Tried it once, was extremely sub par. Then I saw a delivery truck dropping off their bagels one day.... Go to Bordentown bagels! They're way fresher and like 3 min away. 3/10, will never go back here again tbh. read more

This place seriously needs a deep cleaning--everything felt dirty and unkempt. The platter I received was unappetizing: just a pile of meat with overcooked eggs thrown on top. To make matters worse, they only provided flimsy plastic utensils that couldn't even cut through the food. I ended up having to eat with my hands, which honestly felt cleaner than anything else in the restaurant. I'd strongly recommend going somewhere else. read more

Bagel House And More - I'm not sure what this brown slime is running down ! - Bagels Near Me - Hamilton Twp, New Jersey

Service is terrible. Twice I asked them to pre-slice my bagels and they didn't do it but they charged me $.31 per bagel to do it.

Amazing food. Tuna salad is always made fresh Order may take a while but it's always fresh made, hot, and worth the wait read more

Service was great. Staff is friendly, attentive, and considerate. Sandwhich lacked some flavor but was overall decent for the price. Cute eating area with chalk to leave your mark for bagel lovers alike to see. read more

Bagel House And More - Sausage, egg, and cheese on a toasted French toast bagel - Bagels Near Me - Hamilton Twp, New Jersey

Food is fantastic. Service was good/helpful, I had a big order that I made online so I did have to wait 2-3 minutes while they finished packing the order. Ambiance is nice, it's like an average NJ bagel shop inside; it's not trying to be something that it isn't, which I can appreciate. Can't beat the prices especially for the quality and portions of the food. Highly recommend this place. read more

Driving by We decided to stop to get a bagel as we've never been here before. Bagels were very good. Crisp on the outside and soft on the inside. Just the right amount of cream cheese. But the star of the show ended up being the crumb cake that we purchased at the register. The crumb to cake ratio was ridiculous in the best way possible. Definitely the best crumb cake in town. read more

Customer service was perfect, such a sweet little bagel and food shop! Ate the bagels inside of the little shop, and loved the ambiance and the interior! Food was absolutely perfect! I recommend the bagel breakfast sandwich! read more

Bagel House And More - a bagel sandwich wrapped in foil - Bagels Near Me - Hamilton Twp, New Jersey

This is normally the GO TO weekend bagel spot. Cash only. But great bagels and breakfast sandwiches. For some reason today we waited nearly 25 min for 3 breakfast sandwiches. And when they called us one was missing. The line continued to build and more and more people were getting upset for waiting so long. The manual ordering process. Pay whenever system. Take as a many orders as possible without a POS system makes errors highly likely. It's disheartening because we frequently go here. We go here and then get coffee at Dunkin' and the amount of time we wasted here today negates any benefit of the bagel quality. read more

Bagel House And More - Long line - Bagels Near Me - Hamilton Twp, New Jersey

We live close so not only is that part of the convenience, however, the staff is always friendly, they call if something is out of stock they always call to notify. We have tried other bagel places that have had good reviews and this place is much better!! read more

Great service, Great Food! Enjoyed the egg sandwiches as well as the Italian sub! Located close to the ball park and was a great on the go place! Eat in or take out! Perfect read more

THE BEST BAGELS IN MERCER COUNTY. They texture and weight of the bagels are just right and they aren't I really dough-y, if that makes sense lol read more

Bagel House & More (formally known as bagels and beyond) has been under new ownership since fall of 2021. The new owner is great. I'm born and raised in NYC and these bagels can go toe to toe with almost any bagel in the big apple. If they don't have something on their menu just ask, they'll be more than happy to see if they can make it. I asked the owner what he would recommend and he said a jalapeño cheese bagel with veggie cream cheese. The bagel was soft and airy on the inside and you could taste the cheese crust with a little heat from the jalapeños. The cream cheese had awesome flavor but didn't have that dense heavy cream cheese feel. I'm going to be eating here often. read more

The workers here are so friendly... The food is absolutely delicious! my favorite bagel is from here! Everywhere else I go they do too much cream cheese so I always have to get it on the side, but here they do it absolutely perfect! They have never let me down!!! read more

