Amazing! I moved out of NY 11 years ago so when I come visit, a NY bagel is a must! I got a cinnamon raisin bagel with eggs, bacon, CREAM cheese, tomato onions and spinach and wow! Messy but finger living delicious. The servers were super sweet and attentive. Was able to get a seat at a booth by myself because it's seems more like a grab and go spot. Lots of natural light. A great start to my morning. read more

Bagelry - Cinnamon raisin bagel with bacon eggs cream cheese tomato spinach and onions. Mouth explosion yummmmm - Bagels Near Me - Rockville Centre, New York

I'm not sure if the business was sold to others but I preordered bagels and sides and spoke to 3 different people. I confirmed everything would be ready for pick up the next morning at 5:30. Well.... when my husband and I came in, our order wasn't even being worked on! We had to wait, retell the order for the 5th time and then be told by the lady that we should have paid when making the order as if that was our job. Let's take accountability! Oh and they charged me more than the original price! Never again! read more

Glad they were open on Thanksgiving Day. Hubby very happy with his bagel and Lox, and I devoured my egg-cheddar-spinach on a roll ( in my earlier years it was always bacon).... Would have liked milk as a drink option; can't do yahoo anymore. read more

See all

One star - Extremely disappointed this time. I've been a regular customer here for a long time -- we always get our bagels from this place. But today was a whole different story. The guy in the red shirt (staff) was rude, clearly in a bad mood, and made the whole experience super uncomfortable. No smile, no basic courtesy, just attitude. Honestly, I don't come here to deal with someone else's bad day. Totally unprofessional. I won't be coming back after this. read more

See all

Bagels are good. But in the last few months, this man with glasses started working behind the counter and he is extremely rude. It used to be all women who were all pleasant to deal with. Not sure why they started allowing this man with glasses have a prominent role but he makes the whole experience miserable. read more

I will never crush a place with 1 star. However this is a one and done for me . It's obvious the owner never shows their face here. If they moved any slower, time would move backwards . Egg sandwich was absolute rubbish. Bagel was so dry it was silly . The bagel with pepper & garlic cream cheese was terrible. Bagel dry to the bone. I leave 5 stars so the owner reads this and hopefully gets their act together over there, instead of showing up at end of day to pick up the cash. I put this on the owner . Workers were very nice. They moved at a snails pace but nice. read more

Bagelry - Garlic bagel with pepper & garlic cream cheese - Bagels Near Me - Rockville Centre, New York

See all

Tried they're mini bagel with veggie cream cheese and its bland. Ive had better bagels and cream cheese. Service was good but store was a bit cold read more

Good bagels but the place is really dirty. Last time I went there, a small bug on the counter when I paid. Unsettling but gave them another chance today, same tiny clear bugs, so I left and went to Cino's in Oceanside (not bad). The Bagelry owner should invest in an exterminator as soon as possible. You're welcome. Unfortunately, this is common place for the eateries in the area, overall quality of food, service and atmosphere declining as prices skyrocket. And don't blame it on a political party. Not enough competition and the bar is set low Gave it another shot, same see-through bugs on the counter , but more this time. banned. Going to Cino's in Oceanside for bagels now. read more

This is the local bagel shop I go to when I need to get bagels quickly. I haven't ordered anything else but I am sure it is good since there are always people in the store when I am there. Staff is friendly and the bagels are fresh. read more

Good spot for a bacon egg and cheese. Decent line in the morning, but it moves pretty quickly. Plenty of staff there to make things move smoothly. read more

See all

Son gobbled up bagel and butter and said it was soooo good Will return when in the area. read more

Review based strictly on the quality of the bagel. Having a family member who opened up multiple bagel bakeries in the 90's, I can say these are pretty close to perfection. Not big and fluffy like the other bagel joints. Crispy outer texture with the right amount of yeasty flavor in the middle. No need to "scoop" it out. Enjoy read more

Nothing special at all. I asked the counter staff not to cut my sons bagel they still did. The bagels are smaller then usual bagels and a bit tough. Fresh but tough if that makes sense. Ice coffee was hard to mess up with some pumps of caramel. Would Not come again! read more

