Probably eat here 6 to 8 times a year. I want to like it and support local , privately owned businesses, especially in the food space. However , always an issue . This time main course and appetizers arrived essentially the same time. Should not happen in a restaurant open this long. I had a burger and it was extremely over salted. I accept restaurants salt heavy to amp flavor but this was very bad. I ate it as it was my only meal of the day. The salt actually crunched on my mouth. Loosing my tolerance here. read more

Great beer selection, food and service. Staff is attentive. Cindy makes amazing cocktails

Montville, NJ - a packed restaurant full of locals at dinner hour is always a promising sign, and we rolled in on a Thursday evening around 7 to find ourselves miraculously sliding into the last two parking spots AND the only open table, woot! [Blowing on my nails.] The menu is a mix of American comfort food and gastropub classics, but with flair, and has a bit of everything to satisfy different palates. Our eyes were probably bigger than our stomachs as we ordered 2 apps, 2 entrees, and 2 cocktails, and it was an enormous amount of food. The portions are definitely what you'd call hearty, and everything was very tasty. Thursdays are all day happy hour so we picked the fried calamari appetizer at the HH price (still a full and generous plate and didn't seem like a downsized version) which were tender and well-battered, as well as the hot honey wings which were meaty and substantial. The short rib parpadelle with housemade pasta and a perfectly medium-rare, well seasoned hanger steak with truffle fries completed our satisfying and belly-stuffing meal. The cocktails are serious as well - the presence of a drink with egg white is my personal litmus test for a bar that knows what it's doing, so the Thyme to Bloom special had my name on it. I'm salivating just looking at photos of dishes I didn't order, and am already plotting my return! read more

See all

What a gem! The hot honey wings are honestly maybe the best wings I have had in my life, and that's saying something. The homemade pasta is fire. We got the bolognese and it was outstanding. The wedge salad is just absolutely drowning in their homemade blue cheese, and thank god for that because I could drink it straight. The spicy mami cocktail was delicious, as was the chocolate martini. read more

Elevated bar food? Don't mind if I do, babe~ Black Rabbit Saloon is truly a neighborhood gem. It's a modern tavern offering a little bit of everything from your classic pub fare (wings, flatbreads, burgers, sandwiches) to more "upscale" dishes (homemade pasta, steak, salmon, escargot, short ribs). We visited on a Thursday night and the parking lot was packed! We stepped into the restaurant and were greeted by a lively atmosphere filled with happy locals - a telling sign that we were in for a delicious meal! Luckily we were able to snag the last table for two. If you're dining with a large group or during peak hours, I recommend making a reservation. The interior is modern and rustic with high ceilings, barn rafters, wooden furniture, and a sleek bar area. They have regular tables, high top tables, and booth-style seating along one wall. It's stylish enough for date nights, yet casual enough to enjoy a drink with friends or watch a sports game. They have Happy Hour ALL DAY on Thirsty Thursdays *smirk emoji* with an extensive drink menu of craft beers, wines, and cocktails... can't complain about that! What we ordered: *Raspberry Lychee Lemon Drop Martini ($14) - Love me a fruity drink! This martini was refreshing, sweet, and tart with a smooth finish. *Thyme to Bloom Cocktail of the Day ($16) - Includes grey goose berry rouge, pama pomegranate liqueur, thyme simple syrup, fresh lemon, egg white, & cracked black pepper. My +1 enjoyed this! Think of it as a more "fruit-forward" version of a whiskey sour with a silky texture and frothy finish. *Fried Calamari with marinara & orange remoulade sauce ($13 Happy Hour price) - The calamari was chewy, but not rubbery. The batter was light and crunchy. I enjoyed the orange remoulade - it was very tangy and paired well with the squid's subtle sweetness! *Wings with hot honey sauce ($10 Happy Hour price) - These wings were solid - juicy & meaty on the inside with lightly crispy skin on the outside! The hot honey sauce was a balanced mix of sweetness and spicy heat. *Hanger Steak [medium rare] with chimichurri & truffle fries ($32) - Okay, this might've been one of the best steaks of my life. Seriously. It was SO tender and moist, with that bright pink center. And the flavor? OMG - perfectly seasoned with garlic, salt, black pepper, and herbs. The chimichurri sauce was zesty and an amazing complement to the steak. The fries were golden, crispy, and topped with just the right amount of truffle oil and parmesan. Savory goodness! If you're a beef lover... you must order the hanger steak dish! My only complaint? I wish it was bigger, haaaaa! *Pappardelle Pasta with pulled short rib, tomato, & parmesan ($25) - Pasta is one of my favorite carbs. The noodles were homemade with an al dente texture that made every bite of this dish so much more satisfying. The sauce was incredibly rich, thick, and flavorful - a delicious blend of tomatoes, heavy cream, and parmesan. Oh, and the ribs? They were the kind that just fall apart and melt in your mouth!!! Service was great from start to finish. The entire staff (from the hostess to the waitress to the food runners) was friendly. They checked on us just enough and gave us space to enjoy our meal. Our drinks and food were served at a good pace. We were stuffed, satisfied, and wobbled out with to-go boxes. Would I come back? 1000000% yes. Are you kidding me? Generous portions and great value? Count me in. I need a reunion with that hanger steak. Plus.... I need to carb up with more of that homemade pasta. read more

