This was such a pleasant experience. Ordering via the website for pickup was easy. I got a lunch…read morespecial of sandwich + fries. The food was ready when I arrive, fresh & hot. The store itself was *immaculately* clean. Somehow the fries even stayed hot & crispy on my ride home (I feel like fries from any place get soggy right away). The sandwich was a generous portion & they were nice enough to make my sandwich with the modifications I asked for. I will definitely be returning!

My wife and I were in the mood for some Greek food, and I heard about Gyro Jimmy's, so I said let's…read morego check it out. Located on Voice Rd in Carle Place in the back of the parking lot. It is spacious with plenty of tables. We go up to the counter and order 2 gyros and an order of fries. We did not order drinks, and we were asked if we wanted water. So, we took the water. We sat at a table the drinks and food were brought over to us. Great service. Our Gyros were plentiful with meat, and I ordered mine with no tomatoes and my wife with no onions and good portion of fries. The Gyros and fries were very good. We finished the Gyros but not the fries. Nice size portions. We were full. When were finished we were told not to clear the table, they would do it. A quick enjoyable meal for us with great service, looks like this is going to be our new Greek dining spot. Hope to return soon. A must try if you like Greek food.

Came for the lunch specials. I got the gyro pita with French fries. All their lunch specials come…read morewith your choice of lentil or chicken and lemon soup which is nice. I opted for the lentil soup. They started us off with complimentary pita and tzatziki dipping sauce. The sauce was so yummy and very fresh. I actually took the rest of the leftovers home and used it for a few days in a variety of dishes I made. The soup was okay. My grandma got the lemon and chicken soup and it was very lemony and salty. Our food was taking a bit of time considering we were the only ones in the restaurant, I think the server was distracted by wrapping the utensils for tables. She came to take our finished soups. And the food finally came out, huge portions. My gyro was covered with lettuce cuts but not the freshest lettuce. The server was kind of slow for only have two tables. The ambience was nice. Greek music was playing and the decor was nice.

My parents wanted to take me to this Greek spot they'd been to a few times, so one of the times I…read morewas in town, we went. We ordered a lot and the portions are generous, so we had plenty of leftovers. The staff were kind and the standout dishes for me were their appetizers: the octopus appetizer and the crab cakes. Both were delicious and I highly recommend. I feel like sometimes I find the way restaurants cook octopus lacking, but I really loved the way they did it. Crab cakes were similarly so good. Four stars because some of the entrees didn't wow me as much (e.g., the moussaka, pasticcio platter) and the soups that were sides were solid but nothing I'd go out of the way. Overall, a great option in the area.

Very cute place for Greek food! Came here for dinner and loved everything from the appetizers to…read morethe dessert. The "outside" patio area is very nicely set up, and the interior looks upscale as well. Staff and service were very nice and attentive, accommodating to requests, and always trying to elevate the experience. Definitely on the more expensive side for Greek food, but portions are large, so I took home for a second meal!

Our last visit was quite disappointing. We were a group of five, and unfortunately, the service…read moredidn't meet our expectations. The cocktail drinks took a long time to arrive, and they arrived after the appetizers--and were incorrect, so we had to send them back. The main dishes took another hour to be served. I have pictures with timestamps showing the delay, with over an hour between the appetizers and the main courses. During this time, we asked for extra bread and clarification, but the servers seemed unsure and kept pointing at each other, which was frustrating. Later, a manager explained that the delay was due to our ordering moussaka, but if the kitchen was overwhelmed, they could have let us know. We're reasonable guests, but their explanations felt lacking. Overall, the service was quite poor. To make matters worse, they added a 20% gratuity charge--something we usually tip pretty well even though service is too bad to tip. But I don't expect to tip 20％ to this horrible service. We really enjoy the food here, but unfortunately, due to the experience, we don't think we'll be returning.