So the food is good which would have given 4-5 stars but i ordered 2x this past weekend and both orders were WRONG! The first order was missing one scone when I ordered two and both sandwiches were supposed to be on flats which I paid extra, which didn't come on flats the next day I ordered again and I called up the store just to make sure and a young lady answered and said she would take care of it. On this order, which was the exact same order for which I paid extra for the two flats ,for the two sandwiches ,and they would check, on the receipt there were check marks but no one actually looked and apparently checked by a young lady, they put plain bagels. On both days I paid extra and on both days I was shorted. What's worse as I called up and the young lady said she would double check it herself. I don't want anything, but I'll never order from them again. read more

They routinely get the order wrong, like every time somehow. The bagels are good because they are different from anywhere else, but getting the order wrong is pretty maddening. read more

When the old owner was there this was my go to place. The bagels seem the same and that's good but they do not understand orders so well and they round up the change. For example I ordered something that came out to be 1194 they called it 12 dollars. Now I know that's not a lot but if I am one person and they do this all day they have e made Probably an extra 10-15 dollars on customers. It's a shame because as I said this was a good place for bagels. I think your better off some where else! read more

Ordered Uber eats from this place classic bacon, egg, and cheese and added and extra side of sausage this is the best breakfast sandwich I've ever had period this place is official! If you're looking for a great breakfast place this is your spot can't speak about anything else other than their hot chocolate which I ordered as well and was great no complaints. Hope this helps enjoy. read more

If you need a bagel or an egg Sammy in a jiffy but want a soft chewy delightful bagel too. Well lookie here and never regret a thing. They're delicious. Soft and flavorful. read more

have to say this place got better.. coffee was not chunky and it was very good the bagel was soft and chewy... try a bec with a hash brown best thing i've put in my mouth read more

Bagelry - Bagels Near Me - Rockville Centre, New York

Bagels are average at best, usually a long wait. They are very busy, so at least one thing is guaranteed the bagels are fresh.

Decided to try a new bagel shop this week. They have these mini bagels which I think is a genius idea actually. I am not the type of finish a regular bagel in one seating, but I can eat a mini bagel. I bought a few of the mini ones. They have an ample selection of cream cheeses, and I went with the Lox and also raisin Walnut. I would have tried Tuna salad on a bagel but the tuna salad looked too mushed up...like the tuna has been pulverized and the batch just looked "creamy" for my liking. Next day the bagels were a bit hardened which was a bit of disappointment. I did pop it back into toaster and it softened back up a bit but not still sorta hard. The bagels I normally get at the other shop stays soft for a few days after purchase. These were the mini-bagels not sure if that's the way the regular sized bagels perform. If you are buying bagels to eat right then, sure. But if not, you may end up some hard bagels the next day. Lots of cream cheeses and they have then in the fridge to go as well. read more

Always a quick go to when there's no other options. The prices are non existent and apparently memorized by staff...but I've compared receipts and they're never the same amount. Is it a big deal to me? No. But just to be aware. My favorite order is a plain or cinnamon raisin bagel with vegetable or scallion cream cheese. I've had a bagel egg sandwich before but after paying $14 for it with a large iced tea I just get the aforementioned.. read more

The new owners are doing a very good job. The bagels are fresh and the line moves fast. I have witnessed something that I believe is disturbing at least 3 times. The first time was around Christmas a woman handed a 10 dollar tip to the woman that manages instead of putting in the jar she looked around for the help and put in her pocket I have seen her do this a couple other times with bigger tips. She always looks around before stuffing her pocket. These workers work hard. read more

Honestly, I thought I can save money by going into the store. Imagine my shock to the price of two bacon egg and cheese on a roll is $17.47. Which are on DoorDash for $7 each. Highly don't recommend going to this store but door dashing it because they be punching in any total price and it's not fair. The sandwich's are good. read more

See all

I love the Bagelry's bagels! They're super flavorful, the perfect chewiness, and when you get them warm, basically perfect. They have both bagels and flats (if you like more surface area for your toppings, but less fluffy insides), and a good assortment of cream cheeses and other toppings, as well as fixings for sandwiches. They also have a lot of pastries, if you're in the mood for something sweet. It's a small shop, so I recommend planning on getting your bagels to go. Parking can be hard, but that's basically true of every business in the area. read more

