Cakes are fresh, there is a cake for just about everyone. Service is quick and staff will help with any questions. Typical baker which is what I like nothing over the top to take away from their cakes and pastries. read more

The service was ridiculously bad. I went there out of nostalgia. I got macaroons and rolls. They left me standing there for 15-20 minutes because no one knew how much the rolls were. That's fine, but tell me why everyone is ignoring me. Macaroons were good - rolls not as good as I remember. read more

Amy's Pastry - Pastry case. Worst service ever! - Bakeries Near Me - Montebello, California

This pastries are good here, I love their chocolate horn and small butter cookies. The cakes are good too. Customer service is an epic fail. This place has been around for years, I remember going with my grandmother and getting my grandfather's favorite pastries. And my family used to order all their cakes from here. But I am sorry this new generation of customer service staff is just horrible to communicate with. They make no effort to connect and be of service. They walk around like zombies with no emotion. It is heart wrenching went a place you have been coming for years has customer service that doesn't make you feel welcomed or encouraging to want to buy their pastries. read more

We always get our birthday cakes from Amy's. Not going to be the case anymore. For $45, I got a carrot cake that looked like one round of cake was cut in half, with a layer of frosting the same size in the middle. There was more frosting than cake. We were all digging out the cake, leaving a shell of frosting behind (frosting, btw, that no longer has that cream cheese tang). I honestly believe my homemade carrot cake tastes better. So sad because I can remember coming to Amy's since my childhood, but its just not worth it anymore due to price and quality. read more

The lemon puff pastry has changed but not in a positive direction. The powdered sugar pastry used to be extra flaky and light but now it's thick and heavy. However, the lemon filling is plentiful. The chocolate chip pastry stick is full of chocolate chips and covered in sparkly sugar. Two of the refrigerated cakes/tarts seem to be inspired by Whole Foods: a beautiful fruit tart with a shiny glaze and a berry Chantilly Cake. The price quoted on the tart is $37! I used to work as a counter girl at Amy's back in the late 1970s. Good to see that the bakery continues despite changes in ownership and employees through the years. It's a Montebello icon. read more

Overall still good place for getting a cake. this small marble cake with chocolate pudding was now $25 have not been there for a while use to be $15-17 from what I remember but these times everything is going up in price. read more

Amy's Pastry - Marble chocolate cake price went up small cake is now $25 Still good just a tad bit soft - Bakeries Near Me - Montebello, California

My family has been visiting Amy's for many years. The first item I remember trying was their lemon cake. Now I'm usually not a fan of lemon flavored sweet treats but if ever there's a lemon cake from Amy's Pastry, I make sure to grab a slice. It has lots of mini layers and it's not too sweet. My favorite from here are their fruit tarts though. So fresh and delicious. read more

Amy's Pastry - Mini Fruit Tart - Bakeries Near Me - Montebello, California

See all

Amy's Pastry has beautiful sweet treats. However, I cannot say the same about the bakers. They aren't flexible with simple last minute orders, regardless of a pending holiday or a regular weekend. The only reason I continue to buy treats from here is because it's very close to my house. read more

Love Amy's have been coming for years my favorite is the lemon chiffon cake so delicious everything else will not disappoint.

I use to go to Amy years ago, so I decided to go last nite, and to my surprise all pastries were double in price I ended up Ended paying 18.00 for 4 pastries that seem very expensive. I guess Amy is good bye for me. read more

