Baldwin Pizzeria

I loved the pizza, they sell slices that come out of the oven tasting pretty good. They also have a…read moregreat crunch factor. Staff were friendly and my food came out quick. They also gave me a decent sized cup of pizza sauce for free which was greatly appreciated! Awesome place.

While shopping for a few items, we were getting hungry and wanted something light. We saw…read moreParsippany's Best Pizza and thought we'd see if it lived up to the name. I ordered a Margherita slice and honestly, it was pretty damn good! Very fresh sauce, good amount of fresh cheese and herbs. I also ordered a meat lovers because I wanted the contrast. It wasn't too overwhelming but fair amount of cheese and meats. Hubby ordered a grilled chicken Caesar wrap. The chicken was cut up just right so it didn't fall out as he bit into it and it came with a side of chips. It was a busy place and they had a lot of pick ups, deliveries and to-go orders. A group of middle school boys ordered 4 pizzas and chowed down which was entertaining to watch because they loved their plain, pepperoni and Hawaiian pies. Great service and options. It was a little chilly nice the door kept opening and closing, but definitely worth a stop if you are in the area.

The Cowboy Burger

Speciality Pizza

See all

Speciality Pizza

Johnny's Pizzeria

4.3(83 reviews)

3.1 mi

Missed pizza from NY and NJ. When back visiting saw Johnny's Pizzeria and decided to stop in on a…read morewhim. Was greeted by those working behind the counter, very friendly. Interior had seating for dining with cute wall decor (pics of Italy landscape cities). Ordered a Johnny's special to go. As I waited I saw locals picking up orders and talking with the workers. Seemed like the staff built good relationships with their clientele, which seems rare now. Most businesses now appear strictly transactional with the patrons. The pizza had generous toppings of peppers, mushrooms, onions, pepperoni and sausage. All were fresh. The best part was the crisp thin crust and the sauce made of ripe tomatoes. What a gem!

Pizza - ordered 5 pies, went over - and walking in 20min later, they were just making the pies and…read morenot put in the oven yet. That delayed the work lunch. The fresh grandma's was a bit too soggy (fresh moz, tomatoes - all lead to a runny topping set), the regular grandma's was ok, and the favorite was the broccoli rabe w/ sausage in the group. Crust was tougher than Nonna's and overall - had better. Shop is simple, they have some seating and specials, and lots of people from nearby Double Tap which has no food order from here.

Counter

Tomato pie

See all

Store front

Annabella's Pizzeria & Restaurant

3.8(134 reviews)

1.0 mi

Annabella's is a local favorite. The entire staff could not be nicer and when dining in, Francisco…read more(hope I spelled that right), is an exceptional server. Everything I order exceed expectations and the portions always leave enough for great leftovers the next day. Have used them for catering as well and everyone raves about the food and not just because I paid for it :) highly recommended! You won't be disappointed.

This was the best I had in my life and I eat a lot of Pastas across the world. I was staying at the…read morehotel next door for a couple of months. This review was long overdue. I waited so long because I wanted to gate keep this restaurant. Service was prompt and efficient. Everyone's super friendly with an inviting smile. Dress code: casual or come as you are. Foods: i recommend those garlic knots and the spicy shrimp spaghetti. Those were the best knots I had in my life not even in Italy iI had something similar. As far the spicy shrimp spaghetti, I never had any pasta that tasted this good unless I was the one who made it. I honestly would fly from the west coast just to have it. I licked the container cleaned every time. The food is very affordable as well. For pizza I would go for the grandma style or plain cheese. I hope they never change the recipe nor their staff. The food is sinfully good.

Still shows this on their website for deal...

See all

Palermo's Pizzeria

4.2(73 reviews)

1.4 mi

Palermo's has great.pizza! We also love their penne vodka with chicken. The staff is friendly and…read morethey have a great rewards program. Best Pizza place in Parsippany.

Always excellent! Probably have lunch here at least twice a week. Everything is good, and they also…read morehave very good soups! Only place around that sells garlic knots by the piece, which is great if you just want one or two along with your meal.

Friendly service, plenty of seating!

Slices.