See all

The outside of this place- adorable. The selection of beers they had on draft and the hoppy hour all day thursdays- LOVE. The staff were super friendly and accommodating too! We got wings, which were delicious, but I'm so sorry to say, but we didn't love the food overall. With the steak dinner we got, the steak was over cooked and the fries tasted like burnt oil. The pizza also tasted like cardboard with sauce on it and the caesar salad tasted solely like anchovies. I really wanted to love the place and I do for the happy hour and drinks, and I would come back to try it again & order a burger/wrap, but I left a bit disappointed. read more

Black Rabbit Saloon - Beer Bar Near Me - Montville, New Jersey

Adorable place! Lovely service, delicious food. Diverse menu options. We loved it and will definitely be back!

Cute interior and bar, with ample parking outside. Friendly servers and efficient service. Appetizer specials we good - Buffalo bites were best offering. Bavarian pretzel was tasty as well. Nice beer menu with some great selections. Mains were bland and fries were greasy, likely cooked in oil that wasn't hot enough. I live 20 minutes away; not dying to return. If I could give 3.5 stars I would. Rounding up to 4 because our server was good. read more

Black Rabbit Saloon - Entry way - Beer Bar Near Me - Montville, New Jersey

See all

Cute Tavern in Montvale Bootan area. Nice open space with high tops a big bar and small wooden tables. They also have a long table for a big party, but it's a high top. Nice menu with a big variety of casual and some upscale things like short ribs. They have a great tvs so good spot to watch a game. They also have a downstairs seating area with a few tables and a bar. I'd go back! read more

See all

Went there for a Saturday lunch. Got seated quickly. The place nice and kid friendly. Service is fast. The food was good, just a bit pricy for what it is. Overall nice place to catch up with friends since the music is not too loud allows for conversation. read more

See all

The place is really nice and spacious, we made a reservation just in case and the place did fill up at around 1:30pm so it was good that we did! Our waiter was really nice and gave us a good recommendation for their wings - definitely try them if you go, they do $1 a wing on Sundays! Their alabama white bbq sauce is stellar! Their drinks were really good, especially the "year of the rabbit" one. The tacos were okay, the fish was good but the rest (rice and toppings) was lacking flavor. read more

See all

Drinks were excellent service was friendly and helpful. Nice decor with a beautiful bar area. They also have a downstairs for parties etc. Food and the sauces were good. read more

See all

Been multiple times. Beautiful spot, ambiance, and even the location. The service is okay, but the food is beyond mediocre. Such a shame!

Came here the other night to try something new while still staying close to home. Sat at the bar and we were immediately welcomed! The bartender was super nice. We ordered the spiked calamari from the specials menu and the shrimp with shishito peppers. I was hesitant about both but they were oddly good. The spike calamari had calamari olives and hot peppers. I had to get an espresso martini with dessert - it was made perfectly. The blueberry cheesecake was just ok - you could tell it wasn't homemade. We also made friends with a nice older man who sat next to us. All in all, I'd come back here again. read more

See all

"Tried to amend my carnivorous habits Made it nearly seventy days Losin' weight without speed, eatin' sunflower seeds Drinkin' lots of carrot juice and soakin' up rays But at night I'd have these wonderful dreams Some kind of sensuous treat Not zucchini, fettuccini, or bulgur wheat But a big warm bun and a huge hunk of meat Cheeseburger in paradise Heaven on earth with an onion slice Not too particular, not too precise Just ate a cheeseburger in paradise (Black Rabbit Saloon" Jimmy Buffett This is the song that came to mind in this local eatery. Happy Hour is the best all day on Thursday. Most of the time (Mon., Wed, and Friday) Happy Hour is from (3-6pm). Drafts are (2 off), the staff is super friendly, and the place is clean, the flowers are beautiful out front and the air condition is humming. I like conversation at meal time but the large spacious dinning area makes conversation difficult. My dinner date did not mind. Could it be I talk too much. read more

