This place is fantastic. It's also very simple: nothing but pizza. The prices are good, too. A slice of pizza runs for $4-5, depending if you want cheese or a pizza with pepperoni, sausage, or one of the two monthly specials. You can also get a whole pizza for around $30. Let's talk about size. These slices are so big, they have their own zip code. Seriously, a slice is bigger than your head. Let's talk about quality. This place isn't a place that is just a novelty pizza place. Sure, the slices are huge, but they're also delicious. A slice is on the thinner side, with a good red sauce and good cheese. It's New York style, foldable pizza. Let's talk about service. The service is fantastic. The people that work there are very helpful and care about your experience. Remember to give a healthy tip because they deserve it. Go to this place. It's my favorite pizza place in Winchester. read more

Large slice pizza that is thin crust, very crispy, and tasty. It is not gas stations pizza as some detractors have maligned. Those type of pizzas are generally thick, gooey to where you feel like you're eating a rubber tire. It is a step above the 3or 4 bites that you will get at SLICES and better tasting. Worth the visit. They play great funky music, not too loud,.. a hip place to have pizza. read more

Huge slices and PBR. What else do you really need??? Customer service is good with a small but usable seating area. Definitely the go-to for a quick slice and a beer. read more

This place is AMAZING! Great food, great people, and great atmosphere! I LOVE how big the slices are and tasty it is. worth the drive! Another thing that really struck me was how Kind, Polite, and generous the staff was. They went ABOVE and believe me BEYOND for us. Even though they were busy they made sure to check on us and even give us a laugh or 2. I would DEFINITELY recommend this place to everyone!! read more

If I were young and hammered I'd be all over this place. But being in my 50's and not so hammered, yes the slices are huge but that made it suck that much more. read more

I'm originally from Brooklyn NY. Where we pride ourself on our pizza. . I came here twice and to tell you the truth I love it!!! This is honestly the closest thing I can get to a NY pizza. Don't get me wrong Anthony's is good but way too thick and greasy , the one in the mall is good too but again too thick too greasy. I like to eat my pizza without there being a trail of grease and I have to use a whole bag of tissues. . Honestly I'm 32 yrs old and I recommend this place. Other review say its for drunk college kids. Ummmm , I beg to differ. I never went here drunk but you can be since they sale beer . Anyways, don't knock this place till you've tried it. The only down fall is its way too hot in this place and they need to invest in a AC. Other then that I'll keep coming here. read more

The biggest slices of pizza I've ever seen and it's good. I mean for $4 you can't beat the big slices of pizza.

Depending on when you go they may try to serve you hours old pizza that's just been laying out in the open. I'm surprised health department hasnt shut this place down. If it wasnt for drunk people who just dont know better they would have already closed. read more

Benny's is a brand new pizza place in Winchester. The pizza is by the slice but is amazing and huge! Very limited but delicious menu, cheese, pepperoni, sausage and mushroom slices. Benny's is perfect for a quick pizza craving and they're open very late! Highly recommend it! read more

I was really excited to visit as many of my friends had raved about them. It was okay. The pizza took a very long time and it really wasn't busy. They didn't even have any plates- we ate our pizza off of paper bags (not so sure of the sanitation). There isn't much variety and the pizza was kind of ... meh. I think the giant slices are the gimmick and people are enamored of them. The guy at the counter answered the ringing phone when we arrived, and he proceeded to talk to someone for over 10 minutes without acknowledging our presence. While I enjoy the atmosphere and the chill vibe, I think perhaps they are being a bit too "chill" and could step it up. read more

It was okay. I like that they serve pizza by the slice but it wasn't very flavorful. Nice location just wish the pizza itself was better. read more

Benny Meleto's - Pizza Near Me - Winchester, Virginia

Omg when I say I didn't know how I was going to fix this in my car I'm not joking. Come with your seats folded and ready. I got 2 pizzas and it's was more than enough to serve my family of 10 twice over. read more

This pizza place not only has amazing pizza but it's also exactly what Winchester needed! A fun, late night tasty traditional pizza restaurant!! read more

Not much to ad to what others have said. Prices are good, slices are huge. Taste is just slightly different than a NY slice but not in a bad way. I'm really happy to see they have a 28 inch pizza. Can't find anywhere in Winchester with a large bigger than 16 inches and it never quite seems like enough for my family. read more

Breath of fresh air. Open late, trendy, clean. The beer is just what u want and cheap. Perfect read more

