fast service, affordable prices. generous portions. I had the eggplant parm and mushroom slice. Not too hot where it burned my mouth like other pizzerias! Good place to grab a quick lunch or dinner. Can't wait to try more things here! read more

Baldwin Pizzeria - Half eaten eggplant parm and mushroom slice! So good I almost forgot to take a photo! - Pizza Near Me - Parsippany, New Jersey

The best pizzerias I've been to in Northern NJ. Not fancy, but the staff is very nice especially Justin. Food is excellent and their pizza is always good. I personally like their Chicken rolls, and the Shrimp Bistro Salad. Been going about 20 years for quick lunches at work and still get takeout from them. There have been a handful of times things were not perfect, but they have always been very quick to make things right and listen to all feedback. Still my favorite pizza and chicken rolls in NJ. read more

Baldwin's Pizza is one of the best places one can find in this area, especially given the number of pizza places in Parsippany! There are restaurants everywhere and it had been a search when we first moved into the area to find a pizza place that would deliver and that we liked. Baldwin's has excellent service, great prices and a selection of food that will take some time to try everything they offer. Recently, Baldwin's updated their equipment and their menu, which has improved service. The additional items are delicious, especially their Caprina Salad (give it a try if you get the chance). All of their food is delicious, always arrives hot. The only criticism I would give is the busy hours orders take around 40 - 50 minutes; time when it might be good to have an extra driver on hand to get the lunch/dinner orders out in a more timely fashion (What do I know? It may be that this suggestion might not work). Baldwin's staff is very friendly, knows their customers well, and has renovated the restaurant nicely. It's a great place to eat inside or out, or have your food delivered. Unlike Papa John's Pizza, they do NOT put in a forced gratuity of $2.00 that doesn't go to the delivery person. That is just so wrong. Baldwin's Pizza is definitely a winning experience! read more

This is a nice neighborhood place in a strip mall. A little tattered around the edges, but it has been there a long time. All of the tables were dirty though, which is not ok as there were plenty of guys working there and they weren't busy. The have the usual Italian menu, and plenty of slices on hand. I have eaten their slices before and they are pretty good. But I decided to try something different and went for the meatball parm sandwich. It was reasonably priced, coming as a combo with fries and a pop for about 8 bucks. The sandwich was pretty good, with a great roll, ok cheese and sauce, and store bought meatballs. The service was good and the guys were friendly, but the food wasn't exceptional and they need to put some money back into the place. Buy some new tablecloths, for crying out loud. There are plenty of pizza places in town and many of them are better than Baldwin Pizzeria. read more

I was in the area and decided to get a slice. Walked in and noticed how clean the place was. Ordered a slice of Margherita and had to give it 5 stars. Love that the sauce is slightly sweet and how all the flavors come together. Crust was fluffy but crisp and once slice just wasn't enough :) read more

Best pizza in Parsippany! I love this place. I've been ordering from here for the last 14 years and they are consistently excellent. I'm very picky about my pizza, but theirs is so flavorful and delicious. read more

We came across this pizzeria after a day of being on the baseball field with the kids. Service was great! Both the cashiers were extremely polite and welcoming. We started our meal off with garlic knots and sauce which tasted amazing. Our kids had a large plain pie that was packed with flavor. It tasted fresh and they did not skimp out on the amount of cheese or sauce used. I had the lasagna which came with a salad and side of bread. My husband had the cheesesteak and was really happy with the overall taste and value. We will definitely stop by again in the near future !! read more

I LOVE this place. I was staying in the area on business and their slices are some of the best I have ever had -- and I've lived in Brooklyn for 10 years. I drove back here recently just to try it again. Sooooooooooooooooooo good read more

Tortellini en brodo soup is hands down delicious. Also chicken noodle is great! Best bang for buck indeed! Love this place.

I thought the pizza was good but the chicken francese was very salty, and the chicken marsala tasted like nothing but SALT, SALT, SALT. I couldn't taste the chicken or the marsala. If I didn't bring it home to eat I would have given it back to you. I couldn't finish it because I was getting sick from all that SALT. Can you tell me why you have salt shakers on every table, is that a joke? Lose the salt and let ME season it - why should a salt-a-holic dictate how much salt I want on my food? read more

New in town and tried this place out. Very glad we did. For a pizza place... they have some darn good soup!! We go sometimes just for that. They do have good pizza too. Friendly staff, quick delivery. Very satisfied so far! read more

This was ok pizza, kinda like if you walk into any generic Manhattan giant slice pizza spot. My problem is that I'm never looking to eat that kind of pizza. read more

Terrific service. Reasonable prices. Had a quick 2 slices of sausage pizza after attending a convention nearby.