Let me preface by saying that this is my first visit to Bagels and Beyond. They came highly recommended from a family member, especially because of their gluten free bagels. I placed an online order last night for 4 breakfast sandwiches, 1 being a gluten free one that I was so excited to try! I received my order confirmation via email and left in the morning to pick up my order for Father's Day. Well, to my dismay - they never received my order, even after I received a confirmation that my order was received. Honestly, I felt like an idiot. Apparently the manager who gets online orders never sent it in? Huh? I get accidents happen, especially in this time of COVID, and I wanted to give them some grace, but the way you approached it and made it seem like I ordered my bagel sandwiches in LBI and not in your store left a terrible taste in my mouth. Especially considering the fact that you are doing online orders to minimize contact with customers because of COVID - get your acts together! P.S. They were fresh out of gluten free bagels. So no breakfast sandwich for me despite pre-ordering! They ended up making my sandwiches, and messed up the 3 orders I gave them. This first impression will certainly be my last. Honestly, not worth the hassle, and their bagels according to my family were sub-par. Go to Caesar's in Hamilton. Better quality and better customer service. read more

Excellent service and delicious food! The entire staff was so friendly and polite. The bacon on my sandwich was nice and crispy. The bagel itself was awesome too. Will definitely be back! read more

Bagel House And More - Everything bagel scooped out with bacon, egg, and cheese - Bagels Near Me - Hamilton Twp, New Jersey

See all

Showed up 20 minutes before close (I know I am horrible) but this pregnant lady really wanted a pork roll egg snd cheese bagel. There were no more bagels and they were closing up shop. I was totally okay with going somewhere else because I knew lol what a jackass for showing up this close to closing time. The gentleman at the front asked what I wanted, I responded and he went back and made it with no hesitation. This really made my day and it's nice to see there are still nice people in the world. && to top it off the bagel sandwich was delicious!!!!!! read more

Bagels and Beyond is the nearest bagel joint to my new office, so I was pleased to discover that they turn out a very good rounder. The shop is unassuming, but has a steady flow of business. Once I realized that parking was on the north side of the building (U-turn required), I was able to get in and out in 5 minutes. Their bagels are airy inside with a pleasant crunch and chew exterior. They know not to over knead the dough, which makes the innards too dense. They also use ample toppings (like my dried onion nibs), so if you lose a few in handling it is not a great loss. Of course, there is the great joy of dabbing the cream cheese or butter on the bagel into the windfall flakes and eating them. The folks working there are friendly and efficient. The coffee hot and fresh. The breakfast sandwiches looked good, too. B & B will become a regular stop on my breakfast circuit, especially when I need to eat at my desk. read more

See all

I only give them one star because there is nothing lower. I have been here three times since the new owners took over. All three times I called ahead and arrived about ten minutes later. All three times my order was not ready and when I did receive it the hit food was already cold. I also had to wait 10/10 and 20 minutes for my food. This may have been expected if there were people in the store but all three times there were less than three people in line when I arrived. I will never go back! read more

There bagels are good, new ownership allowed credit cards which was great. The service which was already mediocre somehow got even worse. They get my order wrong 95% of the time, which is mind boggling. They also take a ridiculous amount of time to make a sandwich. If you want to start your day in a bad mood, please frequent this place, they will make sure you leave unsatisfied. read more

Great bagels and delicious sandwiches and wraps. I love their bacon! Really good quality for a bagel joint read more

Terrible food very unsanitary found hair in my sandwich they put a half pound of cheese on a sandwich to make it look big. they screwed up a very simple one person order which I had to wait 20 minutes for a breakfast sandwich. highly recommend bringing your money else where I know I will never go there again ceasars in Hamilton is much better and more professional and a lot a cleaner read more

I stopped in here early morning on the way to my grandparents house for breakfast. I got a plain bagel toasted with cream cheese. This place should not be in business. I am not exactly sure how you can even call this a bagel. Bagels should never be this small and this undercooked. When I am considering going across the street to Dunkin' for breakfast...that's sad. Seriously not even worth a review but couldn't give zero stars. read more

Waited almost 20 minutes at a relatively slow time to see people ordering after me served before me only to get a cold pork roll sandwich with the cheese not melted that I needed to finish cooking when I got home. I won't be back read more

