The food and drinks were good. This was my first time at Arni's. The pizza here is very thin and yummy. I had the potato soup which was actually salty, and it came with 2 mini cheeseburgers which were perfectly cooked with toasted buns. It did take about 20 minutes to get my drink. And an hour for the food to come out. I'm not sure why so long, we were only a group of 4 but that's why I give it 3 stars. A co worker of mine had to ask for his ice tea 3 times because he asked for unsweetened and they kept bringing sweet tea. I would try Arni's again. They cld have been short staffed who knows. read more

See all

Great food and good service. Love the salad and we get a pepperoni, pineapple pizza! read more

I love, love, love Arni's! Living on the west side of Indy I don't get it as often as I like because it's so far away....until now! I am so happy this location opened. I had high expectations because I've been to 5 other locations and they're all great - Brownsburg didn't disappoint. I stopped in after some work meetings for lunch and it was packed. It's only been open about 2 weeks so I expected that. I was able to sit up at the bar easily but it was about 20 minutes for the dining room. The food and service was phenomenal. The bartender, Diane, was on top of it. I got the lunch special that includes a 7" pizza w/ 2 toppings and their junior salad. There are other lunch special pairs but this was my selection. My husband and I will make regular stops in since I had an awesome experience and it's much closer than other locations! Meet you at Arni's! read more

See all

Haven't been to Arni's in quite some time. It's a solid place. Pizza arrived hot. 1/2 bbq sauce and 1/2 tomato sauce. Yum. Service was good. Good beer selection, I observed. read more

Order pizza and salad to go, then had to wait 30 minutes. This was at 4:00 pm. Restaurant is not busy. Waited that long to get a burnt pizza when I got it home. It was also ordered with extra sauce which we did not get. Watched the food prep people with gloves on shake hades with his buddy that had no gloves on then go right back to touching food. Then as I am still waiting watched him pick up his phone and play in it with out changing gloves. For their prices food should be better and service should be a premium. Will not return. read more

My husband and I ordered firecracker shrimp but it was clearly chicken. Stromboli bread was good but that's all. Chicken wings just ok. The ham and cheese was the highlight of the entire meal. We ordered crem brûlée cheesecake which we did not receive. Totally disappointing. read more

I keep going back and forth on this one. The four stars is for the dine in experience we had. We have ordered carryout a couple of times. The food is good and when we dined in, our waitress was very friendly and attentive. Their largest pizza is 14" and is tasty. I have been a little disappointed when things are forgotten on our carryout order. Especially when it is a side salad that costs $4.99. That's why I am being a little wishy washy on my review. I would say it is pricey for what you get. I have had the voodoo pasta a couple of times and enjoyed it. Overall I would say that it is good fare but not great. read more

We had a pizza, voodoo pasta, and Greek flatbread. Excellent food, waitress was attentive and helpful and service was quick. .

Visited Arnies for the first time last Friday. I had the salmon salad. It was delicious! My husband had the wings. He enjoyed them. Staff was friendly and the place was busy. We will be going back for some more delicious food! read more

My family came in for dinner Friday evening. We had a horrible experience from beginning to end. Our servers name was Ben and the smell of body odor and cat urine was offensive to say the least. He started out by telling us working there was a nightmare which I think was maybe supposed to be a joke but very inappropriate. We waited quite a while for our food but it seemed a little busy so we tried to be understanding. After receiving our meals he checked how everything was and we told him a couple of entrées were not very warm. He replied with "ok" and left without offering to fix the problem. There was an older woman in a colorful dress that I assume was the manager as we have seen her a couple of the times we have come in. Each time she seems frazzled and almost lost or something but last night she was behaving like the entire restaurant was on fire. We did try to get her attention but we're unable and I didn't even bother asking to talk to her because it was obvious that she was in way over her head. I don't come in a lot but maybe a couple of times a month and usually leave happy. Any other time I've had any issue our server or a manager has promptly and politely fixed it. This was the first time that I've felt like an inconvenience just by being there. Unfortunately I will not be returning after this awful experience. read more

They can't seat 6+ people or split a group because it's too hard. There are open tables, but expect a 40 min wait.