See all

Solid pizza. Huge slices and good value. Really nice crust and sauce, toppings a little sparse. A very focused menu, so you may not find something you want. The staff seemed a little unsure and service was disjointed, but they were friendly and the place had just recently opened so I'll attribute that to them getting their feet underneath them. read more

Reminds me of NJs Sawmill in Seaside. Huge pizza. I couldn't believe how big the box was. The cheese was good. I wish it had more sauce but it tasted great. Some might think a tad bit expensive for a pizza but it was definitely worth it. 5 people and 1 slice left. read more

Pleasantly surprised at how much I enjoyed this place. Not a lot of seating but the service was fast and the food was awesome! We will definitely be back. read more

Good (not great) solid pizza. Portions are huge and price is down right cheap.. You can't beat that they are open past 9 PM... They're open past 11Pm. Those are the pros The cons... Limited toppings Reheated when toppings are added Portions are so large you can only eat one slice with topping choice The venue is very small with limited seating Not a big deal... but no fountain drinks We will return... no such thing as bad pizza read more

In the old "Em". Tax is included in price s. Slice of pepperoni is $5 and as long as your forearm. And, they sell beer read more

Benny Meleto's - Pizza Near Me - Winchester, Virginia

Neat little place in the heart of Winchester. Such a comfy environment where the staff is not uptight and super cool. The food is great as well as the pricing as you can get a HUGE slice and a drink for less than most fast food places. Not to mention the pizza is actually fantastic. 10/10 would recommend to anyone who likes pizza! read more

Great cozy welcoming feeling with giant pizzas. The people working here are laid back and there is variety of cold drinks in the fridges.

I'm not from this area but I went to Benny's after a night out and that pizza was the most amazing late night pizza I've had. It's HUGE and the cheese is amazing. I recommend putting the garlic dipping sauce on it, so good. read more

This is hands-down the best New York style pizza you'll ever eat it is so delicious and made to order and the staff are really really nice

Pizza is amazing and the price is great! No tax is in the prices, Apple blossom might be crazy though

Pizza was HUGE barely fit in the car. Wish we had time to stay and eat it hot but it was delicious at home and plenty for a family of 6!

Cashier went from taking our money and making change to reaching her dirty hand into the pepperoni and placing them on our slice with no gloves. I would never eat that. Asked for our money back. You lost $5 because that girl didn't wear gloves. Oh and $5 for a pepperoni pizza slice? This isn't NYC! read more

Benny's is a Virginia pizza franchise with locations all over the state. I think they could be a great niche for this town. I give the buffalo chicken pizza a double thumbs up but am not myself wild about the mushroom or sausage. Cheese pizza is definitely good. I struggle to decide if it's a place I want to dine in or take out. Last visit it was 15-20 minutes to get two slices. read more

There isn't a pizza I usually don't like but I really did not like this pizza. The crust had little flavor as did the sauce.

I honestly thought the pizza would be big and terrible. What I found was that it is big and delicious! Such a cool novelty and amazing price. I'm not a huge fan of the way they cook the pepperoni, but every time I leave satisfied. This will continue to be one of my favorite pizza places around! read more

I really really wanted to like this pizza. The serving size is hilariously huge, the crust was perfect, the sauce great, but the cheese! The cheese! How do you put an orange-y cheddar-ish cheese into a PIZZA!?!?! If they just made the cheese mozzerella only as it should be then my vote would bump to 5. Until then, it is almost great but sadly just good to very good. Orange-y cheddar type cheese in the pizza! read more

CHEAP BEER! Oh yeah and the food was good! Lol huge slices of delicious pizza paired with a beer; what more could you ask for in a quick bite downtown. read more

The staff was really chill. The environment of the place makes it feel new. The only thing is the wait but it's worth it

This is the only place to get really good pizza in Winchester. The crust is so good, I would go there if all they sold were crusts. It is unfortunate that they do not deliver because you can't get pizza that good delivered from anywhere else. The only options if you want to carry out are to buy the enormous pizza or buy the individual slices. If you do buy the slices, you can carry them out in paper bags or if you buy four they will overlap them and stick them in a regular sized pizza box. This isn't terrible, it just isn't the most convenient and makes it harder to share this awesome pizza with friends and family. Additionally, they have a great selection of canned and bottled drinks that are priced so reasonably it is as if they are thanking you for buying their pizza. They really have a drink for anyone in that refrigerator. Bottom line, I hope they consider delivery and regular sized pizzas because they pizza is so good they do not need to rely on its size to sell it. read more