The lodge was superior with well appointed rooms and hallways. The reception area was welcoming.But the highlight was the 2nd floor deck with a splendid view of the countryside....and a place to watch summer storms as they moved through. We walked around the town and surroundings..quiet and peaceful. The only disappointment was the adjacent restaurant...with uninspired and often fattening food. This was in contrast to the excellent breakfast at the lodging. read more

Went to the Ohio star theater and didn't want to fight the lines at the Amish buffet there in Sugarcreek. Figured we'd give the Amish door a shot since AI generated this as a recommendation. It was $23 a person and another $4 for a coffee. The bill for 4 grownups with the buffet and 2 coffees was $108 on 7/11/26. The dinner buffet at 4pm was one 5 foot double sides buffet. The salad was the same. To put this in perspective, Yoders kitchen is 4 times that. The dessert options, with this paid full buffet dinner was graham cracker pudding or chocolate cookie pudding. The dinner options were breaded fried shrimp, chicken, meatballs, some sort of sausage or kielbasa and a shredded meat of some sort. That's it. That's it. I planned my mother in laws birthday out to the very last minute, to give her the best birthday celebration possible, and I felt so disappointed that this restaurant was so underwhelming. read more

A small but mighty selection when we went (late afternoon). The apple fritter and the fry pie were soooo good! read more

Amish Door Restaurant - Chocolate cream sticks, apple fritter, blueberry fry pie and lemon blueberry scone - Desserts Near Me - Wilmot, Ohio

We used to go here as a treat and we visit the bakery but the last 2 times have been horrible. The chicken looked like it had been sitting out and was so dry. The sausage was extremely dry as well. The corn had absolutely to flavor. For the price they charge with the small selection everything should be phenomenal but it's the opposite. We will unfortunately not be dining there but will continue to visit the bakery. read more

Handy good food restaurant near to best campground. Go for dinner after camper setup when we arrive. Used to go for breakfast & shop bakery the day we leave to go home. Being open for breakfast one day a week is not. OK. The Pandemic is over. ITS TIME TO BE OPEN for breakfast. read more

After all the walk and long drive we came across with the all you can eat Buffet at Amish Door. The food is hot and fresh, and the price range per buffet is not bad at all. The service is perfect, my coffee keeps coming. The place is clean. Overall experience: SATISFIED. and we will drive back full and happy tummy! Will definitely stop again to enjoy their food next time! read more

See all

I've tried 2 other Ohio Amish buffets multiple times and this was my second time here. My sister and I both agree, the food here is the best. They have most of the usual offerings but also serve bbq beef and ribs here. The ribs are tender and delicious. We also think their homemade rolls are really good here along with their peanut butter spread. The restaurant is pretty big and both times that I came for lunch, there was not a huge line out the door. There is a nice bakery attached to this restaurant where you can purchase a pack of those rolls and a bunch of other baked goodies. Service was good and there was plenty of parking. read more

See all

We came here this evening. We had been to visit in the past, and the food was good. This time, they had a special on the buffet. It was supposed to be fried chicken, roast beef and stuff that had been on the buffet all afternoon. They were out of roast beef and the chicken was rubbery. This is our last time eating here. There has to be better options. read more

The food was good. I liked that fried shrimp were on the buffet. Bought a cherry pie and that was delicious. The server was nice but it seemed we were an after thought and had to call out for her as she either stood around or went to the one other table. read more

See all

Not impressed. First, I waited 10 minutes after being seated, feeling invisible ,finally chased the hostess down to get a waiter. The waiter wasn't that great The food was mediocre on the bar.. And they charged a penalty fee for using my debit card without informing me. Doubt I'll return read more

My husband and I stopped to have lunch here today, Thursday, Aug 7, 2025. We were pretty disappointed. We both had the buffet and neither of us were impressed. The dinner rolls are very good, however the rest of the buffet food wasn't very desirable. We've had the same exact buffet food at every other "Amish" restaurant in Amish Country (Tuscarawas/Holmes County). read more