See all

First of all I'd give this place a second chance. Family and I were in the area for some basketball games. Came on a busy Saturday night but was able to get a reservation on yelp which is a huge positive. Walked in for the first time to a small hoppin place with only our table open. 2 kids, two adults. Kids got pasta and grilled cheese which they enjoyed so in a parents eyes it's a win already. I saw a bunch of reviews that this place had homemade pasta. So for my entree I ordered the Cacio Pepe. Unfortunately it was a little sub par. Pasta overcooked and the "sauce" was too buttery and really had no flavor. Also a bit broken. Fresh pasta is tough, 10 seconds too long and its mush. Wife ordered the French onion soup, just didn't have depth. Onions were not caramelized just sautéed. And they used chicken stock and not beef. So it was on the lighter side. She also got the Prosuitto and Fig flatbread. It was extremely crispy. More like a cracker than a flatbread. Flavor was great just not much body. The bar was full and they have a full supply of craft beer on tap and craft cocktails on the menu. Love the vibe though. read more

Everything about this place hit the mark. The menu has a great variety and the food delivered on every level. Service was excellent from start to finish. If you're looking to step outside your comfort zone and try something new, this is the perfect spot. Whether it's an adventurous cocktail or a dish you wouldn't normally order, this place makes it easy to branch out and you won't regret it. A solid go-to for a fun and fresh dining experience! read more

Cool sports bar atmosphere, service was good and enjoyed the food. If you are Cleveland brown fan it is Cleveland Browns backer bar, nj Cleveland brown fans could go to watch the Browns play on Sundays!! Cool watering hole to watch sports. read more

Went there for my birthday recently. It's very loud inside so just prepare yourself for that. Service was okay overall, but the bartender kept chatting with the other bartender which delayed service. Food was just okay. The vodka sauce was very runny and kind of bland. My husband's food was great, though. Definitely recommend the bolognese. read more

This place was great, came around 5pm on a weekday and had a few drinks with wings and a bar sampler. The drinks were excellent and the alabama wings were my favorite! Definently will be coming back. read more

I wasn't sure what to expect given the fact that we'd last been here when it was Poor Henry's, but had heard gods things and wanted a casual family lunch after church on a Sunday. What I liked: - the overall vibe was great. Large, open environment that was clean and bright. Very inviting. - good spot for a bar loving crowd or a family. We weren't the only ones with kids. And they had crayons and menus that cater to kids. -the staff was amazing and friendly. We loved our waitress - there were some drink specials because of the fact it was football Sunday. Generally speaking prices are moderate. I wasn't seeing any specials that blew me away. The food was ok, but can't say there was one food item that is a must have. I'd go back for the vibe but not because I just eat the xyz from the menu. Overall a nice experience and I'm happy to support our local establishments. We will return from time to time. read more

See all

We were in town and looked up reviews for a happy hour place. I ordered a house tequila drink and it was a strong drink for $3! My husband ordered a beer and it was delicious. We decided on the happy hour calamari and Caesar Salad. Both were excellent and priced well. We also split a burger and truffle fries. The burger was great and the truffle fries were room temperature. They would have been amazing if they were hot. Unfortunately our server did not check back in so I didn't have the chance to ask for new fries. They were an up charge of $3 and would have been worth it if they were hot. Overall, we were both happy with our meal. read more

When in the area, we checked this spot out for an early dinner. It's an upscale bar with a large menu filled with sandwiches, pasta, burgers, appetizers. The bar takes up one side of the restaurant with the other side being seating - it's casual but trendy though a bit loud. Service was decent throughout. Large wine, craft beer, and cocktail menu which was great. Super kids friendly with a large variety of kid entree options for $12 including a drink. Crayons and coloring pages galore. They were even nice enough to cut the burger in half for them as my kids were splitting it. I tried the chicken tacos ($18) which was delicious and had a good helping of avocado. We tried the calamari which was also good. read more

