definitely give them a try. The chef salad is enough to make a meal by itself. Just so refreshing and good for the body! Oh, I also buy their garlic butter Parmesan bread sticks... these are to die for. Fresh dough, lots of butter and Parmesan just wish we got more marinara sauce to go with them. One small cup isn't enough for these big buttery breadsticks. I'm so happy I tried All Star Pizzeria because they are helping me through this horrible heat index with no signs of letting up. Wish I had a picture to post but there isn't anything left to show. read more

We order pizza here every Friday night. Love it!! My kids always opt for a large cheese, with extra cheese.

Love this place. Better quality and quantity than the big box chains. They have affordable specials at all times and the staff is very friendly. No issues if there is a mix up in their part, which is rare. Highly recommended. read more

Best pizza around and I think I've tried them all. Fresh toppings, amazing crust, always on time, great service. I used to order pizza from a chain restaurant for our HOA meetings, but switched last time to All Star Pizza and people went wild. I highly recommend this place. If you eat in, the place doesn't look that great but you will love the pizza! read more

not very nice people here, at all. staff is rude and careless. pizza is expensive for what you get. not sure i would support this place.

Best pizza in the springs area. Not super stupid expensive and great pizza. Be back soon.

One of our favorite local pizzas and a nice hidden gem in Fountain. Big fan of their breadsticks!

We spent $100, so worth it, my boys love love love their calzones. The food tastes amazing . I'm done with the chain pizzerias. All Star is now the families favorite spot. read more

Horrible pizza. Everything was way to over priced They don't tell you about the coupons. When asked they said they couldn't do anything about it because the order was made through the phone. 59 dollars for two small pizzas and wings? They had a coupon for 7.99 for a large pizza. Don't waste your time Rude people. read more

Pizza is delicious!!! Flavor, price, service, locally owned and operated, definitely deserve everyone's business! Whenever we have a craving for pizza this is our go to spot!!! read more

See all

I was really, really looking forward to their food as this restaurant in the only one open in the strip. However, you have to call your order in, which is understandable in this time, and wait outside. It seemed like a long wait, and maybe I just came at a terrible time although there weren't any other people in front of me. So about the food. My husband and I both ordered wings, he got boneless and I got bone. He said his were delicious and ate every last one. Mine, however, were chewy and not cooked enough for my liking so I only ate like three out of the eight I ordered. The flavor, garlic and Parmesan, on my wings was spot on though which is why I wanted to keep eat them, but I couldn't get passed that chewy-ness. It kept kept getting stuck in my teeth. They gave us free breadsticks since our order was over $10, so that was awesome! And the wings were super hot when we got them. Thanks y'all! read more

All Star Pizzeria - Sign on the entrance - Pizza Near Me - Fountain, Colorado

See all

Very good sauce and sausage is wonderful. this was our first time here and we will definitely be back again.

I used to love this place and I won't be ordering from here again. The pizza was undercooked. The salad was wilted and why pay extra for icing for your dessert pie when you don't get it?!! The only thing that came out well tonight was the breadsticks. read more

See all

Best food for the price, cheaper than paying the exorbitant prices of the drive throughs

Nice people and good food! I like that it is not a big chain. I'll have to try some other items on the menu next time.

These people make up the rules as they go. The online system is an entirely different system than they use in the restaurant. Also, no refunds- only credit you have to call to use. Twice I've ordered online and they have forgotten things (which would be fine), but they charge a dollar per item, like parmesan and ranch. When I called, the manager laughed and said she couldn't refund me for parmesan when it was free...I explained about the online and she credited me a dollar. Tried to order today to claim my dollar and they told me the minimum for delivery is 20$, when I told them the online delivery said 10$, she got angry and told me it'd been that way for months and they haven't gotten around to changing it online yet. So FYI guys order online. And also just skip this place altogether. Terrible management. Domino's read more

I live on the Mesa where the bigs Pizza Hut, PaPa John's, and of course Domino's dominate the pizza biz, All Star is a hidden gem with great prices, the pizza toppings are so much more flavorful, and I love the vibe, mom and pops are the best read more

