Cancel

    Open app

    Search

    Bagel Shack

    4.0 (1 review)

    Order Bagel Shack Takeout or Delivery

    Bagel Shack Photos

    You might also consider

    Recommended Reviews - Bagel Shack

    Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
    Yelp app icon
    Browse more easily on the app
    Review Feed Illustration

    2 years ago

    Helpful 3
    Thanks 1
    Love this 1
    Oh no 0

    You might also consider

    Surfside Coffee House - Menu

    Surfside Coffee House

    3.7(37 reviews)
    0.2 mi
    $

    Whenever I visit the tri-state area, I naturally crave pizza and bagels -- no doubt they're the…read morebest here. However, I've developed gluten intolerance and it's hard to find places that offer options that accommodate celiac and gluten sensitive folks. I found that Surfside offered gluten free bagels and wanted to give a pork roll, egg, and cheese with salt, pepper, and ketchup. I was worried they wouldn't have any since I came late into off-season, but luckily they had plain and everything as bagel options. We took two orders of PREC w/ SPK - one on a GF everything bagel, one on a GF plain bagel. The GF bagels tasted almost like sandwich buns, but overall the breakfast bagel hit the spot without causing any terrible reactions. The everything bagel's seasoning definitely made it more subtle of the fact that it was gluten free. There's no seating at this place so it's more grab and go. They also offer coffee but I didn't opt for any. What's nice about the inside are the cool gift items they offer as well as the literal surf shop ambiance -- felt almost as if you were inside a shop in Hawaii. Price is premium in general on the island. There was a $4 upcharge for gluten free bagels so altogether we paid an extra $8. Total was around $25, but again during off season, we feel for the business as things start to slow down. Happy to support island businesses as long as the service is friendly and the food is great! Will give Surfside another chance next summer!

    Great coffee, pastries, and sandwiches! Awesome service! The women behind the counter was friendly…read moreand gave tons of recommendations for activities and must-stop places along the island. Will definitely be stopping here again!

    Photos
    Surfside Coffee House - Stickers and gluten free options in the back

    Stickers and gluten free options in the back

    Surfside Coffee House - Drinks menu

    Drinks menu

    Surfside Coffee House - Gift shop mugs

    See all

    Gift shop mugs

    The Local Market & Kitchen - Chicken vodka parm

    The Local Market & Kitchen

    4.0(262 reviews)
    1.1 mi
    $$

    On Long Beach Island, a trendy spot for coffees, pop tarts - their specialty, sandwiches and hot…read moremeal items. The Pecan Squares are gooey and yummy crunch. The Cinnamon Pop Tart was sweet and gorgeously delicious.

    I really love this little market on Long Beach Island for what it has to offer. It's super cute,…read morenestled right as you come onto the island, and has a cozy coffee shop with lots of homemade pastries (the homemade Pop-Tarts and cinnamon buns are a must-try!). They also have a small grocery section with organic and higher-end items, fresh salads made in-house, a deli, and even a grill. I came here this morning and ordered a cheesesteak with fries. The portion of fries was huge--honestly enough to feed a family of four. I was glad I had someone to share with, but keep that in mind if you order. The cheesesteak itself was just okay. The bread was good, but overall it lacked flavor. Personally, I wouldn't come back here for a cheesesteak, especially since there's another spot on the island that does them really well for half the price. I also grabbed a cold-pressed juice from the fridge. None of the drinks are marked with prices, so I didn't find out until the register that it was $7. A bit of sticker shock considering you could find something similar at a grocery store for about half that. That said, I'd absolutely come back for their coffee and pastries. They're delicious and feel special. I may just skip the deli/grill next time.

    Photos
    The Local Market & Kitchen - Deli and little market space

    Deli and little market space

    The Local Market & Kitchen - French ham baguette

    French ham baguette

    The Local Market & Kitchen - Lattes

    See all

    Lattes

    Bagel Shack - bagels - Updated May 2026

    Loading...
    Loading...
    Loading...