Bagelicious was exactly the name. The bagels were good! Service was courteous and speedy. I ordered a plain bagel with cream cheese. I love it when you order a bagel with filling and it's loaded with the filling. It was a generous spread of cream cheese on a big bagel. The bagels were fresh (which it should already be) and various types to choose from. Of course like most bagel shops, you can order sandwiches, salads, by the pound foods, coffee, soda, etc. the staff was nice. Small interior with a table and counter window to eat at. The parking lot needed some work though. Massive pot holes that could that can cause some damage to your vehicle. Other than that, I recommend Bagelicious. read more

Bagelicious - Bog size tasty bagels - Bagels Near Me - Tallman, New York

See all

7 dollars for a medium size coffee a mint chewing gum, beyond ridiculous, this new owner is charging ridiculous prices

This is a food place for a bagel sandwich and a coffee, although I would go to other nearby bagel bakeries to pick up a dozen.

Vegan folks should know that they no longer offer vegan cream cheese. It was disappointing.

This review is for Bagelicious in Suffern NY. Filthy. They wipe the counters with a disgusting filthy cloth then pull the knife from in between the counter, ( omg can you imagine how gross it is between those counters) so they pull the knife out to cuts a sandwich but first they wipe the knife with the filthy rag they used too wipe the counters. Don't eat there it's gross. read more

I was in the area for a figure skating competition and wanted to grab a quick breakfast for myself and my teammates, so we chose to come here. It was a great choice since there are a ton of options (everyone will find something they want) and the price is super cheap for pretty good portion sizes. The staff is friendly and they move pretty quickly despite there being a lot of patrons constantly flowing in. We were here on a Saturday morning around 10:30am and getting the food for four of us took around 20 minutes, with 5 people ahead of us in line. Two of us got bagels which didn't take long since there was no cooking required, but the other two of us got a quesadilla, eggs, and sausage which required cooking. I believe there was only one chef and one small area to cook; things could be faster with a larger cooking area and another chef. All the food tasted delicious and lived up to the name "Bagelicious"! The bagels are huge! And they cost less than $5 with cream cheese. You can get a mini for less than $1, and I feel the mini bagel size is about the same as a normal bagel elsewhere. There are many kinds of bagels and many kinds of cream cheese, each of which add a little to the cost but not much. The coffee sizes are smaller than usual and probably are the most pricey compared to everything else. A small coffee cost more than a mini flagel, and the coffee was really small. However, according to my teammate it was a really good coffee; she would recommend getting it. And in any case, "pricey" is still under $2. One thing to note that wasn't obvious to me is that you pay after you get all of your food, not when you order. This seems good actually since then you can make sure you got everything you wanted when you pay. However, do note that they don't have an itemized receipt available since they manually enter the prices in. I paid for 4 people and we had a rough time figuring out who got what just from a bunch of numbers and no item descriptions on the receipt. This is a minor inconvenience overall though. I highly recommend coming here if you're in the area looking for breakfast, brunch, or lunch to take out or eat in a casual atmosphere! read more

See all

My wife and I visited this place a few years ago and we absolutely fell in love with it. Always fresh, soft bagels with our favorite vegan-friendly tofu veggie cream cheese! We live in Manhattan, and my wife had asked if we could pick up some bagels after doing some errands with my brother. Unfortunately, we arrived half an hour after closing, but the staff were kind enough to let us in and order anyways! Of course, as usual, the bagels were still soft and fresh despite being closed. Couldn't say enough good things about this place, our flagship bagel place for sure! read more