I continue to enjoy this bagel shop, the customer service is beyond excellent! Last week I was short $3 they let me leave with my full order (some of it was chips/muffins- I found that to be incredible in this day and time - and while I returned in less than 24hrs to pay my "tab" I still really appreciated the gesture of kindness. read more

Bagels and beyond is a compassionate and kind operation. They have come to my aide when I was recovering from covid-19. Delivered items to my door that I could not get anywhere else. Their onion bagels can't be beat and the best tuna salad you've ever tasted. Thank you owner Steve. Your the best!!! read more

Their bagels are very good and everything we've ever had from there has been good especially their tuna salad. But this review isn't just about the food. During thus COVID crisis my recovering sister called just on a whim to see if they would deliver (they don't as a rule do so). Well they did and the delivery person was none other than the owner. They now have customers for life read more

I just want to give a huge SHOUT OUT Bagels & Beyond in Yardville!! I drove all the way from Mount Laurel today to find an open bagel shop and stumbled upon this hidden gem. When it comes to the way I like my bagel prepared they had no objection to burning my bagel the way I like it. (Garlic bagel charred/blackened pretty much burnt beyond recognition with a slather of butter). They made it perfectly. Just want to say thank you for being opened during these uncertain times for us all read more

Must be under new (and inexperienced) management. Bagels now tiny. One totally white uncooked and almost wet frozen. Line to return stuff as long as line to order. Never again. Worth the bad experience to cross it off my list. read more

SHORT REVIEW : YOU MUST EAT HERE AS SOON AS POSSIBLE. Long Review : My husband just stopped here this morning to grab a bagel before we headed out for the morning. Now, I pass this place every day and have never stopped in. Always see cars outside though, it just looks like a local hole-in-the-wall. I still can't vouch for the interior, as I stayed in the car when he ran in - but at 9am he said every table was full and there was a line. One bite of that bagel and I know why. He got an egg bagel that had a slice of tomato baked in, with provolone cheese and minced garlic (baked in as well). Cream cheese was his choice of spread. Now, I've never considered my husband a foodie in any way, but I suppose it took the right food. This was the best bagel either of us had ever, ever had. He was willing to let me take 1/2, but I just let him have his moment and devour the whole thing. I pass here every day and will not let one more slip by without a visit. read more

I have been getting bagels here for as long as I can remember. It's close and does the job most of the time. The coffee is great. However, my order does get messed up at least 50% of the time. This morning I added three bagels: one toasted with cream cheese, one with butter and one sandwich. After waiting over 15 minutes, when I got home I realized they both had cream cheese, which I cant eat and had to throw away. Be warned: there is typically a long wait and always check your order before you leave. read more

I love this place! The bagels are ALWAYS FRESH! They make incredible breakfast sandwiches and they have the best french toast bagels I've ever had. I'm from North Jersey, so we know bagels! These are the best bagels in Mercer County! The only downside, they only accept CASH. These days, not too many people carry cash around anymore. I usually have to stop at an ATM machine before I go just to have some cash on hand. There is also plenty of seating (tables & chairs) if you would like to eat in. read more

Slow and disorganized. Lets start with the bad. I ordered a bagel with peanut butter and a porkroll with cheese, it took 30 minutes to get my order. The staff doesn't seem to be able to multitask and take multiple orders. Instead they take one to two orders at a time while lines mount. Be aware that they are cash only, there is an ATM inside but be prepared to pay $2.50 in surcharges. Now for the good. Overall the food is good and what you would expect from a bagel shop. There is a good variety of bagels to choose from as well as a small section of doughnuts. Overall I feel this place survives by being the only bagel/breakfast place in the area. Things like porkroll should not take 30 minutes to cook. read more

Bagel House And More - Bagels Near Me - Hamilton Twp, New Jersey

My Personally crafted favorites: 1.Bacon, egg, and cream cheese on a toasted sesame bagel. -Will blow your top off... 2.Porkroll, egg, and jalapeño cream cheese on a french toast bagel. -Will rock your world... Breakfast sandwiches are off the charts... Once you go beyond the bagel you will become a loyal customer for life. They are willing to create any combination of breakfast meat, egg, and cheese that you wish on any one of their amazing bagels. They offer much more than just bagels. Subs/hoagies are also out of this world, fully customizable with a nice healthy portion. Get nice and full for a decent price. Well priced. Friendly service. Heavenly bagels. read more

Very disappointed with delivery person. Gives me hard time when's he delivers to us. Needs learn manners. Or find another one to deliver.

