We really love this place! Ive definitely had better pizza but who hasnt had something better? For Eureka this place to me is the best pizza around. Decent prices, delivery, great daily specials, salad bar, beer, arcades for kids, tvs, $2 beers at happy hour (micros too), private party rooms and excellent service! Typically we do take out or have it delivered but on occasion we have been know to get that wild hair and eat in! Its an old school style pizza place. Kids ARE running around but isnt that the point of having "pizza night"; you know kids run around playing arcades and parents drink beer and socialize. A great American pass time! Im not totally impressed with their pasta dishes but the sandwiches rock! My fave is hot turkey on a sourdough roll with mozzarella. Yummy! *** Sign up for their rewards program online*** you save a grip of cash! Everytime you order you build cash rewards that you csn cash in on any time! We wait about ever other order and get anywhere from 2 to 7 $$ off! read more

Babe's Pizza-Pasta - Hot Turkey and Mozzarella on a sourdough roll! Awesome - Pizza Near Me - Eureka, California

See all

Stopped here based on good yelp reviews. Most other restaurants here in Eureka had poor reviews so decided to give it a shot. Started off great. Clean place and nice staff. Salad bar was great; fresh and nice variety. I was halfway through the Four Cheese Stuffed Mancotti with meatless sauce when I noticed an abundance of hair throughout the sauce (which was also luke warm). Pretty disgusted and disappointed. My boyfriend enjoyed a build-your-own calzone without any hairy problems. He-he. It's hard for me to give a horrible review based on the other great aspects but not happy about eating someone's mop. read more

Worst. Service. Ever. Pizza is mediocre at best but I like to support local businesses. I ordered one small pizza tonight and after an hour got a call from the driver letting me know he had given it to someone else on accident. He let me know they would have it replaced and to me within 30 minutes. After 50 minutes and still no word I gave them a call where the woman who answered the phone (Alicia) was incredibly rude and let me know she didn't know what was going on with the pizza. She handed the phone off to someone else who said it was a new driver which is why all of this happened. I asked if they could give me any kind of discount due to the hassle and now 2 hour long wait and they said no. Do yourself a favor and go with another business, they may be a chain but you will get better pizza and better service. Such a bummer! read more

Beware of the hords of little muncha kinis this place likes to attract; some very small people with loads of energy(soda),disrespect(dirty) and volume(prepubescent). I go here for the pitchers of beer and the proximaty of it's locale. The pizza is run-o-mill unfantastic and always different in quality and preperation, but never worth mentioning. They do deliver- but the price is kinda steep, I imagine the tips for the delivery drivers has suffered. The sandwiches are a good deal- and so is the take and bake, but it's not great. Like I said, I come here for the cheap beer and the free television. Please alert me if you are thinking of bringing your little league team here during a Giants game, better yet go somewhere else K? read more

One of the best pizza places in Humboldt county! The staff are always friendly, and they have an absolutely huge delivery radius (compared to other pizza places in Eureka) The prices are a little high, but if you check out their daily deals online you can usually feed a small army for a reasonable price. read more

Oh Gawd! I was warned! I should have listened to my friends who live nearby the restaurant!? I'm gonna come back to this review and finish it but wow was this a whole lot of nasty, heavy greasy pizza!? Can we call it that? So gross... read more

This place was recommended and I'm glad we tried it! Had the spinach pizza with garlic sauce. It was really delicious. The crust is the only thing we don't care for so we usually eat a frozen pizza when we don't want to cook but get a salad. They have a great salad bar except they changed their brand of beets recently and they're mushy. I rarely give 5 stars on the first visit but they came close. I will try some other menu items next visit and see. read more

This has always been and will always be my favorite pizza! I have lived in Humboldt, Sacramento, and Los Angeles and been to a ton of pizza joints and I can honestly say that Babes has the best pizza I have ever had. The pizza here is truly unique. Interestingly enough my favorite is the plain pepperoni (boring I know and I usually favor more exciting options at other places) -- I always admire the "fusion crust" that gives the pizza a unique crunch. Recently the place received a long overdue facelift with a cool mural on the wall and flat screen TVs. I like that they left the juke box and it is nice that they usually have multiple games on. It can be busy in the sports season and there are always lots of kids running around during this time, but the pizza is well worth it. The salad bar is also much better than it would have to be. read more

