nice staff but the breakfast bagels are not that good. i ordered a turkey sausage egg & cheese on an egg everything and my boyfriend got a pork roll egg & cheese on an egg everything. what turned me off was they pour the eggs into a container, throw your meat inside of that container and then they microwave it for about 2 minutes. at least the bagels were soft but if you're picky like me and don't like your eggs microwaved then stick to butter or cream cheese. read more

Bordentown Bagels - turkey sausage egg and cheese everything bagel - Bagels Near Me - Bordentown, New Jersey

A staple. An icon. A legend. Our go to. Best, most, fresh, fluffiest, generous bagels you will ever have in your life. I can only make it through half of one they are HUGE. 10/10 recommend will probably be back again in a few days read more

Bordentown Bagels - French toast bagel, with pork roll hash brown and cheese. TRY IT!!!! Delishhh - Bagels Near Me - Bordentown, New Jersey

Came in this morning to get a bagel order for my daughter's birthday breakfast. Place was slammed (as it often is), but the staff just cranked through like a well oiled machine. Everyone busting their butts to get folks served and out the door. Bagels are amazing and the pork roll, cheese, etc that were loaded onto them was delicious. I got the "Bagel Buster" which was a meal!!! Highly recommended. read more

Bordentown Bagels - Bagel Buster - Bagels Near Me - Bordentown, New Jersey

NEVER AGAIN...if i could leave 0 stars I would. This used to be my husband and I's favorite spot. They got our order wrong....no big deal it happens! We ordered 1 toasted bagel POC SPC and 1 toasted bagel SEG NO SPC...the sausage and pork roll were switch and both had salt, pepper ketchup. We called and explained what happened the lady on the phone replied with "it will be ready when you get here" my husband heads over and the lady recognizes him. She proceeds to tell the other lady working "he's here i told him 20minutes" with a very nasty attitude. My husband gets the bagel and it's cold. Overall we didn't appreciate the lying and attitude. Will no longer be going here or recommending it. read more

Great bagels but count them before you leave... we ordered a dozen and got 11... most places give you a bakers dozen...

Great bagels and cream cheese, as well as sandwiches. Quick and friendly service. I wish they were open every day!

Huge tasty bagels!! Tried sesame, everything and FRENCH TOAST bagels. Also grabbed a tub of veggie cream cheese and french toast butter. Super tasty as is or toasted. Perfectly crunchy and chewy. Haven't been in the store yet (Mom picked up), so unable to comment on service / ambiance. read more

Their bagels are a family favorite and when we get them for out of town friends they love them too! Staff are super efficient and friendly. I love the hometown mom & pop vibe too. Nothing fancy, just good food! read more

I moved out of Burlington county in 2003, glad these guys are still around. Love the fact they open at 5am. Went there today before heading north for work, bagels are still fantastic. Kicking myself because they had French Toast bagels there (something that wasn't around 20 years ago) and I probably should have grabbed some. read more

Set in a small strip mall area - this was a fun find for good eats. They have huge, fluffy egg bagels as well as many variations on egg sandwiches for breakfast. We had the traditional Jersey sandwich - egg cheese and pork roll in a hard roll. The only small ding is that the store itself feels tired and could use some fresh paint and a new floor. That of course doesn't affect the food - but it would elevate the experience. (It's not always a top concern of smaller retailers- but appearance can make a big difference!) read more

Hands down best every thing bagel with horseradish cheddar bagel I have ever had. And I eat a bagel every day. I can't wait to go back on Monday! Vincent read more

there bagels are FREAKING AMAZING!!! the staff is always so nice!!! the bagels are huge and the stuff going on sandwiches is ALWAYS amazing!! all time number 2 favorite bagel place!!! recommend everyone try this place!! you will not be disappointed!!! nice and organized place too!! read more

These are the best bagels in jersey hands down. I drive here every other Saturday on my way to the hair salon. They're always packed and super busy. I recommend calling your order in ahead of time to beat the crowd. Their everything bagel is literally the "bees knees", my absolute favorite. The staff is nice, they move with a purpose and the bagels are out of this world! I recommend it! The only reason they're getting 4 stars instead of 5 is because you have to keep it simple here. The eggs/ bacon & etc are made in the microwave... no thanks. I ordered the chicken salad on a bagel, flavorless. But the bagel with cream cheese or the fresh lox on a bagel are on point. Keep it simple here! read more

