Cancel

    Open app

    Search

    Bentino's Pizza

    4.1 (42 reviews)
    ModeratePizza, Italian
    Open 11:00 am - 10:00 pm

    Bentino's Pizza Photos

    BENTINO'S PIZZA ATMOSPHERE

    What's the vibe?
    Casual
    Quiet
    Outdoor seating
    Good for groups

    You might also consider

    More like Bentino's Pizza

    Recommended Reviews - Bentino's Pizza

    Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
    Yelp app icon
    Browse more easily on the app
    Review Feed Illustration

    Reviews With Photos

    a cheesy cheesy bread
    J D.

    This is a delicious gem of a pizza restaurant situated in a small town atmosphere with very friendly and welcoming staff. The pizza and calzones rival the best pizza joints in the Dayton area. It features a cozy bar with local craft brew options, as well as a comfortable shaded patio. Highly recommend.

    Wrong receipt, wrong order, right box.

    Would not recommend this place. $20 for a 16 inch, dry, thin, no sauce pizza. Ordered and paid for pizza at 7 PM, was promised in 30 minutes. Arrive to pick Pizza up, it took 10 minutes for the window to ask the customer two cars in front of me to pull up. I got to the window 40 minutes after I ordered the pizza. Young lady said it would be another 15 minutes. NOTE: I even told his manager, it was my first visit and I am the person that will post a review and she still didn't offer to make it right. I asked if they even made it and she said no. I asked for the manager and it took about six minutes for her to come to the window. She stated her name was Jayla. After giving my money back, she asked me "do you want me to go check and see if it's in the oven. " I said yes, and it took about seven more minutes. It was in the oven all right, just now cooking it 45 minutes later. She came to the window with a pizza and said I'm sorry. She did not offer anything other than taking my $20. No receipt given. You can get the same pizza for around $14 at a LaRosa's or any big name brand that is not dry and very chintzy on the toppings. I would recommend going somewhere else and getting two times pizzas for your money. Pathetic Service. Jamestown Ohio, Whoever the owner is, they need new management. I would not let someone manage my business with things like this happening. This place is way over priced, out in the country and maybe some are willing to pay it, not me. Not worth the trip. I won't go back!!!

    the front of the restaurant

    See all

    12 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    10 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    Page 2 of 2

    Ask the Community - Bentino's Pizza

    Review Highlights - Bentino's Pizza

    The service is top notch, and as far as I'm concerned, it can't be beat in the Dayton area!!

    Mentioned in 2 reviews

    Read more highlights

    Verify this business for free

    People searched for Pizza 539 times last month within 15 miles of this business.

    Verify this business

    Lievita - Cheese sticks

    Lievita

    4.4(54 reviews)
    46.4 mi

    Wonderful food! Amazing service!!!! One of my family's favorites!!! They have a big variety with…read moresomething for everyone!

    So me and my husband for the last 15 years, having coming to visit my in-laws and his family in…read moreWellston, Ohio and we were always come around Christmas and we never went back home to San Diego,California without going to Chillicothe. We would always go to Ivy's and pick out our Christmas ornaments to take back with us. Well, 2024. We were your visiting to see the lighting of the Christmas tree and it was so magical it was snowing carolers singing, and we were hungry, and this girl loves her pasta, so my mother-in-law said there's a really adorable Italian restaurant. Let's go see if we can get a table, so we walked from Ivy's down to this adorable Italian Restaurant and before I even walked in, I knew I wanted to eat there. My husband opened the door and we were greeted with such a smile and hospitality. The seating area was packed. Little kids were playing. The joy of Christmas was in the air and we love Christmas That's why we would always come to Ohio around Christmas time. We have never experienced Christmas like we do in Ohio. We are a family that goes above and beyond during Christmas we even do Christmas in July lol, it's like being in a Christmas hallmark movie when we're here in Ohio we never have experienced living in 4 seasons. We have always grew up with sunshine and flip-flops lol, wearing rain-boots and scarfs and beanies were more of a fashion statement lol. My husband and myself always said once our four kiddos were grown and married and out of the house we would move to Wellston, Ohio, So that we did, September 2026, and that year was the heaviest snow Wellston has seen in years. My husband took me on a date ‍‍and of course we had lunch at your adorable restaurant. You guys had just opened for lunch and we walked in and got seated. There was only 1 other couple in the restaurant and this sweet young girl and the cook welcomed us as if we ‍‍were regulars lol we had the most wonderful ambience and company. We sat at the booth next to the bar and had the most wonderful lunch date‍‍ We shared with them how we had just moved her from California and we were so excited to hear all about Ohio. Not one time while we were there did anyone else come in to eat, It was like it was created for just us to be there as if my husband reserved the whole restaurant just for me lol we believe God has his perfect timing, and right when we were getting ready to leave is when people started coming in to eat lunch, that young girl and guy working there made us feel like home So, that adorable restaurant will always hold a special place in our hearts We will always have dinner as long as we can get a table the evening of the lighting of the Christmas tree, we can't wait to bring our kids and grandchildren and our families and friends. It will be our signature place. So fast forward, my aunt is doing a women's conference in Chillicothe this evening 6/5/26 and it's rare when we can get a group of us ladies together and fellowship and have dinner, so I made reservations for 11 of some very special ladies, that God has brought into my life since I've been living here, and all of these ladies besides me and my mother-in-law have never been to your restaurant. So I am so excited to bring them to our signature spot. With that being said, I will always have a vision and hear those cute little kids playing in the seating area the 1st night we walked in to eat there. It's the little things that matter that make it so very special and the little kiddos definitely make the ambience of Christmas when we were waiting to be seated that night and the little kiddo's were so excited to see Santa and we're singing Christmas carols as we were all waiting to get seated, I never have cared how long I would wait for a table because the ambience was so amazing as busy and packed as the restaurant was, our waitress made us feel as if we were the only ones in the restaurant, My husband and myself ‍‍ are so excited to continue to make memories there and to top it off. The food is absolutely amazing and my husband is a pizza critic, and this girl knows her Italian food So with all that being said, I want to say thank you for the joy that we get walking in your door I am so excited to get ready for my girls night and eat dinner at our favorite restaurant. Love and Blessings, Jeremy and Julie Rider