Great. Chicken gyro sandwich! Lots of meat, good amount of sauce and toppings…read more Also got spinach pie which was very tasty And eggplant gyro sandwich which also was excellent

Not sure how and who gave this place an award of taste of Long Island but THERE IS NO way…read more Premade lamb gyro meat ZERO FLAVOR in the tetziki sauce And the Potato on the still hard to mess up always crispy and flavorful at all food fairs. But here felt like it was almost fake. Either refried or fried and not seasoned at all. And the side of tetziki didn't add any other flavors either . Would nEver waste my money here again and no clue how this place has a that high of a rating .

We were in a mood for some Greek gyros and stopped by for pickup order…read more The staff Ana/George extremely friendly and welcoming. The establishment very clean and cozy. We had the lamb gyro sandwiches well done; by far one of the better gyros in the area! The lettuce and tomatoes on the sandwich were finely chopped; protein well done and sauce topped it off.

First time trying this established I ordered the moussaka and the Avgolemono. I thought the…read moreMoussaka was tasty and the portion size was more than enough. The Avgolemono was much thinner, more watery than any other lemon soup I have had. It was good, but not "knock your socks off' good. We shall try other items next time. Thank you.

Good service and lunch special was good . Do not order lunch special online if you want a soda, coz…read morethey charge extra $$ , it's that if you go there in person, it's free. I wish the chicken portion would be more but i still think it is value for money. Taste is good .

Very good spot for Mediterranean bites and I always get their juicy Souvlakis. Staff is always…read morefriendly and situated in a nice neighborhood with ample private lot.

When you're hungry, you go with what you know will tastes good. I enjoyed the greek salad with…read morefalafel but I am not in the business for paying extra for it. For $19, I should have a large salad, with plenty of lettuce. I'm a vegan, so I I asked to leave out the feta. Still... $19 for this. I can see $12 at most. I felt robbed. And, I'm still hungry even with my dolma (grape leaves) appetizer. I ate every bit of lettuce in there, too. The food is good. The price is exorbitant.

I love Greek food and this spot is unique in that they have a build your own option. You can choose…read morefrom a pita sandwich, rice, or salad and top with protein or veggies and finish off with salad/fries + a drink. If you prefer to just order something off the menu, they also have salads / plates for that as well. I enjoyed the fresh salad ingredients that they provided in my meal. The tzatziki sauce always hits the spot with their gyro style meat that was very flavorful. Definitely would try their platters next time since I love having pita when I get Greek food but the build your own option was only ~$10 so definitely a great value for what you get. I also got their fresh Greek yogurt with Greek honey. I've never seen this option on the menu of a Greek spot before and was definitely intrigued. It was very fresh and thick, my perfect type of Greek yogurt. The honey wasn't overly sweet either and was the perfect accompaniment to the yogurt. Although it was ~$7, they give 2 big scoops of yogurt. You can also choose a different topping but I choose honey. I also ordered roasted eggplant and grilled vegetables. The roasted eggplant was unique since it was more of a dip. It came with fresh pita that was super soft and fluffy. They really have some of the best pita! The grilled vegetables were simple and nothing special. Overall, a great value for the build your own option and very cool that they have fresh Greek yogurt!

Many thanks to yelp for recommending highly Greco BBQ. You'll leave feeling full with yummy food…read moreand wonderful vibes. I like their menu and it includes variety of items. The staff was extremely welcoming and service is fantastic. If you have not tried Greco BBQ you need to at least once.

From the owner: We smoke our meats and fish in~house using oak and hickory. We make authentic Greek dishes explode…read morewith flavor by using tender meats that were cooked low and slow.

Found our new go to spot!!! We found this hidden gem while on a supermarket run at food universe…read moreand noticed a different cart parked at the corner. We missed out on such yummy food as they used to only be open till lunch time hours... now they are open morning for breakfast till dinner. My husband spoke highly of the man- very nice and food was delicious- super fresh and non fattening, doesn't taste like food from a cart and portions are very generous. Will be back again!