Amy's . . . What happened??? I personally haven't ordered anything from Amy's in several years. However, my Mom is still a big fan of their Tea Cakes and Pecan Nut Rings. So when Mom says that she doesn't want a big cake, but cupcakes instead, you order what Mom wants. I tried Amy's Online Ordering, but that was so restrictive and ridiculous that I had to call in an order. That went even worse than expected. The woman who answered my call was rude, pushy, & uninformed. Every question that I asked resulted in "Hold on a sec!", where I was placed on hold for much longer than a "sec". I was told carrot cake cupcakes were a special order and I couldn't order less than 1 dozen. I was told that cream cheese frosting was a special order. I was told that they don't do decorations on cupcakes but would put plastic sugar skull rings on them because I asked for a 'Dia de los Meurtos' theme. A deposit or payment in full was demanded up front for 1 dozen carrot cake cupcakes with cream cheese frosting. Did I mention that the cupcakes are $4.00 each? $4.00 each for nothing special standard size cupcakes. $4.00 each for dry almost tasteless cupcakes where the only richness came from the plop of frosting sitting precariously on top. Am I disappointed? Yes, extremely. Will be making any future purchases from Amy's? None whatsoever. If I need to order cupcakes where will I be ordering them from? Sprinkles or Brioche. Are they more expensive there? Yes, but they are moist, flavourful, and not chintzy with the frosting. * I don't know what has happened to Amy's, but it seems they are content to coast along on a reputation built from years of excellent service and delicious offerings while doing nothing to maintain that reputation. And that's how an institution ends it's days. read more

See all

Good cake with helpful employees. Fast workers and I recommend this location to everyone I know, so please be sure to check it out soon. Try the chocolate cupcakes. They are my favorite here. Plenty of parking. Always a plus right. read more

Amy's Pastry - Here again. - Bakeries Near Me - Montebello, California

I needed to post this review because my family and I have been loyal to Amy's for many years. The cakes are no longer the same. Not sure what has changed, ingredients are cheaper, new owners? Amy's cake melt very easily especially the chocolate mousse. I will post a picture so you get an idea of what I'm talking about. We never had this problem. Cakes look pretty gross, not to mention don't taste the same either. Very disappointed indeed! read more

See all

Always a recommended go to for custom cakes. I've asked for several custom cakes and with even short notice they bring my request to life! The staff is definitely patient and helpful when attending to the purchase. Quiet and clean which is always a plus when looking for somewhere to buy pastry's for events or home. Featured are some custom cakes I requested over the years. read more

See all

Cute dessert options. Red velvet cupcakes is my go to! Employees are always nice and helpful read more

Bought a New Year cake. Frosting tasted horrible. The cake was shifted off the carton baseboard, and the 2022 on top had the 2 smeared as you can see under it had a zero and they smeared off and wrote over it. Please stick to the light whipping cream frosting. The frosting used for your NYs cake was super thick and tasted horrible. If you're gonna charge $30 bucks pls give us a decent look and good tasting cake. These past years the cake at Amy's are just sloppy What happened to the old Amy's? This is not the same place form 20 years ago. read more

Amy's Pastry - Bakeries Near Me - Montebello, California

I hate doing updates like this but unfortunately I dont even know what to say. Flabbergasted is a literal understatement. FOR STARTERS. I placed an online order on Sept 5th, and I had to call and follow up on Sept 16 (yes they did not call within 4 business days.) whatever I overlooked that - and placed my order provided photos and was VERY detailed - even stated that I wanted the cake on a bigger white board (which I was charged for) because I wanted it to say "Happy Birthday Rosa". I was made aware that because I changed the frosting the florets would not match what I asked for - cool I understand. we went over the order once more and even stated this cake would be for a 50th birthday black tie event. I paid in full over the phone. damn near $180. Mind you I've never been disappointed by them before as I order ALL my cakes from here. Sadly that will no longer be the case; idk if whatever decorator did my cake hates the company they work for because they gave subpar work or they just don't like their job. obviously I was more upset they did nothing to fix the situation just offered to write happy birthday on top. THANKFULLY THATS THE ONLY NICE THING ON THE CAKE. Do what you want with this info - I will not be returning. read more

This is my favorite bakery, I come all the way from Texas for the best dessert. Aaron has a great attitude and great customer service! Totally recommend this place. read more

Amy's Pastry - Bakeries Near Me - Montebello, California

Great service and the best Pastries that are fresh and yummy! There is a wide array of choices for everyone to enjoy.

