Love the atmosphere here. In the summer you can look out at the boats cruising the causeway. In the…read morewinter it's still a fun place. Food is always good and the waitress and bartenders are great. The pork chop was tender and tasteful but the canned apples were a turnoff . Fresh apple slices would be so much more appealing.

The restaurant itself was really nice. Comfortable seating, good vibes, clean, modern, great views…read more Service was excellent! Super friendly waitress, quick response. Even though it was busy we didn't feel pushed out. Enjoyed our meal. However, the food was a bit lacking. A few of us had the fish and chips, fish was just okay, the breaded batter was not great and it was overcooked. The coleslaw was just gross. It was bitter, wilted, warm and just plain inedible. The fish sandwich was good and the mac and cheese was served nearly cold and congealed. The watermelon splash cocktail was excellent! But the coconut margarita tasted like pure tequila. Had to ask for some pineapple juice to tame it down so it was drinkable. For the price, the food should be better. Thankfully everything else was wonderful or we would have left very disappointed.

We have been going here since it opened a few years ago . It just slips my mind every time to leave…read morea review. The food is always great and the fish is extremely fresh . I've had several items on the menu . This time I had the haddock sandwich with coleslaw and a cup of clam chowder. The chowder is thick , creamy and delicious. The haddock was lightly battered and delicious as well. My fiancé had the lobster stew and crab sandwich on gluten free bun . The lobster stew is also gluten free. He said the crab sandwich was outstanding! They also have vet delicious French fries ! The restaurant has a farm house feel to it . Very comfortable atmosphere and friendly bar/waitstaff .

1/20/26 bitter cold with intermittent squalls- Oysters are…read moreshucked ever day now, but are $2 per on Thursday- I take this to mean the shucker is a rookie on other days; he was at least today. Had 12 Norumbagas with 2-4 shell bits per oyster. Gained an appreciation for those shuckers at The shop, Freeport oyster house, etc. Got sautéed scallops- about a dozen- perfectly cooked, 10/10. Honestly, a dish you would find on the French coast. So: oysters: 5/10 scallops: 10/10. As I have said previously, don't come here for the oysters. DO come for the scallops if Tara is cooking.

Pondicherry House was a 10/10. The food, drinks, and service were great! The steak special and…read morechicken Marsala were clearly fresh and cooked perfect. Our waitress Stephanie was amazing - very good service, sense of humor, and very kind! We will be back for the food and Stephanie's service !

Ambiance is cozy - I really loved it. The vibe is combo bar/open kitchen/cozy dining. It's not a…read morebig place and they recommend reservations. Parking was behind the place. And the service was really nice. It was a bit warm and one server told us to go ahead and open the window, but another came over and had me close it. So it was HOT. Maybe we were close to something hot? The pasta is made in house which I love. Food was creative. I do want to go back and try more. I had a chicken marsala, and it was classic. My husband had a risotto with scallops and it was good. The sauces are a bit heavy, but delicious.

I called in an order for two lobsters, cooked, to be picked up at 5:00. Gave my name. Checked…read moreprices. Was told they'd be ready. I got there shortly before 5, waited for ten minutes while the guy filled another order. My turn came. No lobsters ready. No order found. Totally disorganized search through orders scattered around the counter. I didn't have time to wait for them to cook the lobsters. I've dealt with this place for years and never had a problem. Hope this was a blip, but if you're calling in an order, be sure they confirm with some guarantee, especially if you have company for dinner!

Our go-to lobster (and steamers and fresh fish) place when we have company or when it's just us…read more Prices are fair. Lobster rolls are simple and therefore delicious! Whole 1.25# lobsters tonight were meaty and perfectly cooked. Lucky to have them nearby.

This place is right across the street from where I live. Guess it's time I review them…read more I've patronized Fishermen's Catch a couple of times, mostly because it's convenient. They offer their lobster rolls on special at least once a year for a few days so that is what I wait for. Lobster rolls are pretty good but could use a tad more flavor. They used to be $35 but now it's $38. Would I pay that for a lobster roll with chips? I think not. I brought my mom here on a separate occasion and she did enjoy her steamed lobster. That time I got their haddock sandwich which came with a side of fries. The fries were crispy and tasty. Service is usually pretty quick even when there is a little bit of a line. They only have outside dining which could get hectic because it is off of 302. Overall, they do a solid job but they are on the expensive side.

My favorite lobster roll. Took me years of driving by to finally try them and I'm disappointed with…read moremy last self for not stopping sooner. The service is fast, the location is convenient & the lobster rolls are perfection. Most recently, I ate here twice in the same week. No notes.

Great fresh food and friendly knowledgeable service!! We make it a point to go every summer for…read morethe wonderful selection! My go to place for sure!!

We always call ahead and place a lobster and steamers order. It has always been fresh and…read moredelicious. I love that it is a small family owned business. They are always friendly and accommodating. We will keep coming back!

Service - food - outside ( and inside) seating area with sun umbrella - they also sell fresh…read moreseafood - clear lobster meat scallops etc....

Cooked 15 min. Black rot...stink...customer service terrible saying I undercooked...15 is normal…read moreSmells rotten

Service and view are fantastic! Forest lobster roll in Maine and it did not disappoint! I was…read moreexpecting a lobster salad... it pure lobster sweet meat... amazing

Okay....I am a bit of a lobster roll snob. Haha! Self proclaimed, of course. I've eaten lobster…read morerolls all through Maine and I keep coming back to this one. They use fresh Maine lobster and know how to cook it to perfection. IYKYK. Then I have light mayo with a side of butter to drizzle. Perfection. Add the causeway fries with the house sauce and YUM! The buffalo chicken Rangoons are yummy, too. Honestly, all of the food choices are the best. It's a locally family owned restaurant so everyone is nice there, too. Can't wait to go back at least one more time!

Great local tavern Excellent food…read moreA little loud Cool outdoor space with a bar, bands, karaoke Service A+++++

We visit Gary's year round and tonight was a bad experience. we arrived and waiting 10 minutes…read morebefore we went to the hostess station to ask if they were going to serve us. in the meantime another table in the dining room was served drinks. The people at the waitress station said they would send our server over. After an additional 5 minutes, we walked out and saw that a couple that wasn't there on our way in had their drinks. We told the waitstaff, still standing at the hostess station that we were leaving and they looked surprised. Really folks, we ate here often in the past and 15 minutes without a server coming over is unacceptable, get your act together!!