We pulled in on a Saturday around 9AM and the parking lot was full and the line was out the door. (I see this as a good sign lol) We ordered 2 sandwiches to go and got them within a few minutes of ordering which was impressive considering how busy they were! Both were delicious! The bagel was chewy and overall the sandwich was packed with flavor. Benny's did not disappoint! read more

See all

Been here twice now, and I'm not understanding why it takes sooo long for bagels to get to you. All i ordered today was a bagel with cream cheese and I still waited 14 minutes. That's too long. They really need someone to come in and rework the work flow process, it seems chaotic. First time I came, I didn't know that I had to ask for my bagel to be toasted. I received a chewy untoasted bagel that was difficult to eat.....the second time I was asked if i wanted it toasted, I said yes. Still chewy, dont get me wrong....the bagels are good but more so chewy than crisp. Personally i think they give you way too much cream cheese, gobs. But that's just me. I'll ask for easy cream cheese next time. Cute shop tho! Hope they figure out the front of house flow better! read more

Benny's Bagels - Blueberry bagel - Bagels Near Me - Fayetteville, Arkansas

My first impression was wow, this place is slammed! As expected, it was late morning on a Sunday. There was quite a line when I walked in, but it was moving along. Loved the vibe inside, very cute little brekki spot to catch up with friends or have a coffee/matcha! I got an iced Bramble from their seasonal menu, and a bagel sandwich. The sausage didn't fill the whole bagel, but it was delicious. While I loved the iced latte and bagel, I spent $21 on just those 2 items. Definitely an every now and then kind of spot for me personally! read more

Benny's Bagels - Iced coffee - Bagels Near Me - Fayetteville, Arkansas

See all

Not enough seating, food and drink is a little pricy for what it is. Tastes alright though. Place looks nice on the inside.

I type this with a bagel and matcha in hand. Both taste amazing. I got the salt bagel and the strawberry matcha, the bagel is saltier than I'd like but not so overwhelmingly that I can't recognize that this is a great bagel. I probably wouldn't get it again but it's still yummy! Now the matcha? SUPERB. Especially considering is a premade matcha syrup. Again, super yummy. I do think it's overpriced at $8 but it'll be nice for a slightly rarer occasion. I only had the matcha and bagel and it took about 15 minutes but about 5 of those minutes my bagel was sitting on the counter waiting to be bagged and given to me. I expected faster service considering they open at 6:30 and I got there at 6:33 but I digress. All in all the food is great but I would make sure to plan to wait for a bit if you're going there just for a bagel to go. read more

Benny's Bagels - Strawberry Matcha - Bagels Near Me - Fayetteville, Arkansas

The bagels & lattes were so good!! The sitting area was clean. Don't try to go if you're in a hurry because you will be disappointed - very slow compared to other local bagel shops. But if you have the time- worth it!! read more

Had to try out the new spot in Fayetteville!! Bennys Bagels was a 10/10 from service, to atmosphere and WOW this bagel. Definitely will be back to try some sweet ones too!! read more

Benny's Bagels - BEC on Asiago w/ garlic and herb schemer - Bagels Near Me - Fayetteville, Arkansas

See all

Without a doubt the bagels are great! The service counter needs help. If someone orders unsliced bagels to go the order should be filled on the spot! They currently put in order in line with the people who have ordered sandwiches. I waited 14 minutes to have two bagels. There were two employees chit chatting the whole time! Five stars for the Bagels...service not so much! read more

Took 30 minutes to just get a hot coffee and they advertised gluten free bagels but they did not have?

We popped in for breakfast on a weekday morning in the summer. Busy and bustling atmosphere at order area. Acceptable wait time. One draw is the cold drinks are just bottled and canned with no option for white milk other than with coffee. Large portions with slathering of shmear. Great little bagel place close to campus. Recommend. read more

Service takes a while for your food to come out and the pricing is expensive for what you get. The bagels are good and definitely fresh but can be pricey just as the coffee is. The menu is very limited as they only offer a handful of items for purchase. The shop gives french bistro vibes but is very compact on the inside. The staff is always in an upbeat mood which makes the experience pleasurable. read more

I ordered two bagels, a cinnamon crunch and a plain to go-got home and they only put the cinnamon crunch bagel in my bag. Come on Bennys, you've gotta get better.!! read more

Stopped by to pick up 1/2 dozen bagels. The bagels are very good and they were fresh and warm! Service was courteous but horribly slow -45 minutes from order to a bag of 6 sliced bagels. It would be nice to have a line for folks just picking up bagels and not coffees and menu items. There were people everywhere and people who opened the done, saw the line, and walked out. read more

The bagels are SO good !!! Such a fun, new place to try in town! The service was great, and at the atmosphere is super cozy and I'm excited to expand my study spots !! read more