Not sure what other people expect from a bagel cafe, but I've never been disappointed in all the times I've eaten here. I come from a different town but when I'm around Shoreham I make sure to stop in. The salads are fresh - chopped the way I like 'em and the bagels are better than any in my home town. read more

Do not go here! The owner is awful, so rude and unprofessional. The food is over priced and not even that good. They treat their employees so badly, it is very disappointing. read more

Do not go here. It took over 10 minutes just for someone to even take my order. I ordered two egg sandwiches and the woman seemed super annoyed that I was even in her store. 10 minutes later they're done. We go to eat the sandwiches and the food leaked all over our clothes when we opened them. The sandwiches were folded very oddly too and everything fell out right away. Also there was no flavor whatsoever. read more

Overpriced, looks dirty and unkept (flies were a around the doorway leading back to the kitchen area on 10/30) $33 for a dozen bagels and cream cheese? Worthwhile to pass this place by, go 5 minutes further east for a much better and less expensive experience. read more

First experience I ordered 8 sandwiches all the same and they forgot 2 of them. Today they forgot my entire order. I walk in and am the only person at the counter, ordered bacon/egg/cheese on a scooped out salt bagel. Also just egg in a scooped out egg everything bagel. (I put the details so when read, the dope who took my order can remember and go home feeling bad about themselves, I can only hope) After 15 minutes I check on my order and the girl "who most defiantly" took my order says she never took it. Did I imagine the entire thing? I live up the bloI will never go in that place again and will, with every breath I can muster rage on and on to all who will listen, about the utter incompetence that goes on in there. Go into Wading River/Rocky point for a breakfast sandwich, or in regard to this place save a 250% mark up and make it at home. Stupid people, stupid prices and I don't think they even boil the bagels. Awful!!!!! *****Went back since last visit since "under new management" $8.59 for 2 bagels with veg. Cream cheese.... holy crap-balls, I'm speachless.***** read more

Every time I go into this place (never again) they don't have Everything bagels. Ridiculous. I always say something and they say "They're popular" - no kidding, MAKE MORE. Who's running this place. Very poor planning. Like I said, it's all the time. This is like an ice cream store not having vanilla. Now both women who make your sandwiches are standing in front of store smoking. Disgusting. I left and won't be back. read more

This is our go-to bagel place. Egg sandwiches, soft fresh bagels...new owners are very nice. Good specials.

This is my go to spot when I'm craving a bagel - they are soft, delicious, and fresh! The place is absolutely packed on Saturdays and Sunday's so expect to wait to order. Their homemade cream cheeses are all very good and I ALWAYS get the jalapeño but also highly recommend the cannoli! They have seating as well inside and outside in the summer, a perfect spot for breakfast! read more

The year is 2008. You wake up and peer over to your BlackBerry, 10 notifications. The boys are hungry, and for more then just breakfast. Hop in the shower, pondering over your life's work and what has led up to this very moment... "Focus" you tell yourself, as you dry off and get dressed. No time for coffee and no need for it either. Adrenal glands start to swell as you put your keys into the ignition. As your car starts, the vibrations from the car send a sensation down your spine similar to Bradley Cooper taking NZT-48 in limitless. Living life a quarter mile at a time, you inch closer to your goal...the pot at the end of the rainbow, everything else is just a blur. You pull into the parking lot, browse around your surrounding and spot the parking spot of your dreams right in front of your destination, it was fate...fate of the gods. You spot your friends, who are waiting in their cars and appear to be sweating uncontrollably. Everyone nods and walks out of their cars together in perfect synchronization. You open the door first, after all...why shouldn't you? It was your idea. You reach over immediately and grab the Shoreham Daily Journal... "my precious" you whisper under your breath. You head to the fridge and open the sliding glass door. If it wasn't for the cold air hitting you, you might have fainted. "Pull it together" you tell yourself, one last time. As you wait in line, you see what you came for...in the back behind the counter. The oasis of bacon and fresh bagels would be enough for some, but you realize that your very fears and dreams have been realized all at once. She is there, she is working. As if the the mounting pressure wasn't enough, you start to realize that she might be the one to take your order. Minutes turn into seconds, as you step up to the counter, sheer panic sets in as you are next in line and you are about to order. She walks up to you, looks you right in the eye asks you for your order.....and you finally realize this is it. 3 years later you wake up at Stony Brook hospital. The doctor wakes you up with both a happy and stunned expression on his face. The doctor tells you you have been in a coma for over 3 years. I would highly recommend this place to anyone. read more

Today I went to bagel lady and ordered a bagel with very little cream cheese and ONE slice of lox. I also got a bottle of diet Sprite and a bag of popcorn. The price was $21! When I inquired she said it was because of the price of the lox. I told her I only asked for one slice of lox and how much does it cost? She said $24 a pound. She told me the bagel would be $3.50 without the lox and it was eight dollars with the lox. I told her it was not right that I was paying $4.50 for one slice of lox. She said oh well several times. She did not even try to rectify the situation. I should've asked for a manager. I have preferred this sandwich in many different bagel stores exactly this way and never paid anywhere near that much! When I did leave and eat my bagel the lox was all dry at the edges and old. Also did not have even a napkin in my bag! I will not return to this bagel store. It was never very good to begin with. The bagels are only ok and they had only one type of chips to choose from. read more