See all

Coniglio’s Old Fashioned

4.0(284 reviews)

6.5 mi

Fantastic staff- also don't be afraid of parking, there is a garage around the corner…read more We called in an order so we would have less of a wait with the kids and Edward took our order and held a table for us. We walked in 15 minutes later and he literally pointed to a booth where our two Detroit reds were just set up and waiting on us- we felt like royalty! On to the pizza- have tried many Detroit style pizzas over the years, I would say this was more Detroit "inspired", Aside from the edges, It had a soft bready crust - a little too fluffy compared to the crisp, almost focaccia-like crust we are accustomed to. Not to fret, it's still delicious! Quality pull on the cheese and the sauce holds its own. Some of the slices had the caramelized cheese halo and those were attacked first. Since we prepaid on the phone we didn't have the option to leave a tip. No worries, quick view of the sweet delights and we ordered some bombolones so that we could add a tip there!

A go to spot for lunch (although on the pricier side). Some of my favorites include, vodka…read morestracciatella pie, meatball & ricotta pie, squash and farro salad, and the crispy chicken caesar hero. Excited for when their extended dining room finally opens up!

Open kitchen with good seating

Croissant and strawberry bombolone

See all

Drink selection

Pasquale's Restaurant and Pizzeria

4.2(98 reviews)

2.8 mi

We got two pizza pies to take home on a Sunday night. The place wasn't packed, and they do have…read moresome space for you to sit on if you do choose to dine in. We got their white pizza with broccoli and then we got a spicy pepper with bacon pizza. The pizzas were OK, I've had better, and were unfortunately a bit greasy for my liking. The crust was very floppy so that also wasn't great. I think the price is reasonable and pretty similar to other places around the area, but I would personally go to a different pizzeria in the area as opposed to this one .

A great slice of nostalgia. This is a neighborhood pizzeria where everyone knows your name and…read morewhat you enjoy eating. I love the pizza. Crisp. Aromatic. Tangy. Yum.

Spinach bacon white pie

Special order meatball ham ricotta

See all

Wood Stack Pizza Kitchen

3.9(625 reviews)

3.0 mi

My best friend hosted her baby shower at Wood Stack a few weeks ago. I really enjoyed my meal and…read morethe service was great too. They started us off with some appetiziers for the table which included avocado toast, rice balls, and salad. For my main course, I ordered the Pappardelle Bolognese which was a huge portion. The pasta was fresh and the meat sauce was super flavorful. The inside is decorated very nice and has a sort of rustic theme. The area where we were sat was the perfect size for an intimate shower. I plan to come back and visit for lunch or dinner in the near future. Avocado Toast: 5/5 Rice Balls: 5/5 Salad: 5/5 Pappardelle Bolognese: 5/5

1st time back to Wood Stack in many 5+ years and gotta say - still not impressed…read more From being seating in the back room when half of the main room was empty to the slow service to all the chairs being uneven - it was just meh. The highlight was the salumeria special - good selection of meats and cheeses. We tried the grandma, bader sting and the prosciutto & fig pies. The grandma was the best. The bader sting is sopressata and hot honey - couldn't taste the honey and sopressata had no flavor. But the biggest let down was the prosciutto & fig - the figs were green? My first thought they were not ripe - the point of this pie is to have savory and sweet - it had no sweet. As I said I hadn't been there in more than 5 years and the menu hasn't changed from what I can remember. Also, if you increase prices, maybe make sure you make sure to remove the old menus first.

Large room/event space

Smoked Salmon Tots Brunch

See all

Pappardelle Bolognese Dinner

Double Zero Pizza

4.6(147 reviews)

4.5 mi

Best pizza we've had since Naples! Perfect sauce and an unbelievable dough. We had the margarita…read moreand the pistachio sausage and both were so good we finished them both! Not much of a place to eat in but worth the trip for great pizza.

We moved back to Jersey a year ago and could not find great pizza. We have finally found it!!!…read more Have been here twice already in a week. The smell of the wood fire as you walk in is amazing. And if you've forgotten a beverage - there's a liquor store across the parking lot!!! Mike is great to speak with as he preps the dough and everyone who comes in is a regular!

Shake Hands with Queen Margherita, Ain't She A Beauty!!

See all

Building

Tabor Pizzeria

3.8(203 reviews)

3.9 mi

Rainy night ordered some take out. Got a pepperoni pizza and some garlic knots. Was greeted by…read morefriendly staff. Dinning room was open and guest were enjoying all kinds of delights. I enjoyed my yummy thin crusted pizza, just with the right amount of crunch, pepperoni was perfectly cooked. I had been craving some buttery garlic knots and this did not disappoint. I was so excited to eat this i forgot to take a picture. I will go back again! Hopefully you will too.

