5+++++ Star Review for The Lighthouse, Surf City, NJ Absolutely loved LOVED our visit to The Lighthouse in Surf City! Everything was on point from start to finish. We had the wings, fish tacos, and a chicken sandwich -- and each dish was better than the last. The wings were perfectly cooked and full of flavor, the fish tacos were fresh and had just the right amount of kick, and the chicken sandwich was juicy and satisfying. The vibe of the place was beachy, welcoming, and laid-back -- just what you want at the Shore. Service was fast and friendly, food came out hot, and everything tasted made with care. Definitely a hidden gem and worth every star. We'll be back for sure! read more

See all

Lighthouse deli is an OG In LBI. I have been eating bagels here since birf foo then I found the sandwiches and I ate lighthouse deli. read more

Lighthouse Restaurant & Grill - Gershwin - Bagels Near Me - Surf City, New Jersey

The food service and location are exceptional. I love this place for breakfast. The people are always so friendly and the bagels are fresh omelettes are delicious. You actually can't go wrong... The best tuna fish ever. read more

Lighthouse Restaurant & Grill - Another incredible meal at the lighthouse. - Bagels Near Me - Surf City, New Jersey

Best deli sandwiches in the area. Whether you the business on the island or in Manahawkin.

We had a lunch (sandwiches) here last year that was excellent - we took it to go since our rental is just across the street. YESTERDAY, my son and I wandered in from the beach and wanted to split a sandwich so we stopped in again and ordered an Italian sub with the works (you have to ask for mayo), some cole slaw and a piece of crumb cake. Sandwich was excellent, cole slaw needed a touch of salt, and the crumb cake was outstanding. While in the shop I wandered over to the spot where they keep the bagels and asked if they made them on site and the young lady responded...yes, we make them fresh every day. So TODAY, I walked over and got half a dozen bagels (two everything, one sesame, one blueberry, one French toast and one habanero cheddar). Weave been getting our bagels from a place up the street FOR YEARS and I will never go back because the Lighthouse Deli has the best bagels on the Island. $10 for a half dozen and they are as good as, or better than, our go-to place back home. I must admit, they get a little backed up at lunchtime (might be a loss of help since we're here in mid August), but it's worth it. You can eat-in or take out, the place is really clean and friendly, and the staff are always friendly and helpful. Seriously, best bagels on the island read more

Fantastic breakfast! Huge fresh bagel selection. They say they have the best bagels on the island...and they're right!! Quick and friendly service. We can't wait to go back to try more of the bagels or some of the lunch items. read more

See all

The food was absolutely disappointing: sad previously frozen McDonald like hashbrowns, omelet was so so, coffee was pretty bad even though they kind of alluded to express li drinks and varieties of coffee drinks. The one bright light was the outstanding waitress who was constantly friendly and checking on us and helped us. read more

We picked up a last-minute sandwich platter and some cole slaw for unexpected guests, and everything was delicious. I thought there would be leftovers, but ... only a wedge or two for the next day. . Thanks to Lighthouse for making it easy to entertain at the last minute,. We will call on you again, I am sure. read more

Great bagel options that taste great! Garlic herb cream cheese on jalapeno cheddar bagel is delish! Very friendly service! read more

Year 2 for the surf city location and they're going to be top dogs when you make a left over that bridge. 30 different style bagels , the subs were tremendous looking on seeded sub rolls. Bigger version of their Manahawkin location with both indoor and outdoor seats to chill a bit before getting back on the beach. Nicest people operate this establishment and don't think cuz it's called a deli it doesn't have the best bagels on both the island and the mainland. read more

Lighthouse Restaurant & Grill - Pork roll and egg on an everything SPK. Didn't need to order double meat. They come stacked. - Bagels Near Me - Surf City, New Jersey

Just had an event catered by Lighthouse Grill. The wings and sandwiches were outstanding, best wings on LBI. Moreover, the staff could not have been more professional or accommodating. read more

Sadly since the change to a full sit down their hoagies are just lacking, less meat than used to be ... used to be my go to for hoagies ... sadly disappointed! Their deli off the island is still awesome and the sandwiches there are excellent! read more

Just don't make the mistake my wife did. I stood outside while she used the restroom. As she left, a hostess loudly informed her on the street that something needed to be purchased before using the restroom, which I promptly did. I hope they have a "no public restroom" sign that we missed; otherwise, bad form. read more

Best kept secret in Surf City! We have been eating at Lighthouse since they opened and have never been disappointed. Michael and his staff couldn't be friendlier and the food is consistently as good, if not better, than some of the other local establishments with long wait times. The catering options are excellent too! read more