Pizza was boring, the sauce lacked flavor and one edge was burnt. The Stuffed mushroom pizza was horrible. Terrible presentation, the burnt cheese on top made it look moldy. This is not the restaurants fault but there were a lot of kids running around bothering customers, while their parents let them run free. Staff never checked in to see if food was ok. Decor was nice, the murals on the wall and TV's for sports were great. Only reason for the 2 stars. read more

I wish I would have listened to the one star reviews. We are driving through on our way to Oregon and decided we had enough for the day so we stopped in Eureka for some shut eye. I looked up the pizza available for delivery since we were tired and this seemed to have the best reviews. I read quite a few on here and they talked about a burnt pizza. I figured that maybe some people were high maintenance and I gave it a shot. Bad idea lol it came burnt. The pizza is a brownish color and it is hard like cardboard with a terrible taste. I wouldn't recommend this place to anyone. I guess you can understand why this place is the best in a city that has not 1 bit two vhs/DVD rental stores haha. Taco bell anyone?? read more

Babe's Pizza-Pasta - Pizza Near Me - Eureka, California

Good pizza, good service, clean. That pretty much sums it up. From what I saw, it's a popular spot for locals with kids and groups. The atmosphere was pleasant and enjoyable. I wouldn't say it's super standout, but it's much better than the pie from Roundtable or other big chains. read more

Probably the best pizza in the area. I lucked into trying Babe's when I happened to be at my neighbors and they had a pizza delivered. To be honest I was more interested in the fact that they had a pizza delivered out where we lived (Freshwater). Then I tried the pizza, and It was one of the best pizzas I had ever had! Babes was always my go to pizza place as they are friendly and of course delivered :-) Now that I live in town, I still make them my first choice for quality pizza at a decent value. Last night, while my parents were visiting, I ordered and within 25 minutes I had a Babes Special at my door.. Thank you Babe's for great friendly service and for routinely producing a quality product. (Cutten Crunch has to be my favorite) read more

Best pizza place in Humboldt. Fast service, fun staff, and multiple delicious pizzas to choose from. Great for birthday parties, fantasy football, etc. I recommend the BLT pizza. Sounds weird, but don't judge it until you try it. read more

They have everything you could want in a pizza place. There are even a couple of game machines, candy machines and a private room for large groups that want to meet separately. There is a gluten free crust option. I eat here at least once a month with my local support group. Always look forward to it. read more

Sorry Babe's you lost a star. While the product is still good and most (key word most) of the staff are friendly and awesome, I have had a couple of rude experiences. SLOW down when you answer! I called to place an order tonight and I heard "Babe's Pizza unintelligible couldn't understand you garbled nonsense HOLD blah blah what the heck did she say" in a very snotty, angry tone. Then a cheery, different voice comes back on the line, 5 minutes later (I almost hung up but my husband wanted Babe's tonight) and takes my order, double checks it, asks if we want to use our points and tells us it will be about 45 minutes for delivery. No problem, World Series night I expected it to be about that much time. However, less than 30 minutes later, the delivery is at our door and nice and hot! Awesome! OK not so much after all. I ordered raviolis for my husband. We discovered, after he had already had his salad, that he got lasagna instead. Not worth the hassle to exchange at this point, BUT still a disappointment. We have also been steady customers for years, we own a business in the area and yet every time we make constructive suggestions to the owner, we get really snippy feedback. As an owner, I get that maybe you don't want to take my suggestions, but you really should stop being rude about it. The business has totally outgrown its location, this is a good thing. They are doing well enough that they need to expand. The solution they came up with to expand, while innovative, doesn't really seem to be working. I think we will be taking a break from Babe's for a long while. read more

Been looking for any pizza place worth anything since moving from the SF Bay Area to Crescent City. Babe's is the only place both the wife and I have tried anywhere in Northern California/Southern Oregon that serves really good pizza. I will be returning. read more

