I really wanted to like this place. I genuinely love the mom-and-pop feel of the shop--it has charm…read moreand potential. I also don't mind cash-only businesses, if they're upfront about it. We ordered over the phone and weren't told, and there's no clear signage when you walk in. You only find out when it's time to pay. In 2025, in New Jersey, that's a frustrating surprise--especially when you can also order through DoorDash. It just doesn't make sense. As for the food, we ordered a couple of Italian subs and a BLT with extra bacon. The Italians had soggy lettuce and maybe two slices of lunch meat--not what you'd expect from a deli. The BLT, despite asking for extra bacon, came with just two strips. Overall, everything was mediocre at best. I appreciate small businesses and want to see them thrive, but between the lack of communication and underwhelming food, it's hard to recommend without some improvements. We're back next week to finish a job and will try again, maybe they had they had the rookies in there today.

Popped in to Sub Shack in Hackettstown for the first time today after being told by many people for…read moreyears now that I needed to check it out. Tiny little spot with barely enough room to think haha, but a huge menu and really friendly employees. Decided to go with "The Super" and "The Shack Special" The super is their version of an Italian. Got it dressed with LTO, oil and vinegar, and oregano. The roll was softer than I normally like for an Italian but it was very fresh and still held together nicely. I didn't eat half of this til just now (maybe 4 hours later) and it still wasn't a sloppy mess. The Shack Special was Roast beef, Turkey breast, Swiss, lettuce, tomato, and Russian dressing. These communists and their salad dressing...tastes good on everything. Again the meats were super fresh and the same roll for this one. I grabbed both to take a few bites for a video and I packaged this one up for my gf and I kept the Italian. These are both half sandwiches and they're bigger than most full size subs from anywhere. Cost for both of these total was around $16. No brainer here - Sub Shack - Didn't Suck!

Erratic hours. "Open" flag is seen waving outside even when they are closed. Hard to predict when…read morethey'll be open.

Worst bagel and deli ever in the tristate area. I had to wait 30 min for a toasted bagel is cream…read morecheese. The wife was flirting with the husband the whole time while I was sitting there waiting for my bagel. The bagel was ready from their cheap toaster, not to mention that the bagel was burnt to ashes, she just stood there acting like there is no customer in the store. Worst bagel ever it's like they come from china Because I can taste the chemical in the bagel. If I had one thing to say positive about the institution, I would say that the cream cheese was very tasty. Thanks for a terrible breakfast in Hackettstown!

Super friendly couple who makes delicious sandwiches! This is a hole in the wall shop that offers…read moregreat food for great value. The super Italian sub was yummy and for the kids, we ordered the beef cheesesteak sandwich. Take your sandwiches to go and eat by the lake or at the picnic table outside! Would love to come back if we're in the area.

Great food when they're open,which could be hit or miss,and kinda pricey. Xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx cxxccccread more

Better half wanted some no cook food for visiting kids, grandkids and great-grandkids. We ordered…read morean Deluxe E-Box Saturday morning. It was ready Sunday on time as advertised. She was impressed by the pleasant staff on both ordering and pickup. We later that evening received many phone calls raving about the sandwiches, fresh bread loads of meat and cheese. Leftovers where a great lunch for me on Monday!

Very clean restaurant. Cheerful and efficient staff. Reasonable prices. Perfectly fresh bread and…read moreingredients. My salads have been exemplary, and my subs absolutely perfect. Great pickles, good selection of beverages--why go elsewhere?

Primo Hoagies makes a solid cheesesteak, especially on their signature seeded bread. I always get…read moremine with Cooper cheese, fried onions, mayo, ketchup, and hot peppers, and when it's made right, it's absolutely delicious, gooey, flavorful, and satisfying. But the consistency is hit or miss. Sometimes it's packed with well-seasoned meat, and other times, it feels like they forgot the seasoning and skimped on the steak. For the price, I expect more consistency in quality. Still, when they get it right, it's one of the best around. 4/5 stars.

I ordered the large Italian sandwich platter from Primo Hoagies for my New Year's Day party…read more The sandwiches were neatly cut and stacked. We had the roast beef and cheese, turkey and cheese. The stand out sandwich, for me, was Nonna's veggie sandwich! It was so delicious with the breaded eggplant, sharp provolone, broccoli rabe and the winning layer of roasted pepper on top! Along with the sandwiches, I was given some small squeeze bottles of oil and vinegar, and a bowl of various peppers and onions for my guests to flavor their sandwiches to their liking. I highly recommend this business for your catering needs!