Nice and clean atmosphere! Very artistic owner the bagels are fresh the sandwiches are good very pleasant. The customer service could be better I asked today if there was any hot chocolate and instead of him making it for me he said the machine didn't have any and he continued to charge me my bagel . read more

good bagels but they are always late! don't let the open at 6 am fool you they won't have bagels until 630 anyway. and bagel sandwiches are very greasy. read more

It's not bagels & beyond anymore, it's bagel house. I know it's been tough to make $, but if the counter staff person were paying attention to me half as much as her phone, I probably wouldn't have been overcharged for things I didn't want on my sandwich. I asked for pork roll & cheese, but got egg too. I didn't have time to wait for another sandwich, I can't stand eggs. I'm certainly unhappy read more

This morning I called to place an order. The girl who answered the phone was rude and acted like it was a bother to take my order. I gave her my first order (double sausage, egg and cheese on a toasted plain). She asked me to repeat it 2 mores times. I did. She then asked me for my next order. I gave it to her (turkey bacon and egg on a toasted plain). After I gave her the order, she asked me to repeat it again because she was still doing the first order! I was frustrated because she specifically asked me for my second order. I let out a sigh. To which she responded, "Are you kidding me?" and hung up! I called back and the same girl answered the phone and yelled, "Your number is blocked! Find another bagel store!". My husband and I were shocked! My husband, who casually spoke to the owner, Steve Puccio, as he waited for his order and thinking he had a pleasant rapport with him, decided to go to the store in-person to speak with him. When my husband arrived, several customers were inside. My husband asked the girl behind the counter to speak to the owner or manager. She stated she wasn't sure if they were there. My husband asked her to check. Without checking, she told him they were not there. My husband asked for the owner's phone number. She took out a piece of paper and wrote the name "Steve" and a number. As she was handing him the paper, my husband explained that he was going to complain about her. She then tore the paper up and said, "It was my number anyway!". My husband told her that she had hung up on me and she began yelling, "Your wife was the rudest person that ever called" and she was surprised that my husband hadn't had a heart attack being married to me! This was said loudly and if front of other customers! My husband pointed up to the cameras and said, "I am sure the cameras are recording this"... she announced in front of everyone AGAIN that the cameras did not work! SHE WAS EXTREMELY RUDE AND UNPROFESSIONAL! She continued yelling and my husband was unable to get a word in. She proceeded to tell him to "leave her store"! We have tried to give this new ownership our business! Orders are often incorrect and the workers are not friendly. I guess Bagel House thinks they are the only place to get bagels in Hamilton. I will use social media to let as many people know as I can about this horrific experience. I would HIGHLY recommend going to Caesar's Bagels and Deli (https://www.facebook.com/Caesars-Bagels-Deli-1399591753680814/) on Flock Road. They are friendly and their bagels are delicious! UPDATE: The owner contacted me and this was his response: All apologies on the mishap today from one of my employees. I stepped out for an hour and was not there to see but I'm reviewing the cameras now and can clearly see how inappropriate my employee was. I care about the community, Hamilton. Even thou this year has given me more lemons than one can handle. I'm trying to uphold this little gem of a bagel store in the town throu the current circumstances. Once my new ovens start up Next week, I can promise that journey will be more enjoyable! I'm soooooooooooooooo sorry you had a terrible experience Sincerely Steve Puccio Owner read more

Now called the Bagel House. Haven't been in a few months, but was always my go-to bagel place. Unfortunately, when I went today, they didn't carry the same variety of bagels that they used to and this may be due to Covid, which is understandable. However, my order was incorrect when I opened it at home and the bagels did not taste fresh. While waiting for my order, 2 other orders were also incorrect. Maybe it was just a bad morning, but extremely disappointed in the quality received. Will be trying out other places now. read more