Bagel Island Sandwich Shoppe

3

119

153

3 months ago

Just what the lower keys needs - a tasty and reliable bagel shop! Extremely reasonably priced, easy plaza parking, small seating inside and outside. 12/10 spot read more

Bagel Island Sandwich Shoppe - Build your own bagel with Turkey - Delis Near Me - Big Pine Key, Florida

Bagel Island Sandwich Shoppe - Toasted poppy bagel with egg, cheese, tomato and onion - Delis Near Me - Big Pine Key, Florida

See all

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Amy P.

3

126

171

1 year ago

Stopped by for breakfast/lunch on the way up from Key West. I got an egg and cheese breakfast sandwich on an onion bagel. The food was hot and fresh and the bagel was nice and soft. Also tried an iced latte and it was nice and strong. Service was great and everyone was very friendly and patient. Great place to try! read more

See all

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Danielle C.

0

26

2

3 months ago

Great food service and the friendliest staff thanks for the great breakfast takeout order!

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Sydney D.

36

14

16

1 year ago

First time in the keys and friend decided to bring me here and it did not disappoint! Bagels were fluffy and buttery and the eggs, meat, and cheese complimented it perfectly. The service was stellar and personal and truly made me feel welcomed. Bagels and drinks came out super quick and then we were on our way. Great place for a quick and yummy breakfast before hitting the beach. read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Noel J.

Super Real life Mario bros

255

166

330

2 years ago

Stopped here for a quick bite while on the way to Key West! This is a cute bagel store with a nice assortment of bagel flavors, sandwiches, drinks and more. The food is reasonably priced and the staff is friendly. There is also a large parking lot which makes stopping here very convenient. I got ham and egg on an everything bagel and it was very delicious and made within minutes! I do wish there was more egg on the sandwich so next time I will ask for 2 or 3 eggs! Overall, I'd definitely come back! read more

Bagel Island Sandwich Shoppe - Ham and egg on an everything bagel - Delis Near Me - Big Pine Key, Florida

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

0

6

13

1 year ago

Service was fast zippy to the point friendly nice atmosphere nice looking place not very dirty very clean place with friendly staff and lots of options for bagels etc, I got the plain bagel with butter toasted and it was quite nice soft but not too soft crunchy sweet and with the perfect mix of butter and dough. I'd recommend this place for anyone looking for a decent bagel place to try. read more

See all

Helpful 1

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

James T.

4

26

23

1 year ago

Food was good and tasty. Service was annoyed we hadn't memorized the chalkboard menu nor could see it 25feet away.

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Mark P.

Elite 26 All-Star

4999

1242

9848

5 years ago

Easy strong four or more. Wow! Who knew? What a wonderful gem of a spot tucked in the corner of the plaza. Delicious fresh baked bagels, pretty good coffee, friendly and helpful; all at a very good value. Love those prices. Damn, I wish I knew of them sooner. Lots of interesting offerings for lunch beckoning me back. read more

Bagel Island Sandwich Shoppe - palm trees in front - Delis Near Me - Big Pine Key, Florida

Bagel Island Sandwich Shoppe - a cup of coffee and a bagel - Delis Near Me - Big Pine Key, Florida

Bagel Island Sandwich Shoppe - a bagel with sesame seeds - Delis Near Me - Big Pine Key, Florida

Bagel Island Sandwich Shoppe - menus on the wall - Delis Near Me - Big Pine Key, Florida

Bagel Island Sandwich Shoppe - breakfast and lunch area - Delis Near Me - Big Pine Key, Florida

Bagel Island Sandwich Shoppe - delicious roast beast sammich ...for breakfast; why not? - Delis Near Me - Big Pine Key, Florida

See all

Helpful 23

Thanks 0

Love this 24

Oh no 1

B H.

0

50

126

2 years ago

Breakfast sandwiches were very good, bagels were fresh Cold coffeee was ok Service was quick, minimal wait Shop was very clean read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Ariana L.