You can rest easy tonight folks, For Linguini Bonotucci... is back for the holidays. Put on your comfiest pajamas, brew up a nice hot cocoa, sprinkle in some of your favorite liquor (don't worry... I won't tell a soul), and place your pillow-soft tushy next to the passionately flaring fire place. Did I get you in the mood? Good. Let's begin. Linguini B was looking more like some thin spaghetti. Determined to become a more well-endowed pasta type, he decided to put himself into someone else is shoes. He didn't wanna be thiccc like Udon. Nor did he wanna get round like an open hole in some fatttt rigatoni. Instead he decided to pick up the player option and become Pici B. A thick spaghett, no doubt about it. But not thick enough that he'd float out in the waves and go unrecognized by a lifeguard for they mistook him for a whale or even a robust island. But how could this man evolve? Take the next step? How could he get on the menu at a dessert shop rather than a brunch location? He pondered. Rather, he dwelled on the topic for his temporal and frontal lobes could not come to consensus. Right when things seemed stagnant, a soft yet serious rush hit his Adam's apple. It was as if the man had clogged arteries. Blood rushed into his extremities. All of them. Give a dog a ******* bone. Woof woof. Was he shooting up adrenaline? Juicing (kale smoothies? Juicing (roids)? No. None of the above Shapiro. Fughetttt about the secret cannot be told. Fine maaaaaa I'll tell them! Geezus I'm gonna murder this woman. Can't I just live my life? The night she falls asleep in the living room is the night I learn how to carve a pumpkin. Great pond in my backyard for this type of business. Don't get on my bad side!!! Lolllllll! The Secret: Bagelicious. So delicious. Marroneee do I love this joint. "Bagelicious. You divine. Mighty fine. Shawty really..." Back it up, Back it up, Back it up... woo wooo! - Ad: You like-a da good food? You like-a the low price? Good. Fine. Dandyyyyy. Come on in don't be scared. Unless some freak with a wife beater and Calvin Klein underwear is in there... (iykyk) - Food Options: There's a lot to try here. From bagels to wraps to sandwiches to smoothies to some cold bottled water. Sponsored by Poland Spring. What taste better than a cold steam of leftover polish sausage and Polish Brown Bear piss? - My Order: This is all that matters. The build up play has been pleasurable... pulchritudinous at least (WOW BIG WORD ALERTTTTT.) But if you wanna become a Pici Pasta (Real Thiccc) you gotta order a BEC on a plain bagel. Glamorously sized and squishy like only a legit bage bage can be. Sandwich is solid... but the second thing that must accompany it in this order is a Breakfast Burrito. Yeah that's right. You're getting both and I don't wanna hear it. Get that mouth hole open this is gonna be a *woahhhh* bumpy ride. Whole Wheat Wrap, Bacon Breakfast Burrito built with the works. And the BEC on a plain on the side. Combo this with a protein shake back home and you're set up for future heart failure. But we all know Linguini B lives in the present. Talking presents? Merry Christmas Folks. To each a grand holiday, and all a happy new year. Moooooo you fat cow! Sorry, mirror pic Friday. Self image problems... we'll discuss in a review on another day. Toodle-Oooo... Always Honest like Abe, This has been a Linguini Bonotucci Review. read more

The servers are very kind and pleasant. Great selection of bagels etc. if the cream cheese u want is out. They will make it fresh for u

Everything has been tasty so far, they have great breakfast and the workers are all nice. I usually get egg platters with home fries and they make it the best in my opinion. The price is good too. This is a nice to go place read more

I admit to being a fussy foodie critic especially when traveling. By happenstance we landed at Bagelicious (thanks to Yelp) and could not have been happier. As you walk inside this sweet unassuming place you sense an authentic vibrancy and home cooked goodness within a casual market / cafe ambiance. I felt right at home! I was drawn to the assortment of fresh baked bagels but opted for the egg white veggie spinach wrap off the healthy menu selection. It was loaded with delicately cooked veggies and avocado w added home fries. I can honestly say it was the BEST breakfast wrap I ever experienced! I also ordered a mango, pineapple smoothie- yum! And shared a yogurt fruit granola parfait cup w hubby which could not have been prepared any better! Prices were excellent, the menu wax extensive and the servers were so friendly! I am tagging this in our top, go-to place folder whenever we out this way again! 5 stars read more

My first time here and the Food was awesome. I ordered the Bobo and the prepared it exactly as I requested. I got the Bobo on a sesame bagel and I requested the bacon to be crispy and the bagel to be toasted. Not many places get your order correct the first time you have ever eaten there, but they did. The next time I'm in the area I will gladly give this place my business. You guys are great! Thanks for an amazing breakfast experience. read more

Bagelicious - The last bite - Bagels Near Me - Tallman, New York

The best breakfast sandwiches, wraps and all around morning food. Then lunch time come and blows everything out of the water. The lunch specials are always home cooked with a touch of love. They will make you feel at home with the family at Sunday dinner. The bagels are fantastic. And the coffee is always fresh. read more

See all

What a gem! Needed something quick before class and couldn't be happier with my choosing to go there. So friendly and quick. I ordered just a bagel and iced coffee but I'd pick a little neighborhood spot over dunkin or some chain any day. Picked a cinnamon raisin bagel after not seeing any more French toast in the case. Pretty good! Hit the spot. read more

I accidentally meet this place but my family and I love it so much every Sunday on our way to church we always get six bacon egg and cheeses . And their customer service is very good especially right now that we have Covid. And the best thing is that they deliver so the days I babysit my sisters i usually get them some thing from there in the morning read more

found this place on accident! very fresh and yummy! if we are ever in the area again we will definitely be stopping by! they had stuff for my whole picky family! read more

Bagelicious is well... BAGELICIOUS! This is a nice little bagle shop off of route 59 in Airmount. They have all the basic breakfast store items, as well as chips, other snacks, fresh baked deserts, coffee, and soft drinks . They are always playing news 12 which is great to catch real quick on a lunch break. I know recently there was a switch over in management a few months back. Other than the walls being painted sky blue, The food and service has stayed consistently good. You really can't go wrong with their stand by stuff like a bacon/sausage egg and cheese bagels. I had a cheese steak sandwich from here and I had no complaints. Not the best I've ever had but I would get it again for sure if the mood strikes me. I really like their chicken quesadilla! It is filled with chicken, pepper, mushrooms, onions and cheese. Almost like the cheese steak, but hey it works out great! Real good stuff I must say. Must add a note that parking here sometimes sucks as the lot gets full quickly. I pulled in one day and became trapped because of no parking. I had to park at Wendy's across the street and run across route 59 which completely dangerous and sucks ass. This is a problem for every business in the lot which is completely out of their control but thought I should let everyone know. Other than that, whether you come here for breakfast or lunch you really can't go wrong with this place. BAGELICIOUS! read more

Awesome bagels everytime I've been there and there are plenty of options to out on them from the assorted cream cheeses to the sandwiches (including several egg white options, love that. Good variety of coffee as well. Big fan read more

Nice people, good food. Apparently that is not enough words for yelp, so I will say it again: Nice people and good food.

