My online order was completely messed up. They gave the nerve to charge so much for each extra topping on the bagel, but not add it to the bagel! Not even toasted like was requested...can't believe they ruined my special breakfast with my family for me and my husband. Never ordering from them again read more

Bagels Your Way Cafe - Where's the bacon and tomato??? Why not toasted??? - Bagels Near Me - Middle Island, New York

Stopped by and had an excellent ham cheese and egg bagel! The service was excellent! Warm, friendly, and very helpful. The Bagel had just come out of the oven when I arrived and was delicious! I also had some of their lemonade which was good. I would love to return! read more

Staff and food/along w specials - make this place ONE OF MY GO~to's in the area. I just had breakfast here - it could not of been better and priced well. EVERYTHING WAS GREAT. So nice and so yummy. Breakfast platter was fire. read more

I fell in love with the bagels; personally got garlic not toasted for first time with plain cream cheese. Im very pleased it was like a fluffy cloud inside, haven't experienced that until now. Everyone working there is very helpful and kind. Place itself is clean and peaceful, smells delicious as well! Love the colorful menu board read more

Bagels Your Way Cafe - a half eaten bagel - Bagels Near Me - Middle Island, New York

Although the bagels at this store are fantastic. The clerk behind the counter is quite unconcerned about hygiene. He kept the same gloves on preparing my order after touching money and other items (register). People watch what other people do especially when someone is preparing their food. I will go there again and correct the clerk next time this happens read more

The cream cheese here was grainy, dried out, and spoiled today. It was a shame because the bagel would have been really good. I will just get my bagels from here with nothing on them from now on and make them at home. read more

the food is good the prices not so much. I've been going here for years but no long can justify paying the amount the charge for a bagel.

Bagels your way is the right way to go!!!' Being a UPSer we surely burn a lot of energy and the appetite for tasty nutrition is a necessity to fuel the body..... Susie provided exceptional service* the cook provided hot made to order breakfast sandwiches * and Bagels your Way provided quality grade A Eggs/Meats & Bagels The overall experience of staff attentiveness was great The women on that day were all friendly and concerned for my order being taken LOVE THAT!!!!! IN & OUT -----ORDER UP A synchronized order of ONE HIGHLY SATISFIED UPS worker ready to continue my work day fueled on QUALITY EATS!!!!! It also helped that this place was SO CLEAN BEAUTIFULLY DECORATED & CASED WITH ATTRACTIVENESS TOPPING IT OFF WITH NEIGHBORHOOD FRIENDLY !!!!!! read more

See all

Great food and the service is impeccable. Make sure to get Jaime she is super friendly and fast! Definitely recommend this place!

This flagship Bagels your way Cafe is as equally as bomb as the Medford location. Another Strip Mall location as well. This spot has a magical bacon tomato cream cheese spread that isn't to be slept on. Bagels flavors are robust and the texture has the spot on chewiness.The crew serves 'em up in a fast & furious fashion. read more

Bagels Your Way Cafe - from the parking lot. - Bagels Near Me - Middle Island, New York

Cleanliness Bagels customer service price highly recommend! My daughter loves this place( she's very picky) and they have a sense of urgency which def helps if your on the move early morning! read more

Great place, only bagel shop I'll give business to in a 10mile radius !!! The bagels are always fresh or at least semi fresh , never hard! Always fluffy and soft , yes I used those adjectives for a bagel! Today's visit one of the best time even though someone took the last of the bacon & egg bagels in front of me but the blonde woman offered if I wait about 15mins I could have a fresh batch but couldn't wait around.. But because the one woman noticed me running outside to tell my gf about no more bacon & egg bagels and changing our list of bagels wanted when I decided to just get a half dozen she threw a few extras in since she noticed me running back and forth also they offer any 1/2 pound cream cheese & half dozen with an extra bagel for $8.99 That's 7bagels & 1/2 pound of cream cheese of your choice for $8.99! read more

Bagels Your Way Cafe - Always a good sign when there's a line up out to the door ( this is a Friday morning around 10:30am) - Bagels Near Me - Middle Island, New York

This place is always packed. I don't get it. The bagels aren't that good. The food is ok. It is conveniently located but that's it. I do go there in a pinch and I am always disappointed. I just don't understand the amount of people that actually go here and why there is always a line to order. read more

Went there this morning for some bagel & egg sandwiches, and ended up walking out with those, along with a dozen & some cream cheese. The people behind the counter are quite friendly, and move quickly and efficiently. The value is good too - a request for a dozen bagels ends up a lot of 16. The house made flavored cream cheeses are good too. I was disappointed in that there was no "tomato bacon" as described in another review - I was kinda looking forward to that :) There WAS a bacon & herb, which is tasty though. The bagels are plump and chewy - but clearly aren't "true" bagels. They don't have that crunchy smooth "shell" that comes from boiling them first, before baking. But the chewy, satisfying consistency is good, and makes for an enjoyable experience. Since they're close to home, I really don't see any reason to look elsewhere for my weekend fix - I was quite pleased. Might even go back and try them for lunch sometime :) read more

