The worst thing is not making your reservations for pie in advance, we get all of our family event pies from Ashleigh s - if one of us fails to make our order in time it is a very sad event! We love her chocolate cream pie the coconut cream pie and the banana cream pie I don't know how she does it but her crust is amazing on a cream pie it's just mouth-watering and I don't eat pie from anywhere else. You can stop in for a slice if there's any left or again order a pie to go you can't go wrong. Inside Prydes (and that's another amazing place to shop) they sell the greatest of everything kitchen related I was on an apron kick this year and I noticed she had a bunch of aprons food little ones. read more

This place has been on my list for a while and it didn't disappoint! On the bottom floor of Pryde's (a fantastic space and shop in its own right), this pie shop was like an unexpected surprise. My favorites were the peach pie and the key lime pie. This is one of the few bakeries I've had where the crust isn't just secondary to the pie filling. The crust on the peach pie is amazing. Perfect, buttery, delicious, with just the right about of crisp and flakiness. Wasn't soggy on the bottom. The key lime had a perfect ratio of cream to pie and the filling was so smooth and not overly stiff/congealed like I've had elsewhere. $6 for a giant slice of happiness is a great deal. I'll definitely come back anytime I'm craving pie. read more

See all

Best key lime pie! I've made an order for a full key lime pie twice now and it is so good. When I came in, they were providing samples for other items and everything is delicious. Such a cute place tucked away in Pryde's Old Westport, great service and delicious pie - I need to try more things here. read more

Ashleigh's Bake Shop - Key lime pie - Bakeries Near Me - Kansas City, Missouri

The best Key Lime Pie I have ever had! Service is amazing! You can preorder pies just simply by a text message.

Ashleigh Bake Shop is a hidden gem (and my guilty pleasure)! I tried both the Apple Crumble and Peach Pie, and they were amazing. The all-butter crust is perfection--flaky, rich, and melts in your mouth. The apple crumble had the perfect balance of sweet and tart with a delicious crunchy topping, and the peach pie tasted like summer in every bite, with juicy peaches wrapped in that golden crust. You can tell everything is made with quality ingredients and lots of love. I'll definitely be back to try more of their pies! read more

Ashleigh's Bake Shop - Apple crumble pie - Bakeries Near Me - Kansas City, Missouri

See all

I've been wanting to stop by Ashleigh's bake shop for quite some time and finally made it today! Unfortunately we came at about 1pm on a Saturday and she was almost sold out. She had a few flavors left so we grabbed a key lime and banana cream pie slice. The atmosphere is very unique because it's in the bottom of Pryde's. I love how old timey and unique it is. It literally feels like you're stepping back in time. The bake shop is more of a "to go" place. Like I said, stop by early to get the popular flavors. I love key lime pie and it didn't disappoint! read more

See all

The most amazing, delicious pies you've ever had. The portions are generous and you can pair your pie with vanilla ice cream.

Always incredible! It's my favorite weekend habit. Pick up a quiche and cookies and I'm good for the week! Ashleigh is wonderful and the best pies I've ever eaten. read more

Best pie in Kansas City hands down!!! Great selection of homemade pies from fruit to cream pies. Ashleigh's pie crust is delicious, I'm typically not a fan of crust. She is very accommodating and provides great service to her customers. Located in Westport, lower level of Pryde's Old Westport Kitchen & Necessities, and is open Thursday through Saturday. read more

No disrespect to any of the other amazing pie shops out there, Ashleigh's is now in the lead for the best pie in KC! I can't believe I haven't tried it before now, but it was worth the wait! The minute you walk into Pryde's Kitchen shop, the aroma of pies baking hits you (if you're there on a Thursday, Friday, or Saturday). Pryde's is like the holy land for kitchen connoisseurs, but I'll review that separately. Located downstairs in Pryde's you will find Ashleigh's Bake Shop, and if Pryde's is the holy land of kitchen supplies, Ashleigh's is nirvana for incredible pie. I absolutely cannot wait to try all of her offerings on splurge days! Today was key lime and it was easily the best I've ever had. Freshly squeezed lime juice, homemade whipped cream and the graham cracker crust was the perfect buttery crisp consistency. Some graham cracker crusts can be too hard or too crumbly, but this was spot on perfection. At first I thought the flavor wasn't tart enough, but the more I ate the more I realized it was so well balanced it allowed all the flavors to shine through, the lime, the crust, and the rich and fluffy whipped cream. We had to get it to go as the shop is small with only a few little tables. We couldn't wait, so it was the first time I ever ate pie in my car, and oh, what an incredible experience it was! One of those occasions that will be imprinted in my mind... the first time I tried Ashleigh's pie sitting in my car on a hot July afternoon! Pie perfection, well done Ashleigh! read more