0

1

0

1 year ago

Staff are extremely rude. Went in one day on our trip and my friend very politely asked for a extra pump of sweetener in her coffee, one of the lady's just looked at her, didn't answer, and turned back around while shaking her head which was very off putting. We thought we'd give it another try so we went in the next day and right when we walked in the staff didn't welcome us. The same lady that was very disrespectful the day before looked at us all again and shook her head and continued to ignore us. Not a welcoming place what so ever! read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Peter M.

79

287

696

4 years ago

I love a great sub sandwich but I am particular about the type of bread, the meat to bread ratio and the selection of condiments offered. This place hits it out of the park in all three categories, it's my favorite sandwich shop on Big Pine Key. The bread is soft Cuban style mini loaf and the meat and veggies are proportional to the sandwich. I usually order the Italian sub with added jalapeños, delicious. I definitely recommend this sandwich/bagel shop. read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Brad T.

0

16

5

1 year ago

Stop in quick for some to-go coffees. Prices were very reasonable and the coffee tasted good.

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Sherry J.

Elite 26 All-Star

84

922

3226

5 years ago

Stopped for breakfast yesterday. RJ had egg cheese and bacon on an Asiago bagel and I had egg cheese and sausage on Asiago. We also picked up 2 bags of day old bagels for $2.50 each, what a great deal! We sat outside and the sandwiches were brought to us in about 5 minutes and were delicious! read more

Bagel Island Sandwich Shoppe - Sausage egg and cheese on Asiago - Delis Near Me - Big Pine Key, Florida

See all

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Melissa N.

2741

1194

6802

5 years ago

They are located in the Big Pine Shopping Center. I have been to this plaza so many times and I just found out about them. I can't even believe it. Definitely the best prices in the Keys. Bagels are just $1 and they are made fresh daily. You can't beat that! Plus, they have so many bagels and cream cheese options. They offer all sorts of tasty sweets, pastries, and croissants. Coffee was pretty good. The cafe con leche was quite delicious. They are not just a breakfast spot, they also serve sandwiches, soups, salads, and other items for lunch. I will certainly visit more often. read more

Helpful 11

Thanks 0

Love this 15

Oh no 0

Kris Y.

46

99

27

2 years ago

This place has great bagels. We stopped on our way home from Key West for a bagel with cream cheese. Both were very good and super fresh!

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Paul W.

0

8

2

2 years ago

The best freshest bagels I've had in a longtime. Great little spot for a bagel, breakfast sandwich, not to mention the excellent coffee. Whenever back in Biog Pine Key will definitely head there for breakfast. read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Stanley M.

Elite 19

67

325

146

3 years ago

Great bagels between Key West and Marathon. They have salt bagels which are becoming a rarity. I didn't look for double Dutch chocolate Asiago sun dried tomato bagels. This is not that kind of place. Lol. Their breakfast blend coffee hit the spot. We sat outside in the front and enjoyed a very nice breakfast. If you're a bagel aficionado like me, you'll add this on your trek to of from Key West. read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Jean P.

1

39

11

4 years ago

Great little mom and pop shop for some good bagels!!! Great selection of bagels. Delicious pastries, croissants and sweets compliment your coffee for a tasty breakfast right here in Big Pine.pastries, croissants and sweets available as well. They weren't able to serve hot coffee on the day we were there because of a water issue but did offer iced coffee. Quick service. Going back for more! read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Diana C.

22

28

8

3 years ago

This was my second time visiting, the bagels are so delicious and taste fresh! I had also ordered a Dulce de leche and yum! My daughter had the Belgian waffle and mango smoothie. The place itself is very cute, clean and the staff are welcoming read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Tom L.