We always get our birthday cakes from Amy's since 2016. The last couple years the cakes have been DRY. This year's carrot cake was beautifully decorated but unfortunately the inside was not fresh or moist at all. Tasted like it had been in the case for several days. For $42 dollars for an 8" cake we expected it to be fresh. Ever since Covid their quality has been downhill and they run out of everything (pastries and bread) by noon and they're open till 7. We will be looking for a new bakery for our next birthdays. read more

Outstanding, delicious, my family enjoyed the Christmas cookie tray recommended to try the cakes, pastries as well

I purchased the heart shaped mousse and it was delicious. I usually get the flourless chocolate mousse cake but it was not available. My family loves Amy's. read more

Amy's Pastry - Heart shaped mousse - Bakeries Near Me - Montebello, California

Amazing fruit tarts and their service is really great, my daughter loves the raspberry tarts, great place all around read more

Amy's Pastry - Raspberry mousse and fruit tarts - Bakeries Near Me - Montebello, California

Love ordering costume cakes here I order in person so never had an issue like other reviewers placing online or phone orders. I also choose to do the earliest pick up time so never had a long wait for pick up and I usually pick up on a Saturday. Flavors I usually get are chocolate with chocolate pudding Or chocolate with chocolate moose and fresh bananas read more

Amy's Pastry - Bakeries Near Me - Montebello, California

See all

Amy's Pastry's has been serving the best cakes and pastries in Montebello since 1954. When I passing through, I have to stop in for a bear-claw. Amy's has the most tastiest bear -claw I ever eaten. California Health department rates the restaurants for cleanliness 'A' being the highest. Amy's is always A rated and my opinion they get an A for their Cakes & Pastries. read more

See all

It was my grandma's 80th birthday and she wanted a pecan ring. We have been going there for sooo many years. They were out, so I placed an order and paid for it in advance. They called me the day of and said none were made so I could get a refund.. But I would have to drive down there. I live 40 minutes away. They said they could make it by that Friday so I said that would be fine. They ended up calling again on the said day, saying the same thing as the fist time. I went in today and picked one up finally. No apology or effort to make up for the lack of customer service. Disappointing and not worth going there anymore. They ruined a special day. Definitely shouldn't have made the commitment to make an order and not deliver, TWICE. read more

I'm done with place. This was our go-to bakery. Quality and taste has gone down hill for a while these last few years. Saturday of mother's day weekend, there was a long line. We already came by earlier in the week to put in our order and paid it. They made everyone wait in line the day of pick up. I'm sorry. If you can't figure out a system for paid orders to be able to pick up separately, from same day orders, f... off. I'm done. This place isn't worth it. Over priced for the quality. Bakeries are ripoffs anyway. So expensive to pay for someone else to bake for you. read more

Amy's Pastry - Bakeries Near Me - Montebello, California

This place made the cake of my dreams. I don't know how they were able to read my mind, especially because the person who took my order had never seen Dazed and Confused. The bakers and service team are all professionals and know what they're doing. If you don't live nearby, I still highly recommend taking your business to Amy's. This cake was for 20-25 people and cost $120 (white cake, strawberries, buttercream frosting) which I thought was extremely reasonable considering how detailed it was. I also love that they airbrush and don't use fondant for everything!!! Delicious and beautiful. read more

Amy's Pastry - Dazed and Confused cake - Bakeries Near Me - Montebello, California

See all

I love it!! They were able to get me in for a custom cake last minute for my sons 3rd birthday thank you! Very delicious! read more

Amy's Pastry - Spiderman birthday cake! - Bakeries Near Me - Montebello, California

Haven't been to Amy's pastry for a long while, but I'm afraid it has gone downhill over the years. The selection of pastries is not as varied or fresh as it used to be, and most items are overly sweet. There are many better places to satisfy your sweet tooth these days. One reviewer says this place is like Porto's ...uhh it's not lol Probably won't be back anytime soon. read more

I've been coming to Amy's the passed few years. I order my cakes here. my go to is chocolate. it's super moist + nothing short from delicious. the staff is always helpful + attentive. this is why I keep coming back(: read more