Good bagels, sandwiches and pastries. They also have excellent home cooked Italian classics (chicken parm, ziti etc). Prices are reasonable. Service is very friendly. read more

This place rocks. The people are really nice and friendly and the service is amazing. Stupendous wraps, all the food here is amazing and very reasonable prices as well read more

I try to go here in the morning whenever i can, though they serve breakfast all day. Big fan of the breakfast stuff and baked goods; I got banana bread from there a couple of times.. best i ever had. The staff is very friendly and i don't think I've ever seen any of them in a bad mood. read more

One of Airmont's hidden gems. Great place for breakfast and lunch! Check their specials and they deliver!!!

I liked the service, all guys and gals behind the counter pay attention to you making sure you don't wait. The menu has abundant selection of paninis, cold salads, wraps, bagels and much more. read more

Best bagels in New York! Get the lox spread on an everything bagel toasted. They load up on the lox and the bagels are perfect. This place doesn't disappoint. read more

As a long time eater of breakfast sandwiches I have to say I have never had a bad experience when stopping at bageliciois. It's pretty much a stones throw from my house, and what a little gem it's turned out to be. There was a period where I was unhappy with he bagels and quality there. They stopped making their bagels fresh for a little while, but that owner who was a total moron for ruining a good little spot is now long gone, and it seems to have been taken over by new people who enjoy putting out a good product. One of the reasons I frequent this spot is because I always feel they make my breakfast and or lunch special just for me. Meaning it's not just another BEC, it's like they really want me to enjoy it. It's a smaller place and there is really not a lot of foot traffic in there so you will be helped promptly, but they aren't going to just pump out your food, they are actually going to make it!!!! The service is super friendly, today I walked in to see the young girl who comes back and forth in-between college semesters to make a few bucks at the bagel store, the second she saw me (and I haven't seen her in maybe a year) it was "hello how are you, so good to see you!! How is your daughter?" It's something like that, that makes it worth going to bagelicious for me it makes my BEC taste all that much better. They are all always kind to my daughter, always chatting with her about whatever. I won't lie, when I first saw it was under new management I was very skeptical. But again today I walk in, they are happy to see me and excited to se my daughter. The women even went as far to split my daughters BEC and put half on a separate plate for her baby pearl who joined us for breakfast this morning. I love to give this place business because of the people and because the make a damn good breakfast sandwich. Cheers to you bagelicious for being awesome read more

Really nice people, went in for a bacon egg and cheese and it was great. Very reasonable prices too, also the bagel tastes very good, definitely going back. read more

Go here everyday. Usually in the morning before school. I always get a whole wheat bagel with butter and a snickerdoodle ice coffee. Friendly, affordable, and convenient. New owners are nice be patient with them. They're black and white cookies are also very delicious and fresh. read more

food is okay. but customer service was horrible. my office has ordered from them a few times and I've never had the best experience, but today left a bad taste in my mouth and will never go back. things happen right? okay. I'm usually the person in the office who does all the breakfast/lunch orders, but someone else did it today. I have a lot of allergies so I thought to myself, yes without looking at a menu, "you can't go wrong with a garden salad, right?", a garden salad is simple, usually lettuce, tomatoes, cucumber and sometimes onions and carrots. boy was I wrong, never have I had anyone put avocado and broccoli in a garden salad. I am deathly allergic to broccoli. like, eat one little tiny flourette and have to be rushed to the emergency room kind of allergy. so once the food was delivered, I called and explained the situation at hand and asked if I could bring it back and exchange for one without the allergen. I was told, "nope sorry, you should have said something about your allergy, if you want to bring the salad back you can, and we'll make you a new one without broccoli, but we'll charge you the same price as the first one." this all being said quite rudely. poor, poor, poor customer service. never ordering from them again. read more

I've lived in the neighborhood for nearly 60 years and there have been other food eateries in the strip mall. The previous owners of Bagelicious were awesome but they moved and sold the store to an awesome husband and wife team. Besides being really nice and accommodating they produce delicious food. Their bagels are huge and seeded in both sides. They have mini bagels that are awesome. They have a big selection of flavored cream cheeses. I asked for some bacon and red onion cream cheese but they had run out. Instead of saying "sorry" they pulled out a 2lb slab of cream cheese a bunch of crispy bacon, sliced red onion and made me my order right then and there-fresh! My favorite item there is the breakfast burrito with sausage on a habanero wrap! They use avocado, salsa and black beans as compliments to the rest of the sandwich-just awesome! Great people, awesome service and delicious food just as they promised! read more

nice people, reasonable prices, clean, good food, just wished they stayed open till 4