Cute little lunchenette feel diner on the main street in the village of Suffern. We were arrived at a weird time the day after Christmas & in a snow storm, we were the only ones in the place. Food was good, nothing special, service was very attentive. read more

See all

Stopped by and enjoyed the food here with my partner. The food was good although it was not exactly in line with what I anticipated based on the menu. For example: they have a fairly extensive "Mexican" menu with Juevos Rancheros on it, but they don't make ranchero salsa and basically only have Pace style Picante. For this south Texan the salsa/picante/no real Juevos rancheros was a bummer, BUT the salsa they did have tasted great and the service was wonderful. *note: I am a Spanish speaker so occasionally my experience will be different than non Spanish speakers. read more

So we went back again as now we live in the area. My hubby had their beef empanadas, you get 3 in an order. They come with a delicious sauce too. I had an excellent chicken salad sandwich and the chicken salad was freshly made with chunks of moist chicken and celery. Service is always attentive and friendly too. If you're in the area try it out, you won't be disappointed! read more

The food here was good, not great. I only had a western omelet, nothing special. The portion was fine, not small but not big, seemed about right. Although the price was a little much, other diners will give you a full plate for the same money. Service was extremely slow. I only saw two servers, but there were only 3 tables with customers. It was a beautiful day and i wanted to sit outside. They seemed unprepared for anyone to sit outside, so they moved some things around, which was not a big deal. I'm not sure if I would go back again, I just wanted to try this place out. But, I may give it another go. read more

We stopped in on our way back home from a wedding. Although there was a street fare going on while we were there, we were sat right away, and the service was good. The menu had a lot of variety to choose from, and I ended up getting a breakfast quesadilla. It was really good. I had a little bit of my daughter's pancake, and it was also very good. If I am ever in the area again, I'd stop back in. read more

Wonderful food and service! Homemade seafood soup was delicious! Omelette was cheesy.

Staff was great and attentive to the people at the tables. Breakfast was very good. They had peppers and onions mixed in the hash browns. Looking forward to more visits here. read more

Cute little place. We always stop here on our way from Wilmington DE to the Hudson Valley. Food is decent and not your run of the mill diner food. read more

Over $35 for a surf and turf, fine but at least give me a bigger piece of meat and flavor it? Three pieces of small shrimps that wasn't particularly good texture or taste. Sirloin cut that was so tiny and thin like it was sandwich meat. I had to salt it myself even though there was some kind of sauce. No vegetables at all! I know times are rough but this is near criminal how they ripped me off. read more

This little diner is so cute! The staff was really kind and the food came out hot and quick. I am a picky eater with a basic palate so I got the eggs and sausage and it was really good. My partner got the Spanish steak and the rice and beans were so yummy! Great find, we def would come back on our way through! read more

The Best Diner - Diners Near Me - Suffern, New York

They have really good potential but they have to step their game up. I recommend they clean the ice machine. Service was amazing but I did leave after my cold appetizer. I would try again only because they have potential. read more

Quick friendly service. Great food. Nice vibe. And they were really helpful in accommodating us.

Service is fine, food is ok, restaurant appears clean. Is it the best diner? definitely not. read more

Food was okay. Service was friendly. Ambiance was a bit bland. Grilled cheese sandwich was okay. I ordered chorizo with egg and avocado. It didn't come with toast, which I think they should offer. I probably will not be returning. This was our first time trying them out. It was only an average dining experience. read more

Do t let the name of this place fool you. They are not "the best diner" in my opinion. Third time I ate there and was very disappointed this last time. They are trying to be overly daring with the dishes the offer on their menu. Their chef does not know the menu descriptions and it is misleading and sadly disappointing. An "Oriental salad" should not come with mozzarella cheese and roasted pimentos with a large sprinkling of Chinese dried noodles on top. Also I ordered their matzo ball soup which I thought would be a nice spin on the classic. The matzo ball was like a rock. I could not eat it let alone even attempt to put a fork in it I also order a "salmon burger" which I expected to be a burger made out of salmon, but instead the brought me a decent size piece of salmon filet on a hamburger bun. Someone needs to check the menu and have a sit down with the chef. Their breakfast items are clearly their better items. Buyer beware! read more