62

347

948

4 years ago

The first time that I went here it was really great. The food was good and I had a smoothie for the road. The second time I only went in for a smoothie and it took a long time and it was the wrong smoothie. But that's OK. It was very good and they were extremely busy so I can completely understand. They're just open back up from their months vacation. If you want a good bagel and good cup of coffee or a smoothie I would recommend this place. read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Becky H.

0

15

1

2 years ago

Cute bagel shop tucked away in a shopping center. Great fresh bagel choices and coffee and smoothie selection. Got the bacon, egg breakfast sandwich, basic but yummy. Also got a chai tea. The lunch menu looked good too. Great pricing!!! Definitely worth the stop. read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Bud K.

0

68

7

3 years ago

Wife and I stopped on our way north this morning and got two egg bagels w/egg and cheese to go. Bagels were so dry they crumbled In pieces. Barely any egg and never did see any cheese. After a couple of bites we both gave up and threw them away. read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Tracy C.

0

1

0

2 years ago

Great sandwiches friendly service, amazing cold drinks. Always such a treat. Our favorite is dulche drink so awesome

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Amy B.

Elite 19

72

85

52

4 years ago

This place is small and can get quite busy but the food and coffee are good especially if you just want to grab something and go. Friendly staff that always treat their guests well :) read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 1

Oh no 0

Barry M.

Elite 22

30

242

3

5 years ago

Stopped in this morning before heading to Miami. Ordered 3 eggs, bacon, wheat toast, hashbrowns, milk, and coffee. It all came out perfect. Nice place to sit and eat my food in silence as a constant stream of customers came through. Lots of light. Very kind and considerate staff. They deserve your business. read more

Helpful 2

Thanks 0

Love this 1

Oh no 0

Michelle P.

0

5

4

2 years ago

I had the plain bagel with lox tomato, onion, and caprice. I've never really had a bagel loaded like this and I am craving it so badly now I leave to go back home tomorrow and I really hope I can stop by and get it one more time. The Pensa de Leche frozen coffee was so good.. my husband and my four year-old each got a croissant and they loved it read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Jim P.

90

310

709

8 years ago

Huge disappointment! We stopped by this place because the reviews said they had good bagels. The bagels were okay, but not great. They were actually the best part of our breakfast. I ordered an omelet with bacon & cheese. The menu said it was supposed to contain 3 eggs. It didn't even have two eggs. And one scrawny piece of bacon. The default bread option was toast, so I "upgraded" to one of their supposedly great bagels with some butter and jelly. Well, that little change added almost $2 to my order. My wife ordered scrambled eggs with hash browns, and she also "upgraded" to the deluxe bagel option with jelly. The eggs were tasteless and the hash browns turned out to be a frozen patty. Really? They couldn't even cut up a potato? Those two meals cost us over $18! Yes, you read that right. We didn't even order anything to drink. And our food was served on paper plates with plastic utensils. Maybe the money they are saving on washing dishes could be put to use on better quality food at a better price! Next time we're in the Keys and pass by this place, we'll be sure to keep on driving. Big thumbs down! read more

Helpful 2

Thanks 0

Love this 1

Oh no 0

Don F.

0

25

14

3 years ago

When the Wife is at the register she is very pleasant and I enjoy going. When the husband is at the register he s kind of an ass. The food is good but don't add anything to your sandwich or you will pay for it dearly. read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Meredith S.

16

8

3

5 years ago

It's so delicious! You have try the onion bagel toasted with the roasted red pepper cream cheese! To die for! We also loved the breakfast sandwiches. We had such a great experience we've been eating breakfast here daily. The owners are so nice! read more

Bagel Island Sandwich Shoppe - Everything breakfast bagel - Delis Near Me - Big Pine Key, Florida

Bagel Island Sandwich Shoppe - Espresso frozen drink - Delis Near Me - Big Pine Key, Florida

See all

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Kate A.

0

19

0

3 years ago

Great selection of bagels with friendly service! I ordered ahead on the phone which was fast and easy. I look forward to stopping here each time I'm in town. I love that the breakfast sandwiches aren't overly greasy. Definitely recommend! read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Mary T.

