I really enjoyed this stop on our way home from Key West. It has two seating areas, one casual area outside, one more formal area inside. We sat outside on a picnic table. It was casual with a great view of the sunset. The food was good, but nothing crazy in my opinion. It was expensive but we were more paying for the sunset view. My wife's fish tacos were good but the serving size was not very generous. The meat was well cooked and well seasoned. The toppings were fresh but the tortillas were falling apart from the moisture. My grouper sandwich was good but the bottom bun was very soft. The fries were excellent! Service was good overall. We did have servers swap during our time and no one really introduced themselves but overall they did well. I wouldn't say it was the best by any means, but if you are in the area and want to have a casual meal and watch the sunset, it's pretty decent! I'm sure there are better in the area. read more

See all

Come hungry, food is great, stay for the sunset. Gorgeous bay views, laid back Keys energy, and the kind of place where one drink somehow turns into watching the whole sunset with great service. read more

The views are fantastic and sitting outside at the picnic tables is awesome. The food was average and the service was well below average. I think the server actually forgot about us at one point. The food took way too long to get to our table and the server was really slow in refilling drinks. The manager was able to assist her even though the server wasn't that busy. The portion size was average and probably not worth what we paid. This restaurant was recommended for its sunset view and that didn't disappoint. However, there are plenty of other restaurants with scenic view with much better food and service. We will try one of those next time. read more

Amazing view, fun place to boat to for lunch, lots of menu items. Note upstairs has a more extensive menu (and a better view) than the bar downstairs. Service was good, food decent, and prices reasonable for the area and view. read more

See all

I was not happy with this place, it was such a money grab. I paid for my son to have the kids steak, I asked for Rice as a side substitute but they wouldn't accommodate. Then I ordered seafood nachos, I asked for some extra pico de gallo and the server rang in an appetizer size with chips for $8! All I wanted was extra pico for my nachos. I wouldn't have minded paying a little extra money but $8?!!! He just wanted to get his check size bigger! I will not be coming back! I will also warn others. read more

Bayside Grille & Sunset Bar - Seafood Near Me - Key Largo, Florida

See all

Mahi Ruben was amazing. Wife had a fried chicken salad that was also great. Beer-- very cold. People that rate this place low are probably whiners and complainers that can't be pleased. Not my kind. read more

This was an amazing spot for dinner and a sunset! Sit upstairs so you can get the best views. I started with the sunset marg which was pretty sweet - probably would go for a different drink next time. I wanted to sample a bunch of different seafoods so I ended up ordering the ocean bounty bucket! Plenty of food for 1 person and would make a good app for 2. The conch was interesting - I read you should go for cracked conch over a fritter but the fritters were good. Always love a fried shrimp and the scallop was really good as well! The mahi wasn't quite as tender as I wanted. Of course had to end with some key lime pie! My servers were super sweet and helpful with recommendations and I got to sit right next to the balcony. Make sure you don't miss the sunset! read more

See all

Great food one of the best cheeseburgers definitely try the smoke fish dip and the couch fritters and the view is priceless. Great service definitely coming back. read more

The food is tasty and you can't beat the view. It's on the bayside and is just everything 'Keys Life' is about. Good food, good drinks, sun and fun. Service is good. We sat at the downstairs area. They had great live music, great drinks and food. We didn't get a chance to take pictures but we had shrimp, lobster, nachos! All were very tasty. read more

Bayside Grille & Sunset Bar - Sat downstairs! Great views of the bay. - Seafood Near Me - Key Largo, Florida

See all

Absolutely enjoyed the beautiful sunset view, live music and had their house specialty rum punch. They blow the conch horn at sunset which was cool. We tried conch fritters everywhere we went and found these to be the best. We also got a slice of their own in house made Key Lime pie. It was a dense cheesecake style that was different than others and so delicious! Wonderful tropical laid back vibe. Definitely would recommend next time I am coming by boat! read more

Bayside Grille & Sunset Bar - Sunset views - Seafood Near Me - Key Largo, Florida