Ready exactly as conveyed. The Portnoy pizza was delicious. The meatballs were succulent. The salad…read morewas ok but loaded up with too much iceberg. Will definitely be heading back.

A frequent customer

The Crispy Bar Pie (with onion topping) -- perfect thinness!

See all

Artie's

4.4(987 reviews)

12.4 mi

Disco ball, bakery, pizza...what can go wrong? Absolutely nothing. As for the pizza, It's kinda all…read moreabout the dough, though the toppings were almost equally delicious. There may be a line but there's an outside area (on nice days) to accommodate the wait. There's also a happy face flag at the construction site next door - reassurance that the pizza will be alright.

I heard that the bakery at Artie's was terrific and decided to find out for myself. Rather than a…read morelong wait on a holiday morning, I decided on takeout (see pictures of some of our ordered). The pastries were magnificent tasting and unusual (e.g. Jersey corn; heirloom tomato, ..). In one word: "Yum." I'm going to try the pizza next time.

Almond croissant

Caciocavallo with Jalapeños

See all

Manhattan

Why does Yelp recommend reviews?

Hundreds of millions of reviews are posted on Yelp, and our automated recommendation software works in the background to showcase the reviews that it …

13 reviews that are not currently recommended

The reviews below are not factored into the business's overall star rating.

John R.

63

6

0

10 years ago

I love trying new restaurants. I saw this from the highway and wanted to give it a try. When you walk in a restaurant, the first thing you expect to feel is hospitality. I came in 2 hours before closing to see that chairs were stacked on the tables and the pizzeria was completely empty. Even though this is how it started, I always live by "don't judge a book by its cover". Unfortunately I was wrong. I was not noticed or welcomed at all. The cashier didn't ask if my food was for dine in or take out. I asked if they were closing soon and they said no. I took it as if they were if the chairs were on top of the tables. It's embarrassing to be an owner of a company that allows rude workers behind the counter when they are the face of the business. read more

Michael B.

0

2

0

14 years ago

Hey, I just moved to the area and being from NY I immediately started to look for a good pizzeria. I tried several in Lake Hiawatha and the one over by Party City and KFC. Honestly, I was very underwhelmed. Run of the mill quick-serve Italian food and the pizza is average at best. A coworker turned me on to Baldwin and wow! Finally some NY style pizza and NY quality. She knows Parsippany inside and out and said Baldwin has been around for almost half a century! I can understand why. Maybe its a better quality cheese or a combination of factors but they definitely know what they're doing. Thanks Baldwin for making me feel at home again! Michael read more

John N.

0

6

0

13 years ago

The closest thing to a "New York Pizza" that I have been able to find out here...nice thin crust, generous amount of cheese and a tasty sauce...being a lover of good pizza, I now go in at least twice a week for lunch...if you are in the area, definitely worth a visit read more

Rchris R.

0

1

0

8 years ago

food poisoning!! my son and i got food poisoning, it's 1:30 am im still puking up plain cheese pizza! how can u mess that up? got a yelp app just to warn people to stay away!!!!!!!!!! read more

Jason S.

2

4

0

10 years ago

really good place and good quality Pizza. friendly staff at really good location.I would certainly go here again. The pizza is divine and is a perfect mixture of sauce and cheese read more

Jennifer B.

8

10

2

8 years ago

Thai chicken pizza. DELICIOUS!!!! That's something unique and hope you make it again. All the food is great. Baldwin's never disappoints. And the staff is always so friendly. read more

Rachel P.

5

7

4

11 years ago

Decent pizza! A little over priced but the plain slice was pretty good. Haven't tried any specialty slices, but my friends say they aren't bad. read more

Kelly S.

1

15

2

6 years ago

Great variety of foods not usually available at Pizza places, which I like about them. Food is great, delivery is fast.

Joey B.

0

28

3

5 years ago

Great food. Good variety including soups and meals. The pizza is really good as well. Always friendly staff/cooks.

John B.

82

69

4

14 years ago

great food and friendly staff - prices a little high, but worth it since the taste makes up for it.