This was a Indian restaurant since 1986. I was talking to the owner when I was in suffern a few weeks ago. He said they decided to switch over to being a diner. Because of the changing demographics in the area. Suffern hasn't had a diner in the downtown for over 15 years. I went in with a friend after a matinee film at the beautiful Lafayette Theatre up the street. They have a good selection of breakfast items. Raps burgers Panini's for lunch. I decided to get the cheesesteak sandwich with onions and mushrooms. It came out and looked very nice. Real slices of steak inside the fresh soft lightly toasted roll. I opted to try waffle french fries instead of the regular french fries for an up charge of $1.50. The steak was very flavorful and juicy cooked perfectly. The waffle fries were crispy and had a good potato taste inside. Service was very efficient and friendly. This is a great addition to the downtown. Definitely come here and grab some breakfast lunch or one of the dinner entrées. read more

See all

Had the broiled flounder over mashed potatoes and steamed vegetables. Best I've had in years. Service was excellent and it's a classy little neighborhood restaurant. Of course there is a phone book for a menu so you'll find something to love. read more

Avoid. Really not.worth it. Poor service and mediocre food add up to a "meh" to a "-meh" experience.

The ambiance was perfect for a date breakfast in bed I love it would recommend please

My wife and I love this place they are friendly courteous and the food is excellent we have always been a great fan of this Diner. We are always happy with them. read more

Friendly service and my eggs Benedict was very good. If you're in the area and hungry, you can make a stop there no problem.

This is a new Suffern restaurant that excites me. It's only 3 weeks old but to escribe it would be a diner that also offers Hispanic dishes. The jury is still out. But I'm so happy that we don't have to drive to Haverstraw to find some Spanish dishes. Best yet they do breakfast with traditional diner food. I wish them good luck and hopes for a successful establishment. Oh here are some wish list items: Tostones Negra Modelo better yet on tap Whole fried snapper Asopaos Can't wait to come back for breakfast. read more

The Best Diner - We're having dinner in one of the booths near the bar. - Diners Near Me - Suffern, New York

Great brunch was a very cute spot with great food, we ate outside and had a nice time.

They forgot part of our order that was delivered and they were so nice and sent it to us as another delivery. Talk about above and beyond service. Very impressed by the fantastic service. read more

Food was decent. Service was good. Prices are reasonable. They make different types of coffee. I personally did not like the coffee. My husband drank it and it upset his stomach. Overall I would go back. read more

This place was a welcome respite of peace after a day at the Route 17 malls! The service was prompt and attentive, and all of our meals were tasty with huge portions. My son ordered a side fresh fruit, and the plate was honestly beautiful. The interior feels cozy and comforting, with soft Christmas music playing. It feels like a spot from my childhood. read more

The Best Diner - My kid and my mom say "The Best Diner is great!" - Diners Near Me - Suffern, New York

I am from Syracuse area. I was attracted by high yelp score. The Diner is clean and warm; the owner is inviting and caring. I started w fresh squeezed OJ, good coffee. My Eggs Benedict was perfect, medium poached, English toasted perfectly. read more

The Best Diner - Eggs Benedict! Delish! - Diners Near Me - Suffern, New York

Price should show as $$$$. I ordered over easy eggs, came under done. To eat other than breakfast, I will have to mortage my house. 2 stars read more

The Best Diner was a pleasant surprise. It was referred to us by a friend and my wife and I were looking for a place to eat dinner in the Suffern area and decided to try our friend's suggestion. The setting and ambiance was casual, very pleasant, clean and relaxing, with decorations current for all the holidays. Soft music was playing in the background without being annoying. Service was very friendly, efficient and very professional; the food was very nicely prepared and plentiful with a great variety. I had a hot beef sandwich, she had grilled salmon. We had a slice of carrot cake; it was one of the best I ever had. The Best Diner is a hidden gem. We have been back several times since and each time had an excellent experience. It is on our now on our regular dining list. read more