The food needs work. I wish I'd taken pictures of the food. While everything was edible and the staff was great - the food was pretty average to below average. They started with a nice complimentary bread basket (banana & cranberry) which would be wonderful at breakfast time. We ordered the Buffalo conch fritters - I know weird right?! The sauce was good and spicy - the conch was shoe leather. My husband and I shared the fish trio which was pretty tasty, but the sauce was thick and strangely flavored - with crispy capers My son had the shrimp and chicken linguine. Another oddball sauce. Meat and pasta were good though. For dessert the housemade key lime pie was actually a cheesecake, but delicious. The chef's choice mango cheesecake - not good. They have the view - now they need to elevate their food game. read more

The service, food and ambiance is great! I would recommend some more attention to the cleanliness of the bathroom! If they would've been clean, it would've been a 5-star! Andrés was an amazing server! read more

Amazing ambiance and service. A lot of waitstaff. Gorgeous view and sunset. We sat upstairs and had a corner table near the women's bathroom. I didn't mind as the sun was already setting and most of our dining was when the sun went down. Started with yellowtail ceviche - strong on the citrus and coconut milk. Tasty but a little overwhelming. The Jamaican peel and eat shrimp were really good. Husband had the lobster pasta special. I got trio fish and they came w Mahi, yellowtail and triple tail mmmm. Side of rice and some seasoned squash. Delicious. Husband was very fond of the sunset margarita. The waitress Geo gave us this complimentary piece of key lime pie because our food took too long (not necessary but kind). We had just paid and were leaving. Geo stopped me and handed me a key lime pie slice and said it was for our food taking so long. We had not complained and I told her that was not expected but aww thank you. How sweet. Very great place to dine. read more

See all

Would have loved to stay for dinner and more drinks at our table... Couldn't get our server or a server to check in. Had our one drink and closed out ((at the bar since our server was MIA). But since this is prime waterfront property, this will likely not be corrected. read more

Great sunset location Food was just ok. I had the danish ribs. Too much sauce for my tastes. The potato puffs you can keep. Not a fan of those. read more

I cannot believe this restaurant doesn't have more stars. Or better reviews. I could not find anything wrong. Neither the service or the food. Everything was SUPERB! We were able to sit wherever we wanted. We decided to sit in a table for four on the first floor, outdoor. Not sure if the second level has inside seating but it was a perfect evening with a nice breeze. We definitely wanted outdoor seating plus the sun was setting. My husband ordered for me a Key Lime Mojito and he had a MoTito. My first Mojito since I'm not an alcohol drinker but it was the perfect drink to relax & recharge. My batteries were fried...lol We also decided to order the Seafood Nachos and it was D E L I C I O U S! The nachos were regular chips. Good but the star of the show was the seafood of course! The fish, shrimp and scallops were seasoned to perfection. It was chef's kiss for real!! I honestly was full with the nachos but I was curious about the Seafood Enchiladas. My husband was still hungry and wanted to try the Ocean Bounty Bucket of fried fish, scallops, shrimp and potato wedges. Oh it also included Conch fritters and a side of cocktail sauce and tartar sauce. Every single bite of everything I tried in that "bucket" was bursting with flavor and fried to a nice crisp. The cocktail sauce (which is never my favorite) was sooo good. I don't know if it's homemade but it was the best I have ever tried. Tartar sauce was pretty good too. I almost didn't have room for dessert BUT I knew I couldn't leave without trying a slice of their homemade Key Lime pie. I figured if the food we ordered was great then I could only imagine what their desserts taste like. I was right. Key Lime Pie 10/10!!! Not too overpowering, very creamy with just the right amount of sweet & tangy. The crust was delicious too. I can't wait to go back and try more entrees and desserts! This place seriously exceeded my expectations and was a lot better than other popular spots in Key Largo! read more

