This morning was beautiful. I got up early, went outside, and did my yoga and meditation to start my day. Normally, my week gets off to a rocky start--especially on the Monday after a holiday--but today, on this Taco Tuesday, I turned it into a Terrific Tuesday. I decided to get some work done on the computer and then went to get my bike fixed. Mission accomplished: it's fixed, and I even fixed it myself! After that, it was time to go feed my hunger. I normally try to wait until noon to get my grub on, so I decided to head to the Bagel Boutique, grab a coffee, and see what these bagels were all about. Of course, just like anyone with a brain would do, I did my research first to see if it was a good place. Some PennLive articles popped up with awesome reviews, so I headed out. Being a New Yorker straight out of Manhattan, I have to say: these bagels were poop. They just tasted like the Thomas' bagels you can get from any grocery store. There was nothing special about them besides the creative toppings. I would never go out of my way to get a bagel from this place again. I wish I would've just ordered them on UberEats so I didn't have to waste gas money and time driving all the way from Harrisburg to Mechanicsburg. Honestly, I think the decor was better than the food itself. They should call it the "Boooo Boutique," because that's exactly what it is. Thumbs down. One star, and that's it. -Branden-Lee AKA B L E E read more

See all

This place is vibes....just straight vibes. From the pink signage and colorful atmosphere what a beautiful looking bagel shop. They display all of the bagels and baked goods perfectly. The service was incredible. Everything was perfectly packaged. Busy time, line was a little long, but they kept everything flowing smoothly on a Saturday Morning. Everyone was very nice! Now for the food.... Bagel Sandwich: plain Bagel, Cooper American, egg whites, bacon....5 Star sandwich.... Another Bagel Sandwich: Jalapeño Cheddar Bagel, Cooper American, bacon, egg, Cheddar & jalapeño smear...once again 5 star sammie. Just take our word, go to Bagel Boutique. Easily one of the best spots in the Cumberland Valley. read more

See all

The Bagel Boutique is an amazing addition to the breakfast scene in Mechanicsburg, combining classic NYC bagels with fun and unique flavor combos. I selected the peanut butter heaven, which was a super decadent bagel, almost more of a dessert than a breakfast item. Between the peanut butter cream cheese, Reese's cups, and chocolate sauce on a chocolate chip bagel, this is heaven for my fellow chocolate/PB lovers and feels different from what I usually see on the menu at your average bagel shop. You can of course get a classic savory sandwich or bagel with butter/cream cheese, but these more eclectic options are a fun way to switch it up! Service was a bit slow, we wound up ordering at a kiosk because the line at the register was taking awhile, and it still took us quite a bit to receive our food. The shop doesn't have that fast-paced efficiency of an NYC bagel joint, but the quality does make up for it. I would maybe try ordering ahead next time, but I liked being able to see what bagels were left/what my options were. read more

Bagel Boutique - Bagels Near Me - Mechanicsburg, Pennsylvania

I'll definitely be giving this place another try. Hubs really enjoyed his sundried tomato bagel egg & bacon sandwich. I had an egg white delight on whole grain everything bagel. While I loved how much everything season is on the bagel, it made the bagel taste extra salty. It was to much salt & I just couldn't enjoy it. It fueled me for my day, but it wasn't savor worthy. The PS I Love Chocolate hot cocoa coffee is Devine, very sweet. We were greated by Izzy with such amazing joy. There's a beautiful sign hanging from the owners thanking their guests for supporting their small business. It's a very welcoming place with plenty of parking and seating to stay to enjoy your treat. read more

See all

Very cute open interior. Service was friendly and fast! The sandwiches we ordered were HUGE. I got the Turkey Sammie & my bf got a bagel sandwich with hot honey. Can't wait to go back read more

Bagel Boutique - Bagels Near Me - Mechanicsburg, Pennsylvania

Food was so good. Strawberry banana smoothie tastes like dessert and really like the puree or syrup they add. Breakfast sandwich was loaded and delicious - added a hash brown and double cheese! read more