122

15

11

5 years ago

Bagels are good, food is made fresh in front of you. Both times I have been in there has been an issue in the kitchen - food mix up, which caused the couple (I assume who own the plce) end up bickering. I don't get good vibes from this establishment but the foods good. read more

Helpful 1

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Liz L.

1

8

2

6 years ago

Went here on our way down to the keys and their sandwiches are amazing. I had the Ruben which is to die for and the hubs had the Shaved Ribeye. We loved it so much we hit them back up on our way home. Small quaint shoppe and you won't be sorry. read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Linda W.

0

52

6

3 years ago

Good bagel and sandwich shop. We peat here 2X week when we're in town. Friendly staff and good food.

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Erin T.

4

43

23

5 years ago

Staff are very friendly. Iced coffee was very bitter and the breakfast bagel was bland. I just don't see the hype.

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Stan G.

19

6

0

3 years ago

Excellent food prep and very friendly people. French toast and bagels were. I'll be back. Next time for lunch.

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Steve W.

62

15

2

7 years ago

Nice spot for a quick lunch. I had an Asiago bagel sandwich and it was great! The service was great too. Very friendly! I'll definitely stop in for lunch the next time I'm in Big Pine Key. read more

Helpful 1

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Jovanni C.

92

33

8

5 years ago

Great spot for a bagel, coffee and relaxing atmosphere. Love getting the sausage egg and cheese bagel from here. Staff are very welcoming, polite and joyful. Quick service as well. Definitely give this place a try! read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Janet F.

0

5

0

6 years ago

Great local bagel shop! A mix of sandwiches, salads, smoothies, shakes and coffee. Affordable prices, friendly staff and good food.

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Joel F.

0

140

7

6 years ago

I went in for breakfast and coffee. The coffee was ok, nothing to scream about. For breakfast I ordered two eggs over easy with a side of bacon and grits. Also toast. The eggs were perfect. The bacon was sliced paper thin. The grits were served in a separate styrofoam container. They weren't hot and a little dry on top. The toaster must have been set on the lightest setting. My toast really wasn't toasted. It was more like dried bread. It was a lackluster breakfast and I'd never go back. read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Joseph T.

0

11

80

5 years ago

bagel island big pine key is the best breakfast on the island! Clean, tasty, and very reasonably priced! Highly recommended spasticity the Lox sandwich read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Page 1 of 3

See more reviews

More info about Bagel Island Sandwich Shoppe

See outside
205 Key Deer Blvd
Big Pine Key, FL 33043
Directions
(305) 872-9912
Call Now
Visit Website
http://bagelislandcoffee.com

Full menu

Hours

What time does Bagel Island Sandwich Shoppe open?

Bagel Island Sandwich Shoppe opens at 7:00 AM on Wednesday, Thursday, Friday, Saturday and Sunday.

What time does Bagel Island Sandwich Shoppe close?

Bagel Island Sandwich Shoppe is closed on Monday and Tuesday.Bagel Island Sandwich Shoppe closes at 2:00 PM on Wednesday, Thursday, Friday and Saturday.Bagel Island Sandwich Shoppe closes at 1:00 PM on Sunday.

Mon-Tue ClosedWed-Sat 7:00 AM - 2:00 PMSun 7:00 AM - 1:00 PM

Payment methods

Does Bagel Island Sandwich Shoppe take credit cards?

Yes, Bagel Island Sandwich Shoppe takes credit cards.

Food & Alcohol

Does Bagel Island Sandwich Shoppe have catering options?

No, Bagel Island Sandwich Shoppe does not have catering options.

Does Bagel Island Sandwich Shoppe serve alcohol?

No, Bagel Island Sandwich Shoppe does not serve alcohol.

Indoor Amenities

Does Bagel Island Sandwich Shoppe have TVs?

