Cancel

    Open app

    Search

    Amici Bakery

    4.2 (83 reviews)
    ModerateBakeries
    Open 7:00 am - 8:00 pm

    Amici Bakery Photos

    You might also consider

    Recommended Reviews - Amici Bakery

    Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
    Yelp app icon
    Browse more easily on the app
    Review Feed Illustration

    Reviews With Photos

    Italian Cookie deliciousness. So many options.
    Scott B.

    Excellent hidden gem of Italian bakery. So tastie and beautiful selections. Not far off the highway, so worth the side trip.

    Cannoli galore! Mini tiramisu, Napoleon
    Devika P.

    Nobody does it like Amici. Amici is the best Italian bakery around and everything we've tried is heavenly. My family's go-to spot for cakes, pastries, breads, and especially cannoli's! They have amazing cookies year-round, spectacular cakes, holiday specialties, Irish soda bread during St. Patty's, etc. The staff is so nice and helpful when I come in asking questions and gives me great suggestions that have led me to find my favorites! Their tiramisu is genuinely the best I've ever had, and their cannolis are AMAZING. The filling is perfectly flavored and creamy and the bite is so satisfying and delicious... Amici is a staple in Monroe. Love them!! Definitely a must try!

    Where's the strawberries!!!
    Jonathan N.

    Worst experience ever!!!! Poorest customer service, I ordered a cake with custard and strawberry inside!!! Did not get strawberries and the cake was not how my daughter wanted!!! We texted pictures of how we wanted the cake and chatted with someone from the bakery about the cake. They respond when they wanted to , left us hanging. Ruined my daughter's birthday!!! She was looking forward to the cake and we got nothing but disappointment! Worst yet made my daughter cry on her birthday!! Thanks Chloe for your help!!!! Great job take our order !!!

    Lobster tail, cannoli, hazelnut cake, raspberry cake, and a unknown lol
    Tira M.

    Maybe they had their glorious days, but not anymore! Location: in a small plaza, lots of parking. Very easy to find. Food: I came in there looking for a good lobster tail. Read many reviews and decided to give it a try. When arrived, an old couple was on their way out and recommended so many different pastries to me. They were so sweet and I decided to buy few more things. Ended up spending $19 for 6 items and was very excited. Got home, made a cup of black tea and was ready to dig in. The lobster tail had decent filling but the pastry was not crispy. The cannoli is where I give the stars. It was creamy and crispy. The other pastries were all no good. The hazelnut one tasted very artificial, and the raspberry one was super sweet. The unknown one was a blur to me. Did not make an impression. Service: the young servers were very attentive Price: $3 each on average. I would buy the cannolis again for sure! Overall: will revisit if I am in the area and in the mood for the cannolis

    Tortoni

    See all

    11 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0
    Photo of a c.
    1
    30
    0

    10 years ago

    Try the Lobster tails. Get the full size because you wont put it down. Great bakers from Bensonhurst Brooklyn

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    9 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    Page 3 of 3

    Ask the Community - Amici Bakery

    Any fall? flavors ? or ??

    Pumpkin and apple!

    View All 2 Questions

    You might also consider

    Verify this business for free

    People searched for Bakeries 3,392 times last month within 10 miles of this business.

    Verify this business

    Kapadokya Turkish Bakery - Chocolate cake

    Kapadokya Turkish Bakery

    4.4(23 reviews)
    10.0 mi

    Some good and some not so good at this Turkish bakery in downtown New Brunswick. The good: Acma…read more(like a Turkish bagel) is a flaky, delicious bread that is like a cross between a bagel and a croissant. My wife's caramel macchiato was very good. My tea was very good. The harder Acma which was covered in sesame seeds was just ok. Borak with cheese was just ok. Eggs with suckuk (Turkish sausage) was better than ok because of the taste of the sausage. The eggs left a lot to be desired. The bad: I also got a hot chocolate that unfortunately was Swiss Miss which I noticed after I ordered. Staff was very pleasant and helpful. Debating whether to return again to try more of the many pastries they have. Inside is very comfortable and cozy with Turkish music in the background. Sorry for the lack of pics.

