Maggie's would fit right in on the beach in Brighton as a seaside eatery. It is bright, airy, cheery, and colorful. It is a very welcoming environment. The epoxy counter is a comic book lover's delight from which to order. My wife and I entered for an early dinner. We walked up to the counter and ordered our entrees. I had the fish and chips, my wife ordered a burger. Not being beer conoscenti, we left the choice to the waiter/chef. Within fifteen minutes our orders were ready. The cod and French fries I ordered were delicious! My wife also found her entree excellent. The beer was cold, dark gold, and tasty. The portion to price aspect was a bit lacking: the entree could have contained a fourth piece of cod instead of three. The Takeaway: 1. Excellent food 2. Pricy 3. Great beach vibes for ambiance 4. Good beer 5. Excellent parking 6. No reservations needed I would have given four and a half stars if the program permitted. read more

See all

We decided last minute to do lunch and I remembered someone talking about this place. It was our first time here. It's adorable. Small but spacious and bright and cheerful vibe. We were greeted upon arrival. I had the chopped cheese with fries and it was SO GOOD. My husband had the double cheeseburger with bacon and he's a burger snob and loved it! We will definitely be back! read more

See all

We stopped by for dine in at Maggie's Eatery on a Wednesday. The place has a lively decor with a beachy vibe. We had Ahi tuna toast. Super fresh with avocado and radishes. The salmon burger was delicious. I order the chicken Milanese. My favorite dish, with an arugula salad and shaved parmesan. Summer on a plate. Husband had the lobster roll with fries. So good! We all shared a chocolate cheesecake and a mini blueberry cream pie. All made in house. Service was fast and attentive. Fantastic option in the area. Can't wait to go back. read more

Food was a decent meal. I wouldn't go out of my way but for lunch while we were out it was fine.

First of all, the guy who answers the phone is so.... Friggen nice! I mean right outta the gate ya like the place because he's friendly. Then the food? Delish is what I'm sayin'. My husband had the salmon and I had a Greek salad with grilled steak on top. According to hubby, and the lack of evidence he left on his plate, he loved it! My salad was generous and fresh. The Greek dressing was perfect and the steak was tender and flavorful. What more can I say! Cost is about average for the area. Overall a hit! read more

Steak sandwich was delightful. Friendly staff. Wish you guys had a closer location. But still worth the hour drive. GET THERE! read more

So I been wanting to come here for a while & I'm so glad we did!! We really enjoyed our meal. It's located at the end in a large shopping center with plenty of parking. The food tasted fresh & was really delicious!! The fries were not hand cut but they were really good too! The portions more than ample. Overall I would say It's an above average luncheonette with elevated food in a relaxed atmosphere. It's definitely on my go back list. Fun Tip: They serve beer on tap. read more

After Yelp sent me an advisory that this food place was racking up 5 stars in my neighborhood, I had to check it out and ordered a lunch. So this is just a take out joint, however it's chef owner has placed emphasis on simple dishes and good food. Bravo on both accounts. The Buratta and arugula with prosciutto sandwich was fresh and delicious. Prepared well equally,was the crispy chicken sandwich with pickled vegetables. Congrats to the chef / owner. A much needed food place in the culinary deprived area in Suffolk county. read more

The food here was absolutely amazing! I got the Fish N Chips and the person I was with got the hot lobster roll. It's obvious that everything was made with patience and care. The place is decorated really nice and has an old school vibe with some modern flare. Food was flavorful and I will definitely be coming back! read more

Maggie’s Eatery And Take Away - Fish N Chips - New American Near Me - Miller Place, New York

Went for a walk at Cortwood Landing County Park and was looking for a place to eat when we were done. So glad I saw all the good reviews here and wanted to add my own. Everything we ordered from start to finish was fresh and yummy. You can tell everyone that works there puts their hearts into the dishes. My husband & I were talking on the way home trying to decide what our favorite flavor was and we couldn't decide. All great quality and delicious food. For reference we ordered the chips and guac, leek soup, chili, & grilled cheese combo and a salmon poke bowl. read more

Food was fresh, and delicious. Service was also very good. Don't be fooled by the fact that it's in a shopping center and not fancy. Maggie is the owners grandmother, sweet. read more

OMG!!!! Such fresh food! And a great atmosphere. Wife and I enjoyed the Fish Tacos and the Guacamole Nachos. Family owned and the service shows it. We will definitely be back to check out the rest of the menu! Best of luck on your new place! read more

Absolutely love the food here! Wether you get the shrimp tacos and the steak salad or the time poke bowl, everything is made fresh to order and tastes amazing! read more

Food was great and they made it soo quickly! I'm so happy I found a good new spot close by!

This is an absolutely fantastic, delicious addition to the food options in Miller Place. I highly recommend this restaurant. The owner is a chef. His passion for delicious food shows in his dishes. My wife and I also had the nachos appetizer which was delicious. We will be back again and again. read more

Maggie’s Eatery And Take Away - Maggies cheese burger - New American Near Me - Miller Place, New York

See all

The food is amazing and never misses. The chef and front of the house have amazing service. The ambiance is nice and chill. We go in and take it home to eat it. It's a nourishing and tasty meal every time! read more

Great food to eat in or take out!! Loved the steak sandwich and avocado toast!! Will be back!