After a mix up of ordering pizza here tonight and selecting pick up instead of delivery all star was nice enough to deliver me my pizza! We were so appreciative because my vehicle isn't here right now that my teenager went and got money from her OWN pocket to offer a tip because the transaction had already been paid and couldn't be recharged. Pizza comes I send her to the door don't see any problem- I receive a call from the manager who basically told me off and went on about how they delivered a service and I said I didn't have a car for pick up ( which my car is with my husband at work) but there was a car there (My roommates car who I'm not at liberty to use) then went on to say the next time this happened there wouldn't be any delivery offered. Won't be a next time I reintegrated to him as I did with LISA on the phone how much I APPRECIATED the gesture and even allowed my teen to offer cash at the door! I was told that's a LIE my teen didn't offer him any tip and when the driver was asked he had the nerve to say she POCKETED the money. I'm thinking this is insane- entire time dudes talking to me like I jipped him out of something and didn't spend 40 plus to feed my family multiple times now. He says this is a far area to deliver to etc. ( but they deliver every other time no issue) and wishes me a good night. Incredible. Their food is decent but for this type of BS I'll pass everytime. I'm astonished by the attitude and nastiness this family owned business has shown my family tonight. All over a mix up! That they offered to deliver for! My teenager doesn't have to pocket cash she has spending money all her own. She also said the driver was SUPER RUDE to her at the door and showed up with an attitude- if they didn't want to deliver the pizza why say they could? Sucks we love supporting family owned businesses but this one gives me the ICK spend money elsewhere read more

Friendly service, cute atmosphere. Food is excellent--and very well-priced! It's my "hidden gem" pizza joint. I randomly found it one day and now go very often. They have the best pizza for the lowest price! read more

The pizza is great and the calzone even better, friendly staff. This is my place to go in Fountain.

2 minutes ago Bought a chicken parm on January 10th when I came home there was no chicken in it I called the store and was literally told he must have forgot to put the chicken in it will get that replaced for you came in today to get that replaced and they want to charge me for the meal that they literally forgot to put the chicken in and then verbalized it Worst place ever if you mess up own up to it and replace the item I was just asking for an apology and someone to acknowledge it I did not need the item replaced I was literally going to throw it in the garbage if you replaced it but you did not care enough at all to even say you're sorry and own the mistake that you guys made as a company worst customer service ever read more

I just wanted to let everyone know my experience. After reading these reviews I wanted to make sure All Star was acknowledged for excellent service tonight. The last time I ordered, there was a problem which I did not report at that time. So I explained to the manager tonight what happened to my order last time, and she went above and beyond to make sure my order was perfect. I do not live close, but they delivered to my home in about 30 min., that is amazing for a Friday night. The manager also called me to make sure I was happy with my order, and I told her it was the best pizza I have had from them! I do live close to Dominos, Pizza Hut, and Papa Johns. All Star put these guys to shame! I want to acknowledge Tiffany and Lisa for their excellent service! Ya'll are awesome!!! I would have posted a pic, but we ate it all! :-) read more

Staff is amazing, food is always delicious and filling! Great local spot for dining in or take out.

Best in fountain area ! Huge wings and flavorful ! I didn't eat out much but this was my to go

Pizza is very average for takeout in Fountain. Very comparable to big chains but price is a lot better. They usually have a lot of specials for takeout on the daily. Sometimes they tell you it's 15 minutes when it's more like 30, so I usually show up around 25 minutes for take out. I have only ever had takeout, but there is usually a few people eating in when I am picking up my order. read more

We moved to Fountain a few months ago and were looking for a pizza place that was not only reasonably priced (Pizza Hut, Dominos are not) when we stumbled on this place. We have tried all of their various pizza crusts, along with some of their other offerings (they have sandwiches and other yummies) and we just love them! Their prices are great too, no need to rob a bank just for a pizza! read more

Horrible service, inconsistent pizza. Staff is rude are careless. Go literally anywhere else

Worst. Pizza. I've. Ever. Had. When I am trying a place I have not tried before I always go with plain cheese pizza. If you're cheese pizza isn't any good, then it's likely it will all be the same. This pizza arrived luke warm, and the best way to describe it would be if you took a 7-11 slice and left it out overnight, then popped it in the microwave the next morning for just 15 sec. It had very lite sauce and I would be shocked if it was made to order. It seemed as if it had been sitting around all day and was then reheated. On a scale of 1 to 10, I gave this a 1.4. I do not recommend. Save yourself some money and just go grab a 7-11 pie, which is 10x better than what I received. read more

I'm from Buffalo, NY and know my pizza. Hands down this is the best pizza you can get around fountain

I ordered a 5 topping pizza, picked it up, and discovered when I got home it was a cheese pizza. I called in the problem, but was told that there was nothing they could do since it was a web order. The web order confirmed I ordered a 1-5 topping pizza (all supposed to be the same price), but the management said it didn't count if I could not see the list of toppings I ordered. I had no reason to expect the order would echo my choices. So I got stuck with a so-so cheese pizza when everybody was expecting a sausage with extras. Lousy. read more