Bagel Boutique - Gianna's Classic - Bagels Near Me - Mechanicsburg, Pennsylvania

See all

The quality of the food and selection on the menu is 100/10. The servers at kind yet a little frazzled .. but attentive. The efficiency still seems to need some work ... we should have ordered online ... but not sure that would have helped unless we did so an hour before. We ordered at the counter and the same person taking the order stopped to grab our bagels and muffins. Then finished taking our order for drinks and a hot sandwich. We joined the masses waiting for their orders, shuffling from place to place to allow others to walk about. Eventually someone called name to ask a question about our bagel order since she was pulling them ... I told her we already got everything but the drinks and sandwich. She seemed surprised but said that our order would be out soon. We got our drinks soon after, and I finished my coffee while waiting for the sandwich. Then we received the sandwich and got on our way home. Where we discovered they gave us a second set of muffins ... one of which was upside down and melty since it was on top of the hot Sammy. The dining room is packed, but well over half the folks are waiting - to either place an order or waiting for their food. Only a few tables of folks actually eating. Not the quietest place or be but full of energy! Make sure you get on the WiFi too - it's an AT&T dead zone! read more

See all

Wow what an experience, I see what the hype is all about. I ordered a sausage, egg, and pepper jack cheese on everything bagel. The sandwich was fresh and a generous portion. They have a huge menu to choose from and I can't wait to try other delicious food. Employees were very helpful and friendly. Ambiance was a little loud it was hard to hear when they called your name, but what they did with the interior it amazing!! read more

See all

New Breakfast/Lunch venue in the Mechanicsburg area - woohoo! I waited a few weeks before braving the crowds for the first time ...was pleasantly surprised when I did. During both of my visits (so far), I ordered the 'Hollywood' Breakfast sandwich (toasted sesame seed hoagie roll, seasoned steak, two sunny side up eggs, gouda cheese, lettuce & tomato) - and each time it was great! Steak was perfectly done (juicy, not dry & overcooked). Dining is open-concept and can be quite noisy if it is during the busy times. Although I haven't tried them yet, the bagels look quite tempting. I definitely recommend the breakfast sandwiches! read more

Bagel Boutique - "Hollywood" - Bagels Near Me - Mechanicsburg, Pennsylvania

See all

Everyone there is so friendly and nice every time I go in they always greet me by my name I guess cause I'll be going there every single day or just about every day. read more

See all

Great breakfast sandwiches. The Porky Pig may be the best I have had in the area. Tends to get crowded and a bit to get your bagel but worth it. Recommend ordering ahead on Local by Toast app and pick up. read more

Go to bagel boutique immediately! You will not be disappointed! I went early on Sunday morning. The line was manageable. They offer sandwiches, coffees, smoothies and have many creative bagel combos! I decided to get half a dozen to go. I got the everything, asiago and sun-dried tomato bagels. For the cream cheeses a.k.a. Schmears, I got the veggie and the chive and onion. Hands-down, these are the best schmears that I have ever had. I love a good bagel and love trying new bagel places in my travels. These by far are the best veggie and chive and onion cream cheeses I've ever had. They also have flavored butters. I will go back to try their sandwiches, special bagels sandwiches and even their lunch items. It is nicely decorated with some fun items, such as a selfie wall and directions on how to store your bagels! read more

See all

Wow!!! My friend said this was a must-stop while visiting, and she was absolutely right. The bagels were delicious, and I honestly wished my coffee never ran out! The employees were great, and you can tell they run a tight ship. Even though it was busy, there was a great flow and positive energy throughout the place. I can't wait to come back! read more

See all

My sister and I go to this place quite a bit! They have the best bagels! The owner told us that he goes and gets the dough from New York because people say it's the water in NY that makes the bagels taste so good! Whatever the reason these bagels are delicious! I love it that I can get vegan cream cheese in my bagel!! They have many different types of bagels! They also have sandwiches and a variety of food! It's a cute little place and we drive to Mechanicsburg to go there! Worth the trip! read more

See all

First timer! Grabbed two bagel sandwiches. The lox of which I loved sandwich. This was a solid purchase 100% doing it again. Grabbed my wife the Gianna sandwich which looked amazing. Let's hope that makes it to her. Literally thought about turning around to grab food for lunch. read more

