Four adults out for a Sunday dinner. We thought we would need a reservation for a table at 5:15 but they're "first come first served." We didn't need to wait; handicap parking was available right at the ramp; easy in and out. Our booth was comfortable, and the appearance of the dining room is improved (cleaner, brighter, smooth floors and tables) from our last visit (over 2 years ago). Three orders of fried clams. One order of chicken parm on pasta. Servings were huge!! Fries were hot and fresh. Drinks didn't break the bank (1 wine and 1 Lone Pine beer, 2 sodas). When we go back we will order an app and 1 fried clam platter for the 3 seafood fans. Yes, chicken parm again! read more

My wife and I just had the worst meals we have had in a long time. We remember a time when Bay Haven served quality meals. Last night I had the haddock dinner. The salad and fries were fine, but the haddock was heavy and greasy. Could not finish it. My wife had the shrimp with onion rings. The shrimp were tiny, heavy and greasy. the onion rings were big and greasy and tasted horrible. Had 1 glass of $12 pinot grigio and it tasted like vinegar. the bill came to $75 and change. the waitress was great, but the food was horrible. We went home with very heavy stomachs - not feeling well. Would never go back again! what happened? new ownership? new cooks? read more

This place had a cool vibe & a cool atmosphere. It was pretty packed on a Friday night. Food that I saw looked really good. The menu is medium to a little pricey, but I think you get what you paid for. For as busy as it was, customer service was really on point. I would definitely come back here and try something else on the menu. Fish & chips looked really Good..!! Another cool place to add to the GOOD LIST.... well done Guys...!! My Burger was .Com read more

See all

The service is always top notch. Portions are large. Bloody Mary was good. Alfredo makes it worth the drive! I love the clam cakes as well. read more

Bay Haven Lobster Pound - Fisherman platter - Seafood Near Me - Cornish, Maine

See all

3.5 stars... I have been eating here on and off for 20 years, used to be great, maybe my taste has changed... the wait staff was great, younger kids... I ordered the fish chowder, celery was in big hunks and very raw, the chowder was thin, more like a bisque and there fish was some nice big hunks of fish in it... the crabby patty's were not fried long enough and were quite mushy while the dipping sauce was nice... my wife suggested we get the poutine (which we try everywhere quite frequently as we travel a lot) and something put me off about it, the hand cut French fries were undercooks and some fries were still quite raw and inedible, maybe it was the oil they were fried in? Or maybe it was something off in the gravy but it didn't taste right like something was spoiled or off in them... it was a Large bowl with cheese and gravy which we did not finish... Over all I would like it to be like I remember it over the years, but it was just ok, the fish chowder was the best part of what we ordered. Overall, 3.5 stars. read more

Bay Haven Lobster Pound - Crab cakes and poutine - Seafood Near Me - Cornish, Maine

See all

This place has gone downhill. I heard the place changed ownership a while back. They changed the batter on their seafood. It's no longer that crispy seafood. We ordered a side of chicken tenders thinking they would be hand made and they were the same flat, frozen chicken tenders you get at a pizza joint. The amount of food you get has been reduced to mostly undercooked French fries. When the plate comes out you think WOW until you eat the first layer of seafood and find a huge amount of fries underneath. I did notice the place was pretty empty and can understand why now. We used to have to wait in line to get in. So sad that a place that was so good is now just another lowered quality place to eat. Our server was outstanding which is a plus. read more

After a couple of disappointing times, The wife and I decided to try once more. Again another disappointment. She had a hamburger sub that was chopped up greasy (I think it was) beef. Steamed clams that were not cleaned. Felt Like I was eating beach sand. Cole slaw had absolutely no flavor. That will be that last time we go there. So sad that they went down hill so fast. read more

To be honest, I have never had a bad meal or experience here. Huge portions & great waitstaff make for a great atmosphere.