See all

I've been coming to Bordentown bagels since moving to Bordentown and their breakfast sandwiches never disappoint, but today I had an especially positive experience. I needed a bagel tray to bring to a gathering and one of the workers offered to slice all the bagels and cut them in half to make it easier for people to grab. She organized them very nicely on the tray (photo included) and even brought them out to my car. They didn't need to offer to slice all of the bagels and bring them to my car, but this is the type of customer service that separates a good business from a great one! read more

See all

Pork roll, egg and cheese sandwich consisted of a pre-formed round microwaved yellow egg patty, one very thin slice of pork roll and two slices of yellow ultra-processed fake cheese product. If I knew that's what Bordentown Bagels serves up I would have just bought a Sizzli from Wawa. read more

Bordentown Bagels - a bagel sandwich with egg and cheese - Bagels Near Me - Bordentown, New Jersey

Maybe bagels aren't my area of expertise... But I've had enough over the years to know good bagels from crap bagels... The bagels here at Bordentown Bagels are very good. Arriving at this bagel shop can only be described as pulling into a pit stop at a raceway.. literally!! I damn near passed this place and the little cutoff road it's on, even though I could see it from the main road. Back to the bagels... great flavors, soft and tender on the inside, while the outside has a nice chewy texture. Like breakfast and lunch sandwiches? They have plenty! Like getting baited into buying something that you didn't even walk in for?? Try the cinnamon sugar bites they have on the counter. Worth every dime. Say goodbye to the pleasant staff, and be careful backing out while people are speeding into this parking lot/pit stop without paying attention to where they're going.... Enjoy!! read more

Been coming there for years. Their eggs are microwaved as hell. But the bagels are pretty good. However I will never return after today when another customer caressed my arm to move me and I got upset. Rather than tell the other customer to keep his hands to himself thr rude ass lady behind the counter got an attitude with me and said "I'm not doing this" yeah NOT DOING YOUR JOB of addressing the harassment that just took place and making me, the victim of harassment, the bad guy. She didn't care about losing my business and she won't stand up for you either if you get touched there!!​ read more

Full disclaimer that I'm Californian; I'm basing this on what I know about food. I really like these guys. From an operation stand-point, it was a well-oiled machine at 6:20am on a Saturday. I asked for a dozen assorted and was at the cashier in less than a minute. Cashier was polite and quick. I was maybe inside for a total of five minutes (mostly floundering around with my cream and coffee (self-serve). The bagels are great. I keep coming back the slight crunch in the crust. It's chew is light despite the bagel's apparent weight, and there's a light salt in the chew. If this spot was in San Diego, I'd be a regular. read more

Bordentown Bagels is AMMMMAZING. My fav is their french toast bagel but you can't go wrong with anything. If you haven't been you should go an go everyday. The service is outstanding. Their bagels are incredible. My girlfriend describes them as: "They have the best bagels in the whole world" "This bagel is amazing" "The bagel place has hands down the best bagels and cream cheese I've ever had. While the atmosphere in the morning on weekends is of high expectancy due to the long wait, it is well worth it. I'd travel and I do travel a long time for the bagels! Jalapeño cheddar bagels are to die for. Best I've ever had." "I think the bagels are so good because of the hole. It's big and allows for a lot of the rest of the bagel to be developed and reserved for cream cheese or any sandwich toppings. My tomato slices can fit on such a big bagel. The whole makes it big which is nice." She lives an hour away in Pennsylvania so she stacks up when she's local to Bordentown. Go ahead, become a regular at this place. It's fantastic! read more

terrible service. short tempered and rude to customers.the lady i ordered from told me i messed her up. no way to talk to your customers!!!! i wasn't satisfied. would not recommend!! read more

Best bagels ever! I always get the French toast bagel and it is heavenly. So fresh, perfectly soft inside with a delicate cinnamon sugar crust. read more