This is the best pizzeria in town by far! There customer service is amazing, very clean, and the food it's absolutely delicious! There's not a time I've ordered from Baldwin pizzeria that I was the slightest bit disappointed. read more

Very rude employees in at the Baldwin Pizza in Parsippany NJ. You come there with a side of order of employee attitude and downright stupidity when dealing with these people. Every time we walk in the place, this being the last time ever, there's no management, there's no direction. Every time we order an item, she rings it up and makes us pay for it, add another item same thing, place had no common sense and is not worth going there anymore. Had enough of the moronic stupidity from this place. We're done! read more

Great pizza and great customer service! I had the margarita pizza perfect balance of cheese and sauce and basil! Sauce was very tasty!

This is my well done pie delivered as is. I don't think I even need to say much more. Called back and they said they'll need the pie back as well as pictures. I've had this happen before and the RIGHT thing to do is say keep it and we'll bring you a brand new one right away. Not wait 20 mins till we do it the right way and then take the bad pie back. Super unprofessional. read more

Baldwin Pizzeria - Pizza Near Me - Parsippany, New Jersey

This greasy pizza place is slightly below average in my opinion. The grease is a little excessive but the toppings are decent. Nothing to write home about so don't expect much.... read more

Walked in to get 1plain slice..guy with a bad attitude, could tell by the angry look on his face..gave me the last slice on the tray in the oven, it came out looking like an abortion with cheese missing, small and old looking..I asked for a different one..with his nasty attitude told me "that's all they have" keep in mind it's 6:30 on a Friday evening..there's a lot of pizzerias in the area..avoid this one!! and from previous experience their pizza sucks anyway! read more

Have passed by many times but didn't go inside since the pizzeria looks small. Guess the food won't be good. BUT really love this place after first tried the chicken pasta with vodka source. It's incredible great!!! Strongly recommend. I don't cook at all my stomach become more and more picky with food. I have to say the food there really meets my taste. A friend recommends chicken pasta with red source, it's OK to me since I am not very into red source. But seafood combo and soup are awesome! The price there is good. With the coupon even better. Might consider it as my another kitchen. read more

I had the worst Chicken Parm hero thatI have ever experienced: dried out chicken, plastic cheese, tasteless sauce, and mediocre bread. I will stick with Pasquale's in Boonton. read more

Food is delicious!!! Pepperoni lightly cooked is our family "go to order", we order: large Chicken Caesar salad dressing on the side & chicken noodle soup. My critic would be the never order Caesar salad with dressing on it bc I've received a soggy salad numerous times. (That can happen to any place) and my kids love the chicken noodle soup which I personally add water at home for less sodium. Their dough and sauce is delicious. I recommend his place read more

Saw the so-so reviews and took a chance on ordering a regular 16 inch pizza for take out. Picked it up 13 minutes later and it was definitely worth it. Loved the thin crust. Maybe they got their act together or maybe I was just lucky. read more

We LOVED Baldwin Pizza. My Wife has ordered their Sandwiches and We have ordered pizza slices from them. I like their Caprese (sp). Well as of tonight we are never going back. My Wife ordered dinner for the three of us the Caprese for me soup for my Daughter and a Monte Rey sandwich for Herself. They gave her the Monte Cristo which has ham. She doesn't eat ham. When we got home and she opened her sandwich to eat they gave her the Monte Cristo. She called and told them of the mistake, the Owner's reply was that is what you ordered. She said no I don't eat ham. They replaced but did not even offer an apology for their mistake. They lost a customer and they are very close to us. read more

Went in this afternoon as my wife and I were in the area and looking to grab a slice. We went in and ended up with a garlic knots, a medium pie, and a chicken francese sub. Everything was surprisingly good. Only negative was we wanted a personal pizza to share and we were told that they didn't have anymore personal size dough. On the other hand, we had lots leftover to bring home. read more