Black Rabbit Saloon - Calamari - Beer Bar Near Me - Montville, New Jersey

See all

The restaurant is pretty spacious and the aesthetics were warm and welcoming. The staffs were also very friendly and kind, and even offered to remedy our appetizer when it was overly seasoned and salty, which we really appreciated it. They offer a wide range of food and they were all pretty good and decent. Our favorite that evening was the calamari which was perfectly friend without it being too oily and without the coating falling off. Overall it was a very pleasant experience and we would definitely come back for a chill, comfortable, and simple dinner! Thank you for reading and best of luck! (: read more

Unbelievable dinner experience last night , party of 4 , enjoyed perfectly poured cocktails, chicken quesadillas appetizer, eggplant parmigiana, cheesesteak , panko chicken pita sandwich was very tasty, Pappardelle Pasta ( Homemade Pasta ) was very flavorful with pulled short rib, tomato and parmesan cheese - service was outstanding Jorden did great job, over nice atmosphere. Highly Recommend !!! read more

Black Rabbit Saloon - Pappardelle pasta dish with pulled short rib, tomatoes,Parmesan amazing flavor, highly recommend. - Beer Bar Near Me - Montville, New Jersey

See all

I used to love poor Henry's even though it was just okay with food but it was there for so long as a steady okay burger place that I missed it when it was gone. The black rabbit Saloon that it has replaced is totally different inside is not any better. They have a limited menu with just okay food. Nothing is great everything is just okay. But it is just around the corner so I will be going there but not with the same settled familiarity i have with poor Henry's. Things change . Not always for the better read more

Reese, behind the bar did a great job making us feel welcomed and directing us to a few menu items. The wings with white sauce were well cooked and a nice change from the usual "Buffalo" coating. She gave us a side of the Hot Honey, which was just a bit too spicy for me, but I prefer less heat than most. The cheese steak was excellent! Generous amount of medium rare steak, onions, and peppers, all perfectly seasoned. A side of truffle fries and we were good for lunch. The atmosphere was a little on the sparse, cold side with no cohesive "vibe". That kept it from getting a fifth star. For food and service, it is definitely a 5 star place. Thank you, Reese for an enjoyable rainy afternoon. read more

We stopped for lunch at this restaurant that used to be Poor Henry's. We had frequented Poor Henrys a lot years ago when I worked locally. Place is beautifully renovated and bright inside but a small suggestion would be adding comfy chairs as all are wooden. Our server was delightful and very attentive and we loved the specials; the lamb burger and the meatball parmesan and both were nice portions. The skirt steak sandwich while tasty, some of the pieces of the meat were tough and chewy and should not have been for $25. The fries were tasty as well as the drinks. Overall a good experience just a few things they can improve on. read more

Excellent establishment! Will definitely return for the food and drinks. Pleasantly surprised. I was skeptical about the white Alabama bbq wings but def a must try and the cocktails were also stellar, along with the service! read more

Black Rabbit Saloon - Great spot! The chicken sandwich had an excellent taste combination with the cutlet, fresh mozz + crispy prosciutto. - Beer Bar Near Me - Montville, New Jersey

Ambiance: Loud and energetic Service: prompt and pleasant but could have been more attentive Food: elevated bar food at a decent price however the Lamb burger special was over cooked. PS: my Old Fashion was barely a shot and lacked the flavor an old fashion should have... read more

Decent beer list but whats the point if the service sucks. Never got a setup for my food or even a check for that matter - guessed what I owed and threw it on the bar and left. Barely a sign out front to know it's there - must not be much to do in Montville for such an average place to get the reviews it gets read more

My first time here with a couple of friends. Started with a glass of white sangria which was quite good. Then we shared fried calamari with sides of marinara and orange marmalade. It had to be one of the best I've ever had and it wasn't even from an Italian restaurant. It was cooked perfectly and I was surprised to learn that I enjoyed the marmalade. Who knew?! Then I ordered the grilled chicken sandwich on ciabatta bread. That was the only misstep, the chicken was tough. Our waitress Claire was very friendly. read more

First time coming here and will definitely be going back! Our serve Olivia was extremely nice and helpful when it came to pick our food. She came back multiple times checking in on us. I didn't do an appetizer as they gave bread with this AMAZING olive spread. It was delicious. For my entree I did the blackened salmon and omg was it so good! So many flavors it was hands down one of the best salmon meals I've had. My husband got the pappardelle and he said it was really good!!! read more

Black Rabbit Saloon - Bread and olive spread - Beer Bar Near Me - Montville, New Jersey