Bordentown Bagels - a variety of doughnuts - Bagels Near Me - Bordentown, New Jersey

was very disappointed when I found out my egg was being cooked in the microwave and my pork roll wasn't even seared. so if you don't like microwaved eggs and uncooked pork roll do not go here read more

Incredible bagels!! We moved to the area about a year ago and thrilled to find this place for our weekend bagel breakfasts. The specialty made cream cheeses are my favorite, especially the strawberry! One star off as they are having trouble maintaining social distancing inside their shop on weekend mornings. I had to leave the last time there as I did not feel safe. I also feel they treat their regulars much better than their new customers, but hopefully I will reach regular status soon! read more

I totally forgot they do seasonal bagels. The pumpkin bagels are fantastic. They also offer pumpkin butter and pumpkin cream cheese =]

They really shouldn't allow 10 plus customers to crowd together inside their tiny store, plus another five workers. This is ridiculous and unsafe during a pandemic! Have people line up outside (under the shelter of the awning) and only let a maximum of three customers in the store at a time. That would allow some distancing, although not even 6 feet, since the store is so small. People have to wait to order anyway, so why cram them in the store to do that?! Also, organize it so those who are only buying dry bagels can order, and get in and out quickly, as opposed to those waiting for bagel sandwiches to be made. They are very unorganized when it's crowded. I won't be patronizing this store anymore, since they are not enforcing safe practices during the pandemic. read more

The bagels here are so delicious & the prices are great! The weekends are busy but the line moves quickly.

Great breakfast sandwiches and fresh bagels, friendly staff and homey environment, great selection of spreads read more

Bordentown Bagels - Bagels Near Me - Bordentown, New Jersey

Bordentown Bagels is located in the Hilltop Center along Rt. 206 North. Don't rely on Yelp directions to find it for you. The place is strictly takeout with a small public area surrounded by workspace and bakery in the back. The service is friendly and fast. The women working the counter are fresh and full of "Huns," and "Babes." Make me feel right at home. The bagel I had (Onion) was all right, but not high on my list of favorites. The crust was too soft and was indistinguishable from the chewy core. There were plenty of Onion Flakes to provide taste, but the pleasure of biting through a crunchy skin was missing. Still, it was a large wheel and they packed plenty of good Swiss into it. So, overall I was left with mixed feelings about the experience. While I would not go out of my way to return to Bordentown Bagels, especially in light of the fact that a better bagel (to my taste) is nearby at Bagels & Beyond, neither would I debate those who enjoyed this style bagel more than I did. To each his own. read more

Bordentown Bagels - Bagels Near Me - Bordentown, New Jersey

People in my apartment complex raved about Bordentown Bagel! So I had to try it. First of all the bagels with just cream cheese are good! But if you plan on getting a hot breakfast sandwich please save your money! They microwave all their hot food! I ordered a bacon egg and cheese on a bagel it was Horrible the microwaved egg tasted absolutely Nasty!! My wife got pork roll egg and cheese on a bagel, I have Never seen pork roll that looked like the mystery meat they served us! It was disgusting and I'm sure the microwave didn't help it at all! I really wish they let the customers know that they cook all their hot food in the microwave! I would have Not ordered any hot food from there. Well that was my first and last time eating at Bordentown Bagel! I hope this review helps you save money! read more

This is all because of the bacon! One of my go to sandwiches is everything lightly toasted with cream cheese and bacon. It's not healthy but damn is it good. I was only in town to help my brother move and he asked that I pick up something on my way. Purely due to convenience I made my selection. At the store when placing my order I was asked if I want a few slices or a sandwich, yes sandwich please. What came back was not the usual 3-4 paper thin slices but the New York Deli stack of meat. Yeah! I was in bacon heaven. Oh and the bagels were good too. Just the right size and chewiness. Beyond my choice there are plenty of standards and a few others like French toast that looks pretty good too. Be warned, they are not the fastest and they can get busy in there, if u can call ahead you might want to place a pick up order. I was lucky to hit them off peak the first time but had to wait the second. Parking is limited, and google doesn't seem to pick up the small access ramp to the row of storage off of 206 north. read more

