One of the better bagel stores in the area; always has been. Calling your order and they will have it ready when you arrive and for the most part, they are accurate. Delicious bagels and many other options of appetizing that is fresh and delicious as the name would suggest. If anything, a small nitpick is that sometimes they don't alert you to little things like the fact that they very nicely will give you a drink soda or a bottle of water if you order a sandwich; of course it's no great charity because the sandwiches are today's prices. But there's other times if you bring a drink to the register that they might not mention the inclusivity of a drink in your order, which isn't exactly a great policy. read more

Bagelicious - For the price, at least you get an unhealthy amount of bacon. - Bagels Near Me - East Meadow, New York

Food has been really good & now the atmosphere is great. New owner is doing all the right things! read more

Bagelicious - Looking good! - Bagels Near Me - East Meadow, New York

I'm done with this place. I've been going to Bagelicious since the 1980s, and even after moving to California 20 years ago, I'd stop by every time I was in town to grab breakfast and a dozen bagels to take back. I've recommended it to countless people, but that ends now. On Tuesday, January 6, 2026, I picked up egg sandwiches and bagels to bring home, and every single one had hair in the dough--or maybe plastic fibers from the mixing equipment. It was so obvious that I can't understand how no one noticed while making them or cutting them for the sandwiches I ordered. Did something fall into the mixer? Long Island is full of great bagel shops, and on my next visit, I'll be trying a different spot. Farewell Bagelicious read more

I asked for cream cheese with chives, and I got cream cheese with scallions that were definitely old and tasted nasty I also noticed on the window that they had several bags packed up and marked for events in the next few days Meaning, the bagels in those bags are going to be nice and stale by the time those bagels get to wherever they have to go. I'm done with this place It's a whole new management The girl at the register had no personality has lousy customer service. read more

Great service! Very tasty bagels, I would say the whole wheat everything is my favorite. They offer mini bagels, and one free mini bagel to babies which is very sweet! Ambiance is a regular bagel place read more

We love coming here. The bagels are always fresh & delicious. They are very friendly and the way the place is set up it is easy to help yourself to their delicious coffee while you wait for them to prepare your order. read more

Simple bagel sandwich order wrong!! Chaotic system. No wonder why orders get screwed up. Girl at register with no personality. Used to like going here. Not anymore!! read more

The food is just acceptable. Each day you don't know how it is going to come out. The service is week. No ac in the summer. Barely any ventilation. read more

Completely messed up the entire order didnt give me what I asked at all burnt the bagels to a char almost and very rude and gave me a expired coffee would not recommend going anywhere near this place the food was terrible and way to over priced never go there go to figs deli read more

As a former Long Islander, I ALWAYS make the stop at Bagelicious when I am back in town. I mean - you just have to! This is exactly what you are looking for if you are seeking a LI bagel cafe. Tons of bagel and spread options, baked goods, sandwiches, you name it. The best part (to me) is the group of older men who meet here in the mornings for coffee and to hang out. They are just adorable and #goals. My favorite is their poppy bagel with scallion cream cheese, but you really can't go wrong! read more

Bagelicious - Poppyseed bagel with scallion cream cheese - Bagels Near Me - East Meadow, New York

What a gem! All you folks who give this less than 5 Stars need to understand how fortunate you are to have this place in your backyard. We live in Georgia and there is nothing like this place . Bagel selection is extensive, fresh and delicious . The spreads are delectable and great service. Multiple coffee options. The owner is friendly and helpful as well as prone to throwing in an extra bagel for free! I have come here every time I visit the area ( used to live in Uniondale) . So good we're taking a done back to Georgia today.. wish I could take the whitefish salad too! read more

I ordered a mini bagel at 8 am. My mini bagel was not hot or warm. I asked if they have any hot bagels, mini, or regular bagels. He said they were made around 5 am. I dont see why they don't have warm or hot bagels around this time. I took the mini bagel anyway. he went to the cash register and took my money. After my transaction, I realized he wasn't wearing gloves. And took another customer. I realized they must have changed ownership. I didn't recognize the people. read more

Been there a few times . In my area ao I go there a lot. Good food and fast service every time I would tell others to check out

It's really the only place open early to get breakfast on a bagel. It's definitely convenient & staff is friendly. It's a little on the pricey end but at least I can buy breakfast early in the mornings. read more

Do not get bagels from this place. Been buying bagels there 30+ years! New owners are out to screw you.Always buy dozens of bagels. She tells me 2 bagels free + 1/2 lb cream cheese. At checkout tries to charge me for 1/2 lb cream cheese. NEW OWNERSHIP IS SNEAKY! ZERO CUSTOMER SKILLS! read more

I recently visited Bagelicious with my family the other day, and I couldn't have been more impressed. I ordered the everything bagel with the veggie cream cheese and it was amaaaazing. Unlike other places that sell you stale and dry bagels, they go above and beyond to ensure quality and taste. I also got the freshly squeezed orange and really enjoyed that as well. The workers are also so nice and friendly. Will defiantley be returning to try their wraps soon! read more

Best bagels in the East Meadow area. Lots of delicious add ons to choose from. Staff are always friendly and welcoming. Plenty of seating available. Most importantly and the reason why I keep going back is the proper infection control they practice. Staff will change gloves each time they handle foods and will never touch the register or tables with gloves on. read more

The quality of the food was at best mediocre, especially for the price point. To make matters even worse the place was filthy. The tables were not cleaned off, the floor was littered, and the garbage cans were overflowing. We should have left before we ordered. Will definitely not go back. read more