This spot has been on my list for a while and I wish I could give it a better rating but it did not live up to my expectations. While the restaurant itself was open, airy and had a nice vibe, the service and food fell short. I ordered the short rib quesadilla which was extremely spicy, I wasn't able to eat it. The rice balls lacked flavor depth and that disappointed me the most because they looked delicious. I'm not sure how you can mess up truffle fries but this batch missed the mark. My date had the salmon and said it had good flavor and was cooked nicely. The service started off pretty slow and the waitress seemed uninterested in taking my order. After she realized how nice I was :) she turned the leaf. For the price point, I would skip this place unless you're trying it for happy hour or just to grab a quick drink. read more

See all

Burger was pretty good/great, egg plant was dry. Ordered sweet pot fries and got regular on a take out. Fries were eh

Walked in on the Friday of Valentine's Day with no reservation. Staff were very accommodating and was able to seat us right away. Service was also quick as we were able to get in and out in an hour (our choice). This was a casual "saloon" restaurant good for families to bring kids. Food was interesting with a good variety. We overall enjoyed our meal but found the execution "ok". The short rib was fall off the bone tender but the meat was dry. The flavor of the steak sandwich was really enjoyable but more saucy than I liked and the greens were hard to bite through . read more

See all

Great tasty selections on menu, new look, and so far, all Very good. Owner had a nice vibe that came through with the overall experience.

***3 1/2 stars*** One of my toxic traits that I'm sort of but not really trying to fix is picking restaurants based on the name (which really did me in a few years ago when I selected the dust-covered Moose Tooth Grill in Lake George for lunch), but a) I didn't select this one and b) it was actually fairly decent. I came here with my Bitch Pack on Friday for an early dinner around 5ish. This was about as convenient a "meet in the middle" place as we could have found, literally a minute or two off 287. Despite not being very familiar with this immediate area, Black Rabbit was very easy to find with ample parking options. I was a few minutes early but the hostess was very accommodating and without hesitation showed me to a table to wait for my tardy compatriots. I liked the vibe in here instantly; it's one medium-sized airy room with a bar area to the right of the entrance, barn-like rafters and feels both modern and rustic, if that makes sense. A lot of items on both the food and drink menu looked intriguing (definitely my kind of place in that regard), and I decided to go with the Elevation for my weekend nip, featuring vanilla-infused bourbon and espresso. Eh. This was surprisingly one of the low points for me. Texture-wise, I wasn't crazy about the fact that it was kind of icy (a fact not disclosed on the menu, which makes me wonder if it was even supposed to be) and I just didn't think that the flavors complemented each other well; the bitterness won the day. Black Rabbit made a big comeback though with the app and entree. I split the tuna tartare with one of my chums, and we were both big fans. I devoured my portion very quickly and accidentally got caught gazing hungrily on the remaining portion that wasn't mine. Doesn't say a lot about me, does say a lot about the tuna tartare. I really liked the rice cake foundation, which gave the dish a nice crunch (not dissimilar from a crunch layer in a sushi roll). The gnocchi was excellent as well - a LITTLE heavy on the cheese but I was enamored with the sauce, which was on the sweeter side and thick without being crunchy. That was also probably inhaled too quickly, but no matter. The comeback unfortunately was short-lived; we split the chocolate fudge cake, which honestly was just not that good. The biggest reason was that they DOUSED the cake in cocoa powder (see attached), so I literally inhaled/choked on it when I took the first bite. Either mix it into the cake, or do a super light dusting, but I'm not interested in suffocating during dessert. Big miss for me, and what sadly tipped the scales and made this something other than an unequivocal positive experience. The service was just okay. One of the benefits to hanging out with a group of people with the souls of 80-year-olds is that you're not usually pressed for time at a 5PM dinner, but the waitress WAS noticeably not as present as she should have been. It was fairly busy so that's at least a partial excuse but I noticed a few times when I looked up for her that she was just chatting away with the hostess at the front - optics can be unfair, but they matter. There was a lot to like here atmosphere- and food-wise and I WOULD come back, but when you're already thinking ahead to the next visit and how you need to pivot to some other options, that's a problem. read more

See all

Great drinks, decent food, friendly waiters! We liked the quick service and laid back atmosphere. read more

Black Rabbit Saloon - Beer Bar Near Me - Montville, New Jersey

Food******** Service******** Ambience****** All good bar food and drinks. Service was very good. read more