I'll always support local businesses but in this case this case they need to start more sites! The bagels, cream cheeses were in such variety it was hard to choose. Bagels were pretty darn big and portions were ample. Small town charm, good food and great service. You won't find that at any bagel or coffee place. read more

Cute shop, fresh bagels--albeit not that innovative or highly crafted. The cream cheese is clearly commercial, as is the fish. A friendly and welcoming environment, but not the most interesting food. read more

My first time visiting this restaurant. The decor is super cute. I love the open floor layout. They have so many delicious menu items to choose from, but I went with the chipotle chicken wrap. It was packed with wonderful flavor and didn't lack any ingredients. The staff were friendly and efficient. I'm looking forward to my next visit. read more

Bagel Boutique - Chipotle chicken wrap - Bagels Near Me - Mechanicsburg, Pennsylvania

I was really excited to support this woman owned shop. So disappointed , they have zero personality in the shop. Why are the workers so unhappy? My bill was $73 for 2 bagelAlso , the prices were astronomical! I wanted to be delighted but I was not. The bagels were nothing special and our sandwiches were so overpriced. I took a friend for breakfast . My avocado was black! What?! I will not return. One positive note. The fresh mango juice was delicious. That I may come back for . A side note ; the kitchen door opened to our table and the worker just pushed out a cart into our table. Never said a word to us! The layout was ridiculous. read more

This establishment is new to the area and I love a good bagel so I had to visit. The ambiance screens woman owned im not entirely sure about that but regardless I love the pink and black esthetic. There are cute signs you can hold up for a selfie wall and everything. The bagels were fresh and super flavorful, speaking of flavors.. the mango juice & smoothie were so fresh and naturally sweet. Service, the ladies were super helpful with all the questions I had ( and I had plenty) thehehe. If you're in the area be sure to pop in, and just be mindful of the intersection.. it's not the best set up for the pulling in and out so be careful. read more

See all

Never open. They have not been open when stated that they are open numerous times. Public was told due to emergency repairs yet that is not the truth. Would love for the customers to be given honest answers. read more

Best bagels I've ever had! Sandwiches are huge too. I loved the Big Dill on a bagel! Come with a big appreciate they will not disappoint.

I have gotten take out from here 3 times and the experience was excellent. I had the pork roll egg and cheese, gyro, and an everything bagel. Everything was great! The bagels are fresh and the staff friendly. The service is quick. I'm pretty sure everything they serve is fantastic. Heading back there soon. read more

I've been here twice in two weeks I love the bagel sandwich I've gotten so much. This is so well designed on the inside. Love the quality of service. Food is great. I had a drink and it was okay but I might stick to food when I come next time. I love the self ordering kiosk. I would recommend to anyone. read more

OMG is all I can say. I got chopped Italian sandwich. I was so amazed by it I forgot to get a pic. Lol. This has to be one of the best sandwiches I have ever eaten. This is a must stop again. read more

We initially went to the Bagel Boutique on a Sunday morning. The parking lot was full and it was packed inside. Unfortunately, ordering was not easy on such a day. Tried to order online but the system would not allow us to do so. When we got near the front of the line the cashier says she couldn't take orders because her computer wasn't working and then she walked away. At that point, we'd already been there a while so we just left. Hopefully, management will develop a better system for crowd control. We went back during the week and it was a very positive experience. Ordered online with no trouble, and our food was awaiting pickup right on time. There were a few people inside but it wasn't a Sunday type crowd. The food was excellent. We enjoyed the waffles, bagels, and a bagel sandwich. Overall, recommend it and will be going back again (albeit probably not on a weekend). read more

They don't know how to toast bagels you asked for a double toast and it comes out, not toasted no matter how many times you tell them to toast it read more

Super busy but fast service. You can either on two kiosks by the door or wait in line and order in-person. All orders are to-go but they have tables you sit at and bus your own. Near the door are napkins, cutlery, and condiments. All tables were dirty and needed cleaned when we were there. I wiped ours off with napkins but there was dried food and stains. The peanut butter protein smoothie was 10/10! Hubby had cannula beans moth with caramel. It was good but not a ton of flavor. I had the California blt and added a folded egg, subbed regular cream cheese for the chive/onion cream cheese. This was delicious on an everything bagel. The bagel was soft and not too tough. It supported the sandwich well. Husband had the chicken and waffles stack. He loved it! We also got a side of tots. They were semi-warm and not crispy. Would not recommend. Especially for being busy, you would think they would be fresher. We also took home the garlic and cheese stuffed bagel. We heated a couple pieces up for dinner and it was amazing. Best thing there. Vampires will not come near you read more