My partner and I love this place. We have recently made it our regular spot Saturday mornings. All of the employees are hardworking, quick, and friendly. I have to say, the woman working the register on Saturday mornings is SUNSHINE and radiates warmth and hospitality. As someone who works in the restaurant world, I cannot say how much I appreciate this kind of service!! I get the tuna melt on a garlic bagel and my partner gets sausage, egg, and cheese, on egg everything (and 2 hashbrowns) and we think they are absolutely perfect every time. read more

I go here all the time. I love the bagels and the staff is really nice. My 1 star review isn't because of the quality of service or food. It's because when I walked in there, I seen a sign that says you guys are closed on Monday because of staff shortages. Pay your employees a living wage and there wouldn't be a staff shortage. read more

Excellent, fast, friendly service! Stopped here on my way to work for the first time today. Got myself a pork roll, egg, and cheese on an egg bagel. Eggs were light and fluffy, not as much porkroll as I'd like but the sandwich was cheap, I'm sure I can ask for extra next time. But the sandwich was great and just what I needed to start my morning. Also got an everything bagel with cream cheese. Solid. Homemade good quality stuff going on here. I will definitely be back, nice to know I have a good bagel spot on my commute to work! read more

Fantastic bagels! Big, fluffy, often still warm from the oven. My co-workers are nuts about them. My boyfriend, who claims he doesn't really care for bagels finds them oddly satisfying. The store made flavored cream cheeses and butters are also outstanding. Their veggie cream cheese is a crowd pleaser. The French Toast butter is to die for! Their coffee is remarkably good. The folks who work there are amazingly efficient and cheerful. Highly recommended read more

Definitely one of the best bagel joints in the Trenton area. Good, made in house, chewy, BOILED bagels aka real bagels. Nothing too exotic just standard bagel flavors like poppy, everything, pumpernickel, egg, blueberry, etc. And for you heathens, yes, they will even toast your bagel even though they're always fresh enough and they shouldn't be toasted. But I digress. If you're in the area and want a bagel, this will satisfy the craving. read more

Bordentown Bagels - Bagels Near Me - Bordentown, New Jersey

See all

Great variety but didn't like the texture of these bagels. Very hard. Didn't taste fresh.

As far as bagels in south jersey go, I guess Bordentown Bagels is ok although a little too doughy for my liking. But I can't get over the fact that they put the "everything" seasoning on only half of the bagel ??? What's that about. Plus they microwave their eggs. Ugh. But if you don't have easy access to a real NY bagel - this will have to do. It's the only game in town. read more

Points for great service - I love the ladies who work here! And the bagels are very good, and bonus for offering a few varieties that seem to be missing from my go-to bagel joints (Bagels and Beyond, Central Perk). I agree with several of the comments made by other yelpers: the outside of the bagels could definitely be chewier/crisper, and I was somewhat disappointed that they microwaved my egg (and I suspect the sausage too) for my breakfast sandwich earlier this week. It was a HUGE sandwich - I couldn't finish it! And, it was certainly edible. But a proper grill would make all the difference. This is probably a 3-star establishment based on food alone -- there are just so many good bagel places in the area! Where they surpass those places, though, is in service -- for instance, a few of the longtime staffers at Central Perk are downright miserable; you won't find that attitude here. Also, at BB, you get a baker's dozen, and again, the selection is quite decent. It's worth noting, too, the coffee at Bordentown Bagels is very good. read more

This is my usual go to breakfast spot if I'm in a rush. The bagels are delicious and reasonably priced. They workers there are kind and quick with the orders. The only thing that I personally don't like is that they microwave their eggs. I mean, I still eat it because my egg and cheese bagel is still bomb. But I always prefer a freshly cooked egg than a microwaved egg. read more

Bordentown Bagels - Honey wheat bagel with egg and cheese. Salt, pepper & ketchup added. - Bagels Near Me - Bordentown, New Jersey

See all

Been going here for years and I love taking my new friends from out of town to have their first REAL bagel & they always love it. French toast is amazing but everything will always be my favorite ! read more

Bordentown Bagels - Jalapeño bagel with bacon egg cheese and a hash brown ! Truly blessed. - Bagels Near Me - Bordentown, New Jersey

See all