The food is tasty. I've always had the wings and a Greek pizza. The service is always fast and friendly. The ambience is inviting and warm. I can see why this is a local town favorite. It gets a bit too loud for me, but that's just the nature of the restaurant. It's a great date night please. It's a fantastic family place. It's just a fantastic overall place. Music bingo with the famous DJ Wes (thedjwes.com) makes it even "funner", lol. Cash prizes are generously provided by the town favorite judge & attorney, Tom Kirkbride (kirkbridelaw.com). They have open mic night with live karaoke. Just an overall fun place. It could use a good scrub though. (xoxo, nancyjdavis.org) read more

This place is amazing, the staff is friendly, the food great and it's always a cool setting and good music read more

See all

I was craving some pizza and was staying in Fayetteville. Do I decided to try Anthony's. I am glad I did! The place was hopping on a Friday night. Karaoke was going on. I got a small meat lovers pizza and an order of fried ravioli with meat sauce. Pizza was good. I liked the crust. The ravioli was good, but the meat sauce with it was fire! Luckily there was enough to put some on my pizza too! Great place to eat on the square in Fayetteville! read more

Anthony’s Pizzeria - Meat lovers pizza - Pizza Near Me - Fayetteville, Georgia

See all

I would have live to give a decent review of this place but, sadly I am unable to do so. My husband and I attempted to have dinner here. We walked into the interior of the restaurant and it was a little too loud so we decided to seat ourselves outside-;according to the exterior posted sign customers are able to seat themselves if dinning on the patio. Well, the waitress was busy but she didn't even acknowledge our presence. There was only one other couple seated near us and a few others waiting at a reserved table. She walked pass us twice and not one word, no menus, not even a welcome - we sat for 15-20 minutes. Nothing so, we decided to leave. We can and will spend our dollars elsewhere. Too bad because we were scouting for a hang out spot for about 30-45 heath-careo workers. read more

Staff is really great! We do Tuesday Jackpot Bingo for a while! Food and draft beer is always good! Varied menu to keep it interesting! Lunch specials are AWESOME!! read more

Anthony’s Pizzeria - Daily specials - Pizza Near Me - Fayetteville, Georgia

We had wrapped up a class in the area on a Friday at 6 p.m. and wanted to grab dinner in Fayetteville before heading home. I think we may have tried this place once before (maybe right after they opened / transitioned from another pizza restaurant?), but we wanted to check it out again. Parking is on-street nearby. There seemed to be plenty of spaces on the adjoining Lee Street or around the courthouse across the street. You enter via a semi-enclose patio (which is probably more open in warmer weather) and then enter the restaurant proper. We passed a server who told us that we could sit anywhere so we grabbed a booth. The place is pretty large. They just have the one huge dining room, with a bar along the left wall as you enter. The to-go station is ahead and to the right slightly. It was pretty busy when we were there, but they never seemed to have a wait. Maybe the enclose patio handles the overflow from the main dining room? Our server showed up quickly and took our drink orders. The menu had a variety of options including pizzas, sandwiches, burgers, etc. My wife opted to try a cauliflower crust pizza for the first time and it turned out to be quite tasty. I tried a small slice too. I got a burger and was happy to see that one option from their sides was fried okra! The pizza came out at least 5 minutes before the burger, but I eventually got it. I thought it was good, and also enjoyed the okra a lot. The servers got busier later, so it took a little while to get the check and a to-go box. Prices were pretty reasonable. We enjoyed our dinner here and would be glad to return. read more

It was the Best Pizza we have had in a long time. We will be going back. The service was great and was the ambiance.

Oh my! I guess I must give credit where credit is due. After a long day at work, hubby and I stopped to get some wings. Well, I've had recommendations for Anthony's and I decided to give them a try. If you say you sell "pizza" then bring it. Coming from NYC I must try your pizza to see how it compares. ANTHONY's did not disappoint this city gal!!! We got lemon pepper and teriyaki wings as well. Can you say wowza!!! Hot, crisp, nice sized and perfectly sauced and coated. I will definitely be back as this will be my new go to spot when I'm on this side of town. Here are my to go pics because everything was soooo good and I can't eat it all. Maybe next time. And trust me, there will be a next time. read more