We had a Male server covered in tattoos (not that I care about the tattoos just makes him easy to identify). Dude was one of the worst servers we ever had. no rolls, no refills. Dude just seemed to hate working in a tourist trap. Other than that, the food was okay. Clean restaurant. Probably would have enjoyed it if it wasn't for our server. We all got the buffet. read more

Amish Door Restaurant - Buffet - Desserts Near Me - Wilmot, Ohio

I have come to Amish door very consistently over the years. Today was very underwhelming. Pot roast and chicken were SO dry. Rolls were not soft at all. I was very dissatisfied with my meal. Has really gone down hill lately read more

Typical Amish buffet Great salad bar Warm bar had chicken, beef, shrimp, potatoes, stuffing Nice servers read more

See all

Always a great buffet !!! However, the buffet price has soared in recent months, so I don't drive down there as much as I used to.....

Another fine Thanksgiving meal here at the Amish Door buffet style. Large salad with plenty of all kinds of vegetables to top your lettuce, and all types of Amish salad dishes-just to name a few, potato salad, macaroni salad, 2 kinds of coleslaw, Graham cracker pudding and much more. Broasted chicken white and dark, roast turkey, and ham, real mashed potatoes, dark and lite gravy, tasty sweet potatoes, green beans, noodles, dinner rolls with real butter, Apple butter, or peanut butter, finish your meal off with desert homemade pie, apple or pumpkin cream, iced pumpkin bar cake. Good cup of fresh made coffee with your desert. Well managed and hard working staff. Nice family atmosphere-good place to take family. Make sure to stop in the bakery for tasty baked goods such as pies, rolls, donuts, also containers of prepared salads and a favorite of mine red beet pickled eggs and lots more. read more

See all

Great buffet of roast beef, fried chicken, yeasty rolls with peanut butter sauce, oh my!! The hidden gem is the house made French dressing. (Sold in gift shop) Excellent experience must for an Amish country tour. read more

Restaurant was big and clean. We were surprised to see a self service salad bar , but they did have hand sanitizer and disposable gloves for people to use. The food overall was good. The burger came with fresh cut fries and my salad was HUGE . I would have preferred it was served on a plate vs a deep bowl as it was a little hard to eat until I worked my way down . Server was very friendly and was efficient . read more

Amish Door Restaurant - Bacon burger and fries - Desserts Near Me - Wilmot, Ohio

See all

Me and my mom came here while outlines country for our annual fall trip. The staff was kind and helpful making sure we had everything we needed. The restaurant is large and open allowing for lots of seating without feeling too crowded and it was a nice place to sit and eat. We both got the buffet as we often do with restaurants like this. This buffet had some items we don't usually see on Amish buffets like fried shrimp. My mom also said their salad bar is the best she's seen out here whit a lot of choices. I thought the chicken was delicious, bursting with flavor when you take a bite. It's at the level of some of our other favorites in the area and only slightly behind our number one favorite. I thought their form tender roast beef was the best I've had on a buffet in this area and that was a highlight. The noodles were just average for this area (which is to say still pretty good) we would definetly come back again if we find the time. read more

Food is incredible fresh and delicious. Service fast friendly and extremely helpful. The dining room was beautiful and clean

First time to visit. Busy place for a Wednesday afternoon! We waited for about 5 minutes to be seated so it wasn't too long The food was wonderful! We took a spur of the moment trip to Amish country and had a great day! John had heard of the Amish Door Restaurant and we decided to go there for lunch. Great idea! I had broasted fried chicken ! Oh my, it was so juicy and tender! The sides weren't skimpy either! I think I brought home enough food for the next day for lunch! Of course, the desert's were as wonderful as the food!! We could have stayed longer but we had another business to visit! read more