Having been a part of the neighborhood for over 15 years, this establishment used to be the epitome of a perfect bagel spot: clean, friendly, and fast--the qualities that drew people from all corners of Long Island. However, my recent visit revealed a stark contrast under its new ownership. The once pristine atmosphere has been replaced with a disheartening sight of filth, with overflowing trash cans cluttering the dining area and a shared coffee station marred by the remnants of last week's use. It's a disappointing departure from the excellence this place was known for. Feel free to chalk me up as a "hater" but it's GROSS. Call the health inspector. read more

Solid bagel, I also got a cinnamon roll as well snd that was great too. Bagels came out fast even thought it was busy. read more

Bagelicious - Everything bagel, sausage, egg and cheese - Bagels Near Me - East Meadow, New York

Really can't recommend this spot for bagels. Just bought 2 bagel sandwiches and 2 drinks totaling $14.05. I asked for a cheese bagel with tomato and mayo. I got a bagel which wasn't really fresh with 1 piece of cheese and tomato. My husband was smart enough to ask for extra cheese. He got 2 pieces of cheese instead of one. Really? That is the best they could do? For $14.05. We could have gotten 2 sandwiches from a deli for that or could have went to subway for a hero with fresh bread. That is our last trip to Bagelicious. There are other options that will include more that 1 piece of cheese on a sandwich. read more

Bagelicious - Actual receipt of purchase. - Bagels Near Me - East Meadow, New York

Idk if the owner changed recently but this place sucks now. Got a dozen bagels and it came out to over 20 bucks and I questioned it and they now charge more for rainbow bagels. I said I'll just take plain. They changed it but only gave me 12, you get 2 extra, then proceeded to argue with me saying there were 14 in there. Then they counted. Will be finding a new bagel spot cause this ain't it anymore! read more

The bagels here are outrageusly fresh and tasty. So are the spreads. There is a large selection of coffees and pastries too. The staff are very friendly and helpful. I always get the same thing: Everything bagel, scallion cream cheese, lettuce, and tomato. It's so delicious that I ignore the temptations to try the other delectable looking items. Maybe next time.... read more

See all

I love their bagels. My usual is an egg bagel with egg salad, small cole slaw and a regular coffee. They have so many different kinds of bagels it is often a hard choice. They also have delicious breakfasts from pancakes to omelets. For lunch they have delicious salads such as chicken and tuna salads. They also have a nice selection of freshly made coffees. read more

This place sucks now it used to be a great place orders are wrong. They do not put enough food on the bagels charge you $30 for an egg salad and a bacon, egg and cheese I will never go back read more

I usually enjoy this place a lot, and had a good experience for the past few years but as of late their customer service has significantly decreased. For example, placing me on a 10 minute hold twice in a row for a pick up order is not ok. We arrived at the place and there were less than four people in the store and employees were chatting.... Aside from bad customer service, I do enjoy their food and coffee. read more

I tried this place once and didn't like it, but I don't jump to Yelp because I had a bad experience. I showed to the barbershop a little early and figured I'd give them another shot while I waited, they didn't win me over. I don't like ketchup with my eggs and they did me dirty. Attached is my order and what I got. Disappointed... twice. read more

Bagelicious - Bagels Near Me - East Meadow, New York

See all

Thinnest layer of cream cheese I have seen. Got three bagels and all three had a tiny spread. The owner, at the register, was in the phone and not even paying attention to customers and had a rude demeanor. This place has gone downhill with these new owners. The old owners ran this business so much better. Too bad for the neighborhood. read more

Great place for breakfast. Extensive menu and fast service all at a reasonable price. Easy parking too! read more

Bagelicious - Bagelicious Bistro - Bagels Near Me - East Meadow, New York

Trying to find our local bagel shop, the line was out the door. I thought we had a winner, but the people were off on this one. The bagels were thin and just didn't have the NY appeal. I will have to keep looking. read more

Bagels are average at best. Everything is excessively overpriced and then to make it worse they charge 4% credit card fee. Asked for a bacon egg and cheese on toasted bagel it wasn't toasted. Counter lady had an attitude. Tables and napkin holder were all worn out, dirty and beat up looking. read more

Delicious in the morning. Fresh bagel great bacon egg and cheese sandwich. French Toast was too pricey for 2 pieces. Ample butter and syrup were appreciated. Cinnamon bagels were deeeeelicious. read more

Bagels - five stars. Lox spread - five stars. Customer service - five stars. Been enjoying their bagels since 1989. read more

If I can give zero stars I would. I stopped going here to try the new bagel place in town toasted, I don't know which is worse. It's a fight of competition to see which bagel store can taste worse then the other an mess up the order. Such a simple request for an egg sandwich to mess up read more

Well I think the pictures speak for itself. They put mad egg in my sandwich and 2 pieces of bacon... I don't even like eggs like that. I don't know how they are always busy if they suck. Last time I go there lol. read more

Bagelicious - Bagels Near Me - East Meadow, New York

See all

It's good but the everything bagels are a tad too salty for my liking. Other than that the staff are polite and you get your order quick

What a sed excuse for an egg sandwich... if you can't nail a BEC on long island I really dont have much faith in your competence read more

Bagelicious - Bagels Near Me - East Meadow, New York

This place is great! Busy in the morning but still got immediate and great service. Food was good too. Will be back

Best bagel I've ever had! The lox is so fresh and the cream cheese is the perfect consistency, definitely my go to for bagels!

Solid bagel store, amazing workers, great bagels. Bagels could be a bit bigger though