Went to BayHaven for the 1st time in a few years, total disappointment! The parking lot was almost empty on a Saturday night, which I should have taken into consideration after some of the more recent reviews, but went in anyway. I ordered a cocktail that was on the table tent to be told they don't have it... chose something else. Ordered an appetizer and our meals. I had a salad as 1 of my sides. The salad came out immediately, still waited for the appetizer.... After a long wait with few customers the dinners came out... 6 shrimp in my companions baked shrimp with crabmeat stuffing and my baked haddock & scallops with lobster stuffing was horrible! Both stuffings were made of stovetop mine had no lobster & so much butter it wasn't edible. The crabmeat stuffing you could actually see the cubes of dried bread! No happy medium. The seafood was dry in both, even with all of the butter in the 'stuffing'. The bill was over $80 for 3 beers and 2 meals, the appetizer never came! Horrible experience! Will not return and this was a great place once upon a time! read more

Food is top notch. Service is spot on. Nice town. Interesting shops. What more could you want? read more

Cannot say enough as to how good the fisherman's platter was. Seafood, fresh and fried perfectly. the fish was cooked in super clean oil and tasted great. Two adult men shared the platter, ate our fill and had enough left over for another meal. Yes, a bit pricey, but seafood is not cheap. The over all quality was excellent and totally worth the price. Service was excellent, waitperson was attentive and friendly. read more

Friends invited me to lunch here, last week. I've never spent a lot of time in the area and hadn't heard about the place previously. 8 of us went - 5 adults and 3 kids. We made a reservation and our table was ready when we arrived. I had the shrimp dinner, my daughter got scallops. Both were very good. My granddaughter opted for the hamburger dinner with onion rings and was shocked at how big it was. We all had food left over - which we brought home with us - so portions are generous. Comfortable, really laid back environment. Nothing fancy at all but that's just what we were looking for, and we didn't feel rushed at all. The waitress was friendly and efficient - she even took a picture of the motley crew once we finished eating. The whoopie pies looked good but I didn't have enough room left to try one. Maybe next time. read more

Bay Haven Lobster Pound - Scallops, burger, fries and rings. All a hit. - Seafood Near Me - Cornish, Maine

We visited Bay Haven for seafood, we always wish it was like it was in the old days. When we walked in the hostess just looked at us, no smile, no expression. She walked over to us and asked how many and if we wanted to sit in the restaurant or tavern. We chose the restaurant. Off we went to a table menus down and that was it. We all looked at each other and said maybe we should of drove to the other restaurant. Our waitress came over and took our order. She brought us rolls, butter and cole slaw. The rolls were in the microwave a little to long. Hot and rubbery. The butter was good! We all just laughed. I must say our fish dinners were very good. We did order dessert and the coconut cream pie was excellent. We will be back. But sadly, Bay Haven won't be our first choice. It is so true the first person you meet at any business really does matter. read more

See all

Great swordfish! The service is incredible and a nice cozy feel to the place. Love the place and I go any chance I get

We've been going to Bay Haven for 20+ years and it's just sad how far the place has fallen, except the prices which have skyrocketed. The place has been going downhill for some time but it is at rock bottom now. No rolls before or during dinner, warm oven fresh rolls used to be a signature of Bay Haven. The coleslaw was inedible, nowhere close to ripe cabbage cut to large and not a trace of any dressing. The fries at least were adequate. The clam strips were cooked to the point of becoming rubber, it was like chewing on an eraser. The Fisherman's Platter was 75% shrimp and we suspect they may have been canned salad shrimp. Portions size is down and the price is way up. There's a reason the formerly always full parking lot now just has a few cars in it whenever we drive by, which is what we'll be doing from now on. Just a massive disappointment for a place that used to be 'the' go to for our group of friends. read more

We love the service there. They were a little longer on our clam cakes so they bought us new ones and an extra one.. I had the seafood Alfredo. It was fantastic. I had to bring half of it home. My fiancé had the fisherman's platter and it was more food than we could imagine. Definitely worth the money even though it's a little pricey you get what you pay for. read more

Bay Haven Lobster Pound - Seafood Alfredo - Seafood Near Me - Cornish, Maine

See all

Food was good Service was good Prices were outrageous Probably won't be back The value for the money just isn't there. read more

I have worked in the food service for 40+ years I'm so old school that I used to do Caesar Salads table side If you have an item on your menu you should at least know the basic Ingredients the wife and I have been to your restaurant 6 time [ because I believe everyone can have a bad night ] today was the last time we will visit you we both ordered a Caesar Salad w grilled Chicken and no Croutons to go what we got was Romaine Lettuce [ that's a good start and really the only part that was right ] with the Lettuce we got grated Parmesan cheese [ should be shaved or shredded ] the only time you should use grated is while making the dressing and the best part of all was the sides of ITALIAN Dressing Italian Dressing DOES NOT go on a Caesar Salad read more

I have been going to Bay Haven for 30 years but since the new owners took over it has been all downhill. Today I had a clam roll - $20.00!!!- with 10 small and very greasy clams. Horrible. Don't waste your time or your money. Such a disappointment. I won't be going back. read more