I've been going to the Bagel Lady Cafe since I was a kid. They have the softest bagels around. There's more on the menu than bagels and whatever you select is sure to be fresh and made while you wait. I highly recommend their bagels. The staff is always friendly and accommodating. read more

The bagels are awesome. But the service is by far the worst. Never have I ever seen staff move so slow and ass backwards. Literally nobody EVER on the register. Whoever takes your order makes it (slow) then slowly walks to register to ring you up. While 5 people build up around the register the line grows. No prioritization, I have literally seen people make coffee while the line is out the door. Call in your order! You will STILL wait a very long time as you can see your sandwich sitting. Can't blame the staff, they are severely understaffed. read more

Bagel Lady Cafe 7+ Bagel Lady Cafe 3.6 25 reviews Bagel Shop OVERVIEWREVIEWS 1 of 2 CALL DIRECTIONS SAVE Describe this place Choose descriptions of its features & vibe 99 NY-25A #18, Shoreham, NY 11786 (631) 744-0071 Suggest an edit Own this business? Add business hours Add website From the menu Add food photos View all Questions & answers Be the first to ask a question Reviews from the web Facebook 3.9/5 16 votes Yellow Pages 5/5 1 review Foursquare 6.2/10 12 votes Street View7+ Photos Add a photo Map of Bagel Lady Cafemap expand icon Review summary 5 4 3 2 1 3.6 25 reviews "Decent options for sandwiches, bagels and salads." "Very nice place to go for breakfast." "All in all - would recommend this eatery as a go-to for local WR bagel lovers :)" More Google reviews Rate and review People also search forVIEW ALL Mt Sinai Bagel Cafe 4.4 (16) Bagel Shop Bean and Bagel Cafe 4.3 (67) Bagel Shop Bagel Cafe 4.1 (19) Bagel Shop Bagels Your Way Cafe 3.6 (34) Cafe Moriches Bagel Deli Inc 3.5 (27) Bagel Shop View all Web results Bagel Lady Cafe - Home | Facebook https://www.facebook.com ' Bagel-Lady... Bagel Lady Cafe, Shoreham, NY. 350 likes · 213 were here. Coffee Shop. Bagel Lady Cafe - 10 Reviews - Bagels - 99 Route 25A, Shoreham ... https://www.yelp.com ' biz ' bagel-lady-... (631) 744-0071 · 99 Route 25A Shoreham, NY 11786. Bagel Lady Cafe, Shoreham - Restaurant Reviews, Phone ... https://www.tripadvisor.com ' Restaurant... Bagel Lady Cafe, Shoreham: See 22 unbiased reviews of Bagel Lady Cafe, rated 4 ... 99 Route 25a Ste 18, Shoreham, NY 11786 -1844. 2 of 2 Reviews from the web Facebook 3.9/5 16 votes Yellow Pages 5/5 1 review Foursquare 6.2/10 12 votes Google review summary 5 4 3 2 1 3.6 25 reviews "Decent options for sandwiches, bagels and salads." "Very nice place to go for breakfast." "All in all - would recommend this eatery as a go-to for local WR bagel lovers :)" Rate and review on Google Google reviews Most helpful John Calabrese John Calabrese 3 reviews in the last week This is my favorite bagel place in the area. Their French toast bagels are wonderful. Except they usually run out within a couple hours of opening and they are often small and don't let them rise enough (believe it's called proofing). That's why I only gave 4 stars. Great flavored cream cheeses also. Never ordered any real food from here so I can't comment. Although I do get a sausage, egg, and cheese on roll from time to time which is also very good, if a little overpriced. All in all a 4 star place like I said. Very good but not the best on long island (which it would have to be to earn 5 stars from me). Also on a side note bagels are only $8.50 A dozen Mon, Tues and I think Wed. Otherwise they are $12 read more

the service here is really bad. workers always seem pissed off. i had a girl asked me if i was being help i said "no". she said she would be right with me than never came back. ive never seen people move so slow before in my life. if the world was ending they would all be dead from moving like snails. read more

The new owner needs to smile and say hello... and make sure there is coffee in the self-serve coffee pots...

This place has good bagels . But they take forever to ask you for your order and also make your order . I dread going here but it's the closest bagel place. Their prices are super high. Lower your prices and get more/better staff and this place would be fine . Bagel with veg cream cheese = 4.25$ read more

Love this place. They have great bagels and food plus the people who work there are super nice. It's my new go to place.