See all

First off the pink is a whole vibe and aesthetically pleasing, I just loved everything from the pink painted parking lot to the New York City back drop! The bagels were amazing but very messy, they definitely need some heavy duty napkins! Would definitely not be able to eat this on the go, have to sit down for this one. Will definitely be back and can't wait to try a different bagel next time! read more

Bagel Boutique - Bagel - Bagels Near Me - Mechanicsburg, Pennsylvania

A+!!!! They did it again!!! Another continuation of their vision, hard work, and dedication to bringing amazing food to the West Shore. I got the bagel sandwich with turkey sausage and it was the best breakfast sandwich I ever had in my life!!! I washed it down with their hand pressed homemade OJ and it was insane! Was there a line? Yes...but...they just put in new kiosks and it was well worth the wait anyway! Besides...how many amazing places have no people in it!! My family and I absolutely loved it...I'm sure you will too!!! Great people and great food! A+!!! read more

Bagel Boutique - Incredible hand press OJ on site - Bagels Near Me - Mechanicsburg, Pennsylvania

See all

I won't be going back. This morning I stood in line at the counter while others were placing their orders. I had a quick question about a coffee before ordering -- I usually use the kiosk or order online, but today I wanted to ask in person. After waiting nearly ten minutes, when it was finally my turn, I was told (rudely) that they were "too busy" to take counter orders and that I needed to use the kiosk. Before I could even ask my question, the worker walked away and left me standing there. To make matters worse, when I turned around, a group of about eight teens had just walked in and filled every kiosk, leaving another long line. At that point I walked out unsatisfied. Customer service like this makes it clear I won't be back. read more

I loved the look and vibe of the boutique. There were so many options to pick from. We ordered three bagels. A specialty bagel (Cookie Monster) a breakfast sandwich, and a plain bagel (toasted dark) with cream cheese. The plain bagel didn't come how I ordered it, which was a bummer, however it was good. The cream cheese is a thick layer. If you like a lot of cream cheese this is your spot. The breakfast sandwich was hearty and delicious. The Cookie Monster was loved by the kids and was very rich. We ordered two lattes, both with oat milk. The price for the coffees was comparable, even with the up charge for the specialty milk. We spent $34.50 for 3 breakfast items and 2 lattes. Cute and aesthetically pleasing environment. They had ample amount of seating and it was clean. The service was fast and friendly. Overall I would try it again. read more

See all

Best bagel sandwich everrrr!! I got The Stinger and highly recommend. Decent size menu with lots of options that all sound amazing whether you want something sweet or savory and that goes for drinks too. This place is newer and you can tell they put a lot of effort in the appearance. Super cute and clean inside, and great service! read more

Bagel Boutique - The stinger - Bagels Near Me - Mechanicsburg, Pennsylvania

See all

Truly 3.5 Pros- Tasty and fresh bagels, novelty varieties and an array of schemers. I don't have to drive to resslers anymore and it's just down the street from my house. Big fat breakfast sandwiches. Tasty flavor combos. Tasty, creative beverages and fresh juices. Cons- execution of bagel sandwiches. I don't enjoy eating them because all the contents drip from below. I find my self constantly reassembling the sandwich and looking like I have zero table manners from the mess. We asked for them to go light on the schmere and though it helped a wee bit, every thing still slid from below and dripped. I went during the 3 weeks of opening and have visited 1x a week since. All the sandwiches I have tried so far have not been easy to eat. They all are very flavorful though. Overall- The have an amazing foundation and a solid bagel. All ingredients individually are fresh and tasty. For now, I will just stick to bagels and spreads. Maybe I'll wait a few months before getting sandwiches. I will likely try lunch sandwiches. I also love their fresh juices. They are amazing. This will definitely become a go to Breakfast spot for me. I know the owner is super involved, and created valley bistro, which is my fave lunch/brunch spot. I will continue to support them as they continue to establish themselves and reinvent things . read more

