I have been thinking about getting a second earlobe piercing for the longest time but I'm terrified of needles so I kept putting it off. I came to this place after seeing their work on instagram for some time and got two earlobe piercings done by Sammie. She was super friendly and explained every step to me and reassured me the whole time which made me feel super safe cuz honestly I was really nervous. I took a deep breath and she was done before I even breathed out I barely felt a slight pinch. My ears did not hurt at all there was maybe a slight pinching sensation like someone biting down ur ear lightly for like a day and then no pain at all. If you're nervous about your first piercing I definitely suggest this place Sammie was so kind. If you're not a fan of needles like me you can rest assured this place will make sure you're okay every step of the way! And I love my new piercings! I'll definitely be coming back for more. :) read more

Came in for a handwriting memorial tattoo. I saw Mikey and had communicated with him prior to my appointment. He was super nice and did the tattoo exactly how I wanted it. I am beyond happy with the result and would recommend him to anyone! read more

When my mom passed away, I knew I had to get the perfect tattoo to honor her. For 2 yrs straight I had so many ideas about what to get but could never quite put it into words let alone paper, then I met Thomas Simonetti, it was almost like he was in my head, he knew exactly what I wanted right down to every little detail. I even cried a little when he showed me the final drawing. Now that's what I call talented!!! read more

Authentic Arts Tattoo & Piercing - DreamCatcher with Pelican Feathers, Cherryblossom and it says Till the last petal falls - Tattoo Near Me - Smithtown, New York

Alex is the best! I've gotten two piercings there now, a nostril and a vertical labret. First time I was very nervous, it was my first piercing, but she made it so much easier.She is very thorough when it comes to explaining everything and making sure you are comfortable. Highly recommended! read more

I got a septum done by Alex and she was the best piercer I've ever experienced. She was very comforting and talkative and really explains the whole process to you before she starts the piercing process. The prices are also very reasonable and they offer a large selection of jewelry that you can purchase before starting the process and Alex shows you how the piercing will look on your face and helps you find a correct size. I went in a group of three where one friend got a nostril stud and another got nipple piercings and we all loved our experience with Alex. I'm very happy with my septum and the placement is perfect. It doesn't hang off my nose too low and I can flip it up to hide without it feeling uncomfortable at all. Definitely go to this place for any kind of piercing and book it with Alex! read more

I've done a whole sleeve and a couple extra ones here. The staff is very professional and accommodating. They're a mid-range priced shop usually going at 150-200 an hour but for a larger tattoo you can't beat the quality or the price. Definitely recommend justin hauk read more

Authentic Arts Tattoo & Piercing - Tattoo Near Me - Smithtown, New York

I checked out more than a dozen tattoo shops when I was ready to start my sleeve/chest/back piece. A monumental task that few artists would be able to tackle. I lucked out in the end when I found this place and my artist Dan. The first thing I noticed about this place was that there was no lame wall covered in stencils. What the walls ARE covered with is original paintings and artwork by the tattoo artists. The place is always buzzing and lively. I have sat for 10 short sessions so far and I have NEVER been the only person in the place getting work done. Consider that I go on weekdays around noon and you will get an idea of the huge following this place has. Good tunes and good people pumping out great work in a bunch of different styles. Most importantly...... No BS. 3 guys I work with, my next door neighbor, my sister, and my girlfriend, have all chosen Authentic Arts for their next tat after seeing my results. The bottom line here is..... Figure out what you want. Bring the idea to the artist you like and let them run with it. Go home happy. read more

There is not one negative thing to say about this shop ! The owner Tommy is absolutely fantastic...He started a sleeve on me and does amazing work ! I will not go to another tattoo shop, no one in the shop is pushy they all listen to what the client wants. My boyfriend wanted roman numerals in a tattoo Tommy is doing for him, Tommy stated his opinion but stated it is up to him on what he wants. " I will do whatever you want its your tattoo" Words of Tommy The shop and the crew are amazing ! read more

They were amazing. I walked in with a friend wanting a lily pad on the water, and when I called other places, the artists had no idea what to do. Jay listened to my description for about 30 seconds, then drew up something amazing. Overall, I love my tattoo - it looks incredibly realistic, while also artistic, and the detail is extraordinary. He also touched up another tattoo I have, and did an amazing job with it. I would recommend Jay to anyone. The other staff & artists were also very friendly and the place was clean! read more

Very happy with my micro hummingbird! Rachel was cool af and I squeezed in a piercing while I was there. Loved the vibe and super clean.