Very very disapointed in my experience at Bay Haven. We ordered takeout..the young woman at the counter said the wait was over an hour...I said fine no problem. ..we ordred 2 entrees 1. Haddock and scaollops w/ fries and slaw. 2. Fish & chips,. add onion rings. Well we got the haddock (fillet) and scallops, 2 oz cup of slaw and fish chunks and onion rings. The chips and tarter sauce did not make it. No tarter sauce, no lemon, just threw into a box. The fish was overcooked and not seasoned. The fries not seasoned. Scallops were decent as well as the slaw. $80 and I feel robbed and disaponted. Would I go back? No. read more

See all

Something changed. Hubs got whole belly clams and there were hardly any whole bellys and the clams were really small. Once I got my order that originally came out wrong I ate alone because my husband had finished his meal before my correct order arrived. Service was good but it's not the same. 2 dinners without alcohol was $93...say what! Most likely won't return. read more

You want to support a family owned business then head over to Bay Haven in little ol' Cornish. We started with the onion rings (no photo) that were superb. Then moved on to the clam chowder along with the steamers, fried clams & Chicken bacon ranch sub. Everything was absolutely amazing! Others in our group got the lobster stew, fish n chips, fried scallops & lobster casserole. Anything on the menu will not disappoint. Now let's mention Brooke our absolutely amazing waitress. She did not skip a beat & remembered every little thing our group of 11 orders without blinking an eye. Highly recommend & ask for Brooke read more

Bay Haven Lobster Pound - Steamers with butter - Seafood Near Me - Cornish, Maine

It has been awhile and understand new management took over so we did take out as we were working outside for the day so a quick order ahead with grab and go. New management maybe but same old Bay haven. Take out is same price as inside eating but no rolls or salad to go. Consider going inside next time... let's consider the dinner now. We ordered 2 cups of lobster stew. Recipe changed that they added sherry too much as the lobster also tasted like sherry. One cup had just the right amount of lobster to stew. Second one had just a small piece of lobster. Too bad we were at home or would have gone back. My wife ordered the lobster sandwich that tasted excessively fishy and not the way lobster is, Even rinsed it added fresh mayo but still not very good. Seems it was left too long and should not have served it. Hope all goes well later after it rests in our stomach. I ordered the fried combo with Clams and Scallops. Not many scallops like in pictures on their web showing how good everything is. The clams were clam strips with one that actually had the belly. Clam strips is an option on the menu to add, but we did not. Hand cut fries are always good and bountiful so it looks like a large plateful of food and if it was not for those fries, I may have gone hungry. Time will tell if this place gets better or not. read more

This restaurant was highly recommended by several communities near us. OMG. The sizes of their portions and the selection of food was great. Steamers were shared with 2 people, as there was 14 clams. Then came the lobster stew which was a milk broth loaded with lobster. It was on the thin side not like a true stew. Main means consisted of fried whole clams with mashed and peas and carrots, fried while clams with double baked loaded potato and cole slaw. I had the fried clam strips and scallops with double baked loaded potato and a fisherman's platter. This truly should come with a warning ...can serve 3 people comfortably. HUGE. Needless to saw he had a huge portion for take home. We all brought home food . Prices were good, market price. They offer many baked options as well. Only 30 minutes away. read more

See all

Amazing meal from start to finish! Our food came out quickly, but with adequate time to enjoy our appetizers first. Our server, Brooke, was PHENOMENAL. She made sure all orders were taken down and served with precision and consistently passed by to make sure drinks were filled. We were part of a large group and she split the check up without a single error, which isn't as common as one might think. And the food was delicious. Perfectly cooked and seasoned. Fresh seafood isn't cheap, but the portions are massive so you won't leave without leftovers. We come back every summer for a reason! read more

See all

Bay Haven Restaurant is an absolutely fantastic place to get your seafood fix. The lobster and the fisherman's platter are two definite recommendations. The lobster is wonderful, but no real surprise there, we are in Maine. The fisherman's platter is truly a wondrous and indulgent feast. Add some steamers to either dish and it just get even more fantastic. The service was great and the atmosphere here is simple but that is part of the appeal. All in all, this was a great experience. The northeast has some incredible seafood. In my opinion, the best in the country. It is because of places like Bay Haven Restaurant that makes the northeast achieve the title of best seafood in the country (well, at least in my opinion). I will definitely give Bay Haven Restaurant my recommendations and I will give it five stars for my overall rating. read more

