Stopped in to pick up lunch for my sister and I. Everyone very friendly. Loved my tuna on bagel. Bagels are nice and soft and most importantly fresh. read more

Bagel Toasterie - Bagels Near Me - Commack, New York

Yummy breakfast food! Endless options, quick service, good quality food. Love the endless sandwiches, coffees etc that you can choose from! staff friendly and attentive read more

Nice clean place. I routinely come here for breakfast or lunch. It's always crowded. Many different options to choose from. They have halal bacon for BEC. Additionally all the chicken is halal. The brothers who own this are Turkish and are always kind. read more

Bagel Toasterie - Bagels Near Me - Commack, New York

Never can make my bagel properly, butter and a little cream cheese. Every-time hardly no butter and a lot of cream. For 4.75 I won't be back. read more

Always get my breakfast from them, great service. Make sure to try their fresh coffee read more

Bagel Toasterie - Greek omelette and hash browns - Bagels Near Me - Commack, New York

This is my second time personally visiting the location and the theme is the same. Slow customer service. It wasn't necessarily a busy time and there were only three customers in the store yet an everything bagel with bacon, egg and cheese took almost 15 minutes. Prices were reasonable but the everything bagel was more like a barely everything bagel. The sandwich was tasty but the bagel was very chewy and doughy. There was zero crisp to it and the top was the same pale color as the bottom. They had a slow but steady flow customers while I was in the shopping center but I likely won't return. This isn't a bad place but it was not worth going back to with so many other bagel locations around. read more

See all

This is my third and final chance for this place. I was really hoping to have a good experience there cause it is one of the few bagel stores that have tables to sit at after you order. Went yesterday ordered two hot heroes ... both of them ice cold I asked for cranberries on one I open the sandwich up. They were literally eight little cranberries at the end of the sandwich. Half of the order was missing. I had to get up and keep asking the girls behind the counter to who I think might not understand English very well because every time I asked for what was missing, I had to repeat myself three times I can't understand. Doesn't the owner read the reviews they have a prime location that place should be busy all the time. Don't waste your money. read more

Rude staff overpriced just not a good experience I will eat elsewhere i'm surprised me, but the place took such a drastic downturn. The former managers were great. The former help was grave, but I went in today. And it was like there was a light switch that somebody turned off and the guy in charge was a rude arrogant pompous. A** the food sucked, the coffee was stale. The price was a rip-off and the place wasn't that clean, not to. Mention There wasn't any toilet paper in the bathroom, which really was like the icing on the cake. I'll never be back read more

Great service, super nice people! Such a nice place I will definitely be returning to. Excellent lunch. Seems so simple but some places just don't get it right. Great lunch deal - $8.99 sandwich, side salad, pickles and a drink. Highly recommend! read more

Bagel Toasterie - Bagels Near Me - Commack, New York

See all

Food is always fresh and customer service is amazing! One of the only bagels stores to sell halal beef bacon and chicken! read more

Bagel Toasterie - Halal beef bacon, 3 sunny side eggs with butter toast! Perfection - Bagels Near Me - Commack, New York

By far the best egg sandwich I've had in a while around the commack area. I am SO glad I gave this place a try! I had a SECSPK on the most delicious egg everything bagel, totally going to get another one tomorrow! read more

Fellow in my photo in orange t-shirt is spectacular. I've had him before. Used a sandwich coupon which was a great deal but took almost 15 minutes to get it and the small macaroni they included had a chemical taste to it suggesting it wasn't homemade. That always will knock stars off my reviews. read more

See all

food was subpar. I ordered - few things and for $40 they messed everything up. horrible service. if I can give 0 stars I would.

"Get your morning toasty with the best bagels in town! Perfectly toasted and deliciously crispy - because life's too short for cold bagels! Stop by, and let's make your breakfast un-bagel-ievable! #BagelGoals #ToastyGoodness #BreakfastDoneRight" read more

See all

Went today and had the hungry man on a flagel. Service was very good (nice women at counter) as was the food. I thought prices were reasonable and I will be back read more

Ordered online for pick-up and order wasn't ready when I arrived, even though confirmed via email that order was received. Gave therm the order # and they couldn't find anything. Maybe because I selected to pay in cash since they charge a $3 delivery fee on $15+ orders & 3% credit card processing fee. They didn't charge me due to the confusion (this the 2 instead of 1 stars) - but if I had ordered for my colleagues and had multiple items, that mishap could've been very inconvenient and time consuming. Based on my first experience & their prices and kinks they still haven't worked out, unsure that they're going to last. Very disappointed. read more

Bagel Toasterie - Egg white sandwich. (They forgot to cut 1/4s, go figure!) - Bagels Near Me - Commack, New York

Great breakfast. Good bagels and egg sandwiches Service is excellent ! The place is big. Very clean. read more

very slow to make things not sure if it's because he is too cheap to hire help but you need more than two people working there in the mornings plus the owner is very rude and nasty. Very poor customer service at this place based on the attitude of the owner, this place does not deserve any customers. read more