I got tattooed with Mike and it was a great experience! We bonded over the fact that we both didn't really want to small talk while he was tattooing me lol. I guess that in itself was small talk but hey it worked for us!! He was patient and his work is amazing. Definitely recommend! The place was clean and warm and had good vibes too. read more

Tommy is the man! I have gone to him for a full sleeve, full chest piece, and more. I will continue to go to him and his shop! He is incredibly creative and awesome to work with. Everyone in that shop is awesome. Plus you dont feel un wanted when you walk in or as if they are better than you. It is a very welcoming shop and they really know how to make you feel at home read more

See all

I've been getting my tats done by Mikey Tubs for quite a few years now. He is a highly skilled professional and a very talented Artist! I would highly recommend getting tattooed by Mikey Tubs!! read more

Emmi is knowledgeable, professional, and well practiced for piercings! The shop has a beautiful selection of jewelry and a separate room for full privacy. Emmi walked me through each step and explained what she was doing. I felt very comfortable and the pain was minimal. The prices are very reasonable (they accept cash and cards) and overall I look forward to returning to have my jewelry changed. The shop did a great job taking extra precautions for covid and I felt comfortable that I was in a sterile environment. Check out Emmi's instagram for examples of her work! read more

Me and my friend went here for tattoos and I'm not complaining about the price of mine but my friend literally got a quarter size tattoo and they charged her $125! I've gotten bigger tattoos than that and was only charged $75! read more

Just went to get my nose pierced on Sunday the girl Emily was super super sweet my two friends came with me she explained everything to me and actually tell you truth it didn't hurt too bad and if I could do it pretty much anyone can do it because my pain tolerance is very loud I definitely recommend her thank you so much Emily for making it very fun experience! read more

Authentic Art and Tattoo!! I have personally seen the happy clients and the beautiful work done. When I am ready to get another tattoo. I will be coming here and specifically asking for Mr. Simonetti! Wendy L. Jarva Owner of Sicchic Fight Wear, LLC. read more

Justin Hauck did an excellent tattooing me today as habeas in the past, The other staff there were very polite and professional read more

I have gotten 5 of my tattoos done at this location. I am usually a walk in (I'll admit, my tattoos are usually a last minute, drastic decision) and I am always helped immediately in some capacity. I have had a few different artists work on me, Justin has done the most of mine and he is AWESOME. Everyone here is great in my opinion, as my friends have gone to other artists and have also loved their experiences. I find everyone here to be extremely friendly and I do not think I would go anywhere else for a tattoo at this point. Prices are also reasonable, even if they are more expensive I would prefer it because I KNOW they are going to use clean, safe equipment that will not harm me, which is a big deal to me. read more

Thomas Simonetti is clearly one of the best tattoo artists on the island. The shop is clean and everyone there treats you with courtesy and professionalism. They listen to your ideas and incorporate them into excellent and vibrant work. If you have a bad tattoo - they are the best cover up shop in the business! read more

Funny before I started this review I read some of the other reviews. One complained that you couldn't ask a question or make a comment without the staff making fun of you. That is absolutely true!!!! How can you get a good tattoo when you can't discuss or get professional feed back. Awful! They con their clients if the client isn't happy with the tattoo by only using water to make corrections and then laugh at the client when they leave. The owner should be in the shop because apparently he doesn't know what is really going on when he is not there. read more

I am so unhappy with this place, do not go if you're not looking to spend a ton of money. I went for two cartilage piercings. The shop is nice and clean but they only carry fancy earrings, not normal surgical steel piercings, so you have to buy their more expensive earrings before you get pierced. It came out to more money but at that point I was like whatever. BUT they put these weird backs on the earrings for swelling or something. I have many piercings and have never had that but again... whatever. They told me to come back a month later for new backs. I called a month later and asked if I need an appointment for that or if I can just stop in and the woman on the phone said I can come any time. I drove 25 minutes there and they tell me I have to come back with an appointment. I make the appointment and go back again that night. THEY CHARGE TO CHANGE THE BACKS. I walked out spending another $30 to have backs put on and they are not normal backs. Now I can't get the earrings off at all and one of the backs was so small it embedded in my ear. I have never had this much of a hassle with such a basic piercing. Do NOT recommend. read more

Annabel did an amazing job on my tattoo. Would totally recommend going to this shop. Super clean, warm and welcoming.

Nice, clean shop. Everyone is friendly. All the artists are very talented and sell their paintings that are displayed on the walls. I have been going to Dan K. For years and always trust his advice and work. read more

I highly recommend Mikey Tubs for any type of tattoo you're looking for. I had a few tattoos before I found him and he's done every piece on me since. Very quick but detailed and solid work. He's done almost an entire sleeve on me and some other work. 100% recommend and wouldn't get tattoo'd buy anyone but him. read more

The piercer Alexandra was amazing! I came in super nervous to get my tragus pierced, and she was super helpful in explaining every step! I felt totally comfortable and love how it came out! :) read more

Alex is awesome!! My friend and I came in for some piercings a few days ago and she was excellent. Very sweet and knowledgeable, really took the time to make sure all sizing and sterilization were exact. Really made for a comfortable experience, highly recommend!!! read more

