Everything about this story brings up such great memories. From the oldies & disco music to the…read moredelicious ice cream and baked good it is all the best. The staff is always pleasant and has the best service with a smile.

After a hard-core day of riding dirt, mud, trails and backroads our group of hard-core bikers…read morescurried into this establishment for a few scoops of frozen heaven. The first thing that caught our dirt Filled eyes was the unique candy selection on the wall. Stuff I have not seen since I was a child.: (Not that I am old). Next my eyes focused on the digital menu board that displayed the plethora of scrumptious choices of their homemade ice cream. Halfway through the menu a little bit of drool was dripping on the floor from my Saliva glands making my mouth water profusely. So many delicious choices, I had to find out what was the biggest and baddest of their selections. It turns out to be the banana split served in a tub. This 55 gallon drum look alike was filled with bananas, three different kinds of ice cream, chocolate syrup,other toppings, whip cream and cherry! Oh my goodness..... I think my head is going to explode.... ....good thing I am wearing a motorcycle helmet. That mess would not be pretty in such a beautiful store. After Ripping my wallet from my pants, I cheerfully paid then rushed to Carry the payload of ice cream out to the picnic tables across the street by the stream. After enjoying the beautiful view of the stream and the babbling brook, I Wielded a plastic spoon like a samurai wields his sword, slicing into the frozen cream with expert precision. The whip cream, chocolate and flavored ice cream I had ordered all culminated in an explosion of flavors in my mouth. I think I let out a little scream of ecstasy as it slid down my throat. There is nothing like homemade ice cream to get you excited for the next bite. I probably gained 2 pounds from eating this enormous treat that was Prepared with love. But it's worth every pound I might gain. Shortly thereafter it was time to get back on the motorcycle and ride a few more mountain tops. The sun was warm and starting to get an orange tint as it was contemplating setting in a couple hours. The warm wind was blowing the leaves ever so slightly, the Mountain tops were screaming my name like a lost child screams for their parents at the mall. What a great day, what a great ice cream store, what a place to Stop!

Looks like new owners since the last time I stopped here. Only had ice cream, but the "small"…read morecone was huge, and the price was right! Great service too!

Amazing food & ice cream!!!…read more Always fresh & delicious. Friendly service. Beautiful outdoor tables with plenty of parking, shade & an enormous old tree.

Excellent ice cream. I'd seen a recommendation for this place on a baseball thread in Reddit, of…read moreall places, & it was spot-on. Reasonable, good choice of flavors. I got the soft serve "twist," my friend got a hard flavor. We both said it was "as good as any other we've ever had" & we are both ice cream afficionados. Reasonably priced, good-sized portions. A bit hard to find as the address is Rt 28 but it's in the back. Nice array of pigs, chickens, ducks, a cow & several goats in the back. We're "city" people so enjoyed seeing the animals almost as much as we did eating the ice cream.

Cooperstown seems like the ice cream haven or something. As we drove here from my mom's we passed…read moreby like 6 places. I only wish we could have tried them all. I picked this as the 2nd place to try our following night after dinner. No one was disappointed. If you can only go to one ice cream place I'd go to this or the other one I went to if you look at my reviews :P

Delicious house made ice cream. Tried a flight of mint chip, Oreo coffee, peanut butter cup, and…read morerocky road. Cute spot with really nice staff. Will definitely stop in again if traveling through.

Delicious homemade ice cream with some of the best service I've ever gotten at an ice cream shop. I…read morewent two nights in a row and both nights the employees were not only nice but actively friendly, smiling, and sincere. It smells like freshly made waffle cones and you can see them making them and the ice cream right in front of you. Just a wonderful little parlor.

Amazing homemade farm fresh ice cream/ gelato and cheeses. High quality and delicious, unique…read moreflavors that can be enjoyed right there on the farm where it's produced. Beautiful view, friendly owners and adorable dog who loves frisbee.

They're the nicest people and have some of the best gelato I've ever had. The farm is so cute and…read morethe eggs are delicious. Everything is delicious

The best candy anyplace Fresh candy, excellent old fashioned…read morefriendly service Can have your own box assortment of as many as you like A great place for one of a kind gifts that will be rememberd Bottom line Will be back Carl L

A wonderful store with many different items, including souvenirs, candy and syrup, and chocolate…read moretruffles as well. Many unique items for sale in this store. I found maple syrup in a cool jar, and some delicious chocolate too. Definitely recommend to check this store out while in downtown Cooperstown.

Great place with great menu/ choices. Staff was very friendly and efficient. Adding a few more…read morethought because Yelp makes you.

Got all of our orders correct. Their non dairy ice cream is tasty! I wish more places offered non…read moredairy options. Friendly and efficient staff.

Woody's Ice Cream Place is a great place to stop for a good variety of ice cream treats…read more Located in a small shopping plaza in Herkimer, this family owned & operated landmark offers over 20 flavors of Turkey Hill hard ice cream and also Upstate Farms soft serve ice cream, serving up cones, cups, sundaes, shakes, malts, freezes, and other cold treats including the Boston shake, which is part shake on the bottom and ice cream sundae on top. The place has an inside counter area with indoor seating with air conditioned comfort. There's also an outside order window and a few purple picnic tables in front (no smoking is allowed in front of the shop, so others can enjoy their ice cream. This is a great rule). I stopped here recently on a very hot Saturday night. Since just ate dinner at a nearby restaurant, I decided to order my dessert at Woody's. I got a double scoop of Colombian Coffee hard ice cream cone, which came out to about $3 and change. The ice cream cone was pretty big and a very refreshing treat for dessert. I will definitely have to return to Woody's for a Boston shake on my next visit to Herkimer. CASH ONLY

Had their no sugar added peanut butter swirl ice cream which was packed with peanut butter and mini…read morepeanut butter cups. Maybe they were sugar-free, maybe not, but it was delicious.

THE BEST ice cream at the most reasonable prices!! Going to…read moregrannies has become a tradition for our entire family when we come up that way.

Prices have got out of control since the new owner took over. Quantity of ice cream has…read moresignificantly decreased over the past few years as well. Complete rip off compared to how it used to be. Used to pay $3.75 for a Sunday. Now that same Sunday is $6.25!! I can buy a half gallon of ice cream for less than that. Would not recommend going here anymore.