Wow, California roll cream cheese is outstanding. Bagels are water boiled, always fresh. read more

Why does this place not have a billion positive reviews?? They are the BEST bagels around. Without a doubt they are far superior to the rest in the area (and beyond the area too). The bagels are traditional water boiled (as all proper New York bagels should be!!!). They have the perfect amount of chewiness while still being soft and utterly delicious. Egg and cheese on a plain or whole wheat everything...so good. This place should be packed at all times. I think they deliver and I know they stay open 24 hours on Friday and Saturday nights which is awesome. Easiest 5 stars I have ever given. read more

Really too bad that such great bagels have to be enriching a far flung enclave of bay ridge- where as I would travel a mile out if my way gladly to consume these immaculate huge holed beautiful gastronomic monsters! The place looks like every other bagel place, flashing lights, boars head signs. But inside the manager is particular to detail when taking orders. Bagels are so wonderful and crisp and the huge old boiler takes up the back. If only every bagel shop were at least an imitation. read more

Super cool spot I just discovered! Food is always fresh..I'm very surprised. I always see the young man taking great care of the store. And the customers. He always has a pleasant disposition and makes the best sandwiches! I def recommend this hidden gem read more

Bagel Supreme - Food is always fresh! ! Any time ! Day or night! - Bagels Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

Small place. Offers an assortment of fresh bagels and cream cheeses in addition to muffins, some hot and cold sandwiches, chips, coffee, and soft drinks. They had a French Toast bagel (signature) and a crunchy caramel cream cheese which looked interesting. I ordered 5 different bagels with different toppings and my order was 100% accurate. Bagels were good, reasonably priced, and big. Some of the things in the display looked like they'd seen better days. Don't expect service with a smile though. The counter guy barely makes eye contact, grunts responses, and walks away while you're talking to him. It's whatever, that's the Brooklyn way. I'll probably be back to try that French Toast bagel, maybe on his day off... read more

Ordered a bagel sandwich and it was delicious. Yiu can tell the bagels are fresh and made on premise. Nothing spectacular about the place but if you want a good bagel this place wont fail. read more

Best place ever. We drive 30 minutes just so my 6 year old can get the strawberry cream cheese bagel. Staff are super nice and friendly too which makes it a great experience every time. read more

I'm a regular by nature as I live only 3 doors down from Bagel Supreme. Their Bagels rock! Hands down, the best I've ever had! The grill food is great too! I just had what I'm calling The Best Breakfast Wrap Ever. I think it's the best breakfast wrap ever. Going back for another in a few minutes. Btw, they're open 24 hours on the weekends! The entire crew there is awesome! I have no complaints. read more

Bagel Supreme - The Best Breakfast Wrap Ever! - Bagels Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

See all

The bagels here are actually really good and I would have given this place 4 stars if the guy behind the counter wasn't trying to charge me for a water that I already had when I walked into the store. My wAter was already open and i had already drank a substantial amount on my way to the bagel store. Even the wrapper was slightly torn a bit, my point clearly I had already brought it into the store with me. The guy was looking at me as if I was lying. Really?!?!?! Do you think I started chugging the water in the store?! After I told him it was mine he proceeded to give me $1 dollar less than I was owed and when he saw my face he grabbed another dollar. Unreal!! Needless to say I have never had that problem before and will not be coming back here. read more

I've been buying bagels here for almost twenty years. The ownership has changed and the place has been renovated a number of times, but the bagels have always been great. They are handmade water bagels, not the crappy rack bagels that some places try to pass off as bagels. I don't know why this place isn't recognized by the "Best of" lists that come out periodically, because the bagels are outstanding, especially if you get them fresh out of the oven - crusty on the outside, chewy on the inside. They don't skimp on the toppings (everything, sesame, salt, etc.) like some bagel places do, although the bagels have gotten considerably smaller over the past 2-3 years. They are still a decent size, but not like the huge size they used to be. Also, the prices are reasonable (currently $8.99 per dozen). The service here is always friendly too. Oscar is a nice guy and the other people behind the counter are helpful and pleasant. read more

My favorite neighborhood bagel shop for years, the staff are great and the bagels are always fresh.