The shop is terrible their was mold on my pies the service was awful I asked for a refund and got yelled at and called a racial slur

I love to bake but I have not mastered pie crust. It never turns out great for me, to my shame. Thank God for Ashleigh and her peerless pie crust. When I don't feel like embarrassing myself on yet another holiday, I order an always perfect pie or five from Ashleigh's Bake Shop. Do try the sweet corn and roasted poblano quiche. It is divine. Fair warning, the Bake Shop is on the lower level of Pryde's. I adore unnecessary kitchen gadgetry and try to shield my eyes and proceed with caution, but I never pick up a pie order without buying something else on the way in or out. If you, too, are the curious type, allot some time to explore. read more

Bountiful Bakeries Asleigh's Bake Shop The lemon shortbread cookie from Asleigh's Bake Shop located inside the iconic Pryde's green general store on the edge of Westport is perfectly balanced and not too sweet, which to me is essential. Shortbread cookies are my all time favorite kind and the lemon one from Asleigh's is one tough cookie to beat. If I had to come up with a Kansas City Top 10 Cookie's (and I just might!) then this would be on it, so would another lemon, sweet and savory combination cookie but that's for another time and review. The offerings at Asleigh's are highly impressive and span the true gambit of baked goodies. They change the glistening jars and pie plates seasonaly if not weekly and with what they do always excites my tastebuds. The last time I was in the pies that caught my eyes were a tantalizing salted honey custard pie and a goat cheese honey pie however, I had to go with a saucer-shaped shortbread with the slightest hint of tangy lemon. The crumbly factor was in tact and the rich buttery flavor of the shortbread balanced the sweetness with the right amount of fat. This is not a delicate cookie but rather thick standing up to a warm cupper or brightening a cold day. Asleigh's Bake Shop inside of Pryde's is as iconic as it is inventive and deserves a full 5/5 stars, just remember the hours are a little wonky so plan out a stop into Asleigh's and you'll be glad that you did. read more

See all

This is the best place for pies! Ashleigh and her mother are so nice. I haven't met her dad, probably because he's keeping the ovens going. LOL I love that I can text my order and it's delivered to my car when I arrive. I have not had anything less than delicious. Bonus: Best chocolate chip cookies too. I'm so glad they are here. read more

My parents came into town and they love pie. I found this place on Instagram and based on the limited hours I figured it was a small shop locally owned. I was right. They are inside (lower level) of Pryde's Kitchen and Necessities. My experience started when I noticed you can text them your order. I texted the number to let them know that I would be coming on Thursday to pick up pie and asked if I should order ahead or if it would be safe to pick up and select based on what's available when I get there. She said I should order ahead because they often sell out before end of the day. I ordered one whole pie and several individual slices for my party of six. Everything is fresh and amazing. When we got the pie out after dinner, and everyone selected their pieces the amazement at the wonderful flavors from everyone at my house was almost shocking. My favorite was the Keylime pie. I don't even know how to put in words how much flavor was in this pie. (My mouth is watering as I type this). We ordered a whole banana cream pie, and it had fresh made Whipped cream topping. It was all so tasty. This is a must try if you like pie. Super super friendly and easy ordering over text message. Definitely put this on your list. And... As I mentioned, it's in the basement of a small kitchen store that has so many wonderful and unique items. I can't wait to go back just to check out Pryde's. read more

See all

The best pies and chocolate chip cookies in the area! Ashleigh is so nice and very accommodating. I love planning to pick up treats. Plus, there's a pickup door and your order will be delivered to your vehicle. read more

Quaint little bake shop inside and on the 1st floor of Pryde's coocking and home improvement shop. You wouldn't know it's there unless you went out of your way to find it, but let me say it's totally worth a little detour. They mainly serve coockies and pies (whole, by the slice, or in mini-pie version). Strawberry-rhubard, coconut cream, classic punmpkin, chocolate German... they have a wide, mouth-watering pie selection. And, of course, offer coffee to go with it. Seating is limited, yet cozy; it's honestly almost like eating in your favorite family baker's kitchen. read more

Ashleigh's Bake Shop - Valentine's day cherry pie - Bakeries Near Me - Kansas City, Missouri

See all

Delicious pie with friendly, prompt service! I ordered a raspberry rhubarb pie over text and Ashleigh had it ready the next morning for curbside pickup. It was so yummy and my husband and I were huge fans of the crust. We will definitely be back to try more! read more

Ashleigh's Bake Shop - Raspberry rhubarb pie - Bakeries Near Me - Kansas City, Missouri