The service was fantastic. The ambiance is nice. The restaurant is clean. The salad bar has many options. The roast beef was dry and somewhat bland. Pork chop was fine, but not out of this world. My baby enjoyed the macaroni and cheese and the mashed potatoes. I remember this being better years ago, and it was not necessarily bad per-se, but not outstanding either. I think there are better choices in Amish country. This property is in a beautiful idyllic setting, and I may try it again, but I would likely venture further past the "door" of Amish country and try a few others first. read more

We just stopped for lunch at The Amish Door and had a great experience. We chose meals from the menu instead of the buffet and everything was delicious. Our server, Luke, was amazing and definitely added to our great experience. Would highly recommend...and ask for Luke! read more

Everything you need in one destination Hotel, restaurant, and shopping all in one place Great food, great accomodations, and plenty of shopping read more

My fiance and I have eaten here twice, we visit amish country about once a year around the holidays as a little day trip getaway for some shopping. We came for the breakfast buffet, and for the price it wasn't bad. The potatoes were not edible, they were so raw they had a crunch, also the bacon was so thin and had zero flavor it was a waste. BUT, the waffles were thick and delicious, they had apple butter out with biscuits and those were great, the sausage is definitely not cheap/freezer sausage because the taste was out of this world, i have never tried sausage this good especially not on a buffet, and im not a huge pork fan. Our waitress was very attentive, she did get talking to a table next to us and forgot my ketchup, which was no big deal but she felt bad and gave the senior discount off the bill, very nice gesture and things that keep people coming back to a place when service/food wasn't exceptional. Overall i'd recommend the breakfast buffet if your in the area, theres something for everyone, fruit, yogurt, pancakes, french toast, waffles, ham, bacon, sausage, potatoes, eggs, hash, biscuits/gravy etc. give it a try! read more

Great food. Literally the BEST chicken I've ever had: fall off the bone tender and the breading was tasty! The mashed potatoes were top 5 potatoes I've ever had in a restaurant. Sliders and roast beef sandwich my family had were good as well. A huge plus is the bakery right next door! Our only concern is seeing all the added stuff in the bakery ingredients list. If they're home made, why do they have things you usually find in store bought bakery items. Still, everything was yummy! read more

Not impressed! Our server brought our meal and disappeared. Got our order wrong and our drinks were never refilled. We won't be back! read more

Food was amazing! The fried chicken was awesome! The mash potatoes and gravy were great!

Great food in Ohio's Amish country! Their buffet is excellent, and the attached bakery gives additional options for dessert if you don't want to eat a sweet treat in the restaurant. Highly recommend! read more

Overpriced, mediocre food and as others mentioned- not sure what exactly about this place is Amish? BEWARE- kids meal (grilled cheese and fries) is $8.99- and that's not including the drink! Holy cow. And I'm not talking specialty bread or cheese. I'm talking 2 pieces of Wonder and a slice of American. Also- there are 2 buffets, one little salad bar that's $11.99 and a hot bar that's $19.99. The mashed potatoes and gravy were good, as well as the fried chicken. That's why it gets 2 stars instead of 0. Oh and the rolls are awesome. read more

Another great restaurant but needs to add to the menu. Amish food is wonderful but a healthier version would help. Too much fat and heavy sauces read more

Good home cooking! Nothing fancy but filling food. The buffet price of $15.99 was a bit high. Two kinds of chicken, roast beef, breaded fish, Mac & cheese, green beans and corn o the cob, noodles and gravy plus a salad bar! With a few desserts. Guess the $15.99 doesn't sound so bad after all! One small thing though, upon leaving I noticed a sign saying 10% discount for seniors on Monday. We were there on Monday and don't believe we were given it ! We are obviously seniors! Guess you have to ask! read more

Since we are out of state I really wanted some good Amish food, so we decided on this place since it was the closest Waitresses were knowledgeable and very good, polite and patient We had questions about a certain pie and waitress told us that's her favorite and brought us a slice ( brown bag apple pie) Food was out of this world and plentiful Everything was very very fresh and delicious won't even come close to describing this awesome food We 'll certainly come back next time we are visiting mom and family The only complain that it's a bit pricey and no senior discount till Monday We ended up buying 3 delicious pies and delicious apple butter Can't wait to come back read more

MID. except the desserts. The desserts are scrumdiddlyumcious. Highly recommend those. The other food is ight. The service has never been a complaint. The ambiance is nice. But it is over priced . read more

This is a restaurant that I love going here with my family annually especially in the fall time!! So delicious!