Yes, Bagel Island Sandwich Shoppe has TVs.

Outdoor Amenities

Does Bagel Island Sandwich Shoppe have bike parking?

Yes, Bagel Island Sandwich Shoppe has bike parking.

Does Bagel Island Sandwich Shoppe have outdoor seating?

No, Bagel Island Sandwich Shoppe does not have outdoor seating options.

Does Bagel Island Sandwich Shoppe have parking?

Yes, Bagel Island Sandwich Shoppe has parking options.

Other Amenities

Is Bagel Island Sandwich Shoppe wheelchair accessible?

Yes, Bagel Island Sandwich Shoppe is wheelchair accessible.

Does Bagel Island Sandwich Shoppe have free WiFi?

No, Bagel Island Sandwich Shoppe does not have free WiFi.

More Info

Health Score

Park Avenue Island Deli

4.6(45 reviews)

0.7 mi

Amazing sandwiches! That's all, must try! Had three different ones and all were just amazing!read more

Super yummy! Quick stop to eat before heading back to Miami, and it did not disappoint. The food…read morewas fresh, flavorful, and hit the spot after our trip. Definitely recommend stopping by if you're in the Keys!

Menu

See all

Egg n 1 Egg & Cheese So yummy !!! quick stop to eat before going home to Miami

Murray's Market

4.2(38 reviews)

5.9 mi

Excellent customer service great prices and products. Easy in and out. Highly recommend!!!read more

Everything. Also I enjoyed but not sure if they still give the steak bones for your doggy.read more

Murray's Market

See all

Goldman's Bagel Deli

4.5(359 reviews)

27.1 mi

Connie was our awesome server! Food was perfect, large portions to share, and pretty much…read moreeverything on the menu is a win. I absolutely recommend this place for breakfast and lunch, and if there is a line, it goes quick.

We had great food here! We could tell it's consistently good because there were many regulars…read morethere! Always a good sign when traveling. There was both indoor and outdoor seating. Though our waitress was very busy, she was on top of it and service was quick!

Pick up

See all

Service and prep are

Green Turtle Wine & Spirits

4.2(9 reviews)

47.8 mi

We went twice for breakfast in July 2025 and food was excellent. Great friendly, fast service.read more

Had wanted to try this place for some time. Waited an hour after placing order, waitress shared it…read morewith old be a few more minutes, then manager came by and said they were plating our breakfast, then a few minutes later, watch a table in our waitress's section (seated 15min after us) get served. We chose to walk out due to respect. Nobody owned up to mishandling our order or service

See all

Main entrance

Ana's Cuban Cafe

4.5(320 reviews)

28.9 mi

We enjoyed our breakfast sandwiches and Cuban coffees. Note there's no seating, so get it to go.read more

After walking the entire length of Duval Street and visiting the Southernmost Point buoy, we were…read morehonestly too tired to walk all the way back to the area with the main restaurants. So we started looking for something nearby and came across this place. It's not a traditional restaurant -- they've basically turned the porch into a seating area. You order at the counter and wait for them to bring your food. There's also a small general store right on the porch. We placed our order, and it took a little while for them to prepare everything. The fried banana was really good. My sandwich, though, was pretty boring. Still, it was a chill and peaceful spot to sit in the shade, eat lunch, and watch all the cool cars go by -- a nice, relaxed lunch overall.

Ana's Cafe Key West, FL_Sanju-2

Bacon and Egg $12.50

See all

The Courthouse Deli & Whit's Frozen Custard

4.2(83 reviews)

29.2 mi

•$

We stumbled upon this place while walking to the Hemingway home. It was a nice break on the way…read moreback to the dock. While small, the menu is extensive! We had milkshakes and while expensive, worth the price. They were flavorful and cooling.

Would come here in a pinch but wouldn't be my first choice. Sandwiches are a little too pricey for…read morewhat they give you. People are nice and service was fine. Just think you can get better food else where.