Went back to The Market to have them cater our Halloween party with two 3-foot subs. They built an…read moreItalian and a Turkey with Swiss for us and our guests devoured both... not a single slice was left. The bread, the meat and the sides were SO GOOD! Definitely planning to use them in the future for more catering opportunities.

P.S. Make sure you ask for a bag for your take out sandwich. The young woman working the counter…read morehanded me my sandwich wrapped in foil - no bag. I had to ask for a bag to carry out my sandwich in. Great sandwich though. A review was posted seven months ago regarding their over charging the credit card fee in violation of Visa's agreement. They replied that they would address it. They haven't and it's even worse than the original post indicated. The following is a repost from just yesterday. What's going on with them charging 4% for using a debit card? It's illegal. In the U.S., it is generally illegal for a merchant to add a surcharge (an extra fee) directly to a debit card purchase. This is prohibited by federal law (the Durbin Amendment) and major card networks like Visa and Mastercard.When it is IllegalDebit Card Surcharges: Charging a specific fee just for using a debit card, even if the cashier runs it as a credit transaction.Minimum Purchases: Merchants are not legally allowed to set a minimum spending amount (e.g., a $10 minimum) for debit card purchases.Cash Discounting Misuse: A business cannot charge a fee for debit cards while disguising it as a "credit card fee." Food was good but they shouldn't charge customers a 4% Visa credit card fee which is over the 3% that is permitted by Visa. Seven months ago they said they had to fix their system to allow only a 3% charge on Visa cards as the Visa merchant agreement allows only a 3% maximum. They're still charging 4%. Visa caps merchant surcharges on credit card transactions at 3% (or the merchant's actual cost of processing the transaction, whichever is lower). If your state imposes a lower limit than 3%, you must adhere to that local restriction instead.Key Surcharging Rules & LimitsMaximum Cap: The absolute maximum fee is 3% for Visa credit cards, regardless of whether your actual processing costs are higher.

So happy we stumbled upon this place. We live close by never went in and I'm so glad we did this…read moretime. We got the original cheesesteak and the steak BLT and both were so good. The quality of the food was 10/10 and the steak BLT is so delicious. Service was great and the place is really clean and cute.

This was a pit stop for us on the way back from camping. We didn't know this place was right across…read morethe street from a lovely lake and grassy area to chill at after our meal, so that was a nice surprise. This is a small restaurant, it kind of feels like you're in someone's house. You order at the front. We got the senatore cheesesteak and a mushroom Swiss burger. I'm not a huge fan of cheesesteaks and enjoyed my burger more (it was a smash burger with nice horseradish sauce on it) but the cheesesteak was also one of the better ones I've had. I would come back if I'm ever in the area.

There are many sub shops in New Jersey and some are really good. This many years old but young in…read morespirit sub shop is worth the trip from anywhere. Great bread frames the thumanns deli meat. Tangy vinegar is charming along with oregano and spices. I love this place

Hands down the best sandwich shop around! We've been going to the Sub Base for about three decades…read more Have never been disappointed ever. I have had sandwiches from the first owner (poor guy was a Jets fan) and Scott the current owner (a Giants fan). They both put a lot of love in a sandwich. I've had several varieties and they are all great, not to mention the chili and soups! I highly recommend!

My office's go-to spot for stellar bagels. A varied selection, always fresh, and always yummy. The…read morecrafted cream cheeses are great too. Also a good amount of flavors for your savory or sweet tooth. Every week my favorite changes. This week, I'm in love with the French Toast bagel with Walnut cream cheese. You cant go wrong with the place. They also have hot food made to order and pizza if you so fancy. Service is fast so know what you wanna get before you get on queue.

Bagels are ALWAYS burnt. I asked for everything bagel toasted. This was my third time trying…read morebagelsmith I would not return.

Check out hot bagels abroad in hackettstown, New Jersey. They have a great variety of bagels, I…read morelove the super egg everything, the jalapeno cheddar and their classic everything bagel. We stop here frequently on the weekends for the kids and it's an easy place to get a quick bite.

They have the most rudest associate. Waiting in line four customers ahead us me when a lady walks…read morein and I thought she was just looking at what selection she was going to make . The rude one said can I help who's next and the lady who cut in line steps up , I say excuse me I was next and she ignored me then a nice young lady came over to help. I pointed out that I was next and then the rude one there is plenty of us to help you and that I was rude and I could have been nice. When I stated from now on I will take my business else where she said good get out. She never is nice when I go in there and she never gets my order correct. I never say anything because it is busy but today she was way out of line . She should have told the customer that cut sorry there is a line and they have been waiting there were people behind me as well. Don't even what to give one star but for the young lady that was nice