I really wanted to a go a bit higher on my rating, but after careful consideration, 3-stars OK feels like a fair summary of our experience. You want to know what tipped my star-rating to 3-star instead of 4-star? It was the poorly toasted bread on my club sandwich. I even checked the website before I wrote this review to make sure I wasn't speaking in error here: "CLUB ARNI - Turkey, ham, bacon, American, Swiss, lettuce, tomato, mayo, toasted multigrain bread. 10.99" I've said in other reviews, I'm a sandwich guy. My kid loves to make jokes about it while he orders fancy steaks and homemade pastas, but whatever, there are worse fates in life than being a sandwich guy. Club sandwiches happen to be a favorite of mine, I happen to be partial to the triple-decker club sandwich I used to enjoy on the regular at every local diner in Chicago, but I haven't been able to find that style here in Indy, which is fine, it's just a sandwich. But my bread. It's not that my bread at some point didn't find itself in a toaster. When my sandwich came out I thought to myself that's odd, I swear that bread is supposed to be toasted, and when I touched the bread it was warm, it had definitely been IN a toaster, but it was not toasted. And sure I could have brought it to the waiter's attention, but I was hungry, and on a serious note the toasted bread most likely wouldn't have elevated this review to 4-stars as the three meals we ordered were OK. So here's some positive feedback. This is a new restaurant, it's really nice on the inside, and the bathrooms have those hands-free door openers so you can wash your hands, and then open the door with your foot instead of your hands, and that's nice. The staff that helped us was friendly and attentive. I'd definitely give this place a second shot. And truth be told, I feel like we committed a bit of a restaurant goer sin by not ordering something Arni's is known for. I mean, Arni's is, to the best of my knowledge, a pizza and burger joint, and while their menu is pretty expansive, none of us ordered a burger or pizza. I'm always in the mood for pizza, it's just the rest of my family was pizza'd out, so I went with my old standby, and boy, that toast thing sure irked me. But again, the food was fine, it was OK for sure, which is still positive, the staff and building are fantastic, and I think they'll get it right with the toaster one day. read more

See all

Maybe because they have only been open a week or so, I won't rate this one quite as high as some of the Arni's I have been to. It was clean and the food was okay, but for our Friday lunch, the wait to be seated was a half hour and growing while we waited. They take your phone number so they can text you when a table is ready, I assume they want you to wait in your car, but we decided to wait with our masks on to keep in touch with how long the wait was going to take and that nobody was getting seated before us. Right around the estimated time, they just told us since we were near the entrance not far from the host desk. Everyone was in masks, so though it got crowded when more people entered, many walked out due to the long wait. Most folks have to get back to work, so half hour waits will have to be improved on. My wife asked and didn't get a satisfactory answer why they were so backed up. I asked if we could at least have a menu to look at while we waited so that we could place our order right away. That was helpful. One thing I didn't anticipate being a surprise was that the beverages didn't list prices, so that when my two granddaughters and I ordered milk shakes with our meals, that was $18 for the 3 drinks! Even though we weren't seated by the front door, it was quite drafty and my wife and one granddaughter didn't wear their jackets and were cold for most of the meal. The noise level wasn't bad for as crowded as they were. We could carry on a conversation easily. Our food came out fairly quickly, but the waitress forgot to ask if we wanted water in addition to our milkshakes which took a lot longer since she had to get someone to help her make them. Water would have been nice. The food was plentiful which I usually don't mind, but lunch sized portions would have been nice to offer on my wife's Southern Fried Chicken Salad with Honey Mustard dressing. Good taste, just way too much. Our granddaughters aren't so little anymore, so they ordered a cheeseburger and the other a hamburger. The tater tots were definitely preferred. More crisp than the fries. I ordered the Breaded Tenderloin which was thick, but a little dry. It was almost too tall for my big mouth to take in. They only had a dill spear, not dill slices on the sandwich and the mustard was in packets. I also got the side of Brussels Sprouts for $1 upgrade over the fries offered with the sandwich. They had a good, but not readily identifiable flavor, but were a bit undercooked which made them chewy. I like mine grilled until the outer leaves turn crisp and maybe a little blackened. This was just a jaw workout. Probably won't order those again. The service the rest of the time was good and the wait time for our food and upon request, the bill, was minimal. Hopefully, the restaurant will iron out the delays and fine tune the portion sizes and cook times. I think I will wait a bit before heading back, but it was good enough that I don't regret going. Review #3895 read more