See all

Went in on a Saturday evening and sat near the bar. Server brought me my beer and I let him know I was going to order dinner in a few minutes. Then it was crickets. I am not the type to start being loud and rude when ignored. I sat for oven an hour with nothing from the server. I noticed him leaving for the day and at that point I found someone to cash me out. I was looking forward to eating, but instead ignored. read more

If you are looking for a nice outing, cold adult beverage, and delicious food, you're at the right spot! :-) This is my first time at this restaurant, and the food is delicious. I ordered a slice of cheesecake, a pepperoni pizza and spaghetti, for my family. The restaurant is family oriented and somewhat like a nice sports bar. Many tvs on the wall, full stocked bar, and many items on the menu. The restaurant is clean, employees are attentive and friendly. We will definitely be back soon. read more

Anthony’s Pizzeria - the outside of the restaurant - Pizza Near Me - Fayetteville, Georgia

See all

10/10 chicken Parmesan great service very affordable. Definitely going back! Highly recommend read more

Anthony’s Pizzeria - Cheese Bread - Pizza Near Me - Fayetteville, Georgia

See all

Pretty cool little pub. Reminds me of something you'd find in east Atlanta village. Lots of events throughout the week, but very low key. I ordered a slice of pizza & got 2 for $4 which I was happy with! Our server was very attentive! read more

Anthony’s Pizzeria - Chicken tender sub - Pizza Near Me - Fayetteville, Georgia

See all

This food hits everyyyyyytime! Delivery or dine in. Everything is good down to the ranch dressing they use (Ken's) I couldn't attach a picture because I'm currently eating and melting in the inside I loveeeeee Anthony's. I've been eating from this place for a few years now and couldn't believe I didn't have a review. One time my delivery driver from DoorDash didn't deliver my food from here and I was definitely mad but I know she enjoyed every bite. I really can't compare this place to any other read more

We're a family of four, and Anthony's Pizzeria has become one of our go-to spots. Every time we visit, everyone finds something they love, whether a hot sandwich, wings, pizza, calzones, or even dessert. They have a great variety of Italian-style favorites, and the quality is always consistent. The service has always been solid, friendly, and efficient. It's the kind of place where you can count on a good meal and a good experience every time. read more

The family came for dinner. It was pretty packed as the restaurant was hosting a music bingo with a Dj. We ordered pizza, wings and salad. I liked the pizza because the crust was thin. We ordered the hot honey wings but you couldn't taste the honey. Our waitress was pretty attentive to our table. read more

First time at Anthony's and the worst pizza I ever had by a mile. Small topping items completely covered in brown cheese in a cardboard tasteless crust. My Hawaiian was identical to a fellow diners pepperoni in appearance. The bingo was kind of fun (so one star) but I would never recommend the pizza or eat there again! read more

Mary and Kaitlin are the best bartenders period. I will only eat here if they are there.

Full menu of great food. Pizza is excellent! Staff and owners are always helpful. Fun atmosphere with everything from bingo to karaoke to trivia to live music! We love Anthony's. read more

Here are some pointers to consider should you ever decide to eat at Anthony's Pizzeria: - Anthony's is one of the most popular hangouts in downtown (?) Fayetteville - Anthony's cooks prepare some tasty Italian food (and wings, too) - Anthony's staff includes stand-up guys and women - Anthony's puts on a karaoke night that you must check out if you ever get a chance -- in addition to other entertainment nights - Anthony's is situated in one of, if not THE, most popular area of Fayetteville, GA. There's lots of cool stuff to do around there - Being a popular place to attend, Anthony's can crank up the DECIBELS at night, esp. when DJ Wes does his thing.... I will let you, dear reader, draw your own conclusion. read more

THIS IS HOW YOU DO WINGS!!!!!! Honestly I'm going to need for Charlotte NC to take notes. The wings were so flavorful. I got the hot lemon pepper and honey hot, slice of pizza and large banana pudding (not pictured). The wings for me were a 9/10 only because they weren't that hot for both flavors but still really flavorful. The pizza was a 10/10 if you're a fan of chuckle cheese pizza then you'll love this. The banana pudding was also a 10/10. My total for 20 wings, a slice of pizza and a large banana pudding was $32 which isn't that bad for today's economy. I definitely will be returning for more! Now they do charge an extra dollar to spilt between 2 flavors even though I got 20 wings, which is odd but they're still good. read more