Best bagels in Bay Ridge! And they just remodeled. What a big difference. Everything they make is good and now the place is beautiful. Love their bagels. read more

The bagels are tasty, portions are huge, and they offer better prices than other bagel shops. The omlettes are good too - and come with toast and homefries - all for only $6.50! The prices can't be beat! Plus they offer sandwiches and other items. Haven't tried their specialty bagels yet, but looking forward to it. read more

my boss gave me a 10 to get him a coffee. i paid first for that and then proceeded to order my own food as a separate order. i realize that i have 3 dollars change for one coffee. i ask how much a medium coffee was and he says it was 2, i explain i gave him a 10. he doesnt seem to believe me but gives me my correct change. i am now waiting for my BLT that i ordered, i hear the men laughing by the grill but i dont think anything, when i get back to my office i open my sandwich and there is a several big slabs of uncooked or half cooked bacon. mind you i was the only person in the store being that the morning rush was over so its not like they were pressed for time and couldnt cook it properly. i dont know if it was because of the change incident or they just done care, but that shit is gross and pisses me off as the first meal i was trying to have today. read more

Bagel Supreme - yum uncooked bacon - Bagels Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

Terrible combination of a stale bagel with a tasteless spread. It was really disappointing. The "cash only" sign is also taped right over the register so you can't see what they're ringing up. Bad bagels, bad business practices. read more

I have gone to this place a few times but today is my final Time I wound up leaving without my order because I was the only one in the store waiting for 5 minutes for the person to take my order then while waiting 3 other customers walked in and received there food mins you I ordered 4 bagels with cream cheese which takes seconds to do .. and the others ordered egg sandwiches while still waiting they recurved there orders almost immediately I am very dissatisfied with there service and will no longer have my family do business with them read more

Hands down the best bagels in Bay Ridge. This place has been around forever. Although the name has changed, the bagel quality hasn't. They still make bagels the old fashioned way - not the frozen and steamed bagels you see in most places. Downside is it is not a fancy place like Bagel Boy, so don't expect lattes but the product is far superior. read more

Good authentic bagels and a good price. Quality for the price with an assortment of freshly made and tasty salads and cream-cheeses. It's my new breakfast - on - the - go spot! read more

Bagel Supreme might be a stretch, but you get credit for freshly boiled bagels on the premises. Thanks for not giving me ish, for toasting my bagel. Additionally, grilled breakfast sandwiches were good and service is great in Spanish, English, and Arabic. read more

Bagels here are delicious. They're the big chewy dense New York kind that's boiled before baking. Nice crunch on the outside and chewy on the inside. Cream cheese is fresh and the butter is nice and salty. Prices are great too and they're open 24/7 whenever you're in the mood for a bagel. I think the grill closes around 7:00 though. Next time you're in the neighborhood definitely stop by and give them a try. read more

I purchased a $7.50 Pastrami and cheese sandwich with French fries, fries where ok but hot sandwich took forever to prepare on the small grill and sandwich was gross and Soggy. read more

I thank the heavens every day that this place is so close to where I live and to the train station. Seriously delicious. Most of the other bagels in the area I've had are really doughy, soft and bland - not at Bagel Supreme. They toast my everything bagels and they are crispy and salty and amazing with eggs or with cream cheese. Coffee is good there too and they have a decent selection of juice. Also their muffins are super moist and delicious. I don't know how my lazy non-breakfast cooking butt could survive without them. read more

There are a ton of bagel shop options in Bay Ridge but this is by far the best one. All bagels are handmade and they put the perfect amount of cream cheese on each bagel. Lots of parking near by. read more

Of all the bagel places in Bay Ridge, I must pledge my allegiance to Bagel Supreme. Their bagels are simply the best, and the shop is charming in its simplicity. They obviously serve quite a few regulars, and it's not uncommon to be greeted by name. As a perk, it's just a short walk to the shore and parks, which makes for a great weekend morning read more

Really went down hill. I work around the area so I've been coming here for about 10 years. Ill admit I haven't been here in a while since my job moved down to second ave. Really excited to come back today and get the warm, huge bagels I remember. Unfortunately, the bagels are more on the stale side, the lox have to be store brand at best and the lox bagel doesn't come with a side salad anymore. For $8.00 you can't give a side salad? I noticed the "cash only, CC machine is broken sign". That has to be their way of just not accepting CC because they've never once accepted credit cards since I've been coming here for over 10 years. I get business is business, but a happy customer is a returning customer. read more

What on earth is a french toast bagel, you ask? I'm not sure myself, but it is the perfect weekend bagel when slathered with cream cheese! It might be an egg bagel with a cinnamon crumble? It is definitely delicious and worth every calorie! Skip the other Bay Ridge options if you can -- still competitive neighborhood prices (cheap!) and they'll sell you just lox! read more

Hands-down the best bagel I've ever had! The bagels are a good size and are just amazing, especially toasted.

