3.5 stars. I love a…read moregood bagel and Bagel & Deli Shop has been on my list for years since they popped up on my TikTok. I finally tried it last night and it was good and I'm glad I tried it. I can see the reason for the hype especially if I'm a drunk college student. The employee was friendly and offered an opinion when I asked for one which I appreciated. The shop definitely has a vibe and a charm that has collected over the last 50 years.

A nice pick me up for breakfast! The menu is huge, the service is quick and the staff is awesome…read more An Oxford staple that every visitor needs to try before they leave

This place always delivers!!!…read more Love the French toast bagel. The mocha is hands down one of the best in the city!!!

Pretty good bagel. Was out of a lot of options so settled with the Lox on an onion bagel. Not bad,…read moreand tried the fresh squeezed OJ. That was definitely the highlight of the meal. Service was 5/10. Wasn't very friendly for it being Father's Day. Other than that, was not bad at all.

My partner and I grabbed bagels on a Sunday afternoon and there so many varieties and sandwiches…read moreavailable! We were greeted by most of the workers and ordered at the counter. It did take upwards of 10 minutes to prepare the sandwiches, despite only one other party behind us. The bagel sandwiches were delicious and some of the best ones I've had in the area. We ate in store and there are only a few tables. But seating area is simple and good for a quick bite to eat.

Came in with my BFF to get a bagel and coffee…read more You walk in to see the seating area and the bathroom. You have to walk down the hall way to order food. They have a decent selection of bagel and some yummy options. We got an egg, cheese, and ham on a bagel. We also ordered a vanilla cold foam with an iced coffee that was very good. We sat down and enjoyed our lunch. The staff were polite and very helpful. I would recommend coming here if you are looking for something different in the bagel category or just something different.

Ben is a chef that during covid created this business from home. You put in your order and he…read morenotifies u when they are done. Begels are hot and amazing. Everything begel has most toppings i have ever seen. Begels are boiled not steamed which is the secret to greatness. Wish he did sandwiches. .phone number in pictures

This was our first order. These bagels were hot and fresh when I picked them up and right on time…read more They're so soft and filled with flavor. I ate one as soon as I got in the car! And this morning they were breakfast sandwiches, perfection!

Stopped by The Bagelry in OTR for a Saturday morning breakfast and now I get why this place stays…read morebusy. I ordered the NYC Lox on an everything bagel and it was chef's kiss. Honestly felt like I was back in New York. Everything was fresh, balanced, and just done right. I also grabbed an iced cold brew and it was exactly what I needed to start the morning. No ambiance, It's definitely more of a grab-and-go kind of spot, but they do have a standing bar if you want to stay and eat without heading back to your car. Nice option if you've got a few minutes. The staff were hustling the whole time, keeping up with both in-person and online orders, which was impressive to watch. Parking is pretty manageable with paid street parking and nearby public lots. If you're in OTR and want a solid breakfast bagel, this place is worth the stop.

The bagels were quite good! I had two. The Asiago and an everything bagel both toasted. The…read moreeverything had turkey and lettuce. After seeing the pictures on here and google I was hoping for a bit more filling. They both tasted great so not too big of a letdown. The jalapeño cream cheese was a winner for me. They also were fully staffed which kept the line moving. There is no place to sit. They have a stand and dine counter that goes along the windows. Overall a decent place for breakfast bagels. I would gladly come back.

Went to NewYork a while back and had some Amazing bagels! I came here during my search to find…read moreIndy's good eats, and this place did not disappoint. The shop is super cute, the vibe was on point, and everyone--from the staff to the customers--was incredibly friendly. There was a short line, but it moved really quickly. I ordered the turkey bagel on a jalapeño cheddar bagel, a blueberry bagel with strawberry matcha smear, and a mocha vanilla latte. When my daughter saw the blueberry bagel with the green matcha smear, she wanted no parts of it! I think the color threw her off, but the flavor was phenomenal... so I ended up eating her bagel instead, lol. The turkey bagel was really good and fresh. The jalapeño cheddar bagel was soft and paired perfectly with the turkey. At first, I didn't like the latte, but after a quick stir, it came to life and was delicious! I'm definitely ordering all three again and can't wait to come back.

This is such a cute little spot with so many bagel options. Although it was quite busy, the wait…read moretime is not too long and the staff is very courteous. There is no seating outside but there is some outside. Also, there is limited parking outside of the. I really loved the savory scallion and bacon cheese spread (schmear). The matcha strawberry schmear was also very delightful. I got a plain bagel for both options which was soft, a little chewy and perfect when toasted. If you are looking for an inexpensive and quick breakfast, stop bye.

Great bagels. Great service. As close to NY as possible. If it's not on the shelf, they'll bake it…read morefresh.

I had known about the location in Middletown for the longest time but spotted this one on DoorDash…read more I go on there a lot to see what's new. We came in around noon, so it wasn't even busy. Maybe a handful of customers. Some of whom ordered pick up online. I got eggs, cheddar, and Taylor ham on an Asiago bagel. My sister got the same except she went for sausage and on the egg everything bagel. It's not super salted which was good. Very cheesy which I loved! Very light on the flavors. My sister's sausage patty was thick! These are hefty breakfast sandwiches! And the egg everything bagel was phenomenal. I should've gotten that instead as it was more flavorful than the Asiago. The woman at the register had recommended the egg everything as her favorite...I should've listened. My dad liked the blueberry bagel. They warmed it up for him. I'd def come back! Really impressed that they still had all the bagel flavors even though they were going to close in less than 2 hours. And the latkes look good to try next time too. It's a large space. Tons of seating. And a few TVs showing sports. Tons of parking around here since it's by Kroger. Glad they're in the neighborhood!

Dear 5th Street Bagel Shop... I paid 6.95 or so for this…read moresalad. I barely got a cup of lettuce and some of it is brown. When I asked for a garden salad I truly thought it would be more than this. I think your salads need to be removed from your menu if this is what you give out to your customers with a smile. 2 cucumber slices that are chopped, I'm pushing 2 tomato slices chopped, maybe 2 red onions chopped and a couple of banana peppers... as much as this cost you can do way better. From... your lost customer

Delightful Asiago bagel with sausage, egg, and cheese, plus blueberry bagel with cream cheese and…read moretwo raspberry mocha iced coffees. Delicious, friendly service and atmosphere, and efficient.

Excellent bagels and very friendly service…read more Today I ordered a breakfast bagel, Heavenly Hash, which was the best breakfast sandwich I have had for quite some time. It was substantial, with eggs, cheddar cheese, and a potato pancake with house dressing. Service was very friendly, and parking is convenient just outside the door. This bagel shop is nicely decorated and attractive.

This is my Second time waiting for 30 minutes for my bagel with cream cheese to come out like this…read more There was a Very *minor* rush which the team didn't handle well.

We stopped in and got two of the March special Irish cream latte and a pot of gold latte…read more Coffee drinks are fantastic, service is fantastic, they are encouraging the use of your own cup. Nice comfy coffee shop seating. We like the art work that changes and can be purchased. Still haven't made it up stairs.

Another stop on the SE Indiana Coffee Trail!…read more Lovely shop in a great space downtown. Stopped in on a Saturday and tried their turkey trot latte (iced). Excellent drink! Also tried a cheesecake brownie. - so good! Staff was super friendly and very prompt on service. If you are in the area, it's a must-try!