I didn't think I would find it, but I have found the perfect slice of pie! I am a picky pie person so I'm telling you, Ashleigh's is that good. The peach pie was truly amazing and I now understand why it is such a crowd favorite. The filling is stuffed with fresh peaches that have just the right amount of sweetness. But, what really makes these pies stand out is the crust. Man, I could dream about that crust for days... The crust is buttery, flaky, and just a tad caramelized at the bottom. You will not find a better crust anywhere else. While the price for these pies is fairly expensive, it is definitely worth it for the quality you get! If you are a pie person like me, then you need to come here! read more

I've order a few times key lime pie from Ashleigh's bake shop and year after year it's always amazing. I love that I am able to order fresh key lime pie in November. I highly recommend this bake shop for anyone looking for a delicious fresh locally made pie! read more

Ashleigh's Bake Shop - Key lime pie - Bakeries Near Me - Kansas City, Missouri

Wow! The pies!!! We tried the chocolate cream, the quiche and some blueberry/goat cheese/basil pie and they were all SO SO SO GOOD!! We saw several guys in there who were by themselves and are REGULARS and I feel like that alone is saying something. Where do you ever see guys come in for pie when there are no naked ladies around? read more

Ashleigh's Bake Shop - Bakeries Near Me - Kansas City, Missouri

See all

We had Ashleigh's pies at our wedding. FANTASTIC! So flexible, delivered to our venue, and everyone raved about the 5 flavors we picked (chocolate chess, smores, key lime, coconut cream, and apple). read more

Seriously amazing crust! I've had her coconut cream, banana cream, chocolate, cherry, rhubarb raspberry, key lime, and butterscotch. They were all good. You have to order early for special occasions. She was sold out two months in advance for mother's day. read more

After lunch we looked for dessert. Luckily, we found this great spot for pies. They have so many different types of pies. We opted for the salted honey custard and gooseberry. Both were great. The salted honey pie had a nice contrast of sweet and salty. It worked well together. This was the first time I ever had a gooseberry. I liked it. It was tart, but enjoyable. The crust was homemade and you could taste it. The crust was really flakey and tasty. read more

Ashleigh's Bake Shop - Salted Honey Custard - Bakeries Near Me - Kansas City, Missouri

See all

Great bake shop. All the pies have been exceptional, especially the banana cream. Great service to boot.

We planned a surprise Mother's Day/Dad's birthday weekend trip from DC to KC to visit my family. I wanted to find a locally made coconut cream pie - my dad's fave - for our birthday dinner dessert. I texted Ashleigh about 5 days in advance to place a pickup order and she was very responsive and friendly. On pickup day, I wish I had had more time to spend in Pryde's (the store where Ashleigh's is co-located). That place is a bakers/chef's dream! If you've never been, set aside some time to browse before you get your pie. I was so glad I ordered ahead because she sold out of pies that day in an hour! If you want a specific pie on a certain day, I highly recommend ordering in advance, especially on holiday weekends. The pie was... the most freaking delicious coconut cream pie any of us had in our lives. And I come from a long line of Midwestern grandma pie bakers. The crust was thick and flaky and the fillings were rich without being too heavy. Just divine. 10/10 - I'm going to find an excuse to order a pie from Ashleigh every time we come to town. Thank you! read more

This adorable nook inside a cooking store was such a treat! We loved the chocolate peanut butter pie and chocolate chip cookie! Hands down I recommend read more

Ashleigh's Bake Shop - Chocolate cream pie - Bakeries Near Me - Kansas City, Missouri

Ashleigh's is amazing!! I work across the street from Pryde's, and all of my coworkers LOVE going over on Thursdays and Fridays to get some of her pie! She offers something for everyone's palette, whether it is crab pie, brownie pie, or the rich chocolate cream; I've never had a slice of pie from her that I didn't love! She will even warm it up for you if you ask. Plus she is wonderful to talk to, and you can tell she really has a passion for her work. read more

See all

Hands down, the best key lime pie in Kansas City.

This place is a gem. You take a bit of a "kitchen-land adventure" getting to it's location on the lower floor, but it prepares you for the journey your taste buds will experience once you arrive. The shop decor is quaint and perfect. It feels like some of the food halls I've experienced in NYC. It has an amazing feel to the place. On my visit I got the orange shortbread, Pistachio shortbread, chocolate chip cookie, pecan bars and a slice of coconut cream pie. The person helping me, (owner?) was EXTREMELY kind, polite and helpful. In a 100% genuine way, and that goes a long ways with me. She made me feel welcome, and that I was lucky to be there, which I totally was. The cookies are almost like eating small pies. They are huge and thick. They will satisfy most cravings by themselves. They had a very buttery flavor, and soft but textured crumble. All three of the cookies were amazing. The coconut cream pie was delicious. I slayed it in the car, outside of the shop. I couldn't wait. It was a tiny bit hard to eat out of that container, but I managed. It has a very smooth and creamy texture and the crust was amazing just on it's own. NOW.. The Pecan bars!! WOW.. Just divine. They are very rich, so don't over do it (ha right.. It happens). But they were perfect. I was extremely impressed with those pecan bars. Make the effort and time to visit this shop. It's amazing. As a tip: go before close and you may get some deals!! Happy PIE DAY! read more