See all

Prime example of why I Yelp...Travels took me to Jonesboro/Fayetteville area. After finishing some business, I was hungry. I wanted some good grub in a sports bar atmosphere to watch college football, so I did a quick Yelp search and found Anthony's. The recent reviews were spot on. A quick drive took me to Fayetteville square. I decided not to sit on the patio with TVs, instead opting to go inside and sit at the bar. I was promptly greeted and ordered one of the various draft beers they have. After scanning the menu, I started with a side salad and the soup of the day, lasagna. Standard iceberg salad, nothing special, but I needed to eat some veggies so it served that purpose. The lasagna soup was ok. I feel like it could've used a few more spices, but I understand that everyone has different spice preferences. Definitely, could've been hotter. I ordered a 10in pizza next. Nice dough, flavorful sauce, fresh toppings. A pretty good pie! I was happy with my decision to visit and with my selections. I'll stop through again when I'm in the area. read more

Anthony’s Pizzeria - Great food & prices! - Pizza Near Me - Fayetteville, Georgia

Great food & drinks. Service is excellent. Fun things to do nightly. Patio is pet friendly.

Our Fayetteville Family took us to Anthony's on two occasions and we have loved it both visits. Lemon Pepper Wings are Best in town! The Caesar Salad was top notch! Really enjoyed the dressing tastes homemade. Craving Pizza? This is the place layered perfectly. We love the Pepperoni, Mushroom & Black Olive. Trying the Greek next time. Kids shared a large Greek Salad all Freshly made tastes great. The staff is always helpful and friendly. Food Hot Fast. Always Clean areas! Have events or entertainment on the regular. Patio is awesome. read more

The food is fine; service is usually slow. It's a very loud environment. I won't go back because they penalize the use of credit or debit cards. read more

Not at all impressed! That TINY pizza reminded me of school lunch from back in the day and that's how it tasted. It lacked season but it surely had enough grease! I didn't care for the atmosphere either, I won't be returning. I would've been better off buying one from the supermarket and baking it in the oven! read more

Anthony’s Pizzeria - This was as good as it looked - Pizza Near Me - Fayetteville, Georgia

I mean, I don't know what to say about this place. This is my new favorite. EVERYTHING I have tried on the menu is delicious. Friday night is karaoke night and it's SUPER fun. They have a full bar!!! The 1st night I went, I sat at the bar and wondered what was going on with my bar tender. He was forgetful. Slow moving and real space cadetish. I later saw him taking shots with another customer so I figured he was good and drunk. LOL!!!! I haven't seen him since. I wonder if he got fired? read more

See all

Gooooood ass pizza!goooooood ass pizza! Reall good assss pizza!!!!!!!!!!!!! Good service Great ambience read more

Was visiting the area and on Tuesday night it was packed for bingo I believe. Sat at the bar so I can get quick service. I order to calzone one of the largest calzones I think I've ever had. Was good, dough wasn't my favorite, but the ingredients are great. read more

Anthony’s Pizzeria - 3 ingredient calzone - Pizza Near Me - Fayetteville, Georgia

We were at Awkward Brewery and the staff recommended Anthony's and we were not disappointed. We've driven by that area several times but never noticed the place. The pizza was excellent and the fried raviolis delicious. The Tiramisu is usually my final decision on Italian food and was not disappointed. read more

We've been going to Anthony's for over a year now. We bring guests from out of town because it's unique and the food is mostly good. Recently we placed an order for pick up (wings, pizza, 2 Greek salads). When we arrived at the time we were told it would be ready, there was a delay because of the wings. When we got home we discovered the pizza was very cold and we found two long blonde hairs in our salad. It was a busy Friday night and we just dealt with it. We did, however, call to let a manager know. The female manager we spoke with was very confrontational, rude, would not listen and blamed us for the problem. We didn't even ask for anything. They do a lot of business and customers need to know of the bad experiences as well as the good. we told her we were going to complain on Yelp and she was not phased. read more

Ok. So I didn't even know this place existed. I've been looking for a sports bar to watch the NBA playoffs. Luckily during Earth Day one of the owners bumped into us and gave us a card. I like supporting local businesses so we decided to go by on a Wednesday night. It was actually pretty busy for a school night. The service was good, place was clean. Now for the food. The pizza was decent. I wouldn't say the best I've ever had but better than Amici's and the wings were great. The price was also great. Large pizza and 20 wings for just over $30 - win. Definitely going back. read more