Went here for the 1st time this year for lunch. All the lunch items had no prices. Looked at the regular menu. Same thing. ALL seafood is market price now. Got the shrimp lunch portion which was up 25% from last year. Food is still good, but for a Friday lunch at noontime, the place was nearly empty. Now we know why. The poor waitress had to look up everything for us as there were no prices on the menu. Possibly new management??? read more

The food in the atmosphere is very nice the seafood platters are enormous you could feed three people on One platter

A nice, cozy restaurant with great service and delicious food. The seafood pasta had plenty of lobster and scallops and my steak was cooked perfectly. read more

Bay Haven Lobster Pound - Lobster and Scallop Spaghetti along with Surf 'N Turf - Seafood Near Me - Cornish, Maine

See all

Terrible service, took over an hour and a half to get food, staff was rude and food was mediocre. Not impressed for my first trip to Maine :( read more

The wave of nostalgia that I felt when I walked into this restaurant is indescribable. I grew up visiting this area of Maine and going to Bay Haven at least once each summer and I hadn't been for 15 years. The restaurant was updated a bit and they added a bar in back but it was basically just what I remembered. We started off the the poutine, steamers, and lobster rangoons (WOW) and I had the lobster for my meal. Everything was incredibly delicious and I was blown away by the poutine as I didn't know what to expect from a seafood restaurant but it was fantastic with a ton of cheese curds and lots of creamy gravy. My lobster was cooked perfectly and I savored every single bite. Our waitress Gail was such a sweetheart and made our experience even better. I can't wait to come back next year! read more

See all

Took a ride to Cornish Maine today! Stopped in for dinner! Staff ( hostess ) was super friendly! Place is pretty good sized! Menu has something for everyone ! Starters we had Poutine! It was delicious the hand cut fries were amazing, the gravy and cheese was great as well! Husband had some clam chowder he said it was good but a little too thin , he likes it thicker. I had the baled scallops and shrimp with lobster stuffing, it was good. He had fried haddock and scallops. Food was served hot and fast. read more

See all

Food is great, but stick to the hand cut French fries. Nice restaurant atmosphere, with attentive service. read more

See all

Worst meal ever. Clam chowder was milk, onion, celery, and four clams you'd use for fried clams. No potatoes, no salt or pepper and was runny. Clam roll was tiny and the coleslaw was literally mayo with cabbage and carrots. I ordered take out from the bar and got home and had no tartar sauce or crackers for the soup. Biggest waste of $40 read more

I haven't been in about a year and only once then. Not like the old Bay Haven. The service was just ok. Had to ask for the roll. Had been thinking of how great the baked stuffed scallops used to be and ordered them. Big mistake. Nothing like in the past. The presentation is awful. It comes out in a dish, flat on the top, covered in stuffing. Didn't look inviting at all. This looked like brown mud on top and that's being polite. The scallops were small compared to before and the stuffing overpowering. Couldn't taste the scallops and had to have a drink to get the stuffing sticking in my mouth down. I hate to give a bad review, but I can see why there were empty tables and no waiting lines like I remember. For the price of the scallops, and what I got, I will not be going back. Wish I had taken a picture but my phone died. read more

Great fresh seafood. Service is amazing nice people. Seafood platter is amazing. Haddock is great and love the Lobster Bun with the hand cut fries. read more

See all

Come here everyone I am in town. Best services and never been disappointed in the food.

One bad experience two years ago, shame on them. A second awful experience this year, shame on me. My haddock sandwich was inedible. The bread was hard as a piece of bark and the haddock was over cooked. The waitress spoke to the cook about it and he actually told her that he suspected that the sandwich would be returned! To top it off, she didn't give us a credit on the bill. read more

I come up here to camp and visit Bay Haven and in the past has been pretty good. This is the third time where it's been horrible, I won't be back. The fries were cold and the scallops had no flavor but grease, the clams were tough. My cousin asked about taking them to go and my reply was that they will go right into the dumpster, not worth the money and not edible. read more

I wish it were possible to apply a negative star. This place used to be fantastic but is no longer. I am being treated for cancer and do not have a keen sense of smell. Was served up a ~$10 cup of spoiled clam chowder this evening. Sour milk or heavy cream. When my family smelled it was they could do not to vomit. The server (not her fault) comped the soup but not the $30 entree. I hope and pray I'm not sick from this horrific experience. Do not stop and eat here. read more