Front counter and ice cream

Hot Pastrami when it was unwrapped.

See all

Partially chewed and non edible pastrami. Worst ever!

Seaside Grocery & Deli

2.4(7 reviews)

25.9 mi

WARNING! Do NOT shop here! I never take the time to write a review but this business deserves it…read more First off theres no prices on any items so they charge you whatever they feel like ( didn' mind... I get that's it's a huge convenience). Then I noticed the food I bought was expired. I went back to just ask for a refund and the gentl at the register refused and became hostile. I threatened to call police and he threw half what I paid for it in the table. Worst experience as far as customer service....EVER. 0 starts and need a to shut down immediately. Bad business to the fullest extent. Disgusting...

Please for the love of god do not shop here! No prices on any of their stuff. They ring up whatever…read moreprice they want. And no receipt given even when you ask. The deli is days old sandwiches in a small fridge. DO NOT SHOP HERE. Go to Publix 5 mins down the street. Only giving a star because I have to. Otherwise, no stars!

See all

Fausto's Food Palace

4.1(73 reviews)

29.1 mi

We had just arrived in town and needed to pick up a few essential items. It's not a huge…read moresupermarket, but we found most of what we were looking for. There was a good selection of produce, dairy, snacks, and beverages. Of course, there's always a bit of sticker shock when shopping in a small tourist town, but that's part of the price of visiting paradise. Definitely a place we would return to. The staff who helped us were pleasant.

Great little grocery store with friendly and helpful staff. Locals shop here, and it's gourmet…read moreenough to find specialty items for your room (if you're a visitor).

See all

Jersey Mike's Subs

3.7(14 reviews)

27.1 mi

Came in on a Saturday afternoon and it was pretty busy. I ordered with a lovely blonde girl working…read morethe meat slicer. At first she apologized and said she would be right with me (I assured her there was no need to apologize as she was working so hard)! When I ordered with her I asked for the gluten free bread option and she asked if I needed for her to change her gloves. She also explained to me how they don't do the "mini" size in gluten free, the smallest they do with gluten free bread is the regular so that was fine for me. My interaction with her alone really meant so much to me! I really appreciated her attention to my gluten sensitivity. At this point I thought wow, this place deserves five stars. But then I had two more stops down the line. My next stop was the girl who was putting the toppings in the sandwich. She and the man in the back who was putting together a kids meal decided it would be a good time to throw lettuce at each other. Personally, I worked at a restaurant when I was young. I get it. But not in front of customers. Don't throw lettuce into each others stations while there's people around. It was really unprofessional and unsanitary (they were throwing the same lettuce at each other). I will say the boy started it, but it didn't help the girl did it back at him. Anyways after that I had to deal with the cashier who I can only hope was on his first shift. It was difficult for him to understand the sandwich I got, as he was pressing so many different buttons. But at least he went back and asked the girl like three times what kind of sandwich it was before changing it to the right order. Thankfully I was able to see the screen/ which order I ended up paying for. Overall, sandwich was good, stacked with stuff. But they need to do better with training their employees. I wish I got the name of the girl working the meat slicer because she was the only one who had it together!

The date is July 23rd 2025 at about 6pm. The 3 high school/ college aged kids working there, they…read morewere very polite respectful and engaged in conversation! They worked as a team to make one of the best subs I've ever had from this company! As a key west resident me and many others are plagued with migrant fatigue and poor service from them I'm glad to see one company has a good hiring manager and staff!

See all

Why does Yelp recommend reviews?

Hundreds of millions of reviews are posted on Yelp, and our automated recommendation software works in the background to showcase the reviews that it …

4 reviews that are not currently recommended

The reviews below are not factored into the business's overall star rating.

Kathrina R.

11

16

11

5 years ago

GreAt sandwiches! Every time, we like the Italian and the Reuben. But all are great! They are Super friendly

Michelle R.