Smallest stingiest wrap I've ever had. Child size for $12.93! And they charged me for apple and forgot to put it in! read more

Bagel Toasterie - Turkey wrap - Bagels Near Me - Commack, New York

Hey Greenly. Rainbow bagel cream cheese! Bagel Toasterie puts just the right amount of cream on their bagels, not to little not too much! read more

See all

Not sure how they think this wrap is worth $13.99! Service is super slow. I've given them enough chances, too many better places in the area. read more

Bagel Toasterie - Price of wrap - Bagels Near Me - Commack, New York

See all

Bagels done Right! It is a Clean and bright eatery with a friendly staff! I order the same menu items at many shops across beautiful Long Island and their fresh ingredients make a difference. read more

Worst bagels on Long Island. These are not boiled bagels. They are rolls with holes. Their bialys are simply their bagels without holes. There are so many good bagel stores here there is no reason to go to this place. read more

Bagel Toasterie - Bialy - Bagels Near Me - Commack, New York

See all

Their bagels are supermarket quality!!!!! Good egg sandwiches however. The staff there always seemed confused and unprepared. WEIRD!!!!

I love this place. I love the people and their bagels are great I wish everybody would know

I've been here a few times. I don't get anything out of the ordinary. I get bacon and eggs and thats it. The place is clean with a decent sized dining area. No complaints but would like to try a bagel or one of the salads they have up front. read more

Place is clean, service slow and I question the prices- I bought a fruit cup, large coffee, a sport water beverage, a croissant and a local community newspaper ($1.00). There was one person in front of me, waiting for a sandwich to be cooked in the back. I waited for a plain croissant which was brought from the back instead of out of the case, which was ice cold and hard as a rock. They charged me $3.34 for a plain bagel (that I did not order or receive) AND a croissant ($1.99). Is that their way of charging me for the one dollar paper? To my knowledge, you don't charge tax on newspapers. On top of that, they added a 3% "service charge" on my order PLUS tax on top of that.... And asked for an additional tip. No thanks. This is Commack. There's 100 other bagel places in the area... read more

Pros: Nice clean place with plenty of seating, but that's where it ends. Skimpy breakfast sandwiches and overpriced. If I am going to spend $12+ on and egg white and turkey sandwich, I expect there to be more than one slice of turkey on it. Won't be back. read more

Always fresh and delicious I love this place all worker nice and local kids they try best

Good bagels but terrible and slow service. Waited 30 mins for bagels with cream cheese and butter. Two bagels with cream cheese, one with butter and one plain. Nice spot to sit and enjoy a bagel and coffee but be prepared to wait a while for them to spread the bagel. Honestly no excuse for the bad and slow service. Terribly managed but good food. read more

Happy to have a quick place to grab the basics. Sandwiches are really good. Bagels are ok. Staff have been very friendly when I'm there.

I've given this place 3 chances and they've failed every time. Terrible egg sandwich's....even worse side salads and thin and puny deli sandwich's! UNFRIENDLY staff and highly overpriced. I give this place 60 days before they're out of business!!! read more

The past 3 times our order has been incorrect. Always missing items but they still charge us for it.

This place is insanely expensive! Cost $11 for an egg sandwich and small coffee! I could have a sit down breakfast with these prices! I'd find another place! read more

It took 20 minutes for them to make my order when there was only 3 other customers. Do not recommend. They are expensive and the food wasn't good. They are very slow and not very attentive. read more

Food is Phenomenal, I came here for the first time 2 weeks ago and been here since everyday . The egg sandwhiches are 10/10 and so are their heros and dont get me started on the Bagels. The workers treat their customers like they are family and always have a smile on their faces . The interior is very modern and have any type of drinks that u are in the mood for and the dining area is very clean and spacious. read more

I am glad to see a bagel shop open in this location after being shuttered for a few years. Inside is spacious and clean. I went during the first few weeks it was opened, so I do not know if anything has since changed. The good news is, I had a coupon. The bad news..,the bagels weren't anything special. They were quite airy, more the substance of a roll. I will stick to my own favorite spot, but you can give them a try and see for yourself. read more

Wow wow wow they are amazing please go there try their amazing bagels and sandwiches . Avocado bagel is the best Very nice staff and clean feels like home read more

I've tried this place a few times now and had issues every time. First, was a few months ago when we waited over half an hour for an order of two sandwiches while the young person behind the counter chatted with and served his friends ahead of people on line. Also, out of the sides that it was said to include. The other times I've ordered bagels, call-ahead order and very early AM. On the upside, the orders were ready when we arrived. Big downside was half our order was wrong both times. Yesterday's was probably the last attempt. Ordered a whole wheat bagel with fried eggs, nothing else (due to dietary restrictions) and got everything bagel with scrambled and a ton of American cheese. Location is great but wish they were better. read more

Very happy to see this place open - and to finally have a very good bagel available close by. I have had their bagels now about seven times over two months - and always REALLY GOOD!!! I cannot speak for all of the other food but it looks good. The decor is bright and modern and the staff are very competent and friendly. Give them a try! read more