Wow. 17 dollars for six bagels and a little thing of cream cheese. The cream cheese is decent but basically tastes like temptee. 10 dollars for a little thing of cream cheese. These guys are thief's. read more

Bagelry - 10 dollars for a little thing of cream cheese. What a ripoff. - Bagels Near Me - Rockville Centre, New York

I really hate to say it, but the customer service has gone down a lot since the old owner sold to a group of the employees. The new owners simply do not know, or care, enough about customer service. They do not acknowledge you when you walk in and make you wait unnecessarily. They allow people they know cut the line. Overall, my last several experiences have been so uncomfortable I am not going back. The bagels, while generally good (not great), do not warrant such an unpleasant experience in ordering. I have expressed my frustration to them too. If the owners review social media posting and see postings such as this, I hope for their sake they improve. But they've lost a long-time customer. read more

Been on the hunt for a new bacon, egg, and cheese spot and think I finally found it. Bagels are soft, eggs taste fresh, and my sandwich has always been piled high with bacon overflowing. I do wish the cheese was melted a little more. It's consistently never fully melted but the sandwich is still near perfect. Great place! read more

Bagelry - Bagels Near Me - Rockville Centre, New York

I didn't know what I was doing, giving this only three stars years ago. The owners and staff are attentive and hard working. Bagels are warm and fresh. Their bialys are perfect! The spreads are the best in the area. The spreads distinguish them from competing bagel places. Besides, this is The Bagelry! read more

Bagelry - Bagels Near Me - Rockville Centre, New York

UPDATE 5/20 I'm not sure if management highlighted my feedback to the delivery staff, but this morning's delivery was MUCH more pleasant. Just a simple phone call: 'Hey, Victoria your delivery is here - at the front door' 'Oh great, thank you so much' 'No problem, have a good day dear' So much nicer, and no stress, thank you for listening to customer feedback. ------------------------ ORIGINAL: I regularly order from here, and am happy to say the sandwiches are tasty and fresh every time. Coffee isn't bad either, which is a nice bonus. So that there is no confusion in my review, my ratings are as follows: Food: 4 stars Delivery Service: 2 stars (I'm more inclined to give 1 star, but feel it isn't fair to the kitchen staff who are making the food) Unfortunately, the one thing that's going to knock an otherwise 4 or 5 star review down to a 3 is the friendliness of the delivery driver. Pretty sure I get the same guy when I order delivery, and he is consistently impatient, tense, and irritable. Back in the day when delivery guys could go into my apartment building and knock on my door, he would knock once, and if I didn't happen to hear him or come running right away, he would bang LOUDLY on the door and call me - making his displeasure abundantly clear before handing me my delivery bag and turning on his heel to walk out. I would barely be able to utter a 'thank you, have a good one' before his back was turned and walking away from me. And that's after we got through the debacle of getting him through the intercom system. It's the same instructions on every order: dial xxx to be buzzed in. He likely doesn't look at the instructions (fair enough, delivery is a busy 'get going, get in, get out' kind of job), but at LEAST, when he calls my cell phone, he could try not to yell at me 'hey! I'm here! Your food! Can you come down or something?! - What do you mean dial the intercom, I called you!!' *once again, this was before the contactless delivery measures were put in place. My delivery experience this morning was just as poor, but I would be wasting time detailing that one Always rude, always irritated, always unpleasant to deal with. I literally hesitate to order from here every time because I don't like dealing with their curmudgeonly delivery guy. BUT, the bagels and sandwiches are good, so I'm a return customer. It would be appreciated if management could (nicely) remind delivery staff to act decently with customers. read more

Straight up garbage my wife got sick as a dog . Had a bagel with tuna salad and then had food poisoning. Last time going to this place. read more

The bagels are good, service is spotty. No prices anywhere. Definitly over priced. Only reason we came here it was conveniently located.

Bagel sandwiches big enough to feed two people. Prompt service. Fresh bagels. New go to spot.