    Photos
    Lievita - Bar area of restaurant

    Bar area of restaurant

    Lievita - Caesar salad

    Caesar salad

    Lievita - Front of building

    See all

    Front of building

    Galo's Italian Grill - Peanut butter pie

    Galo's Italian Grill

    4.2(233 reviews)
    59.4 mi
    $$

    Hubby & I went for lunch to celebrate our anniversary. The restaurant interior reminded me of…read moreCheesecake Factory. We were seated immediately & our drink order was taken. Freshly baked bread & a plate of roasted garlic olive oil was placed on our table. It was heavenly & we had to remind ourselves not to eat too much or there would be no room for our entrees. Hubby ordered the mixed grill while I got Chicken Parmesan & a chopped salad. The salad was a typical Greek salad & was good. The Chicken Parmesan was huge & took up almost the entire plate. There was a side of spaghetti nestled next to the chicken & it complimented the dish nicely. The server brought a plate of freshly grated cheese & put most of it on my entree. Yum! Hubby really liked the skewer of steak, chicken & shrimp along with the typical veggies of bell peppers, mushrooms & onions. At the end of our meal, the server brought us a lovely chocolate dessert with a strawberry on top for our anniversary. We will definitely be regulars at this restaurant from here on out!

    This has always been a favorite of my family. I came to visit and my dad wanted to stop by here for…read morelunch. The food is always so tasty. I had the veal parm and it was so tasty. The place itself is nice. But when I was looking around, my chair could be replaced and there were a few paint chips and stuffs on the ground. But the service was amazing and they were able to seat us right away a little before noon. Overall it is a very good place and I will be back!

    Photos
    Galo's Italian Grill - Inside

    Inside

    Galo's Italian Grill - Mixed vegetables with Risotto. yum!

    Mixed vegetables with Risotto. yum!

    Galo's Italian Grill - Kitchen

    See all

    Kitchen

    Mediterranean Restaurant & Cafe - Spinach and artichoke dip

    Mediterranean Restaurant & Cafe

    3.9(88 reviews)
    15.4 mi
    $$

    Stopped here for a quick bite while staying in town to camp for the weekend…read more Immediately I was intrigued by the diversity of the menu; they had a wide range of Mediterranean cuisines and all looked delicious. The interior was quant and personal, with the walls covered with old celebrities, European landmarks, and historical events that give it a storied feel. The service was very inviting; we got there 40 min before close (I know I'd hate me too) and they were just as kind as could be. I ended up trying the chicken soup of the day and their crab stuffed cannelloni, which were both pretty good. My only note for not giving 5/5 was I didn't taste any crab in the dish I got, just lots of cheesy goodness (which was still delicious). Definitely a hidden gem that is worth the stop!

    It's Worthy! We stopped for lunch driving through town. I'm…read moreglad we did. We had the Bruschetta: diced tomatoes, mozzarella, basil, a nice balsamic glaze on garlic toast. Yum! I had the Mediterranean salad with chicken. Juicy delicious chicken with fresh romaine, tomatoes, cherry peppers, red cabbage, Kalamata olives and a great dressing. Yum again! My son had the Mediterranean gyro. Lamb & beef piled high on a pita with tzatziki, hummus, red onion, lettuce, jalapeño and feta. He said is was one of the best gyros he's ever had. Service was fast and friendly, a nice guy. As Arnold said, 'I'll be back!'

    Photos
    Mediterranean Restaurant & Cafe - Best seat in the house!

    Best seat in the house!

    Mediterranean Restaurant & Cafe - Bread sticks

    Bread sticks

    Mediterranean Restaurant & Cafe - New menu

    See all

    New menu

    Bentino's Pizza - pizza - Updated August 2026

    Loading...
    Loading...
    Loading...