If I could give this place zero stars I definitely would! This was one of the worst dining experiences I've ever had in my life. I definitely would not support this establishment if you are a person of color. My husband, son, and I visited this evening around 6:00pm. It's a seat yourself restaurant so we found a table and it took 10 minutes to get the attention of a waitress to get menus. The waitress told us that it was her first day and she was nice. After receiving our drinks we waited OVER AN HOUR for our food before finally asking the "manager" how long it would take to receive it. He checks and brings out the mozzarella sticks that we ordered which were cold and flavorless! A random waitress then proceeds to come to our table, touch our utensils that were still rolled in a napkin, and ask if she can take them for a table of (Caucasian) customers to use at another table! Of course we told her she couldn't take them. We then sat and watched three other tables of (Caucasian) patrons that sat down after us receive their food. At that point I asked the manager for the check for the drinks and appetizer and expressed how others had gotten their food before us. The manager was cold, unapologetic , and non-chalant at the fact that we had waited for over an hour for food. The only excuse he gave was that the kitchen got tickets mixed up. He never offered to cover our drinks or take a percentage off of the check for the inconvenience. The fact that my 3 year old said' "mommy can we leave? We never got our pizza" shows me that if a child can notice there's a problem why can't the manager of an establishment acknowledge a problem? All he did was rant about Americans not wanting to work & them being short-staffed, which has nothing to do with me and is irrelevant when others in the restaurant are still receiving their food. I'm glad that I didn't allow my anger to get the best of me because I really wanted to tear some shit up in that establishment. And what's so funny is that they had the nerve to have a sign on the door promoting a Halloween costume party but they asses couldn't even spell 'costume' correctly on the flyer but got the nerve to wanna be rude to somebody! On top of that, why promote a party here when you're already so "understaffed and overwhelmed"? This whole experience was incredibly disappointing and I would encourage no one to support this place! read more

Anthony’s Pizzeria - Pizza Near Me - Fayetteville, Georgia

Such a cool local neighborhood spot. The food is good and the service is great! They make you feel like you are apart of the team. I came and met my brother for lunch and was so glad for the invite. You don't have to go into Atlanta to get some good pizza because it's right here! Will definitely be back. read more

Anthony’s Pizzeria - 3-Item Calzone - Pizza Near Me - Fayetteville, Georgia

Ordered a Large Deluxe thru grub hub for PU @3:40 on 3/25 (yesterday). Asked for No Ham, please cut in squares ... instead received deluxe with Ham and normal cut. Couldn't eat much of the pizza ... tried to pick around the ham, especially since I had no time to return the pizza after pickup... The crust -good, a little more saucey than to my liking, cheese good. The other ingredients were lite on the pizza but heavy on ham... darn I was so looking forward to enjoying pizza and a movie. read more

Anthony’s Pizzeria - Large Deluxe Specialty Pizza- requested No Ham , cut in squares. - Pizza Near Me - Fayetteville, Georgia

See all

Great atmosphere and service. Lots of fun each night but a group of neighbors go Monday nights for Trivia and have loads of fun

Enjoyed this spot. Had a little bad arriving while we're there but didn't get fully setup before we left. The wings and pizza were pretty good but our server could have give a little better attention. read more

Great pizza place and salads and wings are good as well. Have been several times and always had great service even though usually fairly busy read more

i ordered a large cheese pizza and added @ 2.75 per topping pepperoni onion and mushrooms what I got was a small cheese pizza. I was to tired to drive back and didn't want to call and argue with what under paid service person that answered the phone. so I lumped it not sure if I would go back. the taste was fine it just wasn't what I ordered. Disappointed read more

The pizza here is amazing! Along with the wings & everything else. Friendly ppl & nice vibe with entertainment on certain days.

Great place to go for good food, entertainment that includes, open Mic night on Tuesday night after a game similar to Family Feud. Ladies Night on Wednesday night with live music and 3.00 drinks for the ladies and also dart competition. Thursday night is music Bingo with food prizes. Friday night is Karaoke with DJ Wes. Saturday night is going to be live music "again" and every other Sunday there is a live music jam that anyone can bring their instrument and join in. Something for everyone. read more