I was born in France and have been living in Chicago since I was 3 years old while visiting family in france 2-3 a year since then. I wanted my girlfriend taste authentic french food for her birthday dinner, so I searched for the best rated French restaurants and bistros in the city and decided on this one based on the reviews.
When arriving, I was pleasantly surprised at the quaint interior of the restaurant and the truly beautiful outdoor setup. I really wanted to like this place and my first impressions were very good. The staff was all very friendly throughout the night and the fresh baguette really did remind me of being back home.
Now for the food we ordered. We both started with a french onion soup which when it came out, had about a half inch layer of straight up cheese on the top of it. The first few bites we had felt more like biting into a moist block of cheese rather than a soupe à l'oignon. Whether it was supposed to be gratinée or not, i find it hard to believe that this was the intended experience of any french onion soup. Next, the bread in the soup which is supposed to be still crispy at the top of the soup was of course completely soaked with broth due to being submerged under the thick layer of cheese. This gave the entire experience of the soup like eating mush and chunks of cheese in a broth that was itself not particularly tasty. Honestly one of the worst french onion soups I've ever had, and it is one of my favorite classical french dishes. What a shame.
Next came the entrées. We ordered the white fish and the confit de canard and decided to share both of the plates. The fish had a great texture -- a nice crispy crust on the top and very tender on the inside. However, it was also COMPLETELY bland. The green sauce presumably meant to garner the dish with did not ameliorate the dish much either. When eaten with everything on the plate in a bite, the taste became acceptable, but I also believe a restaurant charging these prices should have everything being enjoyable on its own, and much more than that when eaten together. We barely touched the plate.
The duck dish I ordered included a sausage, which was tasty and reminded me a bit of the taste of an italian sausage. Taken with the asparagus and berry on the plate, it overall became palatable. Same story with the duck, although eating the duck alone without the side dishes was a salty, dry and disappointing experience, especially considering they charge 35 dollars for the plate. Perhaps the worst duck confit i've had if i'm rating it on the quality of the duck thigh alone.
The desert, a crême brulée that we shared, was fine. I've certainly had a few that were better and may well have had worse. But again, for a restaurant of this caliber I would have expected something delicious. However, the custard tasted... standard and could have also have come in colder. It felt like they had left it out too long before burning the sugar at the top and for my favorite dessert of all time, it really didn't do much for me.
While I seldom if ever post reviews for restaurants, I did feel inclined to this time since it was for a special occasion and it is the food of my home country that they are serving here. All in all, the most satisfying thing we had for the dinner was the tea they served, which was fragrant, warm and relaxing. That, the charming staff and the setting of the restaurant are its saving graces. However, if you want quality authentic french food, I would try elsewhere. A 125+ meal for two that left both of us disappointed and wishing I had made reservations elsewhere. As pleasant the atmosphere and staff were, for that price I will certainly not be coming back. read more