See all

Quick service. Server was friendly. I ate the smoked mac n cheese with chicken and bacon bits. The chicken was dry but overall the dish was good! read more

Enjoyed the Mediterranean flat bread. Would love a few more non meat options. Always loved the Arni's jr. salad but would be great with more veggies. read more

We were pleasantly surprised to get a table and enjoy good service after hearing about the crowds and long waits. No nostalgia or past personal experience by us for Arnie's; but we've heard about the heritage from friends here and so respect it (we are Marions Dayton fans and have been on the other side of this). So for those who grew up loving Arnie's we feel this location did the job nicely. The restaurant manager made the rounds and helped out in all areas to support ensuring a positive experience from patrons. read more

Arni's - Brownsburg - Fresh fresh fresh and Crispy as requested - American Near Me - Brownsburg, Indiana

To start off tonight dinner after returning home from NY, my family and J got together to go to dinner and we decided on Arni's. Once we got there we were told that we could either sit outside in 90° weather or it would be a 45 minute wait.(we had a group of 7) We asked if they could just push two of the tables together, which after looking around and no one being there; we figured that they could do it but the waitresses just didn't want to! However the food was mid but even after the big group left they still told us that it would be 45 minutes! Like WHAT?! We ended up leaving and going somewhere else. read more

Came in for the stuffed mushroom, they are my absolute favorite. Ben was my server and he was fantastic!! Good service is rare these days and Ben went above and beyond to make my time there great! Great lunch spot! read more

If I could I would leave this company, location -0- stars. Never been to this restaurant & will never come back. This location was empty except for a couple at the bar & 2 tables with very loud teenagers. Hostess tried to sit us next to them & we said no & pointed to another area. She was upset but did move us to a corner. We sat for over 5 minutes while workers walked around and never approached us. We walked out and never come back! read more

This is on of my favorite stops when visiting family I'm central Indiana. I'm a huge fan of the Stromboli. The food is always on point and has excellent flavor read more

Best by far fried pickles I have ever had! They had a Parmesan breading! They also came with a peppercorn ranch and a regular ranch, both good. I had the Buffalo wrap and it was good! My husband had a Stromboli and loved it. I didn't get a pic of his though. read more

Arni's - Brownsburg - Buffalo chicken wrap onion rings - American Near Me - Brownsburg, Indiana

See all

Good variety, something for everyone. Salads are great and the tenderloin was wonderful and huge!

Skip it! We sat down, only to be passed by several times, after 10+ min a mgr walks by and ask if we had been greeted. We said no and she offered to get our drinks started and find our waitress. Another waitress came said she also wasn't our waitress but wanted to get our appetizer going . We ordered the nachos w/ the beans and corn on the side. It came and of course had it on the nachos , not on the side as we requested . I would of sent back only our waitress never came till they were almost gone. She asked to remake them I said no as I can pick them off since it's been so long. We ordered, my personal pizza reminded me of nasty pizza king with its salty crust, and small chopped toppings. The fries were blah with no seasoning. Overall the staff was lacking in attentiveness and not once did I get asked for a refill , but then again our waitress was not existent and the food was not of any standard above Applebee's in my opinion. Definitely won't come back. read more

See all

Overall, the food is really good. The service and wait times just leave some to be desired.

The pizza & salad tasted very good. Overall, the service was ok, but our waiter was very friendly. I love thin crust pizza like this.