Food is fresh , always . And there is such a good variety , American, Latin, and Italian . Pasta dishes are amazing , Spanish dishes are delicious . Breakfast is also wonderful!! Love the cocktails and especially the sangria red or white ! Service is great , very friendly and Efficient! They keep the decorations current for the holidays . All in all a 5 star experience. read more

For a diner, this place was fine. I had a rice with chicken that I could have eaten for two or three meals. It was very good. My husband said the men's toilet was pretty good but not the women's. They have a great variety of Spanish and Argentinian dishes and very good desserts, and what seemed like a decent bar. Service was good, uneventful as it should be. read more

It is a fairly small place but they utilize the space fairly well. The decor is a little mish-mosh, there is no set theme and none of it matches. Also not a big fan of carpeting. It's new and clean, which is a huge plus, but it's also going to get worn out very quickly. Overall it had a very clean appearance, which is good! It would be nice if there was a counter to sit at for dining, it would give it more of that traditional diner vibe. The staff was very nice. We were greeted and seated immediately, and asked for our drink orders immediately as well. Staff was attentive without hovering. Onto the food. I ordered a lot of food, lol. I got a mushroom & swiss cheese omelette, it came with home fries and toast. I ordered rye toast instead of white toast. I also ordered a side of onion rings. First off, I have to say that everything came cooked and prepared well. Nothing was under/over cooked. The toast came pre buttered with a couple of packets of jelly. The onion rings were crispy, tasty, and the onion stayed intact when you took a bite. The home fries were cooked well, but they were plain. Most places add a little onion and peppers, and there wasn't a lot of flavor. Same with the omelette, it was cooked well and was a good size omelette, it just lacked flavor. My friend got the nirvana burger, which he ordered medium rare and without the tomato, and he asked for waffle fries with it. The waffle fries were good. Kinda hard to mess those up lol. And the burger was cooked the way he asked, but he was not crazy about the type of bun they used. All in all we felt compelled to write a review because the name of this establishment suggests that we may be raving about it for years to come, and being that we're both from NYC, there would be a lot to compete with. Was this a good place? Yea not bad. Would we eat here again? If our adventures bring us up here again, sure. Is it the best diner? I would say no, it is not the best. However, I heard it was a new place, and there's plenty of time for them to improve! And I hope they do. read more

Visited here w/friends for breakfast recently and the food was fresh and the service was pleasant. Would definitely go back if in the area.

Neighborhood diner with Latin influence. We had standard diner food for lunch. Breakfast egg wrap with home fries and a chicken chipotle sandwich with French fries. Both were good. The servers were friendly. I would recommend this diner if you are in the area. read more

We've been there about half a dozen times already. For all meals. The service is great and the owner is extremely caring. Food is excellent. I highly recommend! read more

Went there this morning. Had an omelette and it was delicious. My friends was as well. The service was good. They were very nice and attentive there. read more

I rarely write reviews but had to do this one tonight. If you have not been to "The Best Diner" on Lafayette Ave in Suffern then run to it because it's AMAZING. My husband had the Steak Frites and I had the Hangover Burger and now we are sharing the homemade Flan for desert. The menu is extensive but well planned. Everything is super fresh. Seriously ... the salad that arrived with the Steak was crisp and delicious, my burger cooked to perfection and the steak was so tender. Yum yum yum.... Lots of drink specials too and the brunch on the weekend looks like one we won't miss. read more

The Best Diner - Outdoor seating - Diners Near Me - Suffern, New York

The Best Diner was a pleasant surprise. My wife and I were looking for a place to eat dinner in the Suffern area and found this very nice restaurant. The setting and ambiance was very pleasant. Service was efficient and very professional; the food was very nicely prepared. I had a pasta dish, she had arroz con pollo. I had a slice of chocolate mousse cake; it was one of the best I ever had. The Best Diner is a hidden gem. read more

Only went there one time and the food and service was very good but we need to go back again a few more times to give it a fair and realistic rating read more

The ratings for this restaurant do not align with the experience. Many of the older ratings are from when they were an Indian restaurant, which was great. But the diner experience is not great at all. I got a sandwich which was okay, but the place wasn't particularly clean and the service was also just okay. read more