The ham egg and cheese on a flagel that I got here was out of this WORLD. This place is everything I look for in a Long Island bagel place-- the service was quick (even with a long line), my flagel was perfectly toasted, and the cheese perfectly melted. Other reviews mention the price being expensive, but since I'm used to city prices, I would be more than happy to pay the price I paid for my bagel! But of course, the bagels in San Francisco don't even come close, so I won't be buying any bagels out here. Maybe I can get my bagelry bagel shipped out here. read more

See all

I have never had a decent order from this place. When I was pregnant they refused to toast a bagel for me because "why would you want to ruin a fresh bagel". It's my bagel I can "ruin" it if I want to? My husband got breakfast this morning and it was inedible. Overly greasy, runny eggs, raw bacon cheese only melted in some areas, flattest roll which was also soggy. The BEC is a New York delicacy I don't understand how you can screw it up so badly. read more

Bagelry - The worst BEC in the tristate area - Bagels Near Me - Rockville Centre, New York

As of lately, this place has increased their prices, making it one of the more expensive bagel shops in the region, while selling nearly average bagels for the price. To give a brief break down of their prices since they don't make them easily available to customers, their bagels are around $4.25 with cream or whatever regular spread you would like, so the bagels by themselves are around $3.90. Coffee and other drinks are at most $2.50, and their sandwichs range from $5.50 to $10 depending on what you are getting. As for their pastries, their at most $2.50, containers of cream cheese are around $10, and other miscellaneous items range anywhere from $2 to a little over $10. As for the quality of the bagels, they are made fresh from decent ingredients, but get hard very quickly. I've gone here early and later in the day and the bagels, and earlier is definitely the way to go, especially if you get your bagel toasted, less you want a hard to chew bagel. There have been cases where they've overcooked the bagels, and there also have been cases where the bagels vary drastically in size. There have also been cases where the bagels tasted as if they had been frozen overnight, and defrosted for the next day.The bagels overall have a nearly bland to salty taste, often a bit tough, and require a lot of napkins. They use a good chunk of cream cheese, often on the salty side, so if you get a bagel that contains rock salt you may not be too please. Their coffee is a step above a mr.coffee machine and their pastries are store bought. Their sandwichs tend to be very good and are very densely loaded so they maybe the best value, just make sure they charge you the right amount. Overall, this place gets 2 stars because its very overpriced. so here are some tips. First- don't buy any fish product as they have not been known to be the most fresh, second- don't buy their containers of cream cheese, at $10 for maybe an 8oz container its certainly not a good value proposition, third- double check with the person helping you about pricing, sometimes they have been known to overcharge by more than a few dollars, fourth- be prepared to spend quite a bit of money, I've seen people come in and spend well over $20 for a few items, fifth- if you are coming here early in the day, be prepared to what quite a bit of time, even with 5 other people in line in takes over 10 minutes, lastly- perhaps don't tip, especially if you feel compelled by seening other customers tipping, you never know if your experience here will just be them taking your money and never saying another word to you, or them actually respecting your money and service, especially at their high prices. read more

Overpriced place. Never buy cream cheese from these people they will bleed you 10 bucks for a little container that doesn't even cover 6 bagels. There are plenty of decent places for bagels so you don't have to go to this one. read more

Finally a New York City style bagel in Long Island. I really enjoyed this place. The line was long but it moved quickly.

I order here a lot and they are very good at following detailed instructions. Had a problem maybe 1 out of 10 times. They have tasty food and good coffee read more

The BEST bagels in Nassau County. PERIOD! Great crust, chewy inside and if you like garlic bagels -- this is the place to get them. They also make a great "flat" bagel covered (both sides), in their wonderful seeds (except for garlic.) The do all sorts of eggs / bacon sandwiches all day long and have a nice selection of prepared salads (i.e. tuna, egg, chicken, etc.) Nice selection of cream cheeses, good coffee, and they have a refrigerated case with a variety of drinks, lox and other toppings to take home (although a bit expensive.) They have a nice selection of "mishes" (green salad with chicken salad, etc. and a made to order green salad bar. They have GREAT staff there and take really good care of you. But they still NEED a GARLIC FLAT to add to their line-up of yummy bagels. read more