I am not a pizza lover, but the BBQ Chicken pizza at Babe's will forever hold a place in my heart. If you are a pizza person, you must try this pizza. Babe's is located in what is referred to by locals as Cutten- a part of Eureka that used to be its own town but was absorbed by Eureka some time ago. Cutten has its own feel, and so does Babe's. There is parking out front, and indoor and outdoor seating- if it is nice I would recommend sitting outside, as inside is fairly dark. Servers tend to change pretty often, but service is always okay. A little out of the way, but definitely worth the drive. My only complaint is that the prices are pretty high- one star off for that. read more

Pasta terrible. Salad was fresh and good. Pizza was burnt. Calzone was good. Nothing much else to say. read more

We have spent hundreds of dollars on Babe's pizza over the last few years. It was convenient and often tasty. Unfortunately, the last pizza we ordered completely killed our future patronage. There were so many THICK BLACK HAIRS in our pizza that they were clearly put there intentionally. Did we piss Babe's off somehow? Did we not leave a big enough tip the time before? Not sure, but I really wish I had saved the pizza as evidence. I would love to find out who grew those beard and/or groin hairs. My stomach still turns when I think about them. All I can do is say F YOU, BABE'S! I hope you pull the same "stunt" when the health inspector comes around. read more

Babe's Pizza-Pasta - We won't be needing anymore food from Babe's. At least 5 of these disgusting hairs were in our XL combo pizza on 3/4/18. - Pizza Near Me - Eureka, California

This place makes some of the best pizza around. I live just a couple blocks away and its hard not to go here all the time. Their lunch specials are really affordable and their delivery folk are always really nice. The Cutten Crunch and BBQ pizzas are amazing! Friendly staff, too. The only reason this isn't five stars is because there's been a few times where my called in order was messed up -- I once had to wait another 15 to 20 minutes for one pizza in my order that had been forgotten. But don't get me wrong, I will keep going back. The couple mess ups are outweighed by the sheer awesomeness of their pizza. Also, they have a room you can close off for big groups and they will reserve it, which is nice. read more

Best pizza in the area! Reminds me of the old school pizza joints growing up. They have great staff too, everyone is friendly and happy. Try the cheeseburger pizza! read more

The lunch Speical is where it's at. Good pizza with a salad and a drink all for one low price. They also have good garlic knots.

This place would already have ousted the competition if it weren't tucked away at the edge of town. I've been a regular since mving a few blocks away from it. The lunch specials are reasonably priced for huge portions, the salad bar is always well stocked and fresh, and the servers seem genuinely happy to see you. The food itself has never failed to impress, no matter what I've ordered. All of that gets them 4 stars. For the fifth: they have Ms. Pac-Man! read more

Ordered delivery to a local hotel. The large salad for $9.99 will easily feed four people and comes with more fresh lettuce and fresh toppings than I've ever seen on a delivered salad - definitely no bagged salad here. Fresh leaf lettuce, carrots, mushrooms, kidney beans, garbanzo beans, black olives, broccoli, red onion, peas, cucumber, cherry tomatoes. All the veggies were super fresh. This was the best salad I've ever gotten from a pizza place. We ordered the BBQ, chicken and pineapple and added jalapeños. They are liberal with the toppings and the pizza was really good also. The crust had a good texture, thick enough to support all those toppings but not too thick. They don't use a ton of sauce, I probably could have used another ladle of it as we like our pizza on the saucy side, but it was a decent ratio for most people I'm sure. They said delivery in an hour and we had it in 50. If I were ever in the area again I'd definitely be ordering again, just to have another one of those salads! read more

The have the best salad bar! Something about their ranch is magical. There pizzas are great, staff friendly and great atmosphere for parties. read more

Awesome pizza.. loaded toppings .. friendly staff .. quick delivery... I definitely recommend babes over most of the pizza joints here. I usually try to catch the lunch specials for the best deals ..and give the Stuffed Mushroom pizza a try! Good stuff! read more

