Tried and true. A staple for a reason. Bagels are great, service is speedy and nice, the Italian is…read morethe BEST on the island - for real life!! - and the Crumb Cake is OFF THE HOOK. Ambiance? perfect shore quick in and out spot! 10/10 stars!

We got a dozen bagels from here yesterday and unfortunately the quality isn't great. The bagels are…read morepretty standard and not half as good as other bagel shops in LBI. It was also pretty pricey for a dozen bagels.

We tried a blueberry bagel with veggie cream cheese and it was delicious and fresh…read more It's a busy place but they were efficient and did a great job. They have lot of other options too.

I purchased 3 ice coffees, 3 breakfast burritos. I spent over $60.00…read moreThe burritos were tasteless and coffee was water down. I will never go back again.

This restaurant is great. We Went for brunch. We were…read moreseated outside on the patio which was Very nice! Our server was perfect Our food arrived quick & hot

Best bagels in LBI! Amazing breakfast sandwich. Does not skimp on pork roll! Will definitely be…read moreback! And amazingly nice and helpful service!

Hard to find good bagels since I am a North Jersey girl. These bagels lacked flavor and were a…read morelittle on the sweet side. The salt bagel had a lot of salt- which I like but the inside was flavorless. The cinnamon raisin bagel lacked cinnamon and raisins. Still searching for The best bagel in LBI

If your a beach haven local you know the place for that welcome to the island, hangover fix,…read moreperfect bagel. Bagel shack is the best bagel you can get in beach haven and it is year round! Today my boyfriend and I went he was severely hungover and I just was craving a bagel lol. I went basic and got a plain bagel toasted with cream cheese while my boyfriend got a plain bagel toasted with pec and a hash brown. Bagels were delicious as always but sadly were not very toasted:( anyways I love bagel shack and would recommend to anyone!

I have no doubt that this place was really great in the past. In today's day, especially after…read moreCovid I don't think they're prepared enough. I stopped by around 11am and quickly realized they had absolutely nothing out. They really close at 11 and just sell leftovers till 12. They had a few donuts so I got some to try but not much to pick from at all. When I asked about lunch sandwiches that I heard people raving about, they told me after Covid they never reopened that part of the deli. So they said they could still make a breakfast sandwich. I passed on the offer but my boyfriend got a Taylor ham egg and cheese on a bagel. It was really sad to look at, not a good sandwich overall. Would've been better off at WaWa. The donuts were decent but I definitely have had better on the island. I can appreciate how fresh they are but that's about it. Overall the staff was nice and the donuts were fresh but with hours so limited and no sandwiches available, I probably won't be back.

Almost $9 for a bagel sandwich with premade eggs and 1 slice of pork roll on a soggy bagelread more

Went there for bacon, egg and cheese on an egg bagel. It was good. Service was excellent and the…read moreambience was outdoor picnic tables which were fine . Good breakfast place

Nothing good about the experience. 3 of the 4 orders were wrong and the 4th was burnt. And it's…read moreexpensive. Bunch of kids working there (which is great) but there was 0 oversight and accountability. Very poorly run establishment with sub par food.

I stopped in for a quick bagel pickup and was not disappointed in the slightest! There were a lot…read moreof bagel varieties to choose from, but I decided to go for their cheddar jalapeño which looked tasty. This was a completely delicious choice! The bagel was soft and airy while also having a nice balance of savory and spiciness which I was looking for. I do wish they had more indoor seating available and a more cohesive menu for ordering, but if you're getting something simple to-go you'll have no problem.

Stopped here around 12 on a Saturday when visiting family at the hospital next door without hearing…read moreabout it first. There was not a long line and we ordered right away. They have a lot of options for bagel and cream cheese flavors! I loved my cheddar jalepeno bagel with veggie cream cheese. The cheddar and jalepenos were baked on top of the bagel rather than being mixed through, so was not too spicy.

The staff was super kind and friendly! The iced coffee hit the spot. And the bagel -- wow. One of…read morethe best NJ bagels I've ever had, especially with pork roll, egg, and cheese. Perfect balance of flavors, yummy, and satisfying. Would totally come back!

Great bagels, love the cannoli cream cheese monthly special. Friendly staff, quick service!read more

Quick service, diverse selection and as good as advertised. This appears to be an LBI institution…read morefor a reason - they deliver on quality, taste, and service. The ambiance is exactly what you want from this type of bakery: glass counter with ample viewing windows. ORANGE CREAMSICLE donut is INSANE! Cash only. Be friendly and ready to order and you'll be rewarded with carby/sugary, fatty, salty goodness that you couldn't even dream up!

The sign says best grape jelly donuts, and I had to see if it was true. I don't even really like…read morejelly donuts. Somehow, it was true. These were good - not just "good for a jelly donut". They were overall really good compared to ALL donut types. I'll be back next year. There's a line, but it moves pretty fast

This place was super disappointing. I ordered a breakfast sandwich and I have nothing very good to…read moresay about it. My egg was so teeny tiny, it barely covered half the bagel. And on top of the egg was Orange American cheese that reminded me of the one that comes right out of the plastic wrapping... You can't even chalk this up to a one time error because I'm pretty sure that's how it's supposed to be made here! The bagel itself wasn't that bad, but it wasn't super memorable. Other than the quality of the food, there were some positives: the people who worked in there were very nice, their items are pretty cheap, and they were very quick in making your food. It seems to me like this is a great place if you're looking for something super convenient, as long as you don't have very high expectations for the quality of the food. If I were to do this visit over again I would ask for double egg and specify for cheddar cheese (or really any cheese other that Orange American).

Cash Only (if you take anything away from this review it is to bring cash haha)…read more This place is a well oiled machine so don't let any long lines scare you away, it goes quickly. Bagels & pastries are delicious as is their coffee. Staff are friendly & efficient. The store itself is clean but please note there is not indoor seating, definitely a grab & go place.