Very disappointing...I was so excited to see this pop up so close to home, but sadly Bagel did not have the consistency of a freshly made bagel, it was different...after speaking to some others who have tried this place I am hearing these bagels are not made in house, but rather shipped in and steamed before serving? Not 100% positive that this is true or not, but if it is, well thats just unacceptable. Ordered a California BLT and an egg white delight. Both sandwiches were messy but the BLT was almost impossible to eat, ingredients sliding off the sandwich left and right, made it difficult to enjoy? But the bagels were the biggest let down... not to mention way too expensive!!!! $10 for an egg sandwich??? read more

I've been back and it was a good experience. The Guido Breakfast bagel sandwich was delicious. Beware though, it's huge. Great combination of flavors. I also picked up a half dozen bagels and a tub of the jalapeño cheddar cream cheese. They were delicious even a couple days later. I ask for the bagels to be sliced but not toasted. Unfortunately they were not sliced upon arrival home. Should have checked before I left. They are working through the growing pains of a new restaurant. Will Definitely be back. read more

I wanted to like this place, it has great reviews online and it's themed, with different flavored bagels etc. Unfortunatley sometimes you just can't beat a simple, well-done bagel and this is not the place for that. I think it would serve them to go back to the basics... My lox and cream cheese bagel that I ordered did not come with the lox that we paid for... it was just cream cheese on one side loaded with more capers than I could count. Unfortunately we got our order to go and were almost 20 min away when we discovered the mishap or would've went back to have this corrected. You win some you lose some. My husbands bagel was called "california BLT". It sounded yummy but the reality was that this bagel wasn't done well... the lettuce was chopped like a salad, thee tomatoes were chopped like pico de gallo... it was wet, and they upsold him an egg which he got 'over easy'... so although this seemed like it would've been good together, sadly a thousand pieces of small thigns on a bagel just wasn't working and ended up everywhere , drippy, sloppy, and falling apart. To our disappointment the bread was also a 'doughy' consistency and not in a good way. it felt raw or maybe like it would have been better cooked more? Unsure, but the textures left something to be desired, with a soggy feel to it. We left underwhelmed and still hungry. I get that people like bagel places to be different and stand out, but most of the menu options seem like Diabetes orders (reeses smear and french toast bagels, fruity pebbles and oreos bagels). It's not our thing, and it's not really a place we want to encourage others to go if they care about their health. Again, it's a bagel place so take that for what it is, I understand this is Central PA but we can do better. Some of the bagels look like they had been dyed with food coloring, which also I get if you aren't worried about that sort of thing, no problem but food dye is something we intentionally avoid. If they had GF options or offered high-quality fresh bagel-ready toppings this place would be more appealing to us. Having messed up our order today though as a first time customer doesn't leave us wanting to come back for more. Bagel Boutique we know you can do better! read more

Bagel Boutique - Bagels Near Me - Mechanicsburg, Pennsylvania

confused at the hours ? often closed when we visit the store despite no signage . website inaccurate ? phone voicemail full, often can't order on line ?! read more

Visited this place for the first time with some friends recently. ABSOLUTELY worth the trip!! I had the Berry Chic and it was outstanding!! HIGHLY RECOMMEND THIS PLACE!! read more

I've visited two times now. To begin, it's great having another bagel outlet in the area. It's new so any comments take that into consideration. The coffee is very good. The bagel selection, at least in the morning, is substantial. First suggestion: Insure whoever is on the register knows the menu. I ordered an everything bagel with lox. The order taker told me they don't have lox. They did. Second: since they're new, allow time and patience. The menu. Remembering it's Central PA, there are many offerings that you'd never see at a NY/NJ/Florida bagel shop like Oreo bagels. They also offer a salmon BLT. It comes with smoked salmon and pastrami. IMO those are two foods that do not belong together. They offer bialys. With all due respect, bialys may not be well known in the area. They're similar to bagels. Every bagel shop that makes them sell them for the same price as the bagels. Now bagels cost $2.00. Bialys are a whopping $6-8.00. They could be the best bialys in America; but lI'll never know. I'm sure things will work themselves out over time. Good luck. read more