This has now been my 4th stop to this bagel shop as it is conveniently located on my way to work. I can safely say that they have the best chicken salad in the area (waldorf chicken salad) and their bagels are really tasty. Will definitely be changing this to one of my routine stops. Staff is pleasant, food is good, and decently priced, can't ask for much more then that. read more

We ordered a grilled chicken and fresh mozzarella party bagel. It had little thin slices of grilled chicken dried out I may add and a thin Deli slice of mozzarella cheese and a roasted pepper now and then. It was almost all bread. It was $60 just for the sandwich and had less than a pound of meat and cheese on it. Don't order that at this bagel store. Like other reviewer said I believe the only reason they stay in business is because they are the only bagel place locally. read more

First time going here and I will never go again. Walked in nobody came to help me until I went to them. There was 4 people waiting. It took so long for someone to take our order the person in front me ended up leaving. I called my order in and they still got it wrong and didn't toast the bagels or give extra like I asked. Don't come here if u wanna be there for an hour. read more

Very good service, Muffins very good, bagels are not real bagels. has had Keto Muffins (small) need to offer more KETO. https://simplysweetketo.com/shop-1?olsPage=products. Leo Gong Let's clear something up right away: New York City isn't the only place in the world to get decent, authentic bagels. The truth is, you can make bagels that are just as good at home, no matter where you live. They're one of the simplest breads to make, requiring only flour, water, salt, yeast, and malt--and one secret ingredient: time (in the form of long, slow, cold fermentation). Any decent bagel shop knows this and uses an overnight method to stretch out the fermentation process, releasing all sorts of subtle flavors trapped in the flour. While bagel shops often use a type of high-protein flour not available to home cooks to achieve that distinctively chewy texture, regular, unbleached bread flour can also do the trick. The real key is to use a much lower percentage of water than is used for baguettes and other European hearth breads, producing a stiff dough that can stand up to a dunking in boiling water before going into the oven. More than any ingredient or other aspect of the method, this boiling step is what defines the uniqueness of the bagel. That said, bagels do usually feature one other distinctive ingredient: barley malt. While this may seem like an exotic, hard-to-find product, it's actually commonly available at most supermarkets, usually labeled "barley malt syrup." If you can't find it, simply substitute an equal amount of honey. Your bagels might not have that malty flavor, but they'll still be better than almost any bagel you can buy. One final note: If you like bagels but don't want to set up the boiling operation for just six of them, feel free to double the size of the batch and bake enough to freeze for future use. read more

Love this bagel store!! This is the best bagel place in a 10 mile radius...the bagels are always fresh and a lot of times you can get a hot freshy:) they have a beautiful salad bar where you can customize a salad and get it chopped if you'd like. They always have specials-try the honey mustard turkey salad if you see it although it sells out quick! Lots of locals-a sign it's consistently good:) it's hard for me to pass this place and not stop!! read more

This morning I stopped in at the Bagel Lady Cafe on my way home from my dental cleaning and I ordered the best tasting BLT! I appreciated the pleasant service from everyone,especially the owners. read more

Best Bagels around here. My daughter(a foodie, although very fit) who lives in " THE CITY" says these are her favorite. High praise indeed. Try their muffins ,too. read more

Not the worst but also not the best bagels out there. They are local so you really have no choice unless you want to drive. Sandwiches are hit and miss, sometimes they are great other times super watery and under cooked. The biggest issue is the service. Always slow, many times everyone ends up sitting in the back by the grille cooking meals instead of one person cooking and the other people just taking orders and handling bagel only orders. Annoying when all you want is a bagel and everyone is tied up cooking hot meals. read more

This places excels at one thing - finding the slowest people possible to work there. Every time I go customers just get tired of waiting on line and just leave. I absolutely hate coming here. The line isnt even long...the staff all just move like they have hundred pound weights on each ankle. read more

What a fail! The man helping us could hardly do his job. While our order for 4 types Bagels was not challenging, considering there was not a single thing to be done to them other than stuff them in a bag, was still messed up in the end. He kept telling us he didn't have any of what we wanted mean while the lady helping the customers next to us was telling him they were fresh in the back. It was very frustrating. A French toast, whole wheat, and 2 egg everything bagels was some how given to us as 4 everything bagels. And he charged us $10 to boot. Bye. read more

This little shop does pretty well considering it is the only bagel store in town. This is the place you go when you cut school, come home from college, need a quick but great breakfast/lunch or need to cater a lunch for your office. Passing by for lunch?- call up and place an order that way its ready for when you swing by. It'll always be bagged and ready for your arrival. Not a large amount of seating however I highly suggest this bagel/deli store. read more

4 stars is for the Harvest Salad (mixed greens, green apple, cranberries, goat and Sunset panini (turkey, meunster, honey mustard). 2 stars for the service. It's just really slow. Like more than normal. If that's not an issue, then it's great for option for lunch. odly enough, never get bagels here. This salad and panini are so good though. They have a honey walnut dressing they make special in house, and it is the BEST salad dressing ever. 5 stars for the dressing. read more

if ya like rude service and over priced food, this is the place to go! Also the lay out of the place is counter productive....people aren't sure where a line should start to place an order, they make it perfectly clear where to pay~having a tip jar for their crappy service ~ well, needless to say! read more

What a disappointment! Called in a chopped salad order for lunch and was hung up on before I could give my name. Picked up the salad which wasn't chopped and looked like it had been thrown together and was so small it took three bites to eat. Really??? read more

Friendly but slow service, bagels and salads are delicious.