I tried the plain, the everything and the cinnamon raisin bagels. I will go over each, The plain: It was a decent size, the outside was crunchy but not the good crunchy if you know what I mean. The outside actually flaked all over my car seat. I never had bagel flake. The looks of it was unappetizing. It had small bubbles all over the top, maybe from the baking process, Im not sure but I never seen it to this extent. The inside was good though. I just did not like the mess. Overall taste was ok obviously the outside was overcooked and that brought down the overall taste. What I didnt understand is, if they overcooked it why didnt they toss them into the donation pile instead of selling it. (I only hope they donate and not just toss out). Why sell a bagel of bad quality when they can sell ones of good quality? Only assuming that they dont always overcook it. The everything: The coating over everything on the top was sparse. The taste lacked as well. the cinnamon raisin: This lacked taste as well. They just dont put enough cinnamon or raisins to actually be able to taste it. Okay good points: Wed they have a special. One dozen bagels for $8.99. And a dozen means a dozen here, they do not throw in a few extra at this place... I wont be coming back. I could get a bagel like this anywhere in the country. Oh tip for ya, the parking is horrible here. If you park in front of the stores backing out is a pain since you will be backing up straight into the busy street. I advise you to park on the side of the building where it is safer. read more

The bagels are always super fresh and very flavorful! There is always a long line but that's because the food is so good! The only con is one of the employees is either always high or is just an air head! She barley put any butter on my bagel and didn't toast it enough. She was very slow and asked me the same question like 6 times! Other than that one experience today, I have not had any problems with this place! read more

Bagels Your Way Cafe - a woman walking past a window - Bagels Near Me - Middle Island, New York

See all

They always look lost. Like they don't know what the hell is going on. Very disorganized. A guy after me ordered a bacon egg and cheese and his was done long before me. Never have I waited 20 minutes for a bagel w cream cheese. Never again! read more

Went back home for X-mas only to relive the bagel magic of this place, and yeah, it's still awesome.

I don't joke about my mornings.. So when I pick my breakfast/coffee spot, I mean business! This bagel place has perfected the art of my simple but favorite start to any day... Cinnamom raisin bagel... Toasted lightly... With butter... And a large coffee. The bagels are to die for. From time to time I spice it up and try their different cream cheeses (which are all excellent), and the service is ALWAYS accompanied by a smile.This place is the definition of dependable... You MUST try it ! read more

Decent bagel place but looooong lines on the weekends.

I had a cinnamon raisin bagel, which was delicious. My boyfriend had an everything bagel, and my son had a plain bagel. They seemed to enjoy their bagels, as well. My favorite drink is hand squeezed lemonade, and I was excited when I saw that this was offered here. However, I was very disappointed upon tasting. The lemonade tasted like sugar water syrup with a slice of lemon in it. I threw it away, and I'm still a little confused as to why they asked me if I was sure that I didn't want any "flavoring" in my lemonade. Go get the bagels, just get something other than lemonade to drink! read more

Good bagel store to stop by in the morning. I recommend the french toast bagel

Awful rude staff. Nobody wants to be there it's written all over their face. My food was messed up twice. There's an older lady who was talking crap about me by the grill thinking i wasn't going to hear here. Will never be back, and neither will my friends. read more

well,my rule is 3 strikes and you're out!! went there 3 weeks in a row.each time i had issues.their website says best bacon,egg and cheese on long island.actually,it was delicious.however,the website states its $5.46 plus tax.i was charged $6.92 in total.on the next visit,they messed up my order.on the third and final visit,i was again overcharged plus they said it comes with coffee or oj.their website says coffee and oj.also,the first time it came with both.on top of that,it was a greasy mess.by the way,the bagels are okay at best.they are not baked.if you want an old-fashioned brooklyn style bagel,go to bagels 101 right down the road!! read more

If this is the shop across from the fire house, eff them since they changed management.I stood in line just now and watched people with no clue tun around like chickens with their heads off. THEN when it was my turn, I got skipped as one of their friends or whatever walked in to the head of the line and got helped. Nope. Never again here. read more

Went there once- horrible customer service. The clerk never even looked at us as we ordered until we left, too busy talking to co workers. Never again! read more

This place is right near my home and I go pretty frequently. The bagels are as good as any on long island, always fresh. The breakfast sandwiches on a bagel are my favorite though. Highly recommended. read more

i encourage you to watch if they change their gloves while handling food and money. they touch someone else's money then go and make my bagel. also they are almost always empty of bagels at 12:30. read more