See all

Overall not good. I'm not sure of the good reviews. The service and the view were great but that is where it ended. We stopped by on a whim for some good local seafood. We ordered the conch fritter bites, the catch of the day "Keyribbean Style", and a burger. The fish seemed like it came from the freezer section of the local grocery store and was really bland and "cheap" tasting. The redskin mashed potatoes and vegetables of the day were nothing special. Overall I felt like we were eating a fish dish from a local school cafeteria or hospital. The conch fritters were ok but I have had better at other locations throughout the Keys and the Caribbean. The burger was the only highlight. Do yourself a favor and continue down the highway to somewhere else. read more

What a great staff. Teresa is by far one off the best and caring people out there and awesome at her job. The mojitos are always on point. Thank you again for everything. See you again Pete and Amy. PS thank you SO MUCH BEN YOU ARE TRUELY A ROCKSTAR read more

Restaurant is tucked down a small road shared with another establishment. ...keep driving down the back road, you will run right into it. This restaurant has a great view of the water, better as the sun is going down. The food is one of the best in town. The conch chowder was hearty and the jambalaya was outstanding. It seemed as if service was a little short on staff, but they worked hard to make sure you were taken care of. One of the best places on the island. I came to the Keys to see a pretty sunset, and we got dinner with a great view as well! read more

Bayside Grille & Sunset Bar - Seafood Near Me - Key Largo, Florida

The view is great, however, you could only eat upstairs and the windows were locked, meaning the stench of fish is trapped inside and has no way of getting out. The food was honestly not great by any means. I find the amount of 5-star reviews pretty odd considering the experience we had. I strongly recommend going somewhere else. read more

All I have to say is the view is beautiful, but that is it. To say the food was disappointing is an understatement. My girlfriend's rice bowl with tuna was awful and no better than a bowl that you get at chipotle. Absolutely horrendous. $35 for that pile of garbage, what a complete waste of money. I wouldn't feed it to my cat! My triple tail fish sandwich was edible but once again for $30 a complete rip. My margarita had zero alcohol in it.. stay away from this place. There's a Burger King across the street. You'll get a better meal. I guarantee it and you'll save a lot of money. read more

Incredible indoor, bayside lunch today! My family came here for lunch to enjoy the views on the water and was not disappointed! The restaurant was not busy at all so we got the best table overlooking the water. Our waiter was attentive the entire time. We ordered the coconut shrimp and Bayside Mahi Sandwich. Our food tasted so good, and I was planning to eat half my sandwich but ended up eating the entire thing. What a gem of a restaurant in Key Largo, a must go-to if staying here or passing through. read more

Bayside Grille & Sunset Bar - Bayside Mahi Sandwich - Seafood Near Me - Key Largo, Florida

Always a good experience. Staff is. Friendly and knowledgeable. Food is well presented and delicious.

Bayside Grill & Sunset Bar is a great waterfront location, we sat in second floor and had a fantastic view of the Key Largo sunset! Great fish and margaritas. We hung out and enjoyed listening to the live music. Great evening! read more

See all

Service was great! My kids loved the coconut shrimp and fried chicken. We were fighting over the potato puffs! So good! Homemade ranch. Cesar salad was very fresh and the homemade dressing was delicious. Fish tacos very good too! read more

Sat at the bar without a wait. You could tell the staff was busy/stressed and they informed us it'd be a while for food. We happily ordered drinks which came quick and put our food in. Lucky for us the food was out in no time and delicious!!! We loved the you peel shrimp, mahi tacos and mixed seafood bucket--- ESPECIALLY the scallops which they brought extra of! Despite the hectic atmosphere the staff stayed calm and pleasant under pressure and we had a great night! Ended it with a key lime pie! read more

Bayside Grille & Sunset Bar - Key lime pie - Seafood Near Me - Key Largo, Florida