When this place was Pizza Factory, years ago, it was bomb! Now, it takes about as good as dominoes. The crust is like cardboard, cheese isn't melty and stretchy. I haven't tried the other items because if you specialize in pizza, and don't do that right- I'm not sure I'd go Greek with a gyro, or even try a sub?? read more

The pizza outer crust was done but the main crust was doughy. It wasn't good. I've come in before plenty of times before and was good I never complained. Today is was gross. My friends kid had a cookie that was both dry and not fully cooked. I called them and pretty much they told me i could have a discount next time. There definitely won't be a next time. No thanks. Wasted money and I gave her a 9 dollar tip. read more

All Star Pizzeria - a piece of pizza on a paper plate - Pizza Near Me - Fountain, Colorado

Fast service. Delicious hand tossed crust. Sweet sauce. Good portions. Much better than the local chain pizza deliveries. Support small town business. read more

We have an HOA meeting tomorrow with an attendance of 60 to 80 people. A budget of $400. I decided to call ahead and get everything pre-ordered so they had all of the information and all of the supplies prepared for delivery. The lady we talked to was accommodating and super helpful. However, when I asked for 80 paper plates and napkins, I was put on hold and the owner came on and was incredibly rude and incredibly snarky. In fact, he raised his voice saying he would charge me for every single paper plate, and napkin we would use. Now granted that's fine because we actually have a budget but now it became principal when I was planning on paying way more for pizzas and shopping local. That was the entire intent when every year we've done Domino's. I cannot believe the insanely poor customer service from a "local business owner". I asked, would you provide us plates and napkins if we came to your restaurant ? Had we all decided to go into your restaurant and eat and he said "yes of course you're eating in my restaurant but you're getting a delivery so no I'm not just giving you 80 plates and napkins." I'm confused as to why we aren't allowed to have something so little and you're making such a big deal out of it and he hung up. I own a retail business for 14 years so far. I've been in the restaurant industry for over 20 years. Never in my life would I treat someone whose planning on purchasing 400 dollars worth of food from a place with this level of disrespect. In fact, if he would have phrased it in a kind manner instead of yelling at me when I asked for such a simple request much of this situation would've been different now instead of shopping local, which was the whole entire point of leaving dominoes we're going back to dominoes because they have no problem, handing us some paper plates and napkins. Since I know you'll be seeing this, sir, I highly recommend the book "give 'em the pickle" it would do you some good in your customer service skills and what battles to fight over. I'll be sure to be also reporting us to Better Business Bureau since I have your actual LLC name. read more

The delivery time wasnt bad and the food was good until i found out part of my calzone dough was still raw. I had high hopes for this place but I guess this one isnt the pizza shop I'll be eating at. On to the next pizza stop. read more

All Star Pizzeria - a close up of a chicken sandwich - Pizza Near Me - Fountain, Colorado

Order a specialty pizza don't mind paying extra, but when you don't get that and they say they will credit you and don't we'll that's just bad business. read more

The flavor was great, ordered a 20" an thank goodness because the outer edge was 2" short of any toppings or sauce so I really got a 16" pizza. The pizza wasn't cold but definitely not hot after we got through with the first couple pieces it was cold. Would give them one more chance but would eat inside the restaurant so as to give them a chance to make it right read more

All Star Pizzeria - No topping on edge - Pizza Near Me - Fountain, Colorado

I just realized we've never reviewed all star! This is such great pizza and even better calzones! We've been eating here since they first opened, and it only gets better each time! Thank you guys for such delicious pizza and excellent service! read more

We ordered a bacon ranch pizza with Parmesan garlic chicken wings. The order came promptly and arrived hot which was good. But the actual food was pretty bad. The pizza tasted like they Literally squirted kraft ranch on it. The pizza reminded me a lot of freezer pizza. The chicken and bacon were pretty good though. The "chicken" wings we got tasted like frozen reheated chicken nuggets. They had no flavor and we're very processed. Maybe they messed up the order and gave us the wrong thing. But if this is what chicken wings looks like to them, it's pretty disappointing. Especially since we paid almost 30 dollars for it. read more

All Star Pizzeria - Chicken wings - Pizza Near Me - Fountain, Colorado

All Star Pizzeria In Fountain is definitely worth a stop in if you are tired of chain pizzerias that are in the area (and there are several). My wife and I decided to try it out on a kid free Friday night, and it was excellent. They offer wings, sandwiches, salads, but pizza is where they shine. The offer specialty pizzas like bacon cheeseburger, pickle, and several others, the single pizza allows anywhere from 1-9 toppings with no additional cost. That alone beats the specialty pizzas because you can go wild with topping combinations. All Star Pizzeria is definitely worth stopping in if you are in the Fountain area and are tired of the chain establishments. read more