Babe's Pizza-Pasta - Babes Combo with Anchovies =) - Pizza Near Me - Eureka, California

See all

Absolutely the best in Humboldt. The service is excellent and consistent. The food is delicious and reasonably priced. From the efficient order takers to the friendly drivers everyone at Babes is top notch! read more

Great clean salad bar and yummy pizza! The women in the front taking orders are always nice and seem happy to be there! Haven't tried any of the pasta but you can't go wrong with any pizza or calzone and add a salad- you won't regret it. read more

Babe's is always good. I've had pizzas, calazones, and plenty of trips through the salad bar. Everything has always been top notch. Their lunch specials cannot be beat, and it is a great place to meet up with friends and family to watch the game. Please open another Babe's in Mckinleyville! read more

Pretty much just like I remembered it, move out of Eureka about 15 years ago maybe more, I used to like it so I figured I would try it, glad I did. Happy to see the quality has lasted! read more

We ordered from this location while camping on our honeymoon! We were not disappointed! They have some amazing food and the pizza is some of the best!! read more

Good pizza, good lunch special. If you're not that hungry the best thing to do is just pay for a salad and they give you a to go box to fill with what you want. Otherwise, and this is why this place doesn't get a five, they are very strict on their rules about you are only to get ONE plate of salad, ONE glass of beverage and that's IT. If you want more, you pay more. Kinda silly. When I saw that they even posted signs with all of this information, just to really beat the facts into you, I almost asked for directions to Big Louie's just to be a smart ass. read more

I am not sure how revolutionary pizza can be, because it's pizza, and it's hard to make it badly. we had Babe's "special" pizza - basically it was a meat mountain. it was all the good you want pizza to be, and most importantly, they delivered it to our hotel room. they also brought plates, napkins, cups for our drinks, and even little packets of Parmesan knowing they were delivering to a hotel room. the pizza was great, and the staff who took our order was friendly (as was the delivery man). read more

Love Babe's!! Fantastic service, epic salad bar, fun nightly specials and a WONDERFUL supporter of kids and sports teams locally!

I grew up in Cutten, went to Winship, came here after little league games, dates, you name it.. We were here. This place is a local establishment. Some call the food boring-- YEA YOU TUCKER M, others rave. It's a straight-up local pizza joint. It's not Round Table, it's Not Smugs and it sure as hell isn't Live from NY-- but Babe's has the hometown feel the other guys clearly DON'T. You come here for the low-key vibe, you know it's the ace in your pocket for a small pie if you don't want to go across town for the yellow faced guy. Love it. Four stars. read more

Food is consistently excellent and speedy. The service is friendly and sweet. I always enjoy my time here. Whether it's a business lunch or a family dinner out it's always a fan favorite read more

We are regular customers. Babes has always delivered to our house, until The new owners. Called in for a pizza on Friday night. Was abruptly informed that they no longer deliver to our location. So I drive into pick Up the order. I had ordered salad that night,usually they fix up the salad and I just have to pick it up. Was informed that I had to make the salad, so I make the salad and they are out of the dressing I want. It is impossible to make eye contact wits employees. Took me five minutes until I could make eye contact so I can ask for the dressing. Meanwhile people are pushing and shoving me trying to make their salad. This was Friday night. A lovely Sunday morning we are getting ready to drive to town, when what do we see driving in our neighborhood but a BABES delivery car driving around in our neighborhood. Hmm , maybe they just don't deliver on Fri nights to our neighborhood. Needless to say we will no longer be customers. read more

It used to be my favorite pizza in town. Last few years (before covid) service has not been as it was. Pizza always late/cold/wrong order. Please try to get it together, I want to support you guys again! :-) read more

Best Pizza in town! We drive from Fortuna to get it. Salad bar is great. Love the fact they now have separate arcade really helps with the noise level. Don't miss the daily deals. read more

This dope ass chick works here and she's the best! Definitely fell in love. But we'll never know what could have been.. Pizza- nice and cheezy 5$ all you can eat salad? Wut wut! you, pizza babe. read more