While on our little trip to the Keys, we decided to drop into Bayside Grille and see what they had to offer. This was a 2 story resturant with a beach area with giant beach chairs for photo ops! Also a dock. The lower floor was more casual with a live band and bar area and upstairs was a more elegant dining room with great ocean view. Obviously it was a fantastic sunset view and good food! We didn't need a reservation and we went upstairs to the dining area and were seated directly in front of a fantastic view! Impressive! We ordered the Clams for an appetizer and they were medium size and delicious. I had the Osso Bussco with mashed potatoes. It was good but not the best that I have tasted. It could've been a bit more juicy. My daughter had the Lobster and Crab Cake with mashed potatoes. She loved it. Our server was Melissa and she was very attentive and friendly. We had a nice evening. The sunset view was spectacular. We look forward to coming back. read more

See all

Staff was very welcoming and friendly. Kudos to our server, Jen for handling multiple tables at a time efficiently. She recommended the pecan crusted triple tail and it did not disappoint! We wanted to have key lime pie while in the Keys. It's made in house and is amazing! Great view of the bay! We got there about 4:30 and enjoyed the sunset. So glad we made this our one stop in Key Largo! read more

Great food and ambiance. Meghan our waitress was amazing, very good service. Great pricing too! read more

See all

This is a restaurant with more than just a good view! We came on a Friday night and snuck in to a table facing the ocean (lucky us, perfect timing). While we weren't served right away, they dropped off bread and came back as quickly as they could. As far as I could tell, there were only two servers running the whole show, so we were patient. I got "The Black Pearl" cocktail, which was a piña colada with a rum shot on top. It was fabulous! The food was better than most restaurants with this kind of view. The conch chowder was hearty and the jambalaya was filling! I came to the Keys to see a pretty sunset, and we got dinner with a great view as well! read more

See all

Came to Isla Morada for a day trip with my friend and we ended our day eating here. We got to watch a basketball game, have great drinks at the bar, and eat some delicious food. I think the upstairs has a different menu then downstairs. I would ask about this if you come here. Our server was amazing and extremely attentive. This was the perfect place to wind down after snorkeling. Highly recommend . read more

See all

Our favorite Key Largo brunch spot! Great views of the bay and sunset! Sunday brunch and sunset is our favorite time to go to bayside. Highly recommend the tuna nachos, brisket and egg tacos , Havana fries , loaded brisket fries and the shrimp and grits! Staff is always friendly and tentative. read more

See all

Bland bland bland fish. Texture felt frozen. I wouldn't go back. Service was ok, view was the highlight of evening.

The staff was super welcoming and very friendly. We never had to wait for refills on drinks. Loved the singer for the live music. Gorgeous views of the waters. The sunset view was indescribably stunning. The steak medallions were delicious! The shrimp was slightly over fried but the coconut layer cake is worth just going back every time! read more

See all

Great food and atmosphere. Great large bar and another upstairs. Great views and service is prompt & kind.

If you are looking for an amazing view of the sunset and great happy hour drink specials, this is a great place. Bar area is fun with live music. The food is subpar. Ordered the Mahi Tacos. The Mahi was dry. On a good note the slaw and wasabi sauce on the tacos was good. One in the group ordered lobster. It was just ok. Asked for butter for lobster ( which is normally warm/ liquid) multiple times it showed up solid. The server said it took time to come from the kitchen, yet it was frig cold. Tried the wings, they were just ok. Nothing special. I was told from the local hotels to avoid the place foodwise. I really hope they figure out the food. This place could become a hotspot. read more

See all

We had a blast here!!! Beautiful views, great food, and drinks. There was a live band and we had fun dancing all night. read more

See all

Food was great, view was great, food was a little pricy, but it was good so it was worth it. Live music when we came on a Friday night. read more

Bayside Grille & Sunset Bar - Seafood Near Me - Key Largo, Florida

Loved everything about this place. So much fun! And everyone was so friendly. We will go here every time we are in key largo. read more

Bayside Grille & Sunset Bar - Seafood Near Me - Key Largo, Florida

This little gem by the bay has the best shrimp in the keys. Always fresh, and the spicy steamed shrimp is perfect with a cold beer for sunset. read more