Always such a treat to get cupcakes from here. Taste fresh and look great. Nice item to gift as well!

The location itself is fine and the staff is nice but baked by Melissa is overpriced and overrated

Who wouldn't love delicious bite-sized cupcakes in amazing flavors. Ordered online to pick up the next day. They were ready for me. Staff was friendly and answered my questions. Definitely worth a try. read more

Do not bother ordering pickup for a certain time. You cannot call the store directly and they make you use the Shop app which is the worst app in America. read more

Just a-okay Pros: + Variety of flavors + Great for your instagram + Flavors change with the season Cons: - Pricey - Dried out cupcakes - Not always the freshest cupcakes read more

Baked by Melissa - Bakeries Near Me - Garden City, New York

Came here to buy cupcakes for my office after seeing all the advertisements. Spot was gross! EW. It's a random booth in the middle of walkway. Everything was dirty, could hardly see through the glass. Two girls working but not really doing anything but chillin' their phones. Which makes sense because it's just prepackaged mini cupcakes like the ones you get at a normal store. Just INSANELY overpriced. Which is okay cause everything is expensive in NY. Before going here I was considering buying online, but now I'm so grossed out I would never trust where they are coming from. All previous reviews mention they were either stale or dried out so I'm glad I didn't buy them. read more

The Quick: great if getting cupcakes for an office with a ton of people. The flavors are great and there is something for everyone. That being said it's silly overpriced read more

See all

I received an assortment of mini cupcakes as a gift from a business associate. Sadly, the packaging was probably what the gift giver paid for. A small box of 30 bite-size cupcakes came wrapped in a large cardboard box with insulation and ice packs. the cupcakes were tasty but had the giver done some research, they could have found a local shop that would have provided more for much less. Not worth the cost unless you are into cutesy one bite cupcakes. read more

I indulged today and got some cupcakes from here and I loved them. I've tried them before and they're just as good. read more

Baked by Melissa - a variety of cupcakes - Bakeries Near Me - Garden City, New York

This Baked by Melissa counter is very efficient . The associate explained how everything was packaged and which flavor cupcakes came in each container. You have a choice to choose from what they have available , or get the pre - made ones that are already packaged and ready to go. I love it. $20 for 25 mini cupcakes and $80 for 100 . One mini cupcake alone is $1. Can't beat that !! I would recommend ! read more

Baked by Melissa - Yum . - Bakeries Near Me - Garden City, New York

Sign saying be back in 30 minutiae.. one hour 45 minutes later still no return. Came here specifically for these and wasted my time

Technically the closest location to me is at JFK but you only go there when you're flying. So, this is my go to for craving and must stop while in the mall. Today, I was conservative and only got six but I curing pass up trying the Mother's Day flavor. I really liked the peanut butter cup. read more

Baked by Melissa - Bakeries Near Me - Garden City, New York

Take just one dainty bite out of Baked By Melissa's cupcakes, let the creamy frosting melt in your mouth, taste the tiny, and soft cake on your tongue. Sprinkle sprinkles on your cupcakes, and enjoy them. These cupcakes are very enjoyable. read more

So happy to have this little piece of heaven (that serves little pieces of heaven) near home. Previously only had an opportunity at one of the Manhattan locations when happening to be in the vicinity of one. I look forward to shopping here for tasty gifts! I had the salted caramel this time around... YUM! read more

I don't live near this mall at all, but I had to stop at Baked By Melissa the one time I visited Roosevelt Field. The line was moving super fast, but, the lady helping us asked what I wanted before I could even see what was in the glass, so I felt totally rushed. Usually, I try to be prepared so I'm ready by the time I order, but in this case, I couldn't be since the line wrapped around behind the glass. Please open a location at the Smithhaven Mall!!!!! read more

The cupcakes were mini bites I ate about 5 in less than a minute.. the cashier was super nice .. they were a $1 a cupcake wish is not that bad ... read more

See all

Delicious little mini cupkakes. They have a wide variety and special one's for Valentines Day. And they all look pretty! This place could be a sin or good thing because they are good like pringles, you just cant pop one! The Tye Dye and Salted Caramel are so far my two favorites!! read more

See all

I got the vegan cupcakes for my birthday. They weren't the best but they also weren't the worst I've had. It was just okay. I like how they had many kinds but the flavors just didn't do it for me, the chocolate and strawberry were one of the better ones. read more

I love baked by Melissa cupcakes, the portion sizes are great for me since I'm a diabetic. Located in the mall right outside of the Pandora store. I'm not sure where the cupcakes are made at this location because it's more like a kiosk. The area is clean, with a friendly staff. Be prepared to stand in line depending on what time you come because the line can be very long. read more

Delicious cupcakes. Great for clients as a unique gift that will have them talking. So much fun to taste the different flavors... almost guilt free because they are bite-sized. We keep coming back for them read more

Amazing!!! You should deff try them out. I always tell my friends they are little bite sizes pieces of heaven in your mouth. I love all their chocolate cupcakes. I also love that each month they have a new flavor/ design. read more