My mom's birthday is 3/13, which is a busy time for pies since the next day is Pi Day. She wanted lemon meringue pie this year and a couple of bakeries said they couldn't accommodate us, even though I called a week in advance. I'm so happy with the way things worked out because not only were they kind enough to take my order at Ashleigh's, the pie was incredible! It was tart and lemony with a delicious crust and fluffy meringue. They even decorated the boxes by hand with happy birthday wishes. Everyone who had a slice (or two) said they'd be getting pie from Ashleigh's again soon. It's a hidden gem worth seeking out! read more

Ashleigh's Bake Shop - Hand-drawn decorations on the pie box - Bakeries Near Me - Kansas City, Missouri

Always a pleasure to visit Ashleigh. Best pie ever! So many outstanding varieties, it is hard to decide. Love this shop.

I really thought I didn't like Key Lime Pie. Until my spouse shoved a forkful in my, what else, pie hole. (Bad-dum tish!) Stale dad-esque humor aside, I have quite literally dreamt of this delightful treat. If you have not yet experienced pie at Ashleigh's, you must run...RUN to Pryde's and grab a slice the very minute your schedule aligns with their hours (Thu, Fri, Sat only). Better yet, leave work a little early and head on over. I promise you, it is worth it. read more

I decided the day before my birthday that I wanted pie from Ashleigh instead of a typical cake. I called her on Friday and was able to order an apple crumble to be picked up the next day. I was very appreciative that she was able to add the last minute order for me. As for the pie itself, my family said multiple times that it was hands down the best apple pie of their life. My mom is already looking at the menu to decide what pie she wants to try for her birthday! read more

The only pie place where I've ever thought "DANG, this crust is GOOD." before even thinking about the filling! Ashleigh's is a homey, little bake shop nestled inside the back of Pryde's. Inside you'll see a display case filled with beautiful pies and quiches. You name it, Ashleigh has got it: key-lime, coconut cream, German chocolate, apple, peach, and more! I opted for a coconut cream pie (a crowd favorite) this time on my visit and it was delightful! The crust was perfectly cooked and flaky. The filling was equally delicious as well and had the best coconut filing I've ever had: light, sweet, and full of coconut flavor! Besides the coconut cream pie, I've also had the peach and key-lime pie. Both were equally delicious as the coconut cream and had the same tasty, flaky crust. However, I will say my favorite thus far has been the peach pie! It is subtly sweet, but chock full of peaches! Each pie serving was also big as well and well worth money. Besides pie, Ashleigh has an assortment of other pastries such as various bars and cookies! The pistachio shortbread cookies were looking tempting in a jar. So, I caved and snagged one as well. The cookie was tasty, large, and full of that pistachio flavor I am obsessed with. In all, Ashleigh's has quickly become my go-to pie place. The pies are simply amazing and Ashleigh is very kind! A must visit for anyone who lives in KC! read more

We ordered a peach pie a couple of weeks ago and it was by far the best peach pie we've ever tasted. Just ordered another this week. This pastry shop is a gem!!!! read more

If you are driving down Westport Road and you see a sandwich board that says "PIES" - hit the brakes and pull over. Ashleigh's is inside of Prydes; which is another great Kansas City retailer. She offers about 6-10 different pies at a time and other assorted treats. I had a slice of the coconut cream this time and it was as good as anything I've ever had. Perfect crust and filling. The pecan bar sample was so addicting I had to get one to go. There are 3 small tables with seating for 8, but god-forbid if 8 actually tried to sit at once. She sells slices or entire pies and coffee. Another one of those hidden jewels that make this city wonderful. read more

Ashleigh's Bake Shop - Coconut Cream - Bakeries Near Me - Kansas City, Missouri

See all

I recently got my husband a key lime pie from Ashleigh for his birthday and it was THE BEST EVER!! I've tried key lime pies from dozens and dozens of places since it's his favorite and this was by far the best we've had. Can't recommend enough and am really excited to try her other pies! read more

Best homemade pies. Peach is my go to. Home made crust and filling. Family owned and operated

Did not know about this place but stopped into Prydes and went downstairs and saw the pies. Hands down best pies in greater KC ! If you love pie, and who doesn't, go here ! read more