Home made hash browns are so crispy & delicious!! We also loved the chicken & waffles & egg Sammy. They have everything here & a lot of cool bagel options. The staff is really nice & we're definitely going to come back for more. read more

Lighthouse Restaurant & Grill - The Chicken and Waffles Breakfast & Pork Roll Egg sammmy - Bagels Near Me - Surf City, New Jersey

We just had a great breakfast here. Staff is super friendly (shout out to Crissy!) and the owner was generous with his time. Really good bagels, tons o sausage in the biscuits and gravy and already open for the season. Definitely on our "make sure we stop by" list. read more

My wife & I stopped in for lunch after driving 125 miles to LBI. this is our 2nd time trying this place. The food is very good portion size is on the larger side. prices are fair. Staff is friendly & courteous. The have their own parking lot which is a plus read more

The best pork roll and cheese I've found yet in area. Nice owners very friendly service will definitely return! read more

Great place! Very clean. Good service. Overstuffed hoagies! The cheesesteaks are to die for.

Walked in during lunchtime and quickly was greeted! Ordered a Cobb salad takeout. Service was great, easy parking, great patio- totally perfect for a quick bite! Looking forward to going back and trying other items! read more

Actually good bagels with all the normal options. Bagels are the right amount of chewy and dense enough but not hard or crumbly. This place is a great find. Prices are a bit steep but generally in line with the area. Only real complaint is lack of cold brew but I'll survive. read more

Lighthouse deli has been a family favorite since it opened. Great food and attention to excellent customer service. Highly recommend.

Stopped by to have dinner at the lighthouse. Food was fantastic. We had tuna, flounder and chicken and variety of apps - and it was all excellent. We showed up about 730 and was not rushed out at all. Price was very reasonable. Will definitely be back and highly recommend. Cheesecake was really good. read more

Sandwiches were solid. Service was not. Als didn't have ac which is a bit of a tough scene

Had a great lunch here today! Whole wheat veggie wrap, was out standing! Super nice staff, nice place. Recommended.

Our favorite go to deli! The cold cuts are always fresh and the bread is perfect for sandwiches. Great selection of bagels too with a Friendly staff. Recently ordered a platter of sandwiches. Excellent! read more

Fresh sandwiches not too big not too small. Placed order on the phone - polite courteous accurate order taker who answered my questions. We carried out but it looks like a nice busy deli. read more

Great food and great service! They always use fresh ingredients and have a nice mix of dishes that the owner puts a perfect spin on. You can tell the difference from your average run-of-the-mill place just trying to rake in tourist money. Staff is always pleasant and looking for feedback on the dishes. They serve breakfast and lunch and also have indoor and outdoor seating which is always a nice option. Kids love to play baggo and other games. Definitely check this place out. read more

Breakfasts there is always good. Service great. Very accommodating to a larger group.

Food was absolutely delicious!! Friendly staff , great environment!! Totally recommend!!

This spot used to be another hot spot restaurant that seemed to be doing well however another victim of Covid and it closed in 2020-2021 timeframe. This new restaurant took over and added a new addition to the quiet strip of Surf City which in fact needed another deli/sandwich spot as well as another Bagel spot. The place is rustic inside and the staff is super friendly and welcoming. The menu is a great selection of bagels of all sorts (even Oreo which was cool), sandwiches for breakfast or lunch and a few other selections but that is mainly their focus. The good thing is they are right down the road from another bagel spot that we do like, but cash is king over there and sorry but I no longer carry cash and I refuse to take cash out of a stand alone ATM that charges 3.75 a transaction. Plus in post COVID era, who doesn't offer credit cards as an option? Sorry but Ill stick to a place that takes cards, offers the same if not better service and food and is in the same proximity. Breakfast sandwiches are made to order, tasted delicious and so did the bagels. I will be back here each year and the good news, this is not their only location in Jersey! read more

Cannot say enough about the food, staff or ownership. Top quality all around. From delicious homemade bagels, to premium cold cuts and salads, to a catering service that is outstanding, the Lighthouse Deli will always be our go to place when on LBI. They will meet your every food need and desire with a smile and a passion to provide top quality service. Mike and family provided an exceptional on-site pre-wedding evening Meet & Greet Reception for over 100 guests for us. The planning was so simple, and the outcome was tremendously received by all guests. We continue to get calls from invited guests about the top quality food products. The Lighthouse Deli is much more than just a deli. You must check them out! read more