Baked by Melissa - My fav flavors! - Bakeries Near Me - Garden City, New York

Love your cupcakes. I remember having them years ago when there were only a few shops and now it's a large franchise. I was worried quality would decrease but the cupcakes are just as tasty. This review is based on service. Horrible service here. Not enough staff when I went. I waited 20 minutes for service and there were only 2 people ahead of me. The woman before me finally placed my order with one girl who went around the shelving where I expected her to return with the woman's box only to find a new girl had taken her place and the customer had repeat her large order. Why would you switch shifts or go on break while serving a customer? I'm sure you could have placed the mini cupcakes in a box and rang her up in less than 2 minutes but nope you decided to make me wait even longer. I walked away because I couldn't waste anymore time nor my money for bad service. read more

Cupcakes will always be my favorite food. While shopping at the mall, I had to decide between being really unhealthy with all the food options available at Roosevelt Field, or help myself to a few small cupcakes that do not hurt the waist or wallet. I went with the latter choice and enjoyed the sugar cookie cupcake, cookie dough and the cupcake of the month, lemon meringue. They are so good but I am not sure if they satisfy my cupcake craving enough. Thats why the 4 stars. read more

Baked by Melissa - From left to right: lemon meringue, cookie dough, and sugar cookie - Bakeries Near Me - Garden City, New York

Ordered cupcakes to be ready for 10am on Jan 20 th called before I went they told they'd be open and my cupcakes were ready. I arrive there and there's not a single person in the kiosk didn't get my cupcakes and honestly just very disappointed I couldn't give a review on the actual cupcakes cause I didn't even get the chance to try them read more

I love this place. The mini cupcakes are the bestt. The employees taking your order are really nice on the first note. Also when you make a purchase they give you so many items like stickers and temporary tattoos. I ordered there today there are also employees guiding customers outside the stand. Over all my favorite cupcake is the tie die you should stop by one time! It's a little over priced but it's so worth the price. read more

Baked by Melissa - This is their logo - Bakeries Near Me - Garden City, New York

Horrible service. I ordered something a week and a half prior to the date I wanted it delivered and paid for it to have special holiday wrapping. The cupcakes sat in a facility for over 24 hours and still were not delivered. After being frustrated that they were no longer fresh I called and the "customer happiness representative" was quick to cancel my order, she was not so pleasant. She was not very empathetic or kind as I was very upset that the recipient did not receive their cupcakes to know I was thinking of them. I had called days prior to request that my cupcakes be delivered by a certain time and told the company does not offer that feature it is up to fedex and can be delivered anywhere between 8-8. I was also told that the company does not guarantee delivery on the day that you choose, you are simply choosing an "estimated delivery date"... why pick a date?? I was then told if I wanted the cupcakes delivered for a specific date I should've chose a day or two prior to ensure punctual delivery service. Very expensive for such fickle service. Waste of money and aggravating. read more

I honestly don't see how these are so great. Forgive me for not understanding. But they are cute and they do look delicious. Wish they were bigger. read more

Love this place and so does my wife it is almost a must every time i make it to the mall. I get the variety pack and it feeds all my craving on all different levels. And i will be most likely going by there today, Now that i seen this pop up :) read more

not the best cupcakes I've ever had, but I appreciate the fact that they're so small so you can easily sample many flavors with each mini cupcake you get. read more

Baked by Melissa - Bakeries Near Me - Garden City, New York

I went to Baked by Melissa today and I met Kenya, she was a big help. I've never gotten cupcakes from there before but today was a great experience. Kenya thank you again. You deserve a raise read more

Best mini cupcakes ! So yummy ! Can eat so many at once . They have gluten free now also. Every month they have a flavor of the month. Good stand to have in the mall to snack on . read more

Baked By Melissa is a very nice little shop that sells "bite sized" cupcakes. They are very delicious but they are very pricey for being a one-bite treat. They are very cute little cupcakes and they are made of very many different flavors and flavor combinations such as pistachio nut, cotton candy, red velvet and peanut butter. I like to think the quality and flavor of the cupcakes are higher than your typical chocolate cupcake but as I said, it is a bit pricey for bite-sized cupcakes. read more

My credit card number was stolen and this store showed up on my charges with the entry for the purchase made manually. Do not go to this store to avoid fraudulent credit charges. read more

Came here today! I joined the line then there was a very nice young lady that asked us for our order before reaching the counter. She told us how much it was so I placed an order for 25 cupcakes and she told us we can have one as a sample. When I got to the counter the girl asked the other girl behind the counte if I can have a sample and she gave it to me so angry. Now she is placing my cupcakes on the box and saying out loud to another employee that they should not give out samples for free, and said it a few times BC she was upset. Not only was she talking over my order but was nasty too. I think if she felt like that she should be nice to customers and say what's on her mind after a customer leave. Well I did tell her if she had a problem giving samples, then she shouldn't and next time she should wait for the customer to leave. After this experience I don't think I will going back there. read more

With gluten-free options available, this famed cupcake spot definitely earns a place on my list of favorite sweet treats. At the Roosevelt Field location, in order to purchase gluten-free cupcakes, you need to purchase 25 cupcakes sold in a sealed package. If you don't want to purchase 25 cupcakes, you can turn to the bite-size macarons instead. These are gluten-free as well. For those who do not need gluten-free, you can purchase different size packages of cupcakes of your choice. If you buy 2 packages of 25 cupcakes or macarons, they will give you a discount. This discount is given for every 2 packages purchased. These cupcakes and macarons can be kept in the freezer for later use as well and defrost quickly to serve. They are great to bring to a BBQ or other party where dessert is needed especially when gluten-free guests are present. They offer a great variety of flavors and generally 3-4 cupcakes is satisfying as a serving. read more