Great food ! Large wonder side salad. Building is very very clean ( even the bathroom ) Great service too.

We ordered the white wedding pizza with extra cheese, crispy. I had to send it back to the kitchen twice to be put back in the oven because the dough was raw. The second time our waiter brought it out he had an attitude about it so I gave up on asking a third time. Update: I have food poisoning read more

We went here with our family for lunch on Sunday. The kids enjoyed their burgers, but my wife and I didn't like our meals (Nashville hot chicken sandwich and a flatbread pizza). They also forgot to bring one of our meals and we had to ask for it three times before they brought it (after we had all already eaten). Solid meh. read more

Started off calling restaurant to gauge wait time. Staff replied no wait. Arrived at restaurant 10 minutes later. Saw empty tables, but told 15-20 minute wait. Had to give full name and phone number. Wanted to eat, not apply for a job. Other parties walked in and seated immediately. Assuming those were reservations. After 25 minutes, seated at a table that was empty since our arrival. Ordered appetizers and entrees. Food was slightly above average, worth what was charged for it. Waitress was excellent, best part of experience. read more

Great food and atmosphere. We had something from every section of the menu and it was all super good. Aaron was our server and he was amazing and we have the same zodiac sign. He had the whole dining room but you wouldn't know it he took such good care of us. 10/10 recommend him his energy is amazing. We will definitely be back and requesting him! read more

Always a great local spot to eat at with a diverse menu for all tastes. Lots of different pizzas to choose from some that you can't find at other places. Whether it's a quick lunch or nice dinner they got it all. Haven't had anything bad here read more

The food at Arni's is always amazing, you can't go wrong with anything on the menu! However, the last few times we have been in here, they have gotten our orders wrong or something is missing. We are told there is a wait, however there are always empty tables everywhere. Lastly, the service is subpar. We waited 20 minutes for our drinks and another 10 minutes for a refill. read more

Exceptional service and delicious food! Awesome ambiance: the interior was well designed with quality craftsmanship. Valerie, our server, was very attentive and friendly - and patient - as we decided on our drinks, appetizers, and dinners. The chili, as well as the Mediterranean salad with chicken, was perfect. My dining companion's meatball sandwich was fantastic! Linda, the manager, was also engaging and ensured an excellent dining experience. Must go back again! read more

Best salmon ever!!! Broccoli steamed to perfection! Homemade salad dressing! Yum! Tito's drink special- superb! Can't say enough good things about this place! read more

Jonathon at the bar is awesome. Very attentive and I've witnessed him doing a great job cleaning up after patrons finish. Awesome job and he made a great Long Island. Also the mini burgers were delicious. Glad I stopped in for an early dinner read more

Had a great meal at Arni's tonight., as always, But the reason I'm giving a rating is because of the effort and hustle we saw from the general manager (Linda, I believe) She was moving around the place constantly, covering for everyone who might have been distracted, etc. Just really appreciated her efforts to keep everyone happy. read more

Our cute little waitress Alana is the BEST! She served the food in such a professional manner, checks on us frequently and makes sure our food is hot and good We can see she is going places in this world! Thanks to Arni's for hiring such a great employee read more

Overall our service was good for the hostess to the server and even the follow up from Management checking on our visit. Unfortunately the food wasn't good. The White Bean Chili was served cold, fried pickles where over fried (burnt). Salmon wasn't good. Thinking in terms of a 1-10 scale. Service was 8.0 - Food was 4.0 - overall value was 5.0. I don't think we would give this another visit that was the consensus for all three of us. read more

We arrived and was told by hostess that there was no wait in the bar but no tables in bar so we checked in for regular table then bar table open up so took name off hostess list then then put a reserved table sign on the table we were waiting on. We tried to sit at bar but daughter didn't have ID so I asked bartender if we could just get a regular table and she was incredibly rude and said she couldn't get us a table and went on to argue with me so we left. I've always loved Arni's but Will not be back. read more

Food is very good, service is very good, and the ambience it's OK. The menu has a nice American variety and everything I've had has been very good. read more