Amy's Pastry - Amy's offers cake prints + my daughter's cake turned out soo cute! - Bakeries Near Me - Montebello, California

These were fabulous cakes made by Amy's. I previously posted about Amy's making the green & pink cake with 1 day notice. Coming through for us at the last minute. The red cake, i referred my neighbor. They loved it read more

Amy's Pastry - Made by Amy's - Bakeries Near Me - Montebello, California

See all

We happened to be in the area and craving a snack. We stopped by Amy's and due to the pandemic, waited outside for a few minutes. I appreciated a lot that they limited the amount of people inside the bakery to ensure social distance is being followed and we all feel safe. Once inside, there was no sense of rush to get you to select your pastries. Thank you for doing that and making me feel comfortable to take my time and ask questions. Huge kudos for that. I was a little embarrassed at first asking questions about what each thing was but the staff was awesome and answered all my questions as well as gave me recommendations. We went home with a chocolate cupcake that was decorated like a little turkey (my visit was in November so it went with the theme of Thanksgiving) and a fruit tart. The fruit tart was fresh, sweet and tasty. The cupcake was chocolate flavored but a little on the dry side. I did like that the frosting was not overly sweet. read more

My wife and I got married last week even though we had to push our wedding to next year. We decided last month to still order our "dream" wedding cake for the day and ordered from here! I thought it would be last minute and too niche, but they had no issues taking our order and the price was super affordable and fair! It came out perfect, they even were able to add the little veils! I'm absolutely obsessed with it and can't stop staring at the photos! I was too sleepy to show exactly how much I loved it when I showed up but everyone was really nice anyway lol not to mention it was moist and delicious, the Oreo filling is amazing Thank you so much!! read more

See all

This place went from 10 to 0 realllllll quick, people used to drive to Montebello FOR Amy's but it looks like they're cutting corners now, cases are empty, real lemon filling is now substituted with canned lemon jelly. I should just go to Albertsons because it's no different. I hope they go back to the old ways before they run this gold mine to the ground! Also the 2 stars is only because it used to be good, i would give them no stars for todays quality/taste! read more

Amy's Pastry - Lemon cake - Bakeries Near Me - Montebello, California

Order a cake for my mother's in-law birthday. It was for her 70th year celebration. The cake was delicious and delivered with care. Everyone enjoyed it read more

Amy's Pastry - Bakeries Near Me - Montebello, California

This bakery was my family's go to favorite for the chocolate cake (with chocolate frosting and pudding in the middle) for years. Something changed in their pudding filling and we no longer crave this treat. Amys please let us know when you change back to your original filling recipe. For now you have lost a loyal customer. read more

Most delicious pastries! My grandparents were going here over 40 years ago, so I grew up with Amy's. While a lot has changed, a lot has stayed the same. The pink boxes are now white, you still pull a number when you walk in, and the pastries are just as delicious! They no longer sell egg bread (sadly,it was the best!) The chocolate chip rolls and cigars are just as delicious as before, the apple turnovers are huge! The sampler tower is perfect size and has a variety or treats. Go early for the best selection. They told me you can call ahead and they will reserve and pack anything you want if the made that day, or they can make if you call a few days ahead of time. I stop here whenever I am in the area. It may be a bit pricey, but is so worth it! read more

This is your one stop shop for birthday cakes or a little something special for morning meetings! For birthdays I always pick up a large fruit tart and have it personalized on the spot with icing. If it's a morning meeting and I want to make a good impression, I will purchase individual fruit tarts. Overall, there is nothing at Amy's that is "just average". Everything is unique and fresh. Remember to tell your guests and co-workers where you purchased the desserts! TIP: Don't forget to grab a number as soon as you enter. The dispenser is on the far right as soon as you enter. Enjoy your visit! read more

See all

I recently put an order in for my daughters 3rd birthday. So excited for how my daughter's dinosaur cake is going to come out. I buy all my cakes for all my events through out the year. My family has been coming here for years. Cakes taste super DELICIOUS and this bakery truly has great customer service! read more