Matt S.

0

4

0

10 years ago

Consistently good pizza and friendly staff!

Anup P.

0

8

0

11 years ago

friendly owner..great food

Ladd T.

4

10

1

12 years ago

Not a bad spot to eat

Baldwin Pizzeria - pizza - Updated September 2026

People who viewed Baldwin Pizzeria also viewed

Joe's Pizzeria

3.8

(46 reviews)

I love everything about joes it so good it makes me sad glory to Israel I love there food and…read morethere service is good

Eat at Joe's. Okay let me be a little more specific, I recommend that you Eat at Joe's and try…read moretheir Mango Habanero Chicken Pizza. Because it just happens to be the perfect combination of Savory, Sweet, and Spicy so you're definitely wanna order yourself up some of that. You're Welcome. Sometimes these things just write themselves, know what I mean? Lol Come And Get Your Munch On!!

Pasquale's Restaurant and Pizzeria

4.2

(98 reviews)

We got two pizza pies to take home on a Sunday night. The place wasn't packed, and they do have…read moresome space for you to sit on if you do choose to dine in. We got their white pizza with broccoli and then we got a spicy pepper with bacon pizza. The pizzas were OK, I've had better, and were unfortunately a bit greasy for my liking. The crust was very floppy so that also wasn't great. I think the price is reasonable and pretty similar to other places around the area, but I would personally go to a different pizzeria in the area as opposed to this one .

A great slice of nostalgia. This is a neighborhood pizzeria where everyone knows your name and…read morewhat you enjoy eating. I love the pizza. Crisp. Aromatic. Tangy. Yum.

Frank's Pizza

3.2

(53 reviews)

We go here often at my job and have never had a bad experience. It is located in a busy shopping…read morecenter next to a Walmart so there is plenty of parking. The place is pretty big with a seating area towards the back. The service is always great. My favorite thing is that they always have plenty of different kinds of pizzas out. All of the styles I have tried have been great with my favorite being the Buffalo Chicken. They even have large Garlic Knot Sliders. We have even ordered the catering a few times, and the food is always great at a very fair price. Strongly recommend Franks!

A nice place to grab lunch be it pizza or strombolis or pasta. Friendly service and reasonable…read moreprices.

Jefry's Pizza

3.8

(27 reviews)

In the unending effort to sample as many NJ pizzerias as possible, I had the opportunity to stop in…read moreat Jefry's for lunch. This restaurant is located on Parsippany Blvd with plenty of parking and lots of seats inside. One thing I love about a pizzeria is when you stop in for lunch and there are many pizzas in the display case to choose from. That was certainly the case here. I chose a Sicilian slice with pepperoni and sausage toppings. It was excellent! Nice crisp crust and a great taste. Prices are very reasonable...less than $6 for a specialty slice and can of soda. Thumbs up to Jefry's!

My review isn't about the food it's about the employees. I wanted to take the time out to recognize…read moreyour business as your employees went above and beyond for my son in law on Saturday. His car broke down, he didn't have his phone and your employees were gracious enough to allow him to use the phone to contact us. In the midst of trying to get the tow truck there, you guys helped SO much. Extra recognition to Nancy as she was so calm and patient when I called. I appreciate you going the extra mile! Can't thank you guys enough. If I'm ever in the area, I'll definitely stop by for a bite. God Bless

il Torrente Pizza

3.5

(69 reviews)

In a town full of outstanding Pizzerias it'd be easy to overlook this one or that one but if you…read morehaven't been to iL Torrente you really gotta try it out. Their Thin Crust Style Pizza definitely checks all the boxes: Flavor, Texture, and Quality Ingredients are all evident in each and every tremendously tasty bite. Owned and operated by some SuperCool people who work hard at providing their customers with delicious food. Gotta add I'm a big fan of their covered outdoor patio too which offers a ton of shade when it's hot out. Grab a slice or delicious looking Italian inspired comfort dish and munch out in style people. Pro Tip: the place right next door sells Ice Cream and Frozen Yogurt so yeah, this guy definitely likes hunkering down at this spot. Lol Come And Get Your Munch On!!