I absolutely love this place. We've been about four or five times. The nachos are one of the best things I've ever had. So far I have tried the salmon bowl, the Portabella sandwich and a salad and my husband has tried the steak sandwich, fish tacos, and more. It's one of the best places in the area. The chef is amazing. read more

I enjoyed the vegetable bowl with sushi rice, avocado , chick peas, tomato & cilantro. My husband order a grilled cheese & fries and we ordered avocado toast . All ingredients were fresh and delish! Cant wait to return and order the steak salad ! read more

Maggie’s Eatery And Take Away - Vegetable bowl with sushi rice , etc. - New American Near Me - Miller Place, New York

Yum! Super fun menu of super fresh perfectly seasoned options. We had the hummus and pita appetizer. We could taste all the very fresh ingredients. Absolutely delicious. My husband had the hot buttered lobster roll, huge chunks of loot buttered lobster on a toasted bun. How can you go wrong!?! I had the fired chicken bowl, absolutely delicious. We had the churros dessert and the cheesecake both we're prepared beautifully and delicious! Epic new restaurant. read more

I got the capri sandwich, fast service and so hospitality from the staff was so nice. A small cozy environment casual dinning

Delicious. Food fresh. Gluten free options available. Staff really nice. Cute atmosphere. Worth a visit. Yummy. read more

Love this place. Fish dishes are my favorite!! The chef/owner is often there so is frequently the person cooking tasty homemade meals.

Amazing ! So glad to have this place in our town. The food was so good. The chef / owner is very nice and you can tell they actually care about the food they are serving. This is so rare these days. I will definitely be back. read more

I stopped in for a quick bite and found this place clean and accommodating . They substituted freshly made tortilla chips as a gluten free option with my salad. Very helpful and delicious!! read more

Food is amazing best shrimp tacos and chicken bahn mi. Great for lunch owner is so nice and accommodating.

Amazing food!! Best tuna bowl I've ever had!!! Definitely recommend!!!!!!!!!!!!

Stopped in for lunch today, everything was amazing! Best crème brûlée I've ever had! Stopped in for lunch today, everything was amazing! Best crème brûlée I've ever had! read more

Amazing, fresh food. Very nice staff. Seems ultra clean. This area needed a spot like this so so so badly. I am happy to come here to support them. read more

I'm so happy to have this place in our area. best food around. Fresh and delicious, a cut above anything else in the area.

Good food. Nice people. What more do you need. Had shrimp tacos that were great. They were very good to the wife and I. Very accommodating. The wife loved her tacos. Definitely will return. read more

Good food - would like to see more chicken dishes available to take out...fish was great and have been there 3x already... no problems

Great arugala, sweet corn, and tortilla salad special (sweet and salty) to go. I added the steak, which added in the hefty cost. I asked the associate to switch the salad dressing from Chipotle, and he insisted that the Chipotle paired the best, and I'm glad I did not switch. I was looking for more when done. read more

I chose Maggie's Eatery because it was conveniently located and the reviews were all good. I couldn't have made a better decision! I ordered the tuna poke bowl which was fresh and delicious with plenty of tuna. My dinner partner had the BBQ chicken bowl and said it was the best barbecue sauce she had ever tasted. Casual dining with super friendly staff. I will be back to try more delicious foods. Highly recommend! read more

Awesome food, small personalized eatery. Order at the counter and they bring your food over. Pretty fast yet extremely good. I had the chicken po-boy and the fish n chips so far and I do believe this is my new favorite place to eat! read more

OBSESSED! This place was so cute! I'm so glad my husband and I came here for lunch today. The food was amazing, and the staff so cute love them! We throughly enjoyed the chicken pot stickers for an app perfect sauces and crunch! My husband is a obsessed with fish tacos and rates them everywhere he goes, he got the ahi tuna tacos, they were so refreshing and flavorful he said it's probably the best fish taco he's ever had! I had the fluke tacos, also one of the best tacos I've ever had! We also ended up enjoying a piece of coconut cake which was amazing! Please don't hesitate to stop here, it's truly a gem and a must go! read more

What a great meal! Everything was cooked perfectly and the flavors were great. Highly recommend the Lobster roll and fluke gyro.

New Spot, did not disappoint! Laid back very casual, more of a take away spot but they do have limited seating for those that want to sit and eat. Food was made fresh to order, mixed offerings; steak, chicken, seafood. Lettuce wrap tacos and the loaded chicken nachos are where it is at. Give it a try, you will be back. read more

very good food very good value pleasant owners and wonderful staff. Will definitely be back

Just wanted to give a shout out to Maggies Eatery in Miller Place! Tyler greeted us who was super friendly! The space was vibrant as well as the items on the menu! I had the lobster tacos, let me tell you, they were TWO HUGE tacos, super fresh and delicious. My hubby got the steak sandwich and it had a ton of flavor to it! The french fries were crispy and salty and our 16 month old couldn't stop stealing them off my husbands plate . Make sure to check them out and support local, everyone! read more