    The vibe inside is nice and cozy. They have a ton of different desserts and pastries that all look…read moreamazing. We tried the blueberry cake which was so yummy. They also have the viral Dubai chocolate. Owner is very friendly. He gave us a small taste of a pistachio dessert. The service was great. They also have Turkish breakfast which is on my list to try next and would also recommend trying their Turkish tea. This is a great place for afternoon tea or late night desserts. They have a very convenient location by the train station, easy grab and go as well if you do not wish to stay long. However, The staff is very hospitable so I'm sure you would want to stay.

    Photos
    Kapadokya Turkish Bakery
    Kapadokya Turkish Bakery - Pistachio cake

    Pistachio cake

    Kapadokya Turkish Bakery - Entrance

    See all

    Entrance

    Laffair II Bake Shop - The front

    Laffair II Bake Shop

    3.5(75 reviews)
    4.3 mi
    $$

    I came here a total of three times. If I would have wrote a review the first day I came I would…read morehave gave Laffair 5 stars. That day I bought a red velvet cake and a bunch of cookies. Everything that day tasted so fresh and so delicious! The red velvet cake slice was amazing! My husband loved all his cookies too! We loved the bakery so much we came back a few days later unfortunately that day it wasn't nearly as good except for the cookies. I bought a carrot cake slice, a cheesecake/brownie slice and various cookies. The carrot cake slice wasn't that great and tasted a few days old. The brownie part to the cheesecake slice was very good, but the cheesecake on top wasn't that great. We did enjoy the cookies. We came back for a third time on Monday Jan 26, 2026 and I purchased a brownie that tasted a month old at least! It was hard as a brick! Needless to say I didn't eat it! I also bought a chocolate mousse cake slice that was extremely fresh and good. As usual the cookies we purchased were all fresh and very good. All in all this bakery is a mixed bag you don't know if you're going to get something fresh or stale. Everything is either hit or miss. I'd come back again and give it another shot, but I wouldn't come often.

    I rarely write reviews, but I wanted to commend Laffair 1I bakery on the beautiful and delicious…read morecake they made for my granddaughter's baby naming. It was outstanding and everyone raved!

    Photos
    Laffair II Bake Shop - Sweets

    Sweets

    Laffair II Bake Shop - Pic 2 of cake

    Pic 2 of cake

    Laffair II Bake Shop

    See all

    Paris Baguette - Plenty of seating

    Paris Baguette

    3.8(32 reviews)
    5.8 mi

    The strawberry cake is TO DIE FOR!! I would come here every day for a slice of it. It is my…read morefavorite so much so, that I got it for my birthday. The pastries here are great as well. The bakery is self-serve, and then you pay up front. All the staff who work here are nice, and always have a nice conversation at check out. The store is always kept clean, and looks very nice and clean.

    For me, Paris Baguette is always a bit hit or miss, and unfortunately this location fell into the…read more"meh" category. When we first walked in, I was impressed by how bright and inviting the space felt. However, a closer look revealed that many of the tables were dirty, and the areas underneath them were even worse. I understand that it can be difficult for employees to constantly clean up after customers, especially during busy periods, but it was clear that the dining area had not been attended to for some time. When I went to select some desserts, I had to ask an employee where the trays were located. I was told that the trays were being cleaned and that customers could use the pastry boxes instead. As I browsed the display cases, I also noticed that the dessert selection was fairly limited compared to other Paris Baguette locations I have visited. Despite the limited choices, I found two desserts to try, and we also ordered a hot coffee and a Korean iced milk coffee. The desserts were delicious and lived up to expectations. Unfortunately, the coffee was a letdown. Both drinks lacked the richness and strength I was hoping for, and the coffee tasted surprisingly weak. Overall, my experience was just okay. The pastries were enjoyable, but the cleanliness, limited selection, and disappointing coffee left me underwhelmed. I would not go out of my way to return to this location, although I would certainly visit other Paris Baguette locations in the future.

    Photos
    Paris Baguette - Very spacious

    Very spacious

    Paris Baguette - Windows from within

    Windows from within

    Paris Baguette

    See all

    Amici Bakery - bakeries - Updated June 2026

    Loading...
    Loading...
    Loading...