Review from a poor man. This place does good food. The…read morestuffed mushrooms app is an awesome app if you like mushrooms and cheese! It is a cheesy goodness of flavor (if you have a hot sauce you like at home, it brings it to a whole new level!). The pizza is good, the salads are meaty and with an awesome amount of toppings. The chicken wraps are very tasty and also a high recommend! Also if you live in town and stuff, you will get something in the mail with a coupon for some money off your order of 25 bucks or more. (Which the way things cost these days, isn't hard to do). Definitely try them! Just well done food with decent prices at this point in this expensive world

Parsippany's Best Pizza

4.2

(412 reviews)

I loved the pizza, they sell slices that come out of the oven tasting pretty good. They also have a…read moregreat crunch factor. Staff were friendly and my food came out quick. They also gave me a decent sized cup of pizza sauce for free which was greatly appreciated! Awesome place.

While shopping for a few items, we were getting hungry and wanted something light. We saw…read moreParsippany's Best Pizza and thought we'd see if it lived up to the name. I ordered a Margherita slice and honestly, it was pretty damn good! Very fresh sauce, good amount of fresh cheese and herbs. I also ordered a meat lovers because I wanted the contrast. It wasn't too overwhelming but fair amount of cheese and meats. Hubby ordered a grilled chicken Caesar wrap. The chicken was cut up just right so it didn't fall out as he bit into it and it came with a side of chips. It was a busy place and they had a lot of pick ups, deliveries and to-go orders. A group of middle school boys ordered 4 pizzas and chowed down which was entertaining to watch because they loved their plain, pepperoni and Hawaiian pies. Great service and options. It was a little chilly nice the door kept opening and closing, but definitely worth a stop if you are in the area.

Valentino's Pizzeria & Restaurant

3.3

(60 reviews)

Super Solid Pizzeria specializing in delicious thin crust style dough but can also put together…read moresome serious Sicilian style as well. Owned and operated by some of the coolest people in the business who are always fast friendly and efficient. Literally everything off this outstanding menu sounds like something I could get into including Italian inspired comfort dishes which [let's face it] always has and always will grab my attention. There are plenty of seating options to choose from and the shared parking lot out front is really convenient. Whether you're dining in or taking out you really can't go wrong with Valentino's Restaurant. Come And Get Your Munch On!!

this pizzeria use to be a great place with great food but past few months it's been awful i ordered…read morea salad last night upon eating it i found 5 staples inside my salad 2 of them inside chicken yes you heard that correct STAPLES! I would recommend checking you're food if you do eat here I will never be ordering here again it's gotten beyond expensive and takes over hour to get you're order and even at that you don't even get the whole order and it's just junk I hate having to write a review this way but sadly with awful service a review needs to be made! be weary here and I hope I didn't eat any staples without realizing it

Mondo Pizza Restaurant and Catering

4.3

(44 reviews)

I ate a slice of this pizza standing in the parking lot and the pizza is BANGIN. So good. Would…read moredefinitely eat here again. Next time maybe inside.

A coworker told me they had the best Sicilian pizza. They did not disappoint. Delicious full of…read moreflavor what pizza is supposed to taste like. Wow a definite party in my mouth. And very friendly service from when I walked in, and walked out. This is a hidden gem of a place. I will be back.

Annabella's Pizzeria & Restaurant

3.8

(134 reviews)

Annabella's is a local favorite. The entire staff could not be nicer and when dining in, Francisco…read more(hope I spelled that right), is an exceptional server. Everything I order exceed expectations and the portions always leave enough for great leftovers the next day. Have used them for catering as well and everyone raves about the food and not just because I paid for it :) highly recommended! You won't be disappointed.

This was the best I had in my life and I eat a lot of Pastas across the world. I was staying at the…read morehotel next door for a couple of months. This review was long overdue. I waited so long because I wanted to gate keep this restaurant. Service was prompt and efficient. Everyone's super friendly with an inviting smile. Dress code: casual or come as you are. Foods: i recommend those garlic knots and the spicy shrimp spaghetti. Those were the best knots I had in my life not even in Italy iI had something similar. As far the spicy shrimp spaghetti, I never had any pasta that tasted this good unless I was the one who made it. I honestly would fly from the west coast just to have it. I licked the container cleaned every time. The food is very affordable as well. For pizza I would go for the grandma style or plain cheese. I hope they never change the recipe nor their staff. The food is sinfully good.

Suvio Pizzeria & Restaurant

3.3

(98 reviews)