I don't know what the other people here are talking about…read more I had a great experience at Maguire Subaru. I had prequalified financing so when I contacted Frank Khan, he had the two Outback models was interested in warming up and ready to go when I got there for test drive. The buying process was easy and quick. The only issue I had was there is residue on my wheel rims from the shipping covers and they said a detailer would have to clean that. Maguire might want to fix that. Service was great and there is a courtesy shuttle to take me to work when I needed to drop off my car to have a wind screen installed for the sunroof. The only other issue was the car lot is very crowded and cramped. I would recommend this dealership. I had more positives than negatives.

I'm a disabled veteran. They took me home while they changed my oil, violated tires and checked…read morebrakes. That was at 10:00 this morning. I called 3 times. THEY LEFT ME! Twice they said they were on their way. At 5 pm, again at 6pm!. I gave up at 7pm. I am experiencing extreme distress because of this and they still have my car!

I worked with Jeff Philip at Honda of Ithaca to purchase a new car Dec. 2025. Jeff was…read moreexceptional. I highly recommend Jeff.

I'm almost at a loss for words for how pleased I am with this dealer for service. Treated me like a…read morereal human being. And they honored the first free oil change even though we're from out of town. Well guess what...you've earned my business for our next Honda purchase, and I'll be spreading the word. You all are doing something right. Truly made my day.

I have to say we have taken all of our cars to Pritchards for inspections and repairs. In the past…read morefew years with warranties we have had to take our cars elsewhere - like local Subaru dealer and were astonished that they tried to tell us work that was needed on the car that IT DID NOT NEED. Took it back to Pritchards after having the recall work done and had Pritchard's go over the car thoroughly - Whew - glad we did. Not only did they tell us what we did NOT need to do they also told us what we needed to do at a substanally lower cost almost $1000 less (!). I trust what they tell me and feel assured they will not tell us to do more work than we need on our cars.

We have been taking our cars there for about 2 years. They have the best service! They are honest…read moreand do not try to sell what you do not need. They also are reasonably priced!

We recently bought a car through Bill Card at Automotive Consultants in Ithaca. I have never felt…read moreso taken care of in a car buying experience! Every step of the way, we felt very confident that we were getting the best deal and the best customer service. We learned so much about the car buying process, which was very helpful especially during these uncertain times when every industry is affected by Covid. It's a priority of his to get his customers a quality, reliable car, and he makes sure of that. We knew we weren't going to get the run around, or risk buying something that wasn't as reliable as it appeared. Bill is an excellent communicator and made us feel like we were his only clients. He made the whole process very smooth and easy, while getting us exactly what we were looking for. I highly recommend Bill Card and Automotive Consultants for your next car purchase! They will take care of you like you are family - which is a really great way to buy a car :)

I brought a 2001 Lexus last year in September since then I've been having so must trouble with it,I…read morepaid a little over 8,600 for it then come to find out the book value is only 1,500 I'm still putting money it

Purchased a 2010 Yaris 5-door in 2020 and the car has been perfect. Highly recommend Bob for his…read moreexpertise and focus on getting you a good value car.

I had purchased a brand new 2024 Nissan Sentra at Maguire Nissan of Ithaca, located in Lansing, NY…read morein August of '24. A week ago, I had my winter tires changed to my all-season tires, and went grocery shopping afterwards. When I got home, I noticed a scuff mark all along the body of my car. Thinking this may have happened at the dealership, I immediately drove back. I spoke to the General Manager, Brian Vorhis, who reviewed my video taped visit. It showed me driving away in an unscathed car. He said that it appears that while I was shopping, someone recklessly hit the side of my car with their shopping car. Since my car insurance has a $500.00 deductible, Brian suggested that it might be wise for me to stop by Maguire Chevrolet Cadillac Body Shop next door before involving my car insurance, to get an estimate of cost repair there first. I took his advice, and dealt with Edward Rogers, the Body Shop Manager. This gentleman took a look at the damage, and immediately said that it appears that the paint was scraped off, he would like to see if he can buff it out. And, amazingly, it worked! When I thanked him profusely, Mr. Rogers said "I always do the right thing by our customers", and refused any payment. Thank you, Brian Vorhis and Edward Rogers for your honesty, and excellent customer service! Monika A.

Truck was at the body shop for repair and ended up with a new dent from maguires parking it next to…read morea scrap dumpster. They didnt fix it, they cleaned my truck half-ass and in the process broke my floor mat holder on the driver side. The door they repaired leaks air into the cabin and has a constant whistling noise when driving. I found glue in my driver side mirror from them trying to fix there piss poor job. They most definitely broke the mirror in the process of swapping it. This company does nothing for there customers and dont own there mistakes. Shop looks like the work they put out. Run-down​​

Maguire Subaru tried to tell me the warranty on my car's drivetrain didn't apply. After I gave them…read moremy VIN. That was a lie. When I told them I had it in front of me in writing, they offered me an appointment TWO MONTHS away. My car was jerking and seizing at low speeds because of a problem with the CVT transmission. Royal Auto in Cortland: gets my car in almost immediately. Gives me a FREE rental car for the week I'm waiting for my car to be repaired. My car is returned not just in perfect working order but incredibly clean. Customer service is friendly and helpful.

service department does work on your vehicle that should only take maybe an hour holds your vehicle…read morefor 3 hours as you are waiting for your vehicle and then tries to say it needs more parts to build the bill my bill was $756.00 for just simple brake pads sorry Royal you won't ever be seeing my vehicle ever again