The best tattoo shop on the island. So clean and comfortable. Nicest artists and piercers! The work they put out is amazing! They do not have stupid flash art on the walls just artwork from the actual artists. The work is always original! All the artists have portfolios to look through so you can pick your style! I really love all work i got from authentic arts! read more

Authentic Arts Tattoo & Piercing - Raptor Jesus: He went extinct for your sins! Done by Thomas Simonetti - Tattoo Near Me - Smithtown, New York

See all

I got my first tattoo done here today, and honestly, I was really skeptical about the places I was going to go to. I saw their website and thought I'd check it out. The staff was extremely friendly, and was willing to accommodate me even though I was a walk in. The store was clean and professional, and they work efficiently. After I explained my idea, the artist that did my tattoo, printed out several sizes of the idea and let me chose which one I felt comfortable with. The whole process of paperwork, drawing things up, re sizing and tattooing took less than an hour. The artist knew it was my first tattoo, so he was very gentle and made me feel comfortable. Before he started tattooing, he showed me that everything he was using was unopened and that everything was covered in plastic to ensure me that it was sterile. By far the best experience I've had! read more

From the second I walked into authentic arts tattoos I knew I was going to have a great experience! From the walls covered in artwork by the artists to their fun and welcoming personalities I could not wait for my session to start! Tommy gave me a tattoo that I will cherish for a lifetime! His energetic personality and awesome artistic skills really came to life in the piece he gave me! I would not recommend any place other than authentic! read more

So I came here for my first tattoo, and I love it. The artist did a great job and I do not regret coming here for it as I am happy with the work I received. My issue with this place is how rude and unfriendly nearly all of the employees are. I have been here numerous times, for my friends and for myself (tattoo, piercings, friends tattoos etc) and each time I am uncomfortable to even go in there because of the attitude I get every time. Don't even bother asking a question unless you want to be insulted/made fun of for what you are asking.The work here is good, but just because of the attitude I won't come here again. read more

I wanted a tattoo and went in Authentic Arts off of a friend's referral. What a mistake. The guy in charge Tom was really unfriendly and made me uncomfortable. I was already nervous getting my first tattoo, so his rugged attitude didn't help. I went elsewhere instead and am happy. read more

If i Could give this place 10 stars, id give them 11......after a grueling day of battling prices and attitudes of other tattoo shops around Smithtown, did I find this little Gem of a tattoo parlor. (also, was referred by a friend, and later discovered that I had family come to this same shop for there tattoo artwork). just by walking in I could tell this was the place for me. Greeted by the nicest men, I began to show them my idea for the tattoo I wanted to get. it made me feel comfortable and excited knowing that they approved and liked my idea, Dan (the artist) was excited to do it. It was also a bonus that they priced it just right. my personal experience at Authentic Arts Tattoo was like none other I've experienced. Clean, Friendly and Caring, and speedy service. I will HIGHLY recommend ANYONE and EVERYONE to Authentic Arts Tattoo if they're looking for quality work. thanks so much guys, for your kindness and generosity. YOU GUYS ROCK! xoxo read more

This is the place to go. Everyone is friendly and welcoming. Everyone there does amazing work and Tommy in particular has done art on me. Body art takes time, patience and planning. Authentic Arts provides all of those things with professionalism and care. Always pick Authentic Arts! read more

A lot of the color has faded and there is some scarification. Great shop but wouldn't recommend Dan.

This is a forward thinking, family oriented Tattoo shop. The artists are friendly, talented and knowledgable. The aim at Authentic Arts is to please customers. Their prices are very reasonable. I had brought my daughter in for some body jewelry and ended up not just getting a tattoo, but, becoming a regular. I highly recommend this shop without hesitation. The place looks more like like an art installation than a tattoo shop. Whether you're covered in ink or want a new piercing, Authentic Arts is unmatched! read more

I absolutely love this place and the staff. So professional, clean...great atmosphere. Tommy took such good care of me, and he is all about making you feel comfortable and happy. The time he spent with me, and his dedication is what will make me go back as well as recommend his shop to anyone. read more

I love this place, I've gotten tattood by I think his names Justin & also Dan! Both of them were really nice . I've also gotten pierced by click several times, only good experiences. kind of pricey, but worth it. you get what you pay for. It's on your body forever. read more

I've been going to Authentic Arts for over a year now and I wouldn't go anywhere else. The owner Tommy is amazing and always exceeds my expectations. The shop is always clean & the staff is super friendly. I always recommend people to go to Tommy & he has never disappointed! The absolute best on Long Island! read more

I just got a tattoo at Authentic Arts and I absolutely love it. Tommy was awesome and extremely professional. This is definitely my new spot to get work done. Ask for Tommy! read more