If you are in the mood for sub-par cafeteria food in a pastoral setting, Amish Door is the place or you. I've been coming to Amish Door with family since I was around ten. My mom and I have continued to visit into adulthood, sometimes several times a month. We'd enjoy the scenic drive to Wilmont and enjoy a leisurely lunch and up until very recently, one could count on consistency in the quality of the food they offered. Last time we visited, many items on the buffet were "off"; the mashed potatoes were soupy, breading falling of the very dry chicken, the "Amish Pudding" clearly made with cheaper ingredients. Mom was disappointed there were no longer noodles being offered. Sure, it's just noodles, but when you've had noodles on your buffet for 30+ years, people kind of expect them. My first, and only trip to the buffet, I selected a chicken breast, a helping of mashed potatoes, and a taste of the pudding. What I sampled there was enough to let me know I wasn't interested in any more. My mother felt the same after her choices from the cold salad bar and piece of chicken. When asked how everything was, I commented to a waitress the food seemed "off". She mentioned speaking the the new manager and pointed her out. I approached the manager as advised and discreetly said the same thing, that the food seemed "off". Which caused her to immediately begin scowling at me while she sourly responded, "You're the only one who thinks so!" I wasn't interested in a dour discussion adjacent to the buffet, and went back to my table. The super attentive waitress comes over to ask if we need anything. At this point, all we want to do is go on to something better. The next thing we know, the unprofessional manager is at our table saying she's going to help us out and only charge us for the cold buffet. Which honestly is a bit of a screw you when it's only a dollar or so less than the hot buffet, and we didn't eat anything past a fork full of our choices. I'm sad to say, it's the end of an era. We won't be returning. read more

The fried chicken was good but not crispy. The Corn was out of a can. Banna pudding was terrible. Apple crisp was great.

Wonderful place to eat. I got coffee and soup. Then we walked over to the bakery. Very nice!

I'm surprised this place has so little reviews. We came during a weekday afternoon to eat lunch at this establishment. This is a restaurant/inn. This establishment can seat over 200 people. They have a separate room that you can reserve for meetings or whatever else you need it for. Food. The reason why we came here. They have a sit down and you order from a menu or buffet style. We chose the buffet style. I'll say one thing, the Amish can definitely cook some delicious food. I took the mashed potatoes with gravy, ham, slow cooked pulled pork and some fried chicken. It was all good. I give the food a 5 star rating. It seems it's a bit outdated inside, the table covers could have been replaced with something more updated modern look. Other then that, I will visit this place once I'm in town again. read more

Amish Door Restaurant - Desserts Near Me - Wilmot, Ohio

See all

This place was cool. It's in the heart of Ohio Amish/Mennonite country. The Amish Door doesn't seem to be exploiting that and has Mennonite women working in the bakery. The food was very good and well priced. The breakfast buffet was only $8.50. The baked goods we got didn't disappoint! The breads were super soft and delicious. Oh, I almost forgot...this is probably the best restaurant coffee I've ever had. Man, it was good. There were only two servers working the whole place and the younger girl seemed to be hefting most of the load. I can't give this place 5 stars due to the stares and upturned snoots we got from staff. We are a young-ish, tattooed military couple. We are very soft spoken, smiley, and polite to staff and didn't feel we deserved the backwoods treatment we got from a place that is trying to so hard to draw the touristy crowds. I would still come back here again for the food because for me, the service doesn't really matter as much as the food and the food was great. read more