I almost wonder if I went to the wrong place based on the other glowing reviews. I was in the area at a friend's place and wanted to pick up bagels to bring back to Boston with me (I usually get them near my father's house). I saw the reviews and went here. As soon as I saw the bagels, I knew they wouldn't be good. They were giant and malformed. When I ate one, the taste was fine but the texture was all wrong. It was very soft with big air bubbles. If you want a sandwich on a bagel, I'm sure these bagels would be fine for that. But if you're looking for good bagels to have with cream cheese or butter, I'd look elsewhere. read more

They have THE BEST bagels in Bay Ridge! They are the reason why I can never stick to a diet, lol.

Start your morning right!!! One of the best bagel store in the area!! Clean,friendly ,great selection,excellent iced coffee!!! read more

See all

Been going here for years. The best bagels in Bay Ridge, no doubt. Bagels are oversized---service is ALWAYS quick and super friendly. Only 3 stars cause, you know, it's just a bagel. read more

The QUEEN BILQIS, recommends this awesome, place to all, why? Because they are Supreme in customer service! Speedy completion of orders, remember your favorite orders too, they smile as they speak to you, always! Thanks for being consistent and genuine Carlos, super sweet Oscar, to the darling ladies Melissa and Maria thanks for the friendly caring dedication... stay supreme in service! The food is always great too :) read more

Best. Bagels. Ever. We wandered into this place one day because my three year old was hungry while we were walking around town. I was blown away by the size and freshness of their bagels. One of my measures of a great bagel is if the plain bagel is delicious without toasting it. These bagels certainly pass that test! Also, the everything bagels are topped perfectly and the price is unbelievable. Nine dollars for a dozen bagels! Their breakfast sandwiches are also incredible and well priced. Definitely recommend! read more

Have been twice since moving to brooklyn for work and I must say the service is outstanding fast too and the food is great. For anyone who has not been I recommend going and trying the "EVERYTHING WITH CREAM CHEESE AND BACON" and a coffee. $5.25 the reason I only gave it 4 stars was because its a cash only shop (atm on site). read more

I just came from the store. While one of the store employees (or perhaps one of the owners) was getting the bagels from his oven, a bagel dropped on the floor. He put it back on the bucket. I asked them: are you going to through that bagel you dropped on the floor. He said did you see me me put it back? Then he said while he is in the kitchen, it's non your business my friend. Beside he was being a rude, doing that means the employees are nasty, and perhaps their food is nasty too. One thing, he had shoes that I think he wears on the street. read more

As a bagel lover this is by far the best bagels!!! Not only do they have amazing bagels all the other food is great. Carlos and Melissa make you feel right at home. Definitely go!!!!!!!! read more

yeah, there are fancier bagel shops around this corner of bay ridge, but for my money, supreme bagel is the best! you get what you want, when you want it, period. this place is cheaper, as well. take a walk down third avenue in bay ridge, Brooklyn and you'll find places where a single bagel can run you as much as $2.50! supreme stays rock steady at a buck. doesn't matter where i am, or what i'm doing, if the yen for an onion bagel hits me, i know exactly - and SUPREMELY where i'm going!!! take a walk over, you won't be disappointed! read more

these guys are cheap, fast, and have the best bagels in town. they make them there too! you can see a big cauldron in the back. it's pretty cool. read more

Terrible service I walked in there waited 5 whole minutes on the register and not one out of the 4 employees asked if I needed help and there was no one else in the store. they were all busy standing around looking at each other. So I had to leave and take my business elsewhere read more

I used to live down the block from this store many moons ago. We now travel from New Jersey to get these bagels and freeze them individually for future use. They hold up really really well! If you get the bagels fresh out of the oven, you are in heaven. Not sure why they aren't more well known. I tell everyone I know about this place. Even though they have changed ownership many times since I left, the bagels are still just as fantastic! Wish we had one like this near us in NJ. read more