Like most people I love pizza and I have had really bad and really great with everything in between. This place is one of the better tasting pies you'll find, the owner is a great supporter of the community and puts out a lot of really good food options. Besides the pizza, we have had sandwiches, pasta and paninis and enjoyed it all. Great place to just grab a slice or get a whole meal. Nice place, nice people and really good food. read more

I had the chicken parm dinner . Came with a small salad which was meh. The minestrone soup was pretty good, As for my chicken parm entree: it was devoid of any good taste as the sauce tasted as if it were poured out of a can with no seasoning. The accompanying pasta was hard and tasteless. This chicken parm dinner would be at the bottom of my list . Chicken parm is one of my favorites , but this one missed the mark. read more

I am seriously picky about pizza..... Just picked up and dined on large pie w/ half onion... This pizza was AWESOME. I also ordered Alfredo sauce so I could put it on my own ww pasta. Best za & value ever By the way I have been eating this pizza since 1975....ITS JUST AS AWESOME EVER. You'll see!!! read more

Hit or miss. Sometimes its good and sometimes its annoyingly bad.

Best pizza in town! The five stars are for the pizza, though. Had eggplant Parmesan and baked ziti that were not edible.

I had the cheese steak first time which was good. Today ordered chicken marsala with linguini. The chicken was alright but the oasta was soaked in the sauce. The suace was really really sour and would not recommend it. The price was pretty high got the chicken and amn extra small chicken salad with a coke for $24. read more

Ordered a slice of pizza. It took ten mins and it was burnt. I saw her talk to the guy and he said sell it. Pizza doesn't take that long to heat up and she was talking to the guy for a very long time about personal issues. We wanted to give it a try but there's an Anthony Francos a minute away. We will not be returning read more

This pizzeria has been around forever and has always been a solid stop for good pizza and Italian food. Today I noticed their new panini menu and decided to give it s try. Got the Baldwin panini with grilled chicken, grilled onions , avocado, mozzarella and chipotle mayo. WOW, what a great panini. Huge, served on flatbread and grilled to perfection. The flatbread trumps the standard bread as it is less dense while still giving the it a great crispy texture. Very tasty and worth a trip if you in he area. This is a 5 star sandwich. read more

Very disappointing. I ordered a Calzone with pepperoni and mushrooms, side Caesar salad. The salad came first and clearly this was just Ken's salad dressing. I can live with that but expected better. Next came the calzone, I cut into it and they forgot to put pepperoni and mushrooms in it. I called them back and they took it to the back. Figured they would remake it ... Nope, the butterflies it and stuffed mushrooms and pepperoni in it. Then brought it back. So now the calzone falls apart as it try to eat it. Can't really tell you how it tasted as I was so shocked how they handled it. The employees watched waiting to see my reaction, you could tell they knew what they did was wrong. Will not be returning read more

My parents used to get pizzas from here when we lived in the area 30 some years ago and I still go there now. They made a good pizza pie and their pasta is also good. Cheesesteaks too! I usually come by here and we have a pizza or a pasta craving. read more

Had a family dinner here and everyone was happy with their meal. Service was great and we didn't feel rushed even though we got to talking after our meal and lost track of time. Food was hot and delicious. Reasonable prices and large portions. Wasn't local for us, but we will make the trip to go back. read more

if i rated it just by the pizza, i would give 6 stars we have been eating there for 40 years! i just had the worst customer service a young girl was extremely rude she kept trying to rush me off the phone. i started to say i need u to tell the driver one little thing yor he won't find us. the girl cut me off and said just give me your address !!! guess wha??!!! the driver got lost like i said he kept calling from his car! im going to miss their food..i give the girls a 0 ues pizza was ice cold disgusting read more

Pizza is ok, I enjoy Anthony Franco's more, however. The buffalo chicken wrap I had yesterday was terrible unfortunately. The chicken appeared to be poor quality and save for a small dash of hot sauce, there was nothing "buffalo" about it. The breading was not very appetizing either. I don't get the impression that a lot of care goes into their food preparation. read more

Baldwin Pizzaeria is a mixed bag. On one hand their Pasta is great... but on the other hand their Pizza is lacking. So judging just by their pasta alone I'd say go for it. One more thing...the staff is pretty friendly but I've noticed that they have a tendency to forget things whenever I order to-go. read more

I have been going hear for 30 years and it is always great and fresh . Thank you for years of great food . I even remember the kitchen staff fight in the 80's when they where stabbing each other lol !!!!! read more