87

2

0

8 years ago

Great little breakfast place! Super quick but made fresh to order sandwiches! A great little find on Yelp!

L H.

0

5

0

15 years ago

Run of the mill bagels but the only bagels around. The coffee is good.

John M.

0

2

0

5 years ago

My morning stop at least twice a week, simply the best.

Bagel Island Sandwich Shoppe - delis - Updated September 2026

People who viewed Bagel Island Sandwich Shoppe also viewed

Marathon Bagel

(414 reviews)

•$

Ate here 2 times on our week stay, because it was that good. It was packed both times, had pretty…read morelong wait times, but your food is made to order and I don't mind, especially because you can physically see how busy it is and everything is made fresh. Their everything bagel is probably the best I have ever had. So soft and fresh. Me and my husband got the pork roll breakfast bagel sandwich with egg and cheese on an everything bagel and one with bacon as well. We also tried an everything bagel with their homemade chive cream cheese. So good! Their iced coffee is pretty good as well. Would absolutely come back!

Popped in for a quick breakfast yesterday morning, during our way down to Marathon…read more We had read about this place online, and decided to give it a try. The bagels are fresh, and the staff is friendly. Giving four stars because of the fact that we did not get to try the iced coffee or any other coffee options.

Goldman's Bagel Deli

4.5

(359 reviews)

Connie was our awesome server! Food was perfect, large portions to share, and pretty much…read moreeverything on the menu is a win. I absolutely recommend this place for breakfast and lunch, and if there is a line, it goes quick.

We had great food here! We could tell it's consistently good because there were many regulars…read morethere! Always a good sign when traveling. There was both indoor and outdoor seating. Though our waitress was very busy, she was on top of it and service was quick!

Morning Joint

4.7

(88 reviews)

Coffee was amazing! Food was delicious and good option for everyone!! Very satisfied with the meal…read moreand the prices, great service too. All around great stop!!

This needs to be a stop on your way to or from the Florida Keys!…read more Serving up breakfast, coffee, matcha and sandwiches this funky spot has a cheeky name that they really lean into. I ordered the Mile Marker 22, which is a turkey panini on ciabatta bread with avocado, goat cheese, honey and some veggies. They knocked it out of the park with this one! I also got a raspberry matcha latte, which was pretty good. It did need some mixing so the raspberry blended better but overall a solid matcha latte. There is indoor and outdoor seating. Lots of colorful murals and just a fun atmosphere. Everything is made to order so you'll get a very fresh meal.

Croissants De France

(136 reviews)

We had researched places to visit during our vacation to the Keys and this was at the top of our…read morelist. It's a cute building and the employees are friendly. The display cases are filled with an assortment of croissants, beignets, buns and more. We tried the butter croissant, strawberry beignets, coconut cream cheese and guava cheese. The flavors were different and tasted good. We were disappointed in the lack of filling and the butter croissant was not as fresh and flaky as you would expect but was tough. The iced coffee is decent and I appreciated that they had almond and oat milk options. I got an added shot of espresso which was definitely needed as it didn't seem to have a strong coffee flavor even with the added shot. We would return but sadly is not going to be our required morning stop, as we had been hoping.

The display case is full of breathtaking delights. Loved this gem so much I came back twice during…read moremy visit to the Keys. Ordered: hot caramel macchiato, breakfast croissant (sausage), prosciutto sandwich, beignets (Nutella and custard), almond croissant, chocolate croissant, veggie quiche

The Courthouse Deli & Whit's Frozen Custard

4.2

(83 reviews)

•$

We stumbled upon this place while walking to the Hemingway home. It was a nice break on the way…read moreback to the dock. While small, the menu is extensive! We had milkshakes and while expensive, worth the price. They were flavorful and cooling.

Would come here in a pinch but wouldn't be my first choice. Sandwiches are a little too pricey for…read morewhat they give you. People are nice and service was fine. Just think you can get better food else where.

LJ’s Cafe

5.0

(77 reviews)

If you're traveling to or through Marathon, Florida, do yourself a favor and stop at LJ's Café for…read morebreakfast or lunch. This family-owned gem was one of the highlights of our trip! My husband ordered the ham, egg, and cheese breakfast sandwich, and it was absolutely amazing. We split it but the first thing we noticed it was huge. The sandwich was served on Cuban bread that they bake fresh themselves, and it was some of the best bread I've ever had; light, flaky, perfectly golden brown, and incredibly fresh. Every ingredient tasted fresh and homemade, including real eggs cooked to order, not the processed "fake" eggs you find in so many places. Be sure to save room for one of their homemade pastries. Like the bread, everything is baked in-house, and you can taste the care that goes into every bite. The coffee was equally impressive; rich, smooth, and full of flavor. It paired perfectly with breakfast and kept me coming back for more. What really sets LJ's Café apart, though, is the atmosphere. This is a true mom-and-pop establishment where family and friends work together. From the moment you walk into the small storefront, you're welcomed like family. The service is warm, genuine, and makes you feel right at home. And here's an added bonus for Florida travelers: the air conditioning is fantastic! After visiting several places in Marathon, we definitely appreciated being able to enjoy our meal in a cool, comfortable environment. I can't rave enough about this wonderful spot. If you're passing through Marathon, make sure your schedule allows for breakfast or lunch because those are the only hours they're open. Trust me, you won't be disappointed!

Coffee was perfect The bacon egg and cheese breakfast…read moresandwich was so good a large portion Guava pastry - yummy

Starfish Kitchen

3.5

(8 reviews)

the food is good and the service is great i definitely recommend coming here for breakfast not…read moresuper pricey either for the keys the only thing i would recommend is a big sign outside so people know where you guys are located

My son and I arrived at 9:00 AM today and it was closed. I hope it was just a fluke and not a…read morepermanent closure.

Georgies Coffee

(109 reviews)

Best coffee shop in the Marathon area!!! By far! I see…read moresomeone was upset because they were closing Welcome to the Florida Keys.... time is fluid here Slow down relax don't post hateful crap. This is a great coffee shop if you missed out going to KW stop on the way home!

We checked online while driving down to Key West. Their website said they were open and accepted an…read moreonline order ($12.50 for ONE specialty coffee). We arrived 7 minutes later and the doors were locked with cars in the parking lot. Employees starting walking out the back and leaving while I called the business line and finally a man answered and said they closed early because of weather. He was not very friendly. He also said he would refund our money the next day. The next morning I received a call from him that he couldn't refund the order but would mail a check. Ten days later we received a check in the mail for $11.50. I shredded the check and disputed the charge through my credit card company for the full amount.

DeLuna's cafe

4.6

(73 reviews)

This is a Food truck that is permanently parked at Boyd's campground. I came here every morning for…read moreCoffee. And food a couple of them. The iced Cafe con Leche was perfect! They use coffee ice cubes. We had an amazing guava cream cheese pastry one morning and the breakfast had the real deal breakfast! It was huge! Eggs a little overdone for me. The steak and potatoes for it were perfect! I got a ropa vieja empanada that we had later. Wow! What flavor! The service here is amazing! Christy and her husband run a great food truck! I highly recommend this place. Great if you are at the campground or in the area! There are picnic tables here if you want to eat it here also

Definitely worth the stop! Came here twice during my recent visit to Key West because my boyfriend…read morewanted a cuban breakfast. They had the best cortaditos I have ever tasted, and we had to return the next day for more. The croquetas were made fresh to order and my steak, egg, and cheese breakfast sandwich was great. We also got a guava pastry! I even liked the little outdoor seating area, which added to the experience. The lady working that day was very welcoming and told us a lot about the history of DeLuna's